When can we stop pretending RDR 2 was a good game?

Pretty sure we never did.

>>715436089 (OP)
Well I thought it was a little fun to explore the olde town as an olde cowboy and stuff lol.

that's a pyrrhic battle anon.
R* glazers are cultists

>>715436089 (OP)
it's one of the best games ever made, what are you talking about

>>715436089 (OP)
Is it really like this? I decided to pirate RD2 but haven't played it yet

Dos vaqueros gays comiendo pudding.

>>715437536
Not really. It is incredibly boring though.

RDR2 really exposed the fact that /v/ermin don't actually play games lol. There is so much legitimate criticism to make about the game being an open world where are all the missions are shooting galleries but you faggots get hung up on reposting 4chan screencaps (made by people who also didn't play the game) so you can be mad on the internet. I will get multiple replies to this post, one of which will be the seething "nuh uh I'm not directly replying to you :^" kind which means I'm right btw

This game made me realize that I'm anti-realism in video games.

I don't want to watch a 6 second animation every time I loot a body for a pack of cigarettes and 2 bullets.

it's okayish to good
story mode is a pile of shit though

>>715436089 (OP)
It's literally a game for women where they can play as hot cowboys having gay cowboy sex catching, collecting and riding horses. While also trying to be a period piece that ignores everything about the period but the drama between the characters and era accurate outfits. Of course the in game characters aren't gonna scream about raping people and killing niggers and indians.

>>715436089 (OP)
its not a game, its a tech demo.
it took me 5 years and 9000 attempts to finally finish this trash game.
every time i started a mission i kept falling asleep from how fucking boring it was.

which is an astonishing feat, i am a huge fan of westerns and wild west.
rockstar somehow made the motherfucking wild west boring.

>>715438543
Based take buried under a pile of coomer rage. You’re not entirely wrong though-RDR2 definitely feels like it was written by someone who watched Brokeback Mountain and thought “yeah, but what if this was 100 hours long and had horse balls physics.” The game tries so hard to be a gritty outlaw saga but wraps it in a modern HBO drama wrapper-complete with melodrama, forced morality, and 1899 Netflix-tier diversity. Still, the gunplay and world design pop off hard, just wish the pacing didn't feel like chewing molasses with a broken jaw.

>>715437536
it is quite possibly the single most boring videogame ever made.

>>715438780
you don't like holding forward?

>actually every single person in the past was a racist sexist evil piece of shit bigot like myself

>>715436089 (OP)
It's not nearly as bad as GTA V, but it's got a lot of the same problems. Basically it's an alright sandbox game, but the story and missions are all miserably awful.

>>715438780
>>715438861
i always thought nu-God of War is the most boring game ever made, but then i played RDR2....

>>715437536
yes

>>715439034
niggers in america were literally treated like animals and told to ride at the back of the bus until like the 1960's you stupid woman.

>>715438778
It's because it's the same as any drama period piece. You see nothing to do with politics and characters just appear and have weird drama while being attractive with zero substance. Like people just ignore shit like Hamilton is about rapping slave owners. Most of them are set in the middle ages and the only thing that would even tell you it's there is that they go to balls wearing big frilly dresses with men dressed up like the fourth musketeer who didn't get invited with a powdered wig and a king and queen exist but the queen has all the power and is nice for some reason.

>>715439136
In the south

>>715439197
in the south they are still being treated like that.

>>715439034
When the subject of your game is a gang of murderous scam artists and bandits at the turn of the century, it's a little annoying when they talk about indigenous rights and critical race theory and white male guilt like a bunch of current-day Bluesky terminally online jackoffs.

>>715439034
>in the past
lmao @ the studies that show how liberals intellectually tone down their speech when talking to black people

>>715439034
>actually every single person in the past was a racist sexist evil piece of shit
is this not the liberal position?

>>715437528
I think you mean one of the blandest games ever made.

>>715439034
but i thought that half of america today is evil, sexist, racist because they voted for the orang bad man? you liberals make no sense.

>press x to watch a movie length animation for a common action

it was always SHIT, story and gameplay

Chuds be like
NOOO I DONT WANT TO DISCUSS GAMES I LIKE, I WANT TO TALK ABOUT GAMES I HATE AND WHY THEY ARENT RACIST AS ME

>>715436089 (OP)
The quality is higher than it's contemporaries. Until that's not a fact, it will continued to be praised.

>>715440029
>you are the boogeyman in my head!
Grow up

>>715437705
>mimimi "legitimate criticism"
This is just as a legitimate criticism as everything else about this poorly written, badly paced pile of shit, you dogfucking cocksucker.

>>715439527
When it comes to the injuns and shit, its supposed to be a parallel to the outlaw life
>life good, hunting (stealing) and living off the land
>then the white man (lawmen) forced us off our land (conqured/civilised it)
>now forced into reservations (being on the run)

>>715436089 (OP)
>can we stop pretending OP isn't a gigantic faggot
I guess not

>>715436089 (OP)
No its very good

>>715436089 (OP)
It was solid enough Rockstar always wants their "cinematic" experiences and after chapter 2 it picks up like an actual western a bit into the story.

I dont get people hating on Aurthur for being cookie cutter and a "modern" protagonist though, the guy is dying throughout the whole game of course he's gonna be like unnecessarily nice to people he doesn't wanna be remembered as a raging piece of shit to the few people that are close to him. I don't wanna sit around care about the historical accuracy of my white man simulator having to be uber racist or whatever the fuck, I'm trying to hunt deer I don't care that Arthur is nice to fuckers in game.

>>715440479
>he doesn't wanna be remembered as a raging piece of shit
The fuck does this matter when he's dead.
He won't be caring about how others think about him, he'll be dead.

>>715436089 (OP)
It should have been a proper sandbox rpg instead of an overly dragged out linear snoozfest of a story with an unsatisfying ending. I was expecting skyrim crossed with shenmue with how people were talking about the detailed world and interactivity of it. It's nothing like that and it sucks.

>>715436089 (OP)
The game is a masterpiece despite that

>>715436089 (OP)
I consider it about as canon as Red Dead Revolver, and about as retarded.

>>715439034
>>actually every single person in the past was a racist sexist evil piece of shit bigot like myself
if they weren't, why do libtards attempt to erase the past? stuff from the 2010s is now considered poison by the libs, 1800s might as well be cyanide

>>715440620
Are you actually retarded? Or do you not having anyone who actually loved you?

>>715436089 (OP)
>WEELL NOAW DYUTCH IT SURE AINT NONE MY BUSINESS WHAT TWO CONSENTIN A-DULTS DO IN THE PRIVACY OF THEIR BEDROOM
>HELL, EVEN 3, TWO TO DO IT AND ONE TO WATCH. DON'T BOTHER ME NONE
>SPECIALLY IF'N THE TWO DOIN IT IS A WHITE GIRL AND A NEGRO FELLER, AND THE ONE WATCHIN IS THE WHITE GIRL'S HUSBAND. AIN'T NONE' MY BUSINESS DYUTCH
What did they mean with this dialogue?

>75 million copies sold, still going strong in 2025 with no new content or mods
/v/chuds, I think it's time we took the L and moved on

>>715440724
>oh you don't think everyone in the past was an absolutely horrible person then why did this tumblr post say they were huh

>>715440832
which town was this dialouge from?

>>715440943
nice selfie anon

>>715440115
i just like the implied assumption that there's loads of old west media out there where characters go around lynching every minority they see and this game is some sort of an outlier

there's a john ford film about a black cavalry sergeant who succesfully defends himself against false rape and murder charges, never seen anyone get pissy over that

>>715441142
>reddit spacing
>false equivalence

>>715441142
>just like the implied assumption that there's loads of old west media out there where characters go around lynching every minority they see and this game is some sort of an outlier
What are you watching, most westerner movies are them being good guys helping people even minorities
The outlier movies are the evil ones

>>715441142
the truth is that RDR2 DOES have some stupid pandering, like Arthur absolutely losing his shit about some dude who was a slavemaster decades prior, or that racist dude in St Denis giving away racist flyers. But most other examples that make /v/ seethe just expose the average anon's stupidity
>women voting? I don't give a fuck, I've never voted myself
>minorities? Grew up with them all my life, don't care one way or another
He mostly doesn't give a shit which make sense for his background

>>715440734
Yes.

>>715439034
Yes,1800s America was in fact quite racist and sexist, you clown.

>>715437536
>when it comes to racism
Arthur hates slavers and racism a lot, and the game forces Arthur to act that way
>when it comes to feminism
Arthur seems a bit apathetic to it, but he can support it or not give a shit. He does help the feminists, but I don't think they made him cheer for women's right to vote or anything
>when it comes to gays
There's a French sex pest who kisses him at one point, but it's treated as a comedic moment where Arthur is caught off guard and the guy does it to get away from a mob or something. The copypastas about Arthur talking about same sex marriage are just jokes

I'm no RDR2 expert, this is just how I remember it from years ago.

I find it funny how Mexicans had more rights than the Chinese immigrants, native Americans and black slaves

>>715441426
>literally every single human at the time was like this, trust me bro

>>715441142
The issue with RDR2 isn't that Arthur wants people to be treated fairly, it's that he wants the opposite. It's never
>well, we oughta get along with them injuns
>well, why not let them women vote like us?
it's
>them injuns and negroes sure is better and smarter and mo' sophisticated than us white folk
>them womenfolk is smart, we menfolk is dumb and shouldn't be in charge o' anything
An egalitarian outlaw would make sense, but instead he's a self-flagellating resident of coastal California from 2015.

