>>717516123 (OP)
If you want the tl;dr then I like Rune Factory 4 because it's an extremely well rounded game with surprising complexity and a great deal of care. I could go on forever, but there's a lot of "you can do that?" with each aspect of the game feeling connected and well developed.
The characters themselves are charming and feel lively with tons and tons of dialog and events as well. They'll even have little personal touches like how if you raise friendship with the clumsy girl and put her in your party then she'll learn an attack that's just her tripping which throws shit at the enemy, or if you bring the girl that's scared of ghosts to the haunted house while doing the story then she'll freak out and try to teleport away.
It was my first farming game, so I'm sure there's bias there, but no farming game I tried after came close