Favorite Zelda game?
For me, it's probably Twilight Princess. I really like the peak 6th gen aesthetics, the desolate, melancholy vibe and Midna's ass
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 8:06:14 PM
No.725473797
[Report]
Twilight Princess for the snowboarding and fishing.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 8:07:28 PM
No.725473890
[Report]
>>725473713
play a real zelda game dumb zoomer
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 8:13:53 PM
No.725474406
[Report]
Twilight Princass
Still can't beat OoT + MM.
TP on the other hand is by far one of the WORST Zelda games in the series. God-awful pacing, forgettable as fuck dungeons, shittons of handholding, tacked-on wolf mode that soon becomes obsolete, bizarre and forgettable items with some literal overlapping + super restricted usage, half-baked as hell story and cast, plus general recycling of old tropes.
The old 8.8 scores were too generous, and as it is apparent ITT, the game literally lives off Midna's r34 and nothing else.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 8:24:24 PM
No.725475241
[Report]
>>725485519
Zelda II. combat is challenging but fair. Can beat it in a couple hours.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 8:28:29 PM
No.725475565
[Report]
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 8:30:14 PM
No.725475707
[Report]
>>725474838
Zelda hasn’t been the same since Koizumi left.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 8:31:45 PM
No.725475826
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
Oracle of Ages overall, but TotK for the 3D ones.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 8:33:38 PM
No.725475997
[Report]
don't have favorite but my top 3 in no order are
twilight princess
phantom hourglass
wand of gamelon
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 8:40:05 PM
No.725476527
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
You can't love Midna for who she is as well?
>>725473639 (OP)
Majora's Mask. Here's my tier list though, including all of them I've actually played:
Top tier:
Majora's Mask, Wind Waker, Breath of the Wild
High tier:
Ocarina of Time, Link's awakening, Minish Cap
Mid tier:
Twilight Princess (The best parts are amazing, the rest is shit), Link to the Past
Low tier:
Skyward Sword
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 8:55:14 PM
No.725477803
[Report]
hummm
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:00:31 PM
No.725478242
[Report]
Zeruda...
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:05:04 PM
No.725478581
[Report]
>>725476953
>Top tier
>Breath of the Wild
stopped reading
>>725476953
>Top tier
>Breath of the Wild
stopped reading
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:14:01 PM
No.725479349
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
i have only played awakening and oracles
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:17:51 PM
No.725479679
[Report]
For me, it's OoT and Majora's Mask.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:18:35 PM
No.725479737
[Report]
Twilight P!
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:34:54 PM
No.725481110
[Report]
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:38:47 PM
No.725481383
[Report]
>>725482416
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:51:31 PM
No.725482416
[Report]
>>725482503
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:52:45 PM
No.725482501
[Report]
>>725482387
>NuZelda
into teh trash list
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:52:50 PM
No.725482503
[Report]
>>725482416
Princesses can't be sluts
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:55:49 PM
No.725482719
[Report]
Ocarina. A combination of nostalgia, tight dungeons, great music, good length, replayability. It's a really great game even if it is a bit janky by today's standards.
TP is right behind it. In spite of being too easy and having too long of an intro, TP has a great presentation and awesome dungeons. I love the core Zelda formula. So a game with a clear sense of "early dungeons" and "end dungeons" does it for me.
For 2D Zelda, I'd probably say Seasons is my favorite with Ages and LA right behind it. All three entries are superb.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 9:56:44 PM
No.725482803
[Report]
>>725478956
i get it, i have the urge to go play it again when i see it mentioned too.