>>715441476
it can be fascinating to read the justification for different levels of racism back in the day, from very educated people no less

>>715441476
Its because "white" its a pretty fluid term and not actually well founded in biology, its more of a cultural term than anything.

>>715436089 (OP)
>pretending RDR 2 was a good game
Only the faggots on youtube do that

>>715441564
it was a different (and better) time

>>715436089 (OP)
I was never able to finish, the game is a fucking chore to play and the writing takes itself too serious considering how bland it is

>>715441715
by any possible metric it's a generational masterpiece

>>715441669
For me its that one case where courts had to decide if some Hawaiian dude was white or not.

>>715441407
This niggas alone in life point and laugh >>715441383
Yeah RDR2 for the most part just pays lip service to social issues and that's it. Most of the time he's only helping to act as cover for a heist like the feminists, or later game when he's dying and wants to do some "good". Almost always it just boils down to do an escort mission and that's it which is boring as fuck.

I tried to be a hero by saving Mary's brother from a cult. I rescue him and bring him back on horseback to meet Mary at the station.

>I come careening into town way too fucking fast.
>Can't stop in time to tie up my horse.
>Smash into the fucking barrier, crippling my horse, myself, Mary's brother and another horse which was hitched up there.
>Start mashing buttons to get back on my feet.
>Other horse which I REKT is pissed at me and kicks me in the fucking head, sends me flying through the air.
>I land in the middle of the street in a broken heap.
>"Sheeiiiittt"
>Mashing buttons to get back up.
>Suddenly I automatically have my hands around the throat of a random passer-by.
>Do not want any of this to be happening.
>Let him go.
>No options on screen to defuse the situation.
>Aw-fuck-sake.jpg
>Try to walk away
>Dude now starts fighting me.
>Meanwhile, across the street, Mary's brother is literally curb-stomping the horse who kicked me into the fucking ground.
>People screaming everywhere.
>Dude fighting me won't give up, I have to beat him to a pulp to make him stop.
>By now people have run off to report me to the sheriff for 'Disturbing The Peace'.
>Lawmen show up instantly and start showering me with bullets.
>Why is this happening to me?
>Shoot back to defend myself.
>Now I'm a wanted man and the whole place is out to get me.
>I now have to murder everyone in the fucking town.

I was just trying to be a nice guy...

>>715441463
Can I shoot the fag? or is the mission mandatory?

best game of the last generation and tendies are still seething

>>715436089 (OP)
>I rob, kill and kidnap people. But I ain't no god dang racist.

>>715441463
Nah there's a gay interracial couple sidequest and he's all pro interracial fags humping each other. I'm not joking.

Here's the thing for you people who want racism to be presented "historically accurate"

The most racially diverse groups in history are often criminal gangs. Pirates and American outlaws. Who knows how they got along or what their dynamics were, but it's a fact that it wasn't uncommon to see many black men on a pirate crew or in a robber gang. The problem is that to a modern Californian writer, the gang of criminals that are robbing, raping and murdering are better people than the white victim who has some racist views. To them, having a good opinion on race or gender trumps everything else and automatically makes you better than everyone else.

Why didn't they just copy The outlaw Josey Wales or any other good outlaw western?

>>715441669
>It is true that the course of events has brought the Indian tribes within the limits of the United States under subjection to the white race; and it has been found necessary, for their sake as well as our own, to regard them as in a state of pupilage, and to legislate to a certain extent over them and the territory they occupy...

>>715436089 (OP)
I enjoyed it for what it was.

>>715437705
Ok but forcing the player character to slow to a walk and holster their guns when entering the indian camp was pretty fucking gay thoughbeit.

Ackshually califronia is just liberal in the cities, most whitee in Cali actually are Republican now.

>>715437759
Me too. 360/ps3/wii was the last time we got actual games. Games these days are all basically simulators. Graphics fags should be on their knees 24/7 for us gameplay fags. They've been proven wrong beyond a shadow of a doubt.

RDR2 is the best game ever

>Why?

…

!

>>715442092
Were they wrong tho

>>715442008
Pirates were still racist, they just (mostly) disliked slavery. That and slave ships returning from the Americas were usually filled to the brim with cash, might as well grab some willing cannon fodder in the form of freed slaves that probably won't live long enough to get paid

>>715442613
This comes right after a passage talking about how indians were organized in legally recognized foreign nations. Then the smooth transition into "and over THE COURSE OF EVENTS we HAPPENED to take over these nations. To TUTOR them, of course ". It's a bit on the nose

>>715442735
Racism as we understand it didn't exist before Americans conjured it up from their weird puritanic collective consciousness. The idea of "white people" and nonwhites was completely unknown. People thought in terms of religion and language before anything else

It's a good game.
Sorry if you're a latinx, you wouldn't get it.

>>715437004
this

>>715442506
because it has amazing graphics, a massive open world full of random events, thousands of context-dependent interactions between NPCs and for the most part allows you to free roam and do whatever you find fun (except the indian camp and the blackwater area as Arthur)

>>715440479
Call me crazy but I genuinely believe Arthur was designed to be the most likeable protagonist across ever. He simultaneously appeals to everyone, he genuinely seems like he was manufactured in a lab. And this is R* most expensive videogame to produce, it's obvious they would take no risk and do everything to appeal to the widest possible audience.

The physics and everything are alright, but the dogshit menus and everything else like crime systems and shit are some of the worst things I've experienced in any game. Was hunting a deer out in the middle of fucking nowhere and got a wanted bounty for skinning the thing, animal cruelty or some shit.

>>715436089 (OP)
It's just a game to be impressed with the presentation and detail of to hold your attention.
The gameplay is somehow both shallow and jank if you're not just doing scripted story missions.

The biggest crime of this game that goes unaddressed all the time wasn't the boring animations, slogging pace, terrible writing, woke pandering, or rail shooter mission design, but the fact the game was so fucking piss your pants easy. Arthur could take 500 headshots and still have half his health left. It was so obscenely fucking easy.

>>715441767
Agreed, it's the most boring game of this generation

After beating it twice i really dont go back to it to goof around in. Theres not much to do. Not enough bandit camps ot anything. Also the environment is beautiful but theres not like really wild overlooks or whatever. Its just realistic. I like horizon more for wandering around an environment. Its more wild and varied.

But the first time though and after it was one of the greatest games ever.

>>715436089 (OP)
You know, for fags that claim that gameplay is king, you sure as shit ain't talking a lot about the gameplay

>>715442801
Yeah, but were they wrong?

>>715444378
well yes because being wiped out by whites is not "necessary for their sake"

rdr2 isn't a wild west / western game
its a industrial revolution game

rdr1 was great because it borrowed from the great wild west movies for those that didn't know /realize
rdr2 is like a made for tv movie on the LOGO channel
none of the characters are memorable except sadie & that's because her character is so over the top & ridiculous
its closer to being a movie than a game theres WAY too much 'hand holding'
Dutch is a sissy the whole time i was playing im thinking why the fuck would anyone follow this asshole.

>>715440705
every time Rockstar makes a game people focus on the stupid story when that's the weakest element in any of their games

>>715443261
>full of random events
lol
>hey it's me again, i got bitten by a snake for 12th time!

>>715444545
I have 108 hours into my save and I've seen the snakebitten dude twice. And Arthur remarks about how he's seen him before, too. Also he bought me an outfit from the store so he's based in my book

>>715436089 (OP)
>Americans werent extremely racist in the past!!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African_dodger

>>715444417
How many other tribes did they wipe out before the white man came? At least we gave them reservations. You know what they did to their losing tribes? Killed and ate every man, woman and child and you'll never know what they called themselves. That is barbarity. What we did was better than anything they could have asked for or deserved.

>>715444684
>Indians exist for 10,000 years without wiping out each other despite their barbarity
>whites wipe out 95% of them and put the rest in camps
>this is the civilized option

>>715444824
>>Indians exist for 10,000 years without wiping out each other despite their barbarity
Not him but I don't think you understand how many Indian tribes got genocided by each other. There were once hundreds if not thousands of tribes across the Americas and by the time Europeans arrived it'd been reduced to several dozen.

>>715441806
>Yeah RDR2 for the most part just pays lip service to social issues and that's it.
except for this character who ruins it every time she's onscreen

>>715444909
>reduced to several dozen
there are currently over 550 federally recognized native american tribes. I guess the US government went around randomly creating new ones

>>715444824
fuck you asshole those people were savages

>>715444824
Are you fucking retarded? They were fighting each other since we fucking came here. There may have been tentative peace between some tribes of equal strength but the second a chance presented itself to fuck over their rivals, they took it. If you're going to sit there and pretend like the indians never warred with each other then you're a fucking moron and everyone knows it. Where are the mississippians then, you fucking clown?

>>715445040
point out to where I said they didn't fight or kill each other

>>715445026
savages without machine guns were wiped out by savages with machine guns

>>715444636
>also known as hit the nigger baby

We used to be a real country...

>>715445024
I mean the Spaniards led to the formation of multiple new tribes, as did the British and French, because they broke up tribal confederations that were formed by tribal warfare and genocide.

>>715436089 (OP)
As soon as I get a lobotomy to become retarded - that's when I'll call RDR 2 a "bad game"

>>715441869
>Can I shoot the fag?
You "can" but if you do the game closes and you're locked out from booting it up again.

