Thread 719991462

NOOOOOOOOOOOOO

>>719991462 (OP)
>GameFags
heh

>>719991462 (OP)
>it's all basic bitch pseudo hipster trash
I'm shocked. Odds are half the ratings on any given game are from someone who never even played it.

>>719991462 (OP)
>chononigger
yeah, worthless opinion

For obvious reasons GameFAQs is skewed towards retro, because what it offers isn't nearly as useful for modern games.
Although shame on them for allowing Chrono Trigger to appear twice, tell me what number 11 is because that's more interesting

>>719991462 (OP)
>Chrono Trigger twice

>>719991462 (OP)
>25 years later and gamefaqs is still right
I kneel.

>>719991462 (OP)
Unimpeachable list

Neither of those are in top 10 on metacritic which is probably most popular site for that shit.
So that basically means there's hundreds if not thousands of websites where those particular games aren't on top 10.

It's funny how nothing on this list is worth playing.

Games that are heavily praised lack anything interesting enough to be hated by midwits and retards, and so all "average of the commons" top 10 lists are dogshit. The only top 10 lists that matter are those of individuals, and you can tell everything you need to know about a person from the media he overrates.

>>719991462 (OP)
That's ok, they have an actually good Zelda game as #1.

>>719991462 (OP)
>Persona 4
>MH4U
Fucking what. This is ridiculous even for Top 10 standards.

>>719991462 (OP)
this list is just awful but it is still the best one out there somehow

>>719991462 (OP)
no game past 2015 should make it to top 100.

>>719991735
11. Super Mario Bros 3 (1988) (NES)
12. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Remastered (2011) (3DS)
13. Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4 (2008) (PS2)
14. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots (2008) (PS3)
15. Sengoku Basara 3 Utage (2011) (Wii)
16. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater (2004) (PS2)
17. Xenoblade Chronicles (2012) (Wii)
18. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (2017) (NS)
19. Metal Gear Solid (1998) (PS1)
20. Persona 5 (2017) (PS5)

Ooh, Monster Hunter. You've got my support. My top 5 would probably just be different monster hunter games.

>>719991462 (OP)
>tendies are retarded
More at 11.

>3DS MH
Tells me everything I need to know.

>>719992058
Tendies like the worst Zelda game (TOTK) you fucking dipshit

>>719991462 (OP)
More like NintendoFags.

>>719991747
And the worse version is higher.

millenialoids have been so annoying with chrono trigger.
i played it and it really isnt good

>>719991996
>Just more nintendslop
kek, how predictable

>>719991462 (OP)
i only ever played RE4
so to me this last is big lame

>>719991462 (OP)
>pedofaqs

That' still going?
Last I heard they banned all political discussion and locked down CE in an attempt to kill social boards

>>719991462 (OP)
If a game like Chrono Trigger was made today (exactly like it) everyone would be calling it mid.
People just hype it up because journalists told them so.

>>719991462 (OP)
gamefaqs? the website for 30 year old boomers?

>>719991996
ANOTHER repeated game in OoT remake...
Also Mario World and MGS4 are way too high, but otherwise I can't knock GameFAQs taste too much

fagsona in the top 10 is criminal
fucking parasocial weebs

>>719991462 (OP)
Tendie
Tendie
Tendie
Based
Based
Tendie
Tendie
Tendie
Based
Tendie

>>719992312
OOT is there 4x in the top 25 (OOT / 3D / Collection / Master Quest)

>>719991462 (OP)
Not enough people calling out the fact that it's specifically Golden that's on that list

>>719991996
Looks pretty good.

>>719991462 (OP)
Video games are not movies. You have to update your top 10 to at least somewhat keep up with the times because these old ass games are extremely prohibitive if only just because of their shitty controls.

>>719991586
Did you just come up with that on the fly? That's pretty impressive comedy chops you have there.

>>719992401
The only good Persona

>>719991462 (OP)
>Vita EXCLUSIVE* in the top 5 games of all time
Vitachads... It took 15 years but we won..

>>719991462 (OP)
Glad to see Gamefaqs can hold such a high level of integrity when sites like here would shit on Ocarine of Time because they're favorite e-celeb said so.

>>719991462 (OP)
Those ratings are from like the year 2003, the total number of users on gamefaqs nowadays is nothing more than 200 lol

>>719992482
arent there 2 of these?