BotW
LoZ, LttP, TotK, EoW
LA, MM, WW, OoA, OoS, ALBW
MC, trains
AoL
OoT, TP, SS
OoT and its clones suck and are antithetical to exploration. N64babies with nostalgia pretending the formulaic, linear and simplistic dingeons are good will not change that.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:06:18 PM
No.725483492
[Report]
Ocarina is still the most cohesive product but I feel like I've played it to death. Twilight princess is far from flawless but it has the highest highs in the series, IMO
>>725473639 (OP)
Favorite to least:
>OoT
>LttP
>OoS
>MM (recently replaying it bumped it down for me, the main quest really is too skinny even with the fetchquesting/prepwork for Ikana)
>LA (DX being my favorite version)
>ALBW
>TP (I do have a better opinion if I space the game out with an hour or two at most a day)
>BotW
>MC
>WW (similar deal to TP)
>AoL
>PH = ST (they both annoy me about equally, I can't decide which I dislike more)
>OoA
>Z1
>FS (but my friends sucked to do coop with)
>SS
>TotK
Haven't played FSA, TFH, or EoW. I don't want to replay anything below WW ever again.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:11:01 PM
No.725483850
[Report]
>>725484031
>>725483035
>Switchbaby
>calling any other games' duneons "formulaic" and "simplistic"
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:11:59 PM
No.725483938
[Report]
>>725485646
>>725483765
Echoes is fun
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:12:36 PM
No.725483983
[Report]
>>725502746
>>725473639 (OP)
Twilight Princess has been my favorite game since 2007. It's cozy as fuck and its gimmicks are really cool. I'm replaying it now and it just puts a smile on my face.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:13:07 PM
No.725484031
[Report]
>>725484153
>>725483850
>>Switchbaby
I played LoZ before you were born. Yes, the games that you played when you were 8 were simplistic and formulaic.
>>725484031
>copying Ubisoft/Rockstar games isn't formulaic
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:15:54 PM
No.725484251
[Report]
>>725483035
>OoT and its clones suck and are antithetical to exploration.
red pilled
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:17:11 PM
No.725484373
[Report]
>>725484438
>>725484153
NTA but the new Zeldas are made in the style of Zelda 1 and 2, as the developers have stated in interviews, and as is obvious to those who play them
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:17:51 PM
No.725484431
[Report]
>>725484975
>>725483035
>OoT and its clones suck and are antithetical to exploration
You can't say that while sucking WW off. Its "exploration" is at best aesthetic until the game is basically over, it's an OoT clone on water.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:17:56 PM
No.725484438
[Report]
>>725484373
>NTA
>the new Zeldas are made in the style of Zelda 1 and 2
>and as is obvious to those who play them
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:19:00 PM
No.725484530
[Report]
>>725499938
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:19:14 PM
No.725484553
[Report]
>>725486649
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:20:01 PM
No.725484615
[Report]
>>725478956
Yeah. Good indicator of a secondary retard with a shit opinion.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:20:11 PM
No.725484627
[Report]
twilight princess is terrible. OP is a rtetard
>>725484153
>OoToddler
>doesn't actually know what a ubisoft game is
>pretends OoT isn't formulaic and simplistic
For those of us who actually played games in the 90s, it was insane that the game didn't have a jump button and Navi basically told you what to do directly or via flying over to what you should interact with. Games hadn't become fully casualized and streamlined yet, so it stuck out. Consequently, that's why you liked it so much. You were a dumb 8 year old who didn't actually play games.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:22:10 PM
No.725484786
[Report]
>>725483035
insanely based. Make them seethe
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:22:11 PM
No.725484790
[Report]
>>725476953
>Top tier:
>Wind Waker
swing and a miss
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:22:29 PM
No.725484816
[Report]
>>725484659
>OP is a rtetard
>rtetard
Never call someone else a "retard" if you aren't willing to proofread your own shit.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:24:21 PM
No.725484975
[Report]
>>725484431
>You can't say that while sucking WW off
Where did I suck it off? That tier is "pretty fun". WW suffers from railroading and shitty OoT style dungeons, but the combat is snappy and responsive and using enemy weapons was cool, the aesthetic is nice, and exploring some of the smaller islands was fun.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:24:25 PM
No.725484987
[Report]
>>725485203
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:25:09 PM
No.725485050
[Report]
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:25:27 PM
No.725485080
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
Oot I guess. I'm not really into nintendo or zelda games that much and haven't even played any post gamecube though so eh.