>>715445085
>Hurr durr, they still existed so they must not be that bad
You know nothing of american history and neither does anyone else because there are several cultures that were wiped completely off the face of the map long before any white man came. Where were their reservations?

>>715445206
so after 10,000 years of mutual genocide there were 3 million indians (low end estimate) when europeans arrived, and there were 200k on the 1900 census after 200 years of civilizing them

>>715445282
lol really?

the words racist / sexist / bigot etc etc are modern inventions
the game was written by trannies well educated on how to turn any and everything into a psycho-babble word salad
no other country would allow its history to be abused like this

>>715441767
In technical achievement only. It's remarkably bland to actually play.

>>715445292
the fact that you consider human beings put in "reservations" as some sort of mercy or a sign of civilization is baffling

>>715445424
it remains a top 30 game on Steam despite having no new content and no mods for 7 years

>>715445298
>indians on a census
Is this nigga for real?
>Hey chief squats on rock, can you fill out this form for me?
The fact we made 200k capable of filling out the form proves we uplifted them.

>>715436089 (OP)
rockstar games have never been good videogames.
they can be fun narrative and interactive experiences with a strong presentation that you enjoy if you like the setting.

but objectively speaking as far as games go, they have always been 6/10 games

>>715437759
same here, so much tedious shit in rdr and such a sluggish feel to it all

>>715445432
As opposed to killing the mothers and their babies? Yeah, I do.

>>715445535
some dude went around asking people and wrote them down. You're not required to write on a census, sure as hell not in 1900 when so many people were still illiterate

>>715445603
ok so if someone takes all your shit and JUST puts you on some empty pasture I'm sure you'll be so thankful because they technically could've ass raped and killed you instead

>>715445608
Yeah bro, some white dude rides into an indian camp and starts counting them. GTFO of here.

>>715445298
>so after 10,000 years of mutual genocide there were 3 million indians (low end estimate) when europeans arrived
The original population of American Indians across the Western Hemisphere was in the tens of millions if not much higher. The Aztecs alone were believed to have massacred at least a million or more, and it's well-documented that they mandated around 20,000 human sacrifices a year on top of aggressively conquering and genociding tribes that resisted them.

you limp wristed sissies dont even acknowledge that the native savages invented 'real estate'
we bought the land
ever heard the term 'indian giver' you stupid ass zoomer? we'renot allowed to use that term anymore, wonder why?

>>715445720
literally yes you fucking tard, how else do you think this shit was done?

>>715445687
Except the person that got put out was the aforementioned ass rapist. Why would you take pity on the ass rapist?

>>715439136
yeah and who put a stop to this? you little nazi bitch
Tyrone is gonna have a field day with your little pussy

>>715445757
I'm talking specifically about Indians in the current USA. Of course the warmer and more fertile central america was way more densely populated

>>715445771
It wasn't done.

>>715441383
>well it does happen several times, but not enough to meet my imaginary criteria I've decided upon (I am biased)

>>715445814
>the person that got put out was the aforementioned ass rapist

>>715445858
What happened to the mississippians, you stupid fucking fag. You want made in america shit, answer that question.

>>715445887
do you think it wasn't done specifically for indians or that censuses in general are a jewish scam? I want to know how deep this rabbit hole goes

>>715436089 (OP)
It was phenomenal. One of the few open world games I got “lost” in where I would just go explore and hunt for hours instead of doing missions.

>>715445917
>well it does happen several times but not even half the times retards on /v/ claim
yeah I don't see the issue

>>715436089 (OP)
>subhuman incels upset Arthur wasn't trash like they are

>>715444824
The only significant difference is the technological advancement and ability to collectively organize. People are people all over.

>>715445974
>What happened to the mississippians, you stupid fucking fag
quick check online says a combination of disease, warfare and resource depletion wiped them out. Is there a point to this?

>>715446104
I say the same thing about the Holocaust

>>715446193
I could tell

>>715436089 (OP)
>"We're just trying to survive why can't the law leave us alone :("
>Casually kills 50 lawmen every mission

>>715436089 (OP)
Why would you pretend a good game is good

>>715446257
>NOOOO U CANT KILL PEOPLE THAT WANT TO KILL YOU

>>715446257
that's the point and it's why Hosea and Arthur lose patience with Dutch. There was no reason to go after that Cornwall train, no reason to save Micah and let him butcher half of Strawberry, etc.

>>715446031
census is smart thats why the romans started it

Hitler also realized this that why he tattooed prisoners of war to keep a historical account of the work camp population
and apparently he started at 6 million and counted backwards from there

>>715436089 (OP)
All I did in this game was hunt and sell the pelts to buy shit. I never finished it because I didn't care about the story.

>>715446257
>kill entire population of a town in canonical mission
>go there later
>town is repopulated and no one cares
>shopkeeper who dies in scripted event is also alive now

>>715446409
to be fair zero games handle this well

>>715446385
The writing is so fucking retarded. Dutch is obviously insane and Micah is obviously evil within the first 30 minutes of the game, yet it's only halfway through that Hosea and Arthur, the "reasonable" ones, even begin to question him and only 3/4s of the way through that Arthur finally goes against him.

>>715446457
>to be fair to the 600 million dollar project,

>>715446409
Literally where I gave up on the game ever being as good as people claim it is

>>715446493
Dutch was a good leader back in the day and Arthur owes him everything. Most of the group does. Their loyalty prevented them from calling him out when he became obsessed with revenge and quick money

>>715446510
To be fair no one but autists care about that and play games for fun

>murder an entire town for a bag of oatmeal

Boring fucking game. My least favourite game I've played this year. Ugh just thinking about it makes me mad.

I want RDR3 to double down on the realism stuff, I really liked the core system in RDR2, imagine a AAAA survival game set in the wild west, kino levels could be out of this world

>>715446589
To be fair, "gamers" are human scum and we only permit them to draw breath so that they may pay more taxes.

>>715446630
the seethe on /v/ would almost be too much to handle

>>715441426
>1800s America
Bro you act like the game takes place in the Antebellum South... It takes place in a fictitious western frontier in the 1890s. Arthur also isn't a typical American... The entire synopsis of the story is that he (and John) were raised since childhood by Dutch's gang of criminal misfits... They aren't normal dudes, raised in normal society, by normal people.

>>715437528
t. only plays mainstream slop

>>715446457
It's a scripted mission though, not the player fucking around in the open world
Even then games like New Vegas or Baldur's Gate 3 let you kill characters permanently.

>the german guy is a shylock

fuck rdr2

>>715436089 (OP)
I didn't like it because playing it is tedious as fuck. Didn't even make it to most of the cringe politics shit.

>>715446724
>kill characters permanently
yes and their corpses will just lay out in the open and nobody will reference them at all. At least that's the case in bethesda games

>>715436089 (OP)
Rockstar isn't even based in cali you dumb faggot

>got $10,000 by chapter 3

>lives in a tent on the side of the road

>>715446724
you're comparing apples and oranges anon

>>715437528
>games
It's maybe one of the best collections of assets and details put into an open world ever, but it is a shit game.

>>715437536
It's not that big of a part, but every couple of hours they force one scene in there. Stuff like making a big show that the outlaws did not approve of someone using the magical n-word.

>>715446179
You're crying about genociders being given places to live instead of being genocided themselves like they deserve. The fact they're around today to bitch about it shows how benevolent the white man truly is. The mississippians, or whatever they called themselves, don't get that pleasure.

>>715446873
it was never very clear to me what Dutch and his gang want in the long run. "Buy some land" ok and? Become farmers? They'd kill themselves before doing manual labor for a living

>>715446958
does it cross your mind that the vast majority of native americans weren't responsible for the mississippians dying out?

>>715446873
Yeah because they are criminals running from the law. Buying property and settling down in one place isn't particularly conducive to evading the authorities.

>we need to get away from the law and civilization
>relocate camp half a mile down the road
>oh no we got found we really need to lay low now
>relocate camp a mile down the road

>>715446257
>game tries very hard to be immersive
>sometimes even too hard with making you go through a 3 second animation for every little thing you do
>mission starts
>small village with 10 houses
>300 police officers spawn in from nowhere
>complete clown car shit show
Immersion ruined.

>hurr le durr movie game
>meanwhile an actually cowboy movie game

>>715447027
They each had their own personal mississippian, you've just never heard of them because they were, you know, genocided, you fucking retard.

>>715447121
>They each had their own personal mississippian
coping strategy to excuse genocide
>they had it coming I swear ! Even if there is no evidence you KNOW they were animals!
and now whites have their own mississippians too but they saved 5% in guarded trailer parks so it's all good

>>715446786
Never said it was perfect, but better than NPCs magically respawning like nothing happened

>>715447052
exactly
how the fuck do cops in sain denis / blackwater know i just curbstomped some guy in an alley? 10¢ bounty and im being shot at
rdr2 is dogshit

>cutscene
>click button to raise glass
>click button to raise bottle
>click button to pour
>do it 10 more times
>cutscene
so this is the masterpiece /v/ has been going on about and I'm too brown to appreciate

>>715447310
it's ok man I hear a new Dragon Ball is coming out

>>715447042
>wahh the game doesn't let me spend weeks trudging through hundreds of miles of wilderness between campsites

>>715447307
>how the fuck do cops in sain denis / blackwater know i just curbstomped some guy in an alley
they don't, you just let a witness live

Game lets me hunt animals, fish, and have a comfy life with beautiful landscapes. That's good enough for me

>>715447374
haven't watched anything past dbz, new dragonball is the rdr2 of dragonball

>>715447268
Show me a single peaceful indian tribe that never killed anyone. Just one. They all came to be out of conquest. You assume an absence of evidence is an evidence of absence. These tribes would've left behind nothing to recognize them. They are truly lost to history because some other indian tribe, the ones you're simping for, destroyed them to the last baby. You are given absolute proof of this in several ways yet you handwave it away. You are the faggiest fag to ever fag.