>>719991462 (OP)
boomercore

>>719992217
You fags always parrot this same opinion whenever CT is brought up and it has never been right. I played it for the first time in 2014, and it immediately became one of my favorite JRPG's. It's just a fun, timeless game even to this day.

>>719992482
Regardless of your opinion on 4, it definitely shouldn't be Golden on there lol

>>719991586
Kek

>>719992893
Isn't that just an improved version of the basegame?

>>719991462 (OP)
>SMW over SMB3
No. They're wrong.

>>719992697
Only IGN had user ratings in 2003-2004 and it looked like this
1 - The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - N64 - 98%
2 - Chrono Trigger - SNES - 97%
3 - Soul Calibur - DC - 96%
4 - Panzer Dragoon Saga - SAT - 96%
5 - Radiant Silvergun - SAT - 96%
6 - Super Metroid - SNES - 96%
7 - The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past – SNES - 96%
8 - GoldenEye 007 - N64 - 96%
9 - Perfect Dark – N64 - 95%
10 - Metroid Prime - GameCube - 95%
11 - Final Fantasy VI - SNES - 95%

>>719991462 (OP)
They have good taste. Rebirth is still in top place after almost two years.

>>719993130
It is, but /v/ pretends Golden is bad because the fog looks different in one of the screenshots that is frequently posted.

>>719993197
3-5 is fucking bonkers.

>>719991462 (OP)
>OoT
Good grief, they’re even worse!

I legitimately believe Half Life and Fallout should be top 10 material and their impact to vidya

>>719993197
I think most of those probably hold up now, but I tried Goldeneye recently and holy shit it's bad.
Even if you get past the worst controls imaginable, the fucking first level plays at single digit framerates 80% of the time. It's like, you're immediately greeted with how shit it is.

>>719993197
panzer dragoon saga has to be the most overrated game of all time. Yes, I have played it

>>719993303
I can replay OOT today and have a good time from start to end. I would shove a rusty fork up my urethra before I'd replay Fallout 1.

>>719993197
Here's Metacritic's user list from 2003
Chrono Trigger SNES 9.1
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past SNES 9.1
Final Fantasy III SNES 9.1
Super Mario World SNES 9.1
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time GC 9.0
Super Mario Kart SNES 9.0
Resident Evil 2: Dual Shock Edition PS 9.0
Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3 GBA 9.0
Super Metroid SNES 9.0
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past GBA 8.9
Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater PS2 8.9
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic XBOX 8.9
The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages GBC 8.9
GoldenEye 007 N64 8.9
Soul Calibur II GC 8.9
Final Fantasy VII PS 8.9
Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening DX GBC 8.9
The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Seasons GBC 8.9

>>719993371
You're supposed to set the controls to 1.2 in the options menu.

>>719991586
Lol

>>719993452
OoT was dropped, and Nintendo fanboys should keep their childhood nostalgia from contaminating community polls.

"If I ever want to bathe in ignorance and dry myself off with stupidity I will visit GameFAQs" - Zach Gutierrez

>>719991462 (OP)
>sloparina of safe pick

>>719993570
Tough crowd with Chrono Trigger and OOT barely breaking 9/10. "Eh, it's a little too perfect, y'know?"

>>719991462 (OP)
>P4G
That's enough to disregard the whole list.

>>719993770
The game was legit that crazy good.

>>719991462 (OP)
>P4G over E33, metaflop, and pee5
Based

>>719993992
I never played P4 because of P3. Was the game that much better?

>>719991462 (OP)
E33 sucks. It would be a joke to have that in a top 10

>>719993570
GameFaqs from 2005 #1: Final Fantasy VII - PS #2: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - N64 #3: Chrono Trigger - SNES #4: The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past - SNES #5: Super Mario Bros. 3 - NES #6: Super Smash Bros. Melee - GC #7: GoldenEye 007 - N64 #8: Metal Gear Solid - PS #9: Halo: Combat Evolved - XBOX #10: Final Fantasy III - SNES

The only Zelda game that should be top 10 is Link to the Past. All the other 3D titles aged like milk.

>>719994204
ALTTP isn't even the best 2D Zelda

>>719994183
GoldenEye over Halo is pure retardation. The games are 4 years apart and Halo improved on just about everything and then some when it came out.