>>725484781
Personally I remember the lack of a jump button being a source of frustration rather than something that made it more casual-friendly. Fuckin retard link leaping off platforms when I didn't intend for him to do so.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:25:39 PM
No.725485093
[Report]
Probably Twilight Princess but I haven't played it in a long time. Skyward Sword is good fun too.
>>725484781
>For those of us who actually played games in the 90s
So not you.
The games that he contributed to.
>>725484987
Please point me to some other games from the 90s that automated actions and treated the player like an idiot (the things all AAA games get shat on for doing now). Hopefully you can actually name some and prove you aren't just an assmad N64baby who didn't actually play games until 1998. Reaction images aren't the skillful sidestep you want to pretend they are. Now let's see those games you list.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:28:00 PM
No.725485285
[Report]
>>725485404
>>725485127
See
>>725485203
Prove you actually played games back then.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:29:36 PM
No.725485404
[Report]
>>725485486
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:30:35 PM
No.725485486
[Report]
>>725485743
>>725485404
>can't name games
Didn't think so, N64baby.
>>725475241
>Zelda 2
>fair
In no universe.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:31:04 PM
No.725485520
[Report]
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:31:41 PM
No.725485576
[Report]
ALttP easily. None of the 3D games are good.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:32:12 PM
No.725485615
[Report]
>>725485741
>>725483765
>MC, WW, AoL, PH, ST, OoA, THF, FS and SS between BotW and TotK
Just say you are a mindless drone convinced he has to hate TotK even if it's objectively superior to BotW in everything but story
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:32:36 PM
No.725485646
[Report]
>>725483938
It is, just wish it had more cohesive design and less menuslop.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:33:43 PM
No.725485741
[Report]
>>725485980
>>725485203
>Please point me to some other games from the 90s that automated actions
Shielding in the first three Zelda games.
>and treated the player like an idiot
In LttP's intro stage, Zelda has to tell you to move the ornamental mantle and to pull a switch to open a locked door.
>>725485615
Sorry. Your game sucks dick.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:33:48 PM
No.725485743
[Report]
>>725485980
>>725485486
>Reeeee engage with my loaded question
No zoomie, no.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:34:49 PM
No.725485826
[Report]
>>725486334
>>725485519
Zelda 2 is very fair. It's hard but it's fair. Most people get filtered by the learning curve so I can see why you wouldn't get it.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:36:24 PM
No.725485957
[Report]
I love Kass!
Majora's Mask.
>>725485741
>Shielding in the first three Zelda games.
You had to point the shield in the right direction. This is not comparable to a 3D game automating jumping and climbing.
>>725485743
>naming games that streamlined and casualized things is a loaded question
It only seems like a loaded question if you grew up with an N64 and feel the need to pretend OoT wasn't always casual, braindead trash.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:38:37 PM
No.725486130
[Report]
>>725486321
>>725485980
>Reeeee engage with my loaded question
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:41:01 PM
No.725486321
[Report]
>>725486130
>can't actually talk about games from the 90s
>just shitposts like an angry monkey
You'll tire yourself out eventually, N64baby.
>>725485826
Zelda 2 sending you back to Zelda's bedroom when you Game Over is some serious bullshit. They knew this too, because Game Overing in the Great Palace sends you back to its beginning.
>>725485980
>You had to point the shield in the right direction.
You have to direct your jumps correctly in OoT as well.
>automatic climbing
Nope I'm preeeeetty sure you had to move Link up/down on ladders and around on vines/climbable walls in the 3D games.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:43:01 PM
No.725486496
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
OoT > BotW > MM > TP = LttP > TotK > SS > WW
Don't care enough about the other 2d zeldas to rank them
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:44:44 PM
No.725486649
[Report]
>>725484553
You know that game's subtitle isn't in english right? It's called Kaze no Takuto
Hell even if the english subtitle was also the one they used in japanese the game isn't called Wind Waker anywhere, it's THE Wind Waker, dumbass
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:45:27 PM
No.725486703
[Report]
>>725487097
>>725486334
>You have to direct your jumps correctly in OoT as well.
You're comparing apples to bowling balls. Why are you trying to compare 3D jumping to 2D shields? Why not compare it to actual like mechanics?