>antagonizes some npc
>8 cops start shooting you

life was harder back then

>>715446650
Yeah there are losers that play weeb gooner games but that has nothing to do with RDR2

first half of the game is great
but it all comes crashing down with the big bank heist

why waste all that dev time and money by making the tropic island?
rest of the game is just misery porn, what a slog to get through

also, the camp upgrades being meaningless, no fast travel and nothing to spend money on in general sucked

>muuuh my shooting cowboy action game has too many gunfights :(((

>>715444983
?? She's a hired gun and barely had a story other than "aw outlaws bad" wtf does this mean mong use your words

>>715439034
/v/ will obviously fall for this obvious ragebait

>>715447453
so immediately EVERY cop knows to shoot me even cops on the other side of town.?
you type with your ass?

>game is a western
>has prostitutes
>you can't hire them
Ummm why???

>>715437598
>pudding
*budín.

>>715436089 (OP)
Red Dead Online alone and the way it forces me to log in every day to do a fucking daily hoping that in the future they will work and expand it so much that I will finally have a use for the literal thousands of gold bars I have made me despise this game with a passion.

>>715447505
>Show me a single peaceful indian tribe that never killed anyone. Just one
ok, the Mi'kmaq Nation

>>715447687
you can hire them for a bath

>>715447674
would you prefer that a judge authorizes an arrest warrant for you and you go through a 6 month trial with multiple instances you fag? It's a video game. Every game does some variation of this

>>715447589

9 years to make the game and half the map is from the old game

>>715447589
>the camp upgrades being meaningless
>no fast travel
Fast travel is one of the camp upgrades, then you can use it at any campfires you set up in the woods.

>>715447736
I can bathe myself but I can't get my dick sucked alone without hurting my back

>>715436089 (OP)
Played it for an hour, hated how "realistic" everything was, having to open drawers and cabinets, peeling open cans, having to search inside people's coats, everything took way too fucking long and I was barely "playing" anything. Tried Online, it was more of the same. RDR 1 was infinitely better in comparison, I have no idea why they made the game so obtuse when all it needed was a new campaign and a graphics update. I didn't even make it far enough in to care about the politics.

I just got the game while it was on sale, tell me what I'm in for. Can I make my character go yeehaw?

>>715447609
who tf said tgat? you probably dont even shoot 400 bullets the whole game minus hunting
65 playable hours and theres like 8 minutes of total trigger time

>>715447863
no but you can make him say giddyup to his horse

>>715436089 (OP)
>No Mexico
>No Undead Nightmare
Absolute trash, zoomers will say otherwise

>>715447863
Another anon said it best. A very tedious game.
Imo it's best played on controller and on a couch. As a PC game it's just awful.

>>715436089 (OP)
>Woke Arthur
I mean, it had to be. We needed to be sympathetic to Arthur for the plot to be impactful. Yes, he needed to be a criminal, but he couldn't be a degenerate. If he was realistic for the average uneducated man of that age, He would likely call every black a nigger, probably not be excited about having any of them in camp, probably see the natives as subhuman infestation on the land, and his most woke opinion would be: "When you rape a woman, don't bust her up too bad". And then nobody would have been too broken up if he ate shit and died. This is true for many games where you play a "bad" guy. Pirates, Vikings, Bandits. Yeah you kill some people, but they keep it real low key on the "rape and pillaging" parts, everyone you kill in assassins creed just happens to be really really bad guys, so it's okay. Your protagonist needs some sort of moral high ground. That's why there's no fucking movies about how hard the nazis had it, having to run all those concentration camps, with the jews being all uppidy about it. Doesn't read well.

>>715439034
Modern people can't really conceive of what historical racism actually was.
It was more casual, but less hateful.
People weren't just going around shooting brown people in the face for existing.
A lot of it was "positive racism". People were very interested and curious about "those people over there", in ways that are now considered exploitative and wrong, but that's just the frame of modern politics.
Actually read old books, and listen to old people without shaking your head at them because they said "red Indian" or something. You'll start to get it.

is uncle tom's cabin woke?

>We need to have our protagonist say nigger nigger nigger I hate niggers over and over again to appease 0.00001% of the audience (that will likely just pirate our game) while possibly alienating everyone else

>>715448087

The multiplayer mode is getting zombies and werewolves and robots.

>>715447863
It's a fun game when you're doing anything but the story. From the very first story mission to the last you're a puppet on strings who'll be punished for walking left when the game demands right.

i just wanna ride a buffalo online

like every rockstar game, there’s like 20 filler missions before a a few missions that move the plot along, absolutely dog shit pacing

>>715448784
I don't mind filler missions but I hate this thing that started in GTA V (I think) where you do something in a mission that you will NEVER do in free roam. Makes things feel like a movie

they should've never did a prequel they should've just made a whole new story that had nothing to do with rdr1
its my belief that the houser brothers wanted to destroy benzies masterpiece rdr1 theres no other explanation

This board is fat tendie central
Rockstar shits on you

>>715448492
>>We need to have our protagonist say nigger nigger nigger I hate niggers over and over again to appease 0.00001% of the audience
more like 99% of the audience

>>715436089 (OP)
Don't complain to me, I was shitting on it the week it came out. RDR2 is solely responsible for me no longer buying games full price at release.

>>715437536
Arthur's most controversial political stance is that he thinks voting is stupid. Otherwise he's practically non-offensive cowboy from the 1899. He's not even casually racist or sexist for banter.

>>715447863
>tell me what I'm in for.
45 second long animations for picking up a piece of paper.

>>715449383
he is asexual too

>>715436089 (OP)
>paid 70 bucks
>forced missions
>endless talking, nobody would shut up
>clanky controls that belong in the 90s
Uninstalled that garbage after an hour

>>715449661
you didn't even finish the tutorial dumbass

>>715441564
>gangs of murdering outlaws were not bigots

>>715436089 (OP)
>modern writers using historical fiction to show how their modern political views fit in to the world of the past, despite common claims to the contrary
This is literally as old as historical fiction as a concept.

>>715449717
they are more like con artists and only really murderous when confronting the irish gang

>>715447624
sadie is a walking embodiment of the feminism crap of the game

>>715449804
You didn't play the game, what a retarded post

>>715447696

Unironically the best comment in this thread so far.

Have you guys tried red dead online? It is insanely shit.

>>715450047
i have, and killing lawmen doesn't count, it's part of the job. they went after those hillbillies because they kidnapped the kid.

>>715444824
They wiped out rival tribes you spastic.
Also under whites there's more native Indians now than in the past, you double spastic.

>>715448784
>dog shit
Yee this shit be dog shit not bussin on god fr fr no cap ahhh

>>715448330
>It was more casual
Yes
>but less hateful.
No.
You are conflating the fact that there was more casual racism, with the idea that racism was more casual.
Like yes, it was more common to do "small" racisms, like calling someone a spic, or not wanting to be seen with a nigger, but at the same time, there was literally chattel slavery, nigger lynchings, cross burnings
>People weren't just going around shooting brown people in the face for existing.
Sometimes they were! Like, very much sometimes black & brown people where just fucking killed for being in the wrong place at the wrong time.

I hate that woke slop since day 1

>>715450170
nigga the fuck you think they had 0 casualties in their robbing career? They literally admitted they all have blood on their hands, civilians or otherwise.

>>715450534
KEK now post your weight

>>715436089 (OP)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ex10r7R3NcY

>>715448287
>I mean, it had to be. We needed to be sympathetic to Arthur for the plot to be impactful.
And because of the way he was constructed, as a schizophrenic non-character whose views and character changes depending on the quest you're on. A man who espouses modern day Californian liberal political views all the while massacring entire villages of white people (very fitting), he wasn't sympathetic at all to anyone who isn't a political-religious extremist.

He shoots up the whole male population of that little mountain town without any of them deserving it, but somehow he gets upset over racism. This is pretty much how the fucking woke mind works at this point. Mass murder and usury are wonderful and acceptable, but don't you dare do the hecking racism!

>>715447863
Its a basic Cabella hunting game with a very bad drama plot atached to it.

>>715448571
This is the attitude towards this and mgs5 that makes me respect the games as experiences that are not for me but clearly have an audience and cater to it well. The stories and missions in the games seem secondary to the freedom the open world provides. People love going hunting, looking at scenery, and riding their horse around. Where it fails for me is the distinct lack of structure, which is the thing others like best. I want a tightly designed number of set pieces in a mgs game for instance. I also want the feeling of isolation of being tactically inserted into a bizarre situation that plays out as the plot is uncovered. People that like mgs5 enjoy that they can slide their cardboard box down a hill and then leap into the air and headshot 5 guards while they’re traveling across the map.

>>715451220
>modern day californian liberal political views
Nigger stop watching right wing youtubers, the dude still murdered, blackmailed and killed.

>>715445330
how gullible are you exactly?

>>715451408
That is exactly what Californian liberals espouse. Murder, blackmail and killing are A-ok, as long as you're not racist. And preferably when you're killing white people, because the core political view of these people is anti-white racism.

