Thread 213469585

and I suppose you would've acted differently, /tv/?

How hard is it to fire your gun

>>213469638
You mean the morality of killing your fellow man.

Yeah, I would have run away sooner. The whole plan was suicide.

>executes an unarmed kraut at the end of the movie
>it's not even the same guy from this scene
this was the best part. he straight up makes himself a war criminal for no reason

>>213469751
>Gets executed for abandoning your post

I hate Jews but I would have absolutely charged in without thinking because a man doesn’t abandon his comrades even if the comrade in question is a heeb

>>213469813
The truth is whatever I say it is after everybody is dead.

Why didn't they just evenly distribute the ammo between the .50cals instead of entrusting it with this dingus?

>>213469585 (OP)
This movie's premise is retarded.

>lets send a whole squad in a wild goose chase behind enemy lines just to save 1 guy because uhhh... his mom is sad or something

And at the end of the movie, instead of just one mother crying over her dead son's body it is going to be several.
Great job.

>>213469585 (OP)
No, I would've shot Upham on my way down.

>>213469585 (OP)
I would have acted like this

If the german made a move I would have had to get it on

What the fuck is Upham's arc? He goes from spineless piece of shit who won't fight to protect his friends, to spineless piece of shit who commits war crimes. Are we meant to sympathize with the character at all? I was a kid when the movie came out and I thought he was a tool then, and I still think he's a fucking tool now. I hope he didn't survive the war.

>>213469585 (OP)
yup would have helped him stab the jew

Killing Nazis are war crimes now is it?

>>213470149
The germ was instructed to turn himself in. He committed the first war crime

Genuinely curious. Why did so many men in the west go to war rather than prison or workhouses during conscription? You are going to fucking die. Even if you are super religious, there is undoubtedly some doubt that when that bullet hits you that's it - just comple blackness. And for what? Over a piece of insignificant land, or political ideologically in a universe that inevitably ends? What's the point?

I just don't get soldiers as a thing at all, even more so if they willingly sign up. You are putting your LIFE, something that you will never experience again, to defend a bunch of grass and land on an insignificant planet in the middle of nowhere, and 100% of the time the political leader sits nice and cozy in his or her office or bedroom spouting 'motivational' bullshit while the young and naive die for nothing.

So, no, I would not have acted differently.

>>213470190
>The germ was instructed to turn himself in.
And he instead escaped, which POWs are allowed to do.
>He committed the first war crime
Even if this were true, he gets a trial.

>>213470285
Because they've been brainwashed by kikes into thinking that some nation that they probably have ancestors from thousands of miles away wants to take away muh freedoms. For their service and to show appreciation the jews have imported millions of third world brown savages into their countries to rape their women and kill them.

Nah, after hearing my squad mate calling me I would’ve run upstairs and stuck my riflebutt up the Krauts ass and pulled the trigger

>>213470285
Military service is unironically a form of suicidal ideation. It's the male equivalent of cutting your arms open after a break up so your ex never forgets you.

>>213470285
WW2 was total war, German and Japanese navy was actively targeting non military targets. It was an “us versus them” situation at that point.

>>213469935
I mean that's kinda the question posed by the movie. Is this guy's life worth more cause his brothers died? Was it worth it that all these guys died so Matt Damon could live? Up to the viewer I guess

>>213470507
>riflebutt up the Krauts ass and pulled the trigger
What would shooting yourself accomplish?

>>213469585 (OP)

yeah i would have shot upham

>>213469935
She would be crying over all 4 of her sons dead bodies anon, and while it’s not real Ramelle was probably based on your typical town that was just a few weeks away from complete liberation by the allied forces

>>213470678
Ask The Führer

>>213469585 (OP)
>lets his white christian brother kill a kike
>WHAT DID HE DO WRONG????

>>213469585 (OP)
I would've cried in front of the TV for unknown reasons when I heard that Oceanic Flight 815 went down.

>>213470285
>comrade am of make demoralization
>>213470451
Yes Ivan we know this is another pol agitation thread.

>>213470771
I would never let my comrade die if had the means to save him. You are a cuck

>>213469668
Kill or be killed. Morality doesn't come into it it's much more primal

>>213470805
You would have to go up against legendary Waffen SS soldier, are you crazy lol?

>>213469668
>fellow man.
Socialists are not my fellow men, or men in general.

He cost the lives of so many fucking men, it's ridiculous. Plus the only dude he killed was a soldier surrendering, what a cunt of a character.

>>213470805
>jews who see me as subhuman are my comrade
lol

>>213469585 (OP)
Yes and I have. But I'm a better class of man

I'd kill a nazi any day now
Not because i'm some libcuck commie or whatever
It is my duty to the comrades and my country
It's war and war where you must kill
No hard feelings

Yeah and i'd rape some german chick because why not?

t. i'm white

You guys are retarded. The scene was supposed to be a metaphor for the holocaust. Basically he has the means to save the Jew but doesn’t. It’s not that deep.

>>213470285
Our countries weren't flooded with niggers and muslims by that point, there was a lot more national pride.

>>213469585 (OP)
I would be able to stop an attacker in a civilian context if I had a gun. In a fucking war? Of course I could. Upham's non-reaction is genuinely bizarre.

>>213470974
Yes Ivan there were blacks and Muslims in Europe 70 years ago.

>>213470149
Yeah even as a kid I thought he was retarded.
>okay fine, he's a translator with no real combat experience
>written as a complete pussy
>actively fucks the squad up several times
>watches Hanks character die because he chose not to do anything
>moment of being a "hero" is shooting an unarmed man
Like are we supposed to go wow he came good in the end? Because it sure as hell didn't feel like that.

>>213470285
>>213470832
Better yet, every single soldier ever (except for Desmond Doss) burns in Hell, because God is quite clear on the 'no killing' rule
>butbutbut Obama/Xi/Putin told me to murder people for their wealth and power, I am inmocent!
St. Peter is laughing his ass off.

>>213469585 (OP)
I would not be drafted into any military service, as Upham almost certainly was. And if I joined voluntarily and aimed for a combat role, I would be better trained than he was by the time I encountered any combat

>>213470911
I see germans as subhumans who cannot help but attack white nations.

>>213470991
Proofs?

>>213470958
fuck jews
i wish they'd gas more of them with polacks
it was never because of them
nazis were larping as the best nation
above americans, above anglos, above russians, above any other
and that's where it should be cut down completely
never let some german be above you
huns and barbarians who sacked the Rome have no sympathy for me
they will only destroy everything to build more shacks in the Colosseum

italian fascists on the other hand...

>>213469935
The military should have a policy saying only 1-2 brothers in an immediate family can be in combat roles, something like that, to prevent the whole scenario to begin with.

>>213470285
Imagine literally every media outlet turning in sync to point you at the enemy.
Disney, netflix, your favorite youtuber, all turning to point you in the direction of war.
Every time you open up youtube it’s the president on the fireside chat podcast again.
That was basically the reality of WW2 civies.
Not just the reality for Americans but also the Germans and Japanese as well, they just didn’t have their own Disneys.