>Nope I'm preeeeetty sure you had to move Link up/down on ladders
I'm talking about how you can hold forward, run, jump off a ledge, grab another ledge, and climb up it.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:45:30 PM
No.725486712
[Report]
>>725486334
>Zelda 2 sending you back to Zelda's bedroom when you Game Over is some serious bullshit.
It's not fucking bad you big baby. It's annoying to walk back but you're given shit like the hammer to make shortcuts in the overworld.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:50:29 PM
No.725487097
[Report]
>>725487489
>>725486703
>I'm talking about how you can hold forward, run, jump off a ledge, grab another ledge, and climb up it.
And being able to grab ledges from a jump is bad... why?
>>725487097
Automating that entire process from beginning to end is bad, yes. At the very least, you should be able to ledge hang and shimmy. Now list some other games from the time that stripped away that much player control.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:56:43 PM
No.725487603
[Report]
>>725488092
>>725487489
You do know video games have had this since forever right
You're a dishonest retard
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 10:56:59 PM
No.725487621
[Report]
>>725487489
oh my fucking god YOU WATCHED VIDEOS AND DIDN'T PLAY THE ACTUAL GAME HAHAHAHA
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:02:59 PM
No.725488092
[Report]
>>725487603
No, they didn't. Which other game from that period just had you hold forward to run, jump, grab and climb? Name some actual games and stop speaking in generalizations. Everything else had manual jumping or even climbing/mantling that were manual inputs like Tomb Raider or Thief. Now list some actual games that automated everything. If you can't or if you move the goalposts to "Actually, automating everything is good" then I'm going to assume you're a retard who doesn't play video games like the N64baby below you.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:05:01 PM
No.725488257
[Report]
>>725499345
>ACTUALLY THIS WAS NEVER GOOD
Lol
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:10:53 PM
No.725488694
[Report]
>>725491536
>>725473639 (OP)
Probably OoT because it clicks just right.
Link's Awakening has a special place in my heart as it is the first non-edutainment game I ever played. Even if by modern standards it's super short.
TP is great for one playthrough, but I kinda hate how the game just abandon's it's own theme after getting the master sword (no more real use of wolf link, twilight realm no longer really exists). On repeat playthroughs the issues become a bit glaring.
I'd love to replay TotK... if it had a Master Mode. Maybe I will replay it but keep myself from making the flying motorcycle. Currently playing AoI, with almost all Aside quests done.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:11:38 PM
No.725488747
[Report]
>>725484781
>and Navi basically told you what to do directly
this, it bugged me since 1998
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:13:07 PM
No.725488852
[Report]
>>725492639
>>725485519
NTA but Zelda 2 is firm but fair, your character levels up and things become ever easier as you go on. Yeah if you run out of lives you're sent back to the start, you only lose experience points though, not level ups.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:18:50 PM
No.725489251
[Report]
Zelda was never good.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:25:59 PM
No.725489781
[Report]
>>725489151
OoT and MM shouldn't be over Botw and Totk, they're the perfect pair.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:29:27 PM
No.725490071
[Report]
>>725489151
spirit tracks is F at best
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:30:55 PM
No.725490187
[Report]
>1. Oracle of Ages/Seasons
>2. Minish Cap
>3. Link's Awakening
3D Zelda is irrelevant.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:47:39 PM
No.725491536
[Report]
>>725488694
The first half of TP is a complete slog because of the twilight segments.