>>715442008
>To them, having a good opinion on race or gender trumps everything else and automatically makes you better than everyone else.
>game is about a brutal outlaw who experiences a critical moment of self-reflection after his life begins to end as a direct consequence of his crimes
>game is literally named REDEMPTION implying he has has done something requiring him to achieve it
>a guy who grew up in an ecoterrorist commune and has anti-social opinions for his time trumps everything else and automatically makes him better than everyone else
retard

>>715449229
I just see two incredible games

>>715437536
There is a mandatory mission where you are forced to drive a Women's Suffrage Wagon.

>>715441075
san francisco dlc

>>715451452
>My political enemy must believe what I believe, but in reverse!
based brainlet.

>>715436089 (OP)
I don't care about the messaging, R* has always been like that and included positive gay shit in their games, what i hate is how FUCKING BORING like 80% of the game is. It's like they took RDR1 and dropped it in molasses. I get that things were slower and R* wants to embody that by making you appreciate that slowness, but god damn there's a limit. This is coming from someone who camped Notorious Monsters in FFXI, so don't even start with the "it's a you problem" bullshit, I have patience, I just also know when something is wanting it.

>visiting a normalfag friend in another state
>he is telling me about the games he likes
>"yeah I really like red dead redemption 2 its like youre actually playing a movie but like its a game"
>LOL hard as fuck for a solid minute

>>715453638
you chuckled for half a second at most

>>715448287
I agree wtih you but they could achieve that by simply skipping the lecturing side of shallow modern politics.
He doesn't have to be a racist but he also doesn't have to be "anti racist." Why the fuck DO we know so many of his views about typical modern terminally-online political issues? These quests and dialogues didn't write themselves.
When people think it's hilarious that he's so progressive on anything and wants to defend interracial gay couples, they're not saying he should have shot them on sight, they're saying he shouldn't even see them. We shouldn't know his opinion on this to begin with.
You don't have many pirate and viking protagonists that go around raping people, yes, but you also don't really have many who even touch on the subject. How many times does Jack Sparrow lecture the audience on rape being bad?

I cannot imagine a more awful existence than being a turbo contrarian. The idea that you have such a strong desire to be "yooniq" that you simply cannot enjoy things that others also enjoy sounds fucking miserable. Just develop a real personality and enjoy things.

>>715453586
>R* has always been like that
What exactly was gay about GTA 2 and 3?

>>715453638
No wonder he turned out normal and you turned out a troon

>>715454128
I'm sure there's something you dislike that's popular
there's an implication in your post that this particular thing is above dislike because it's just SOOO GOOOD
someone could make that argument about that thing you dislike and call you a turbo contrarian too

>>715454149
Isn't there a blatant lesbian thing in GTA3? Maria and uh... god damn... that other bitch I can't remember the name of.

>>715436089 (OP)
As soon as we stop pretending elden ring was good

>>715454128
>anyone who doesn't enjoy what I enjoy is just faking it
Why do you absolutely need everyone to agree with you and like what you like? Are you so insecure and without your own character that you can't handle others disagreeing with you?

>>715436089 (OP)
You guys are giants that can change the tide of video games except when you're not.

>>715439527
this didnt happen though you disingenuous faggot loser, maybe actually play the game and not run around lying on the internet like a pussy little manchild bitch

I think RDR2 is the first game that really made me reflect on how realism is killing games. No, I don't need a cutscene of Arthur opening up a cabinet to loot a can a bans. No, I don't need to be forced to slow walk through camp because you wouldn't sprint around irl. No, I don't want to manually look through shelves to buy stuff.
Beautiful scenery, though

>>715455115
He isn't lying (at least not intentionally), he just doesn't actually know what he is saying isn't true because he didn't even play the game. He didn't even form his own opinion. Some retard on youtube gave him that opinion and he is just repeating it because he is also terminally online and can't think for himself.

>>715455115
After I just got done running around killing random animals for their skins as the game wants for me to improve camp, I'm forced to do a mission with an indian where I'm heavily motivated to kill someone for killing an animal for their skins

>>715455282
Is that the mission that portrays the mass-killing of buffaloes as something the white man did, while the native Americans only took what they needed (lmao)

>>715453921
>I agree wtih you but they could achieve that by simply skipping the lecturing side of shallow modern politics.
I don't think RDR2 is lecturing even in the slightest. Like yeah, Arthur is pretty woke for an outlaw of his time, but he's not like "You shall know, a black and a red is just as human as a white! We must stop this injustice" he's just, ya know, not shitty to the indians.

>>715456183
>indians
Use their actual tribe names, don't erase them with your shitty european otheriing

>>715449494
>Had a son
>Used to stretch out Abigail
>Also still carrying a torch for Mary
I don't think asexual describes him.

>>715437528
Even compared to the first one it's dogshit. The first one had better physics, shooting, sandbox elements and it didn't force you to watch animations whenever you pressed a button. You don't need to bitch about the story and writing to know that it's a bad game, I didn't engage with that crap at all when I dropped it. Dodge a bullet apparently. Still waiting on the crowbcat video to drop so people finally realize that RDR2 is an inferior game.

>>715457621
you just told everyone that you didn't play the first game

>>715456183
>I don't think RDR2 is lecturing even in the slightest.
It considers racism worse than any other crime. It paints the Indians as holy custodians of the land.

mass murderer passing judgment on a former slave owner:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zsiiSVKx8b0&ab_channel=Nestan

watch this if you're too dumb to catch on to propaganda yourself:
>>715450974

Only if we stop pretending bore of the wild or its $70 dlc were good first.

>>715438543
>ignores everything about the period
>except for that women's rights thing, and when it does indulge in that part of history thats BAD because im an angry chud and dont actually care about period pieces or whatever
>also that part where you go to slave owners plantation and read his ledger where he keeps his record of black slave sales
>but thats also bad because le woke trying to tell me slavery is bad
>also that whole part of the story where dutch and arthur are helping indians fight off the army, and the whole native american thing im just ignoring because woke
>actually, fuck history and whatever point i was trying to make i've never actually played red dead 2 and im just mad

>>715442278
>how come the guy who's spent his life in an anarchist gang that violently opposes the federal government sympathizes with the Indians?

>>715456183
It's lecturing by association. Jonathan Reid never stops, look at the camera and defends immigration, women's rights and condemns Donald Trump in 1918 england, but the fact that the game puts a woman fighting for women's rights and paints her in a positive light as she goes on about her politics while it doesn't stop to put any other kind of political opinion or movement in your path says all that needs to be said. The fact that the villain makes a speech about raising a wall to keep undesirables out and other Trump parodies in a 2018 games IS lecturing. It's not a real life encounter, things are added to games for a reason.
Again, how many times does Jack Sparrow makes any comment at all on rape? He doesn't, the series manages to take a historically more-likely-to-be-a-rapist-than-not character archetype and whitewash it to make him sympathetic by simply not making that a part of his story.
If Arthur's story never made him drive a Women's Suffrage Wagon nobody would be questioning why he wasn't going around shitting on women and feminists. People wouldn't think or talk about that at all. It IS lecturing.

>>715437536
Mostly no, but there's quite a whiplash in some missions where Arthur decides it's time to virtue signal

>>715457740
For comparison, I got really into hunting in the first game. You could skip the skinning animation if you wanted to. You didn't have to watch John kneel down and schlick schlick schlick every single time. Played the hunting in the second one and there was no way to skip the animation. The horses in the first one, though janky, threw me off way less often than the second one. Ironically this is less realistic in the second one, because in real life if you've ever ridden a horse it has an instinct for self preservation and won't let you put it into a situation where it would get hurt. It's going to stop and refuse to continue no matter how hard you press it. That's just two examples, but overall the physics and sandbox were inferior in the second game. The only things that's better in the second is the graphics if you're into photorealism.

>The looks of loathing on the faces of the locals delighted me
a woman wrote this

>>715455890
wasn't the point of that scene that the government was paying whites to kill all the bison to starve the indians? That just happened IRL lol, the natives didn't drive the bison to near extinction, that was the white man's greed.

Even if I ignore that shit, the follow the dotted line gameplay and how useless money making shit was made me hate it.
Why even bother with all that stuff, when all the heists and shit give you way more money than you'll ever need.

>>715450473
The idea that the average person on the street back then was reduced to some frothing at the mouth murder-psychopath, simply at the sight of a person of a different race, just isn't really true. There would probably be understandable apprehension, but at the same time poor people had to make a living and deal with the people around them.
Read Moby Dick, idk. Read Heart of Darkness.

>>715458378
>wasn't the point of that scene that the government was paying whites to kill all the bison to starve the indians?
No. Blackdian guy whatever his name is gets personally angry over the loss of life and its portrayed as being justified and truthful, and as something only the white people do. Nobody at the time gave a single fuck about the bizon, which is why everybody killed them en mass.
Same as when later in the game you have obvious plains Indians, Iroquis style roaming gangs who torture and skin people alive for shits and giggles, but instead of being native Americans they're just a bunch of white guys instead.
>that was the white man's greed.
It wasn't greed at that point, it was an intentional military policy of attacking the "livestock" of these nomadic plains peoples in an effort to defeat them in warfare.

