Thread 718820790

Which was better, Silent Hill 2 or Silent Hill 3?

sh2 was better story
sh3 was better game
but they aren't really good games lets be honest the remake had better combat

>>718820858
>the remake had better combat
Kill yourself

2 and it isn't even close

>>718820790 (OP)
Silent hill f

>>718820909
Can't wait for all those kinos hitstuns.

>>718820790 (OP)
SH3 made my jaw clench more overall. Those helicopter monsters were nerve wracking. The prison level in SH2 was pretty tense though. I don't think either made me as relieved when things got back to just being foggy and full of skinless creatures again as the first one

>>718820790 (OP)
I enjoyed both the first time through, but found 3 more annoying to replay for some reason.

>>718820909
>F
Of all the suffixes they could have given it

>>718820889
He's objectively right thoughbeit.

i much would rather honestly replay 1 unironically

>>718821546
Decomp soon brother.

>>718821604
Link?

>>718820790 (OP)
2 is more narratively satisfying and fun to play, but 3 is still my pick because SH1 is my favorite. I like it being a direct sequel, I prefer the atmosphere,and I am in love with Heather.

>>718821546
>>718821604
>>718821708
Emulated it recently and it plays excellently. It's crazy how good PS1 emulation is nowadays.

Silent Hill 3 has the cutest protagonist

>>718821708
SH1 decomp is nearly at 16% btw (and 40% of game engine)
any reverserfags should join in, there's guides for setting it up in ghidra etc: https://github.com/Vatuu/silent-hill-decomp

>>718821903
Thank bro

2 has the better tone and narrative. 3 has the better art direction and combat scenarios. Both are markedly more flawed than 1.

>>718821871
Decomp would allow for a proper PC port, proper higher resolution without game breaking issues.

>>718820909
Souls games are one of the worst curses video games have been afflicted with

>>718822056
>zoomers praise this garbage

>>718820790 (OP)
They both scared the shit out of me in different ways. SH2 is more opressive and SH3 is more relentless. I can only play these games in short bursts and I dread coming back to them. If you play them as intended, in the dark, with enough sound and no distractions, this stuff will get to you.
For some reason, SH4 is the one that gets under my skin the most, maybe because it traumatised me as a kid. I never got past the subway back then.

>>718822127
*rolls*

i like SH3 more cus i like Heather more as a protag

and End of Small Sanctuary slaps

>>718822056
>>718822132
It's actually LESS advanced since it removes light vs. hard attacks and removes hit detection. Instead it's based on spacing and timing turning melee combat into a kind of weird dance or turn based rpg style thing. I hate it.

>>718821903
Corno!

>>718822214
>>718822221
this bitch on the dance team? how can she side step so fucking fast? i just did it now in my room like a weirdo, and I cant move my ass that fast. im only 240lbs and 6'1, is it really cause shes like 80lbs?

>>718821546
I can't get over how much of a perfect game Silent Hill 1 is especially under the presentation standpoint, the whole game is a rollercoaster of "oh shit" moments.

>>718822383
When you're younger, you just move faster

Silent Hill 3 has better puzzles, better bosses, better voice acting, better music, and better graphics. And Heather is a much better protagonist.

Silent Hill 2 has a better story and a better ending.

I like Silent Hill 2 more. Makes me wish SH3 was actually more of a character driven story about Heather's personal hell, like SH2. Which was the original intent, before they scrapped everything and made it about the cult from the first game.

>>718820790 (OP)
I like 3 more and think it's a better game in every way.

>>718822056
Impressive, that makes the original look competent.

>>718822443
>younger

>>718822447
>Silent Hill 3 has
>better voice acting
>better music
No fucking way
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0zlPtpUZ8uQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hj7wzG-yIGY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFmfuRyN_Kc
The rest I agree with.

>>718821604
>soon
>16%
See you in about 5 or 6 years.

>>718820858
>the remake had better combat
Easiest first post bait for maximum (You)s, I guess

>>718820790 (OP)
sh2. sh3 has better visuals and better combat, but worse level design and pacing.

if you took away the sh1 connection, or made the protagonist anyone other than heather, people would treat the game like sh4

>>718822127
I tried to warn people about this after Dark Souls but people love that roll semen.

>>718820790 (OP)
3 has better visuals and sound design, which are what make the series matter in the first place

Eileen shaving

>>718826619
>Leaving all her disgusting smelly hair on the bed