Anonymous
11/10/2025, 11:52:49 PM
No.725491956
[Report]
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 12:01:57 AM
No.725492639
[Report]
>>725492929
>>725488852
If only your character leveled up at a decent rate and not at a snail pace. You end up needing thousands of points to level up and the strongest enemies that can easily kill you if you make a small mistake won't even give you 100, and the assholes even made it so you level up automatically when beating palaces so the most optimal way is clearling the whole thing WITHOUT putting the crystal at the end of the palace and once you have done everything and are ready to go to the final dungeon you have to redo the palaces to put all crystals and properly level up, THAT is somehow the most optimal way to play that shit
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 12:05:31 AM
No.725492929
[Report]
>>725493081
>>725492639
bosses at the end of a palace always level you up no matter how little exp you have when you kill them, you need to be aware of stuff like that
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 12:07:49 AM
No.725493081
[Report]
>>725499431
>>725492929
Wasn't it when you put the crystal, rather than beating the boss? Either way, it's still a terrible design if the most optimal way to play so you don't want to blow your brains out is playing almost the whole game except the bosses, then do a boss rush and then do the final dungeon.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 12:09:24 AM
No.725493207
[Report]
>>725496235
twilight was peak
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 12:10:14 AM
No.725493268
[Report]
>>725493374
for 2d it's lttp, for 3d it's mm. honorable mentions for ww and fsa (if you can get a group). I also remember really liking albw, but I haven't played that since it came out, so I dunno. I should replay it soon, it probably emulates fine
>>725493268
actually I just remembered I did a tier list while talking to some friends a while back
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 12:50:27 AM
No.725496235
[Report]
>>725493207
Yeah the peak of a giant turd
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:32:56 AM
No.725499345
[Report]
>>725500720
>>725488257
It's funny how that's always revealed as Wildfags' underlying view the more you peel away at their individual arguments.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:33:59 AM
No.725499431
[Report]
>>725500163
>>725493081
no, just choose the shorter level up bonuses outside palaces, and the longer ones inside palaces, because when you beat the boss you will get the whole level up
>The one Zelda that tried to grow up and portray a coherent logical world that justifies it's own existence
>Series immediately afterwards becomes feminized slop more intent on appealing to terminally online troons and women who worship Disney movies
A tragic fate for a once venerable franchise
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:40:18 AM
No.725499938
[Report]
>>725484530
rando is so fun
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:42:19 AM
No.725500065
[Report]
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:43:20 AM
No.725500136
[Report]
>>725499780
>The one Zelda that tried to grow up
pic unrelated btw
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:43:38 AM
No.725500152
[Report]
>>725500746
>>725493374
its kinda fucked I do like a lot of the lore and designs from botw/totk but the gameplay is just not zelda
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:43:45 AM
No.725500163
[Report]
>>725499431
And that's still infinitely inferior than just waiting to do all palaces level up at the end, which is a needed improvement with how little exp you get from enemies
Again, shit design, I don't make the rules, I just wish they followed them instead of shitting on the game.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:44:18 AM
No.725500196
[Report]
>>725499780
>The one Zelda that tried to grow up
>Posts TP
lol
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:48:10 AM
No.725500510
[Report]
OOT is the best.
BOTW is pretty good
TOTK sucks
WW is pretty good. Maybe my personal favorite.
Never played TP, should I?
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:49:26 AM
No.725500614
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
Having only played the first 4, it goes:
LA>1>LTTP>2
Attention grabbing midna pic anyways to make you read my post.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:50:42 AM
No.725500708
[Report]
Unironically.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:51:00 AM
No.725500720
[Report]
>>725501361
>>725499345
OoT was never good. It's just your favorite shitty game, not the good ones.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:51:15 AM
No.725500746
[Report]
>>725515528
>>725500152
yeah it just doesn't interest me at all. it was kinda fun to run around for a bit, but after like 2 guardians I just stopped playing and never went back, and never really felt the urge to give it another shot
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:58:38 AM
No.725501310
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
OoT, MM and TP, though I also like WW, LttP and LBW.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:58:45 AM
No.725501324
[Report]
>>725499780
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA holy kek Toilet Princess fans are always so funny
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 1:59:19 AM
No.725501361
[Report]
>>725501520
>>725500720
>it's not good because the game makes me do things >:(
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:00:12 AM
No.725501427
[Report]
>>725506196
>>725493374
This is such a weird tier list, but I respect it, unlike everyone else in this thread
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:01:22 AM
No.725501520
[Report]
>>725501628
>>725501361
It's not good because these are the kinds of braindead things it makes you do.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:02:53 AM
No.725501628
[Report]
>>725501863
>>725501520
Almost a third of the Shrines in BotW are Tests of Strength or Blessings.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:06:09 AM
No.725501863
[Report]
>>725502375
>>725501628
Tests of strength are the worst part but they make up 1/6 of them, and the blessings are just rewards for side quests. I know you didn't actually play through the game and just looked up a list online, but the sidequests and environmental puzzles are peak Zelda. Not that you'd know, seeing as you think peak Zelda is getting a tool in a dungeon that a companion tells you to use on things in that dungeon in between slowly pushing objects along a straight path and then stunning the boss with that tool.