>>715437536
/v/ hates it so you know it's a good game

It is certainly overhyped and classic rockstar, in the sense it is very on rails and freedom in missions is non-existent, but the story is good, and roaming around hunting and fishing is peak comfy; the map is probably the best ever made in terms of feeling alive, the random encounters etc really do make it feel interactive, you actively avoid fast traveling because usually you know *something* will happen if you ride there, not to mention how pretty the game is
Arthur is a very likeable character, yes he has modern sensibilities but honestly if you understand how he was raised by dutch it makes a lot of sense

Definitely worth at least a try

>>715454128
You liked the game because you were dazzled by the production values, not because it was a good game that is actually fun to play. You are retarded.
You just want a movie where you pretend to press a button once every 5 minutes, that's fine, but that doesn't mean that people who play games in order to play games have some personality defect.

>>715460041
What about the posters who said they loved it, you faggot? What about them?

>>715460436
You're inbred.

>>715436089 (OP)
>no difficulty curve or enemy variety to keep the shooting interesting
>outside of weapon type (handgun, shotgun, rifle, etc) weapons are basically interchangeable
>story is a foregone conclusion because you know RDR1 happens and which characters are and aren’t present for it
>the entire crux of the narrative (make money to quit crime life for good) creates ludonarrative dissonance as you can easily make thousands of dollars ingame just by searching bodies you drop during regular gameplay but there’s nothing to spend it on
>tons of minigames and busywork like hunting, but none of it has any meaningful reward that changes the main game
>bloated cast full of interchangeable gruff cowboys and prostitutes you likely won’t even remember the names of without trying to (but your investment in them is supposed to be a driving motivator for the story)
>No fun DLC like Undead Nightmare where the game can actually do something creative and lighthearted rather than trying to act like a super serious movie game
>most of your gameplay time will be spent listening to people talk while on a horse or riding a horse silently and uneventfully through the forest because the map is oversized
I was super disappointed with RDR2. I dropped it after Arthur’s story was done, and I wish I had done so earlier.

>>715437536
>we are outlaws but we do NOT cross the line of le heckin racism!!!

>>715447115
>actual movie game is filled with gameplay
>hurr durr movie game is filled with holding forward in order to listen to endless dialogue
The more you know.

>>715436089 (OP)
I loved RDR1 but every single thing I've seen about RDR2 has been convincing me to avoid it even at a low discount.

>>715457979
>condemns Trump
Anon, the game came out before Trump was even born.

>>715446385
>and let him butcher half of Strawberry, etc.
they were making a move, he had to get it on

>>715450473
>chattel slavery
whites had it worse

>nigger lynchings
everyone got lynched. more whites were lynched than niggers

>cross burnings
oooo spooky. people can do whatever the fuck they want with their own property. it was a glorified bonfire

>>715446630
If there isn't a 1 minute tying your shoes animation every time I get out of bed I'm not buying. I also want it to be really finicky to actually get the animation to start. Like place 7 other interactable items right next to your shoes.

I know the meme from the Joke but why are people saying that their pretending to do or aknowledge something they dont believe in?
Like are there going to be long time atheists saying "I dont believe in god and Im tired of pretending I do." soon?

>>715460769
imagine having to click buttons to control each individual finger as you're trying to tie your shoes and people walking by going like "what in the name of god are you doing, you've been tying your shoes for an hour now", and because time goes faster it's night time by the time you finish and you have to go to bed again

>>715450974
>Old Rockstar would have had Arthur ask the suffragette , "How do you feel about my friend Lenny votin'?" If they were honest they would show that the suffragettes are just as racist as the Eugenicist guy.
This comment feels pretty spot on on the difference between old Rockstar and modern Rockstar when it comes to politics in their storytelling.

this board is a subreddit

this seething little janny tranny faggot was that mad. just kill yourself, loser

>>715449229
they are both boring but botw is considerably worse and somehow even easier than rdr2

Rockstar lost me after they started taking themselves seriously.

>>715447696
>>715450061
I really hope someone important in Rockstar reads this and takes good notes of it. Red dead online is a tremendous disgrace and they should work a lot on it.

>>715461598
Tabletop Tennis?

>>715436089 (OP)
I was having a lot of fun until I got to that part where you drive around the women's rights protest or whatever it was. I laughed and uninstalled.

>>715436089 (OP)
rdr2 was a weird game. it was basically made in the peak trump era and was thus an obvious victim of the liberals' many meltdowns over trump becoming prez. hell, there is a proto-feminist in the game that you could feed to the gators and then they hastily patched it out of the game when the youtubers started making too many videos about it. the gameplay was absolutely insane, but damn, the whole story thing was effed up... also, remember all the times they flee from "the pinkertons", aka, the same THREE fucking guys you interact with throughout the entire game? you murder hundreds of people throughout the game and arthur canonically has absolutely insane elite-tier shooting skills and is portrayed as extremely capable, but he can't fucking whack three simple pinkerton cunts??? it's even worse when they enter the camp, are you fucking telling me that all those fucking outlaws couldn't whack three or four fucking guys?? so yeah, the story is completely and utterly fucking braindead, but the gameplay is elite-tier.

>>715439034
didn't about half of the irishmen in lincoln's army leave the army, when they discovered that lincoln intended to free the slaves? people were a little bit more racist back then, than they are now...

>>715441669
all that blibber blabber was really just the legalese way of saying "fuck em! we own those fucking niggs now!", really..

>>715448330
no, people in the 1800s were racist as fuck and the vast majority of early labor unions wanted to deport all chinese people because they eat rice which is cheaper than bread.

>>715443637
it sold a giga fucking ton, so i'd say they succeeded. unfortunately, because now the protagonist in the third game will be an even bigger faggot...

>>715444057
i dropped it after completing it. by that point, i had played through it for a whole week, if not more, and had done practically everything. at that point, i had been utterly and completely satisfied and was good and ready to close the book on that game forever. maybe i'll play through it again a couple of years from now, who knows, but for now, i'm good..

>>715441973
That one annoyed me because up until the end i just thought they were friends.

Well, it's a decent cowboy simulator if you just ignore what passes for a story, which is just awful. But it's also just inferior as a Western compared to RDR1.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=23v-OwPWnFs
As for the wokeness, even the previous two games were pretty woke, but once the game takes you on a ride with suffragettes it becomes one of the greatest humiliation rituals seen in gaming.

>>715456749
They are okay with that.

>>715445024
how many of them are still pure and not mixed muttoids? it doesn't fucking count if you're 30 percent apache and 10 percent african and 60 percent irish, you know?

>>715460767
>whites had it worse
Demonstrably not true. Whites were at times kinds of slaves, most dominantly european whites were Serfs, but being a serf is objectively not worse than chattel slavery, As a serf you had some legal rights, and while it certainly was not a cushy fun time, you were not property the same way niggers were, Whites also never suffered slavery purely because of their whiteness.
>everyone got lynched. more whites were lynched than niggers
Nope! https://archive.tuskegee.edu/repository/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Lynchings-Stats-Year-Dates-Causes.pdf
1297 white lynchings, 3446 black lynchings, Niggers were lynched more in total number and specially more proportionally
>oooo spooky. people can do whatever the fuck they want with their own property. it was a glorified bonfire
Nigga they didn't go into their fields and have a fun bonfire night, they went to where the niggers lived and burned the crosses right in front of their homes as a warning to get the fuck out before it's them, you disengenious faggot.

DID YOU KNOW:
Both American political parties take donations for Israel and that "Two-Party System" is not a real thing? That is just a One-party state with controlled opposition.

>>715446615
how it should be done

>>715447810
rdr1 was indeed way more fun and streamlined as a game. it was made in different times... simpler times..

>>715437536
ignore the story after the first few missions past tutorial area and once youre exhausted, force yourself through it. the open world stuff is a lot more fun if you ignore the story. i'd say play till you get a fishing rod, but that still takes a while. god i hate this shit

>>715448287
>That's why there's no fucking movies about how hard the nazis had it, having to run all those concentration camps, with the jews being all uppidy about it
i swear, this shit makes me imagine it as a monthy python sketch or a black adder sketch. fucking lul.

>>715464816
Springtime, for hitler, and germany!~

>>715451263
speaking of, how are those games? i've never actually tried one of those.

>>715457743
i just chose the "not my place to judge" answer. was the right thing to do. i'm always nice to racists in my games. you just gotta be.

>>715441694
Yeah bro nobody can tell an African skull from a western European skull. Its just a mystery.
Retard.

>>715457962
>ita an rpg, you can play however you want
>unless we find it distasteful then just deal with it goy

>>715464165
i did know that, actually. crazy shit, if you ask me..

>>715436089 (OP)
Getting different perspectives as well as actually examining the story. It’s rather poorly written. Like Micah’s whole character and how the gang interacts with him makes no sense. He seems to be antagonistic and aggressive to everyone but Dutch and everyone but Dutch hates him. He is far too much of an asshole. Like why does this gang of criminals put up with some random retard that only joined five months ago and has caused nothing but problems? Like you would figure someone would have at least kicked his ass. It’s a shock no one has tried to bushwhack him while out on a job. Could have even played it off as him getting shot by whoever they were after. And the fact that no one put two and two together about how everything started falling apart after the Blackwater job (his idea) is retarded. Also Dutch being cool with him doesn’t make sense. Even if Micah is a bootlick he still shows traits that Dutch doesn’t like and has openly killed people for having. And that’s just one issue, there is also the shit with Arthur getting TB and going terminal in the span of what two months at most? That’s a disease that takes years to get bad.
>inb4 he was doing shit and getting into bad situations
So we’re the people that had it and it still took a while to kill them, it’s not a fast killing disease. In fact it was one of those diseases that ended up getting romanticized since it allowed for the sort of die surrounded by loved ones death people talk about.