>>719994204
>Every puzzle is moving stuff: the game

>>719991462 (OP)
I didn't realize GameFaqs was a tendie stronghold.

>>719991462 (OP)
>GameTendies

>>719994275
GoldenEye is better than Halo in every way. Halofags used to be laughed at, now they're grown up and think their slop is good.

>SM World instead of SM64

No.

can someone explain why gamefaqs seems to not care for shooters but are so enamored with re4? Like no FPS, or any other 3rd persoon shooters, but RE4 is the 3rd greatest game of all time

>>719994382
How did you post that while looking at your feet, grandpa?

>>719991462 (OP)
Good.

>>719994461
RE4 is different than every other third person shooter. It's a Japanese action game that happens to have guns.

>>719991462 (OP)
>>719991735
>>719991626
>>719991996
This is primarily because GameFAQS isn't that active and most people on it do not use the rating system.
I clicked on a random modern (and popular) game and it's still around 100 ratings away from even being viable for being admitted into the global rankings list.

>>719991735
The average age of a GameFAQs user is 42. It's a dead site other than tranny mods and their tranny pets.

>>719991462 (OP)
>>719994638
As an addendum, E33 has 197 ratings and a score of about 8.0. Would not be viable for the Top Rated Games list.
BotW has 9806 ratings though, so it is viable and is in the Top 20.

>>719991586
lmao

>>719994638
>>719994834
Did a bit more research and found a game released this year with only 18 ratings, but the forum was incredibly active, most threads having over ten posts and the few with single digits being basic question threads rather than longform discussion threads.
I believe that most people here just don't use the rating system. At all.

>>719991462 (OP)
Wait a second, the uncs at GameFaqs are right. That's actually *the* list. You can argue about the order, but that's basically it.

>>719993570
Averaged “True User Canon” (2003–2005) from all three lists
Top 10 (consensus)
1 The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
2 Chrono Trigger
3 The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
4 Final Fantasy VI (III US)
5 Final Fantasy VII
6 Super Metroid
7 GoldenEye 007
8 Super Mario Bros. 3
9 Super Mario World
10 Metal Gear Solid

>>719991462 (OP)
>GameFaqs becomes only site on the internet without Expedition 33 or BOTW in their top 10
What about here?

>>719991462 (OP)
BotW was trash and always will be trash.

>>719991626
The only enduring stereotype of the hipster is that they performatively hate popular thing.
Liking the most well known, and famous video games of all time doesn't make a hipster.
You are the hipster.

>>719994098
Persona gets worse with each installment.

>>719991462 (OP)
Here's an earlier capture, I'm not a GameFAG so I don't entirely know when they added the Top Games list, and the older link only goes back to 2015 (that is pre-gamespot being added to the URL).
Unfortunately, the 2015 archive has a Blocked IP error on it, so I have to show 2016 instead.
Major changes
>MGS Legacy Collection, Metroid Prime Trilogy, KH2.5 ReMIX, The Orange Box, and MGS The Essential Collection are dropped from the list
This could be a more general removal of compilation titles from the list.
>Persona 4 Golden Moves from #1 to #5
>Chrono Trigger (SNES) Moves from #2 to #8
>Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate Moves from #6 to #9
>Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistance is dropped from the list
>Final Fantasy III (SNES) moves up from #10 to #7
>The Ocarina of Time moves up from #11 to #1
>Symphony of the Night moves up from #14 to #4
>A Link To The Past moves up from #15 to #6
>Chrono Trigger (DS) moves up from #18 to #2
And below the screenshot I provided, we find
>Resident Evil 4 (GC) moved up from #49 to #3
>Super Mario World was not even in the Top 50 and moved to #10
Really, GameFAQs seems to have had a Compilation title and VN/JRPG genocide, because all of these were in the Top 50
>999
>Ace Attorney 2
>Ace Attorney Investigations 2
>Trails in the Sky SC
>VLR
>Yakuza 5
>Gundam: Extreme VS Full Boost
>Shenmue 2
>Xenoblade Chronicles
>Panzer Dragoon Saga

>>719991462 (OP)
>no FFVII in sight
That's not my GFAQs.

>>719991462 (OP)
Ok grandpa, bed time.

