← Home ← Back to /tv/

Thread 213388997

15 posts 10 images /tv/
Anonymous No.213388997 >>213389018 >>213390256 >>213392379 >>213392471 >>213392532 >>213392625
Why did Stannis, the greatest military commander in Westeros, send his calvary charging into a forest?
Anonymous No.213389018 >>213392540
>>213388997 (OP)
You know how in total war you can toggle the foliage off
Anonymous No.213390256
>>213388997 (OP)
He didn't study the battle of Agincourt
Anonymous No.213390826 >>213392407
It worked out for Hitler
Anonymous No.213391142 >>213391309 >>213392123
The real question is, why did D&D hate Stannis so much? We were robbed of this kino

https://youtu.be/mQ9XDFiFj8o?si=PKfXURDaaZZDU-ml
Anonymous No.213391309 >>213391349
>>213391142
Adaptations need to take liberties dumbass
Anonymous No.213391349
>>213391309
They actually don't
Anonymous No.213392123
>>213391142

KINO
Anonymous No.213392379
>>213388997 (OP)
That's against the wildlings. He won that battle. It's when he tries storming a castle with no siege equipment that he loses.
Anonymous No.213392407
>>213390826
Oh yeah, it worked marvels.
Anonymous No.213392471
>>213388997 (OP)
DxD ruined Stannis. Everybody already know this
Anonymous No.213392532
>>213388997 (OP)
Anonymous No.213392540
>>213389018
FPBP
Anonymous No.213392625
>>213388997 (OP)
It's funny how almost all of the battles in S1 and S2 carried more weight despite being done almost entirely offscreen. The tactics, logistics, and grand strategies of the battles were discussed and you got a real sense that realistic things were happening even though only the preludes and aftermaths were portrayed. When they finally did a big onscreen spectacle for Blackwater, it was done quite competently.

Everything afterwards when D&D departed from the books just shows that the two had learned literally nothing about the source material. Big waves of soldiers just crash into each other.
Anonymous No.213392764
My biggest gripe with the show is how the fantastical elements were taken out. I would have loved to have seen more fantasy knight armors