>>715466402
the term tuberculosis didn't even exist back then

>>715466402
>It’s a shock no one has tried to bushwhack him while out on a job
you literally get so many chances where you could easily do this while playing the game, it really does boggle the mind why cuckstar absolutely insisted on having him be featured so prominently in the game..

>>715437536
It filters people with self-inflicted ADD because of the beginning at the mountains

>>715466402
>It’s a shock no one has tried to bushwhack him while out on a job.
I literally tried to do that during the jail break mission the moment he decided to go back for his gun. Basically lost interest for the game's story right there.

>>715464165
That's good and all, but you lost the election.

>Indians were peaceful and didn't kill eachother till the Yakub man rolled up
>muh noble savage
This is such an insane naive take I almost refuse to believe it isn't trolling.

>>715466816
The biggest one is when he is imprisoned in strawberry and all Arthur had to do was wait until he hanged and then could of just said “ah I’m sorry Dutch I was too late” and I imagine if Dutch tried to yell or give him shit Hosea or someone else would have stepped in and calmed him. Like they wanted their shitty hate sink character so badly. Could have made him interesting, like an undercover Pinkerton or some shit.

>>715466738
Yes, they called it consumption. But for the sake of this I’m calling it TB because most people don’t know that.

>>715437536
>your horse will randomly jump off things and run you into shit
>your horse is really fucking retarded and seems to want to kill itself as quickly as possible
>the horse AI is really bad
>the 300th skinning animation isnt much more fun than the 1st
>not able to finish the mission because X isnt in a pixel perfect spot
>wanted level because you bumped into some guy
>Microsoft flight simulator key mapping, for example to do a gun trick you have to triple tap tab, hold right mouse button and press 1 2 or 3
>story and gameplay are at odds with each other and often it makes no sense:
>murder the women suffrage rioter
>along with 69,420 citizens (including women)
>immediately Arthur turns around and says "aw shucks o'course ill help protect your women's rights protest!"

Its a solid 7/10 game. 6 of the points are from the world and gun play. 3 points for graphics. I deducted 2 points for the story and writing. Bummer.

>>715467352
yeah, that was absolutely terrible writing. i hated that moment so fucking much.

>>715439527
That never happens though. Also criminals were much more likely to actually have black people and indians since they weren't accepted in polite society.

You wouldn't have been an edgy outlaw. You would have been the guy at the bank afraid of the irish

>>715437536
He's very progressive, especially for the timeline. The only people he shits on in the camp are white characters, while talking up and idolizing charles and lenny and dutch. John, Bill and the irishman are his punching bags. There are several quests where he shits on racists and can kill them, same for slavers. He also drives a carriage and helps the womens suffrage movement, essentially the first wave of feminism. He's very anti-racism and pro diversity. He also laments not getting with abigail and raising jons son for him and marrying his ex. He also constantly insults himself in the mirror calling himself an ugly old depressed man. The furthest he goes into edgy is insulting a whore in the first chapter when she calls herself a "lady", because she was propositioning one of the gang members. He also refuses to have sex with prostitutes and is still hung up on his ex-gf who left him. Oh and supports sadie being the 1 man killing crew of the gang.

>>715441254
Trying too hard to fit in, election tourist

>>715442278
you cant even snipe them from distance kek. the reticule goes gray and arthur won't shoot. He'll kill men women and possibly children so long as theyre white but put an indian in front of his scope and he starts having misgivings.

>>715444983
>grabs knife
>runs into open field against odriscolls
>1v8's a bunch of men with guns with just a knife
>covered in blood
>arthur: w-wow, good job sadie!

>>715436089 (OP)
I enjoyed it. It's was comfy riding around hunting and fishing. I wish bounties were infinite like in RDR1. I also hate how the Valentine Robbery broke the game economy.

>>715436089 (OP)
There were radical progressives out west and across the US during the time the game took place
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haymarket_affair
Which largely took place because of a radical progressive ex confederate.

The late 19th and early 20th centuries had an entire radical anarchist movement which successfully assassinated a president in 1901. 2 years after Red Dead 2 takes place. People who think Arthur having mildly progressive views was unheard of at the time know nothing about the time.

>>715436089 (OP)
I'm too lazy to crop the retarded bottom, but the rest is on point.

>>715468482
Tony Soprano was an anti hero who just became more of a villain as time went on, Arthur was an anti hero who became more of a hero as time went on.

>>715441463
The most egregious racism bits are the former slave hunter and the black doctor in Lemoyne. The slave hunter because it is just the most beat-you-over-the-head writing I have ever seen and really only serves to kick some old drunk while he's dying and waste your time.

The doctor because that dude is a fruit and annoying, and because Arthur is just incapable of understanding the concept of racism during that mission.
>I was TOO CHEAP and TOO GOOD and TOO SMART and helping TOO MANY PEOPLE and also black in a former Confederate town.
>gee willikers mister I just cannot fathom why anyone would take umbrage with your presence. It surely is a mystery!
I don't think it's hard or even out of character to characterize Arthur as pretty egalitarian; he's part of a little Robin Hood gang and Dutch has been filling his head with romantic ideas all his life. It's just weird how fucking big his blinders are on very specific things, and sometimes that makes him feel like he fell out of a time machine.

>>715466402
Same for sadie. She basically takes everything Arthur stands for and completely shits all over it and he just smiles and makes shitty jokes.

>Arthur is strongly against unesssesary violence
>sadie kills for fun

>Arthur rejects revenge
>sadie exists for revenge

>Arthur likes careful planning to keep people safe
>sadie has no plan and doesnt care

Yet he despises Micah and sadie just gets lame ass jokes and excuses all her bullshit. Mary Sue shit aside, shes just as much as a cunt to Arthur as Micah and constantly talks down to him about his ideas. She basically just makes excuses for anything she does the same way Micah does it but she gets a pass. I wonder if her being a white woman is relevant. Her character is very overwritten and yet full of holes.

>antagonize a black man
>cops/whole town doesn't join in
Bullshit game.

>>715441694
kill yourself faggot

>>715447624
Sadie's pretty obviously a writer's pet. She gets away with loads of bullshit that any other character would get shit on for and takes up mountains of game time that should have been devoted to ANY OTHER member of the gang.

The native guy has the same problem but he's actually cool and puts his own ass on the line for people so he's not as dislikeable.

>>715436089 (OP)
The political views are the least of RDR2's problems.
I can't even get into it again, but it genuinely baffles me that so many people love it. I thought it was an irritating piece of fucking shit.
RDR(1) is one of my all time favorites, and I will forever be mad that 2 went full retard moviegame.

>Letting women vote and not supporting the literal KKK makes you a post modern bugman

This shit is why /v/ will always be the worst board on this entire site

>>715458962
>Nobody at the time gave a single fuck about the bizon, which is why everybody killed them en mass.
indians used to herd them off cliffs to kill entire herds to just harvest some meat and leave the rest of the splattered corpses there. It's just propaganda and white guilt.

>>715468948
Sadie works better when you stop seeing her as a morally good character. She's not a good person. She's a violent unstable pyschopath.

>>715458962
>they're just a bunch of white guys instead
IIRC the Skinner Brothers are mixed, which is still weird but not exactly as egregious. The Ghost People are mixed too IIRC which always struck me as odd considering they're, well, insular swamp voodoo people.

>>715469314
I don't see her as a good person. I'm really annoyed any time she's on screen. What I mean is that she gets away with stuff other characters would get chewed out for. Arthur and Marston like her even though she's a raging retard with less social and tactical acumen than Bill.

>>715468793
its cause like you said she's
a. not a white male. arthur mostly only ever shits on white men, no punching down.
b. she's not racist. the worst part about micah to arthur is the racism. arthur HATES racists since he deifies african americans and to a lesser extent mexicans and shits on whites, so micah is grotesque to him.

>>715467402
What did you win?

>>715442925
shut the fuck up retard

>>715469373
The Skinner Brothers are a bunch of white people doing what historically the Indians did.

I really want to explore the world but don't feel like slogging through Rockstar mission structure at all.

>>715469179
Disingenuous bad faith arguments? Yeah, I agree.

>>715469607
How is that disengenous? That's the extent of the political shit that's in the game

>>715469582
There were plenty of white trash retards skinning people alive back then.

>>715469815
No.

>>715469485
I agree with that. She should have been called out more for her shitty behaviour. Then again Arthur wasn't exactly in a position to be picky about his allies by the end of the game.

>>715469314
>kills three big guys with guns in hand-to-hand combat all on her own
Heh, nothing personnel

>>715469850
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harpe_brothers

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._H._Holmes

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloody_Benders

literally the first results that came up on google

>>715470015
Pretty dumb I know. Compare that with Bonnie in RDR1 who literally got kidnapped and raped for her stronk wahem shit

>>715470165
>ctrl + f
>skin
>0 results

Go get raped by a hobo or something, you dumb whore.

>>715470620
Are you really that autistic? They're seriel killers

>>715470798
Are you even old enough to be posting here? You're not even acting like a human being.

>>715470884
Here's your L

>>715470919
>claim there's plenty of white people going around skinning people alive
>there aren't
>claim anyone who calls you out is autistic
You seriously have to be like an LLM or something. There's not a single iota of thought in any of this.

>>715436089 (OP)
im not pretending, it is in fact one of the best

>>715468482
damn, the tony soprano bit really gets my imagination going. imagine an arthur who was a conniving scummy sociopath and psychopath all in one? a guy who constantly manipulated people for his own gain? someone who was actually interesting? man, that would really have been something..