>>719992169
13. Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4 (2008) (PS2)
14. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots (2008) (PS3)
15. Sengoku Basara 3 Utage (2011) (Wii)
16. Metal Gea19. Metal Gear Solid (1998) (PS1)
20. Persona 5 (2017) (PS5)r Solid 3: Snake Eater (2004) (PS2)

>>719991462 (OP)
>MH4 ultimate
>top 10

megalmao

>>719991462 (OP)
If it were me the list would just be Chrono Trigger

>8 of them are Nintendo
>2 are sony
kek, snoys btfo once more

>>719991462 (OP)
>ranking sites
Only on /v/

>>719991626
>og games are hipster trash now
Zoomers must be culled

>>719991462 (OP)
Gamefaqs is mostly dead and has been for over a decade.

This is why the "top rated games" are all what the top rated games list would have looked like 15-20 years ago. New games are basically unrated on gamefaqs.

>>719991735
>>719994762
The boards used to be fun before the community all turned gay and left for Reddit

>>719991996
>Basara made the top 15

How is their taste better than 99% of /v/?

>>719996841
why do normalfags like frieren so much?

>>719991586
LEL

>>719991462 (OP)
I'm gonna be honest this is better taste than like 103% of people on the internet with a 2% margin of error. I don't even like OoT or FF3 but it still mogs any faggots 3X3 you'll see in a lot of places.

>>719991462 (OP)
Man, my top 10 is never in any normie top 10.
Cuz normie top 10s are always console crap.
We really need to separate games by market again like we used to with Arcade vs Home Console. Except we should to it as Computer vs Console vs Mobile and maybe a few other special categories like Flash/Web games or erotic games.

>>719991462 (OP)
>2. Chrono Trigger (DS)
>8. Chrono Trigger (SNES)

I still remember when gamefaqs had their "Best game ever" poll and a bunch of you faggots got butthurt when undertale won. I'm still mad about that, it's when I truly knew this place was a lost cause. Shit like making L-block or launchpad win character polls was our bread and butter, so fucking up what was supposed to be yet another OoT vs FF7 wankfest coulda been a shining moment. But nooooooooooo you were too busy crying that it wasn't *your* meme pick that overtook it. You got so obsessed with your culture wars with reddit and tumblr that you missed the real spirit of fucking with gamefaqs itself. it's been like a decade and i'm still stuck here but I'll never forget the day /v/ died in my eyes.

>>719991462 (OP)
wtf gamefaqs are so based??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

>>719999897
just be glad it's not that other isekai with the schizofrenic time skips

>>719991462 (OP)
>no a single Fromslopware game
/v/ take notes

>>719991586
I don't get it.

>>719999897
Every once in a while some new show comes out which is then completely overhyped to hell and back taking up some spot in the top ten before being completely forgotten in a few years. Reminder that Your Name was also number 1 on MAL, now it's number 31. This is the result of modern internet culture breeding a certain type of tourist, the same personality types that act like E33 is anything other than mediocre. If you want to see what these types look like, look at this video.

https://x.com/IssyBoyWasTaken/status/1963015274354856082

>>719996979
>This is why the "top rated games" are all what the top rated games list would have looked like 15-20 years ago.
wtf does that mean games haven't been good in 15-20 years??

I remember as a kid aspiring to be a game FAQs writer.

>>719991462 (OP)
Sorry, shill bots only visit popular sites. Prease understando

I think there are too many contrarians online now, that is a perfectly acceptable top 10 list. I really hate contrarians it's just the path of least resistance to feeling like you're an intellectual when in reality you're just a midwit

Any time a list has zelda as the number 1, i just know it's fucking dogshit to be ignored.

>>719998858
>it's basara 3 utage, easily the worst of the expansions... but on HECKING BING BING WAHOOOO

>>720003372
basically /v

>>720003605
You're right, RE4 is the number 1 greatest game of all time. Ocarina is number 2.

>>720003702
Utage is the best blend of content, roster and balance. Sumeragi would be perfect if it didn't have the fucking roulette wheel.

Why would they rate the worse version of P4 that high?

>>720004427
Nah, even heroes was better than the step back that was 3 and sumeragi despite being more primitive and in the serie's infancy.

>>720003605
yup

>>719991462 (OP)
Chrono Trigger twice jesus christ. I played that game when it was new and I don't think it's that fucking good.

>>719991462 (OP)
Persona and Monster Hunter aside, that's a pretty nice list. I'd have expected so much worse from current GameFAQs. I guess it's true hardly anyone goes there anymore, zoomers probably barely acknowledge the site's existence

>>719991462 (OP)
What a based boomer list. Should I be posting on there instead? They seem to have better taste than nu-/v/.

E33 is babby's first JRPG. The game looks like dogshit and I cannot stand the uppity pompous characters.

>>719991747
It was better the second time

>>719991586
O fuck my sides

>>720006674
>The non bot shill infested site has better taste than the bot shill infested site
Who would have thought

>>719991462 (OP)
>4U in top 10 instead of any nu-MH garbage
That alone makes that site better than any other on the internet

>>719991462 (OP)
They might've gotten bought out by Gamespot ages ago but even those faggots can't erase decades of user-submitted votes so easily.

>>719991462 (OP)
OoT being on top just tells you it's manchildren who never coped with the fact that their game and console was never that popular

>>719991462 (OP)
The List of Kino.
Anyone who argues against any of those games should be disregarded forever.

>>719991586
I still giggle when I say it out loud

>>719991462 (OP)
good list, Ocarina of Time is the most overrated game of all time though, this is coming from someone who played it on release as a kid

>>719991462 (OP)
>BEYOND overrated, but still ok
>Overrated JRPG only Gen Xers suck off
>Overrated casual RE, but still fun
>Overrated
>>>Modern SMT VN Friend Simulator
>Overrated Zelda only Gen Xers suck off
>Overrated FF only Gen Xers suck off
>Same game twice
>Not Tri
>Overrated Mario only Gen Xers suck off

>>719991902
>It's funny how nothing on this list is worth playing.
RE4 and arguably Monhun4U are worth it. Everything else is so basic and casualized it's boring.

>>719993570
I've always maintained that LttP was better than OoT

Way too much Japslop

>>720009113
They're 2 very different games. ALttP came out at the tail-end height of the 2D era while OoT was their first attempt at a 3D Zeld that's just starting out. Not a very fair comparison. If anything ALttP's better than Ys.

>>719993275
I've always said that Radiant Silvergun is one of the most overrated games of all time. People do not understand how glazed that fucking shit was when it was new. It's taken 20 years for it to only partially fade away.

Journalists still lap it the fuck up.

>>719991462 (OP)
MGS4 is rated way too high on there. But I saw their top 30 games and its honestly not too bad. Far better than any normie list you will come across on most other sites.

>>719991462 (OP)
>N64
>DS
>GC
>PS
>Vita
Lmao unc.

>>719991462 (OP)
>>719991996
>Literally all weebshit

>>719991462 (OP)
What's GameFaqs?

>>720012784
4chan's pappa

>>720012784
oldfag gaming forum that loves nintendo and sony

>>720012784
Poorfags with dial up that needed to know how to breed chocobos in Final Fantasy 7.
Really, that was the inspiration for GameFAQs.
Now it's a rotting corpse in the age of high speed internet and youtube, mostly visited by 400 pound balding men and their 400 pound balding tranny gfs.

>>720013526
Nintendo and Squaresoft specifically.

>>720013526
>loves nintendo and sony
Well Sega had been dead for nearly 30 years and Xbox is just there. What else was there to love?

>>719991462 (OP)
Wow an actual good list

>>719991462 (OP)
impeccable taste

>>719991462 (OP)
Absolutely based list without the typical crap like ME2 and TLOU.

Objectively based list.
Funny seeing all of the zoomers ITT having a melty because the list doesn't have their PC FOTM slop like Roblox or Nortubel or whatever the fuck they watch their streamers play.

Persona 4 was really special.

>>719991462 (OP)
Is RE4 fun if I don’t like jumpscares?

I'm more of an FF5 guy myself but I'm surprised FF7 isn't on there.

>>720016401
RE isn't really a jump scare series. At worst maybe 1 of those side modes that's not part of the main game. Then again I haven't played the newer ones since 4. I have played most of the spinoffs like Rev, Zero, and Veronica and either of those were full of jump scares.

>>719991462 (OP)
Based list. E33 is one of my favorite games right now but it has yet to stand the test of time like these legends (besides p4) did.