>>715471053
lazy b8 doesn't hide the fact that you got btfo

>>715437759
Shit, everyone learned that lesson with Shenmue 1 on the Dreamcast. Most of the game is just you waiting for places to open so you can talk to one NPC and head back home, lmao.

>>715471208
he's right tho, indians scalped people, white people didn't skin anyone or anything like that, it's obvious that gang was put in so as to not paint savages in a bad light
are you brown or something?

I am convinced Zoomers are fundamentally fucked. They literally cannot think outside of black and white thinking and practice basic critical thinking skills. The idea that any time before them was a this or that only and not just mixture of ideals and casualized cultural beliefs and mannerisms is so foreign to them. Like jesus christ. Either everyone was lynching niggers at ever corner or its bipoc tranny brown celebration theres no inbetween

>>715436089 (OP)
It sold incredible and its regarded as one of the best games ever made, of course it's terrible like Ocarina of Time and any other game that sells well.

>>715471885
All selling well means is the game appealed to the lowest common denominator.

>>715469571
>assmad from being btfo
damn bitch

>>715471959
Like Wukong or Stellar Blade or any game that "Goes against the woke narrative".

>>715443850
>Was hunting a deer out in the middle of fucking nowhere and got a wanted bounty for skinning the thing, animal cruelty or some shit.
The one thing I hated about this fucking game. In rdr1 you got away with so much but here if you fuck with someone you automatically get a bounty. might as well mod it out

The worst part of arthur was the hypocrisy

>>715471575
By "scalping" I obviously meant brutally torturing and killing people. Though if you really want to be that specific about it I could bring up the Glanton Gang. The guys who inspired Blood Meridian. They were a bunch of white dudes from south carolina who gained infamy for scalping people along the mexico border.

>>715472519
by people you mean indians who were scalping white people

>>715440895
Why is it that every fag on this defaults to sales as if its a true metric of quality?

as an educated racist, you retards make us look worse

>>715436089 (OP)
>why won't this game that's being made by a company that wants to make money let me lynch niggers and shoot up suffragette rallies?

>>715458269
lmao what the fuck
retards here actually defend this dogshit?

>>715472718
Like the white Glanton Gang you mean? how is it that I'm putting documented historical evidence in front of you and you still won't accept it? How hard is to accept that there have been white trash fuckheads in the past who took pleasure in hurting people. I'm not making some left wing arguement by saying that its just a historical fact. fucking hell

>>715441694
good job making /po/ niggers seethe

>>715446409
remember when everyone was excited about ghost towns in rdr1 where you would be able to kill everyone and it wouldn't repopulate

>>715439034
BEAT IT

>>715472857
Or when they ask why their politicians are not using "Kill all niggers and kikes" as a political slogan.

>>715472293
>nigger reaction image
you're not worth a proper response, just kill yourself

>>715454128
>>715454617
>>715454502
This is literally the same logic that the fags who are obsessed with undertale/deltarune games use because how fucking dare I just not like earthbound-likes and am apparently a contrarian.
>there's an implication in your post that this particular thing is above dislike because it's just SOOO GOOOD
I see this shit with them all the time with them

>>715472928
I'm sorry you're right, it's just a coincidence that the gang of people skinning, arrow shooting savages are not indian
you have once again prove your superior intellect

>>715473661
RDR 2 isn't woke

>>715473598
>you're not worth a proper response, just kill yourself

None of you are ready for the truth.

>>715473796
>Just two friends enjoying the moment. Not a cell phone in sight

Kek right wingers are so stupid

All the "progressive" stuff you hate was already big in the 1800s. Feminism especially was huge
We even have Tolstoy sympathetically writing about trannies

>>715473931
>gooner wrote about his fetish
ok?

>>715473931
"Feminism" back then was not wanting to be beaten to a bloody plup by your alcoholic husband for voting. Not exactly the same thing as some polygendered bitch wanting me to pay for her 17th abortion.

>>715454128
No video game is above a dislike or criticism. To suggest otherwise is cult-like and very indicative of a mind that is either retarded or too young and immature to even have a real opinion on a video game

>>715473785
you're a dumbass, you think white mercenaries hired to do the same thing to indians that the indians started somehow proves your point
>there once was a white person who ran a sub 10 second 100 meter dash so it makes perfect sense to make a movie about the greatest sprinters of all time featuring an all white cast

>>715474097
Right but we are talking about the feminist depictions In the video game red dead redemption 2, and the feminism portrayed in the game isnt much different than what was already around by the 1800s

>>715473931
>We even have Tolstoy sympathetically writing about trannies
>source: your blown out asshole
tolstoy hated sexuality in general and thought faggots were a blight on society

>>715454128
>simply cannot enjoy things that others also enjoy sounds fucking miserable.
yes because I actually have taste. That's literally what a real personality is unlike (you) who will suck off the nearest dick that dangles keys in front of your face

>>715474097
Actually abortion activism was already ly a thing back then. The 1800s was when much of the laws criminalizing abortion were first rolled out and the issue became controversial

>>715474176
>that the indians started

>>715474176
Now we're really moving goalposts goddamn

>"Ok SOME white people scalped but that doesn't count because.... It just doesn't ok"

>>715474261
The source is war and peace you fucking mongoloid

Not only would you know this if you actually read Tolstoy, but you would also know his views were a roller coaster and changed dramatically in through his life to the point where he disowned all of his best works

>>715474351
Abortion has been around since ancient times anon. Plato wrote about abortion. Obviously though abortion wasnt a mainstream issue in the 1800s like it is today.
>>715474216
Fair

>>715474584
if you had to take a wild guess what percentage of bow and arrow attacks on white settlers and scalping do you think were perpetrated by white gangs? you know, the thing that we're talking about, the thing that takes place in rdr 2
it's nonsensical, and obviously you've been indoctrinated to ignore it, same way you were indoctrinated to defend that black guy in kcd 2, sad!

>>715474693
do you fucking faggots always just lie through your teeth and expect never to be challenged? go ahead you gender studies retard, explain how tolstoy's depiction of crossdressers (who in war and peace do nothing other than fuck with social norms and otherwise destabilize society) is supposed to be sympathetic? oh wow, he changed his mind about stuff sometimes? he also died hating faggots like you.

>>715475390
I'm not gonna play these semantic games with you. Take your loss with some diginity you fucking retard. If you're implying that I'm some kind of leftist then you should probably know that I never bought or played KCD 2 because of the nigger. Unlike you I didn't fall for that shit.

>>715475565
it's zero percent, never happened

>>715475624
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Joel_Glanton read for once in your life you fucking idiot

>>715475710
>His fiancée was abducted, scalped, and killed by Lipan Apaches
>their organization scalped Native war tribes who had been attacking settlers in America and Mexico to claim the bounty for scalps.
nothing even close to rdr 2, because the injuns dindu nutin

>>715475710
>Indians scalping
>1000s od cases

>whites scalping
>1 time because his wife was scalped and it was a revenge story

I thought you had something but all you had was an L. My dude pull up. Youre below the terrain atm.

>>715475924
"Never play checkers with a pigeon. Even if you beat it the damn thing will just shit on the board and claim it won."

As I originally said people like you are the reason /v/ is the worst board on this entire site.

>>715476206
you've been done, pipe down

>>715476228
Literally documented evidence that you're wrong and you still won't accept it. Shut the fuck up kid

>>715439034
Now this is a decent bait, unlike the one in the vtuber thread I just roasted.

>>715476289
sorry mate but I'm gonna go shoot my bow and arrow passed down to me from my dutch grandfather and dance around a fire in a loincloth

>>715442925
Brown people and Europeans both think like this, united in their historical illiteracy.

>>715436089 (OP)
>b-b-but it's like a realistic and polished game bro that must mean it's good!!

>>715468462
You disingenuous lefty fuckbags are truly something, you will dig to the center of the fucking earth to find the ONE thing that just barely supports your worldview, and why people did in a particular way and tout it was the final word on everything, nevermind the fact that you're fucking wikipedia as your source.
Like I'm in awe at how often this happens with you people.

>>715447696
I have never seen anyone say budín in my whole life, and I've lived in spain my whole life.

>>715436089 (OP)
This game doesn't respect your time and tries to make up for it with its graphics.

>>715468462
Communist terrorists existed at the time, but even the communists were racists. The protagonist is just a 21st century liberal.

>>715460041
this! other great games /v/ hates are concord, suicide squad, dustborn, dragon age veilguard, avowed, the upcoming marathon...

>>715474101
Just let him be the above it all voice of reason.

>>715451426
Dude falls for /pol/ ragebait. Literally the dumbest of the dumb.

>>715437536
>Is it really like this?
It's worse
There's a mission where you literally have to protect a bunch of feminists from evil chuds
There's a racist character and you gain karma for killing him
The entire midgame is full of "racism bad, women good" missions, where Arthur proudly explains his progressive views

anti graphics fags turning a blind eye to how graphics tricked people into liking this game and moving the political zeitgeist and overton window to the point that people will say with a straight face these games are not political weapons and that i need to go back to /pol/
but graphics dont matter amirite. graphics matter about as much as sex

>>715436089 (OP)

not trying to be edgy but why wasn't arthur even a little racist?

>>715439527
>I know literally nothing about American history, the culture war has completely warped my outlook on the world
That's (you)

Anyone have the Arthur/Dutch AI voice recordings?