What is it about TotK and BotW that causes such autistic and retarded impulses to surge forth from the carcasses and axe wounds of trannies and faggots alike? Why are they like this?
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:12:40 AM
No.725502375
[Report]
>>725502992
>>725501863
>you think peak Zelda is getting a tool in a dungeon
Yeah, like Zelda 1. That game you faggots pretend to worship and use as a justification for BotW's aggressively anti-Zelda philosophies.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:16:58 AM
No.725502746
[Report]
>>725483983
Nintendo just release it already
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:20:16 AM
No.725502992
[Report]
>>725504304
>>725502375
>you think peak Zelda is getting a tool in a dungeon
Way to cut off the rest, you dumb faggot. And the 2 most used tools in Zelda 1 were bought in shops. Stop pretending you played it.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:20:57 AM
No.725503043
[Report]
>>725503275
>>725473639 (OP)
I've been replaying Twilight Princess.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:21:23 AM
No.725503074
[Report]
Oot= soul
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:22:28 AM
No.725503134
[Report]
>>725482387
Astonishingly based list anon
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:22:56 AM
No.725503171
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
TP has hot Link and Midna, the new ones have somewhat hot bird people, I'd probably go for TP for pure hotness, but OoT and MM have an unmatched aesthetic and surreal quality to them that perfectly blends foreboding atmosphere and childlike whimsy, so as much as I hate not being a contrarian as is my nature, I have to go with OoT overall.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:24:27 AM
No.725503275
[Report]
>>725503043
You should give Skyward Sword another go with the switch version, pirated or not it makes no difference, but it's alright with the wagglan excised.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:24:35 AM
No.725503283
[Report]
>>725503395
One silver lining of TotK: it destroyed the ability for whiny faggots to reductively complain about TP being "too much of an OoT wankfest".
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:26:17 AM
No.725503395
[Report]
>>725503685
>>725503283
TotK has a trillion of amazing things and it's not even close to being a OoT copy like TP was what the fuck are you even trying
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:26:38 AM
No.725503424
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
Wind Waker and Majora's Mask are my favorites, they're both flawed masterpieces.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:27:01 AM
No.725503450
[Report]
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:27:45 AM
No.725503504
[Report]
Okami
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:28:20 AM
No.725503541
[Report]
>>725503831
I'm beginning to think this is an engagement farming thread. Or a thread that they're trying to turn into one, at least.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:28:53 AM
No.725503593
[Report]
>>725503675
>>725473639 (OP)
OOT and MM. Don't care if it's a basic bitch pick, they're extremely popular for a reason.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:30:08 AM
No.725503675
[Report]
>>725503593
>they're extremely popular for a reason.
The same reason that Halo or FFX are popular.
>>725503395
It being a BotW rehash and wankfest you fucking tard
>>725503685
>It being a BotW wankfest
One of the biggest problems with it is that it didn't acknowledge BOTW enough.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:32:06 AM
No.725503831
[Report]
>>725503984
>>725503541
isn't it all a distraction? look at how many new games came out, but there's these same threads every day about generic slop
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:32:33 AM
No.725503863
[Report]
Not Slop of the Goyim, that's for sure
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:33:01 AM
No.725503901
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
The series will never ever reach the peak of ALttP to LA to OoT to MM. Basically the best 2D and 3D games all in a row.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:33:56 AM
No.725503984
[Report]
>>725503831
Kill yourself. You and everyone like you, shitting up the board just to make Hiro some extra pennies.
>heh exactly what i'd expect from a [game]fan
Slit your wrists.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:34:31 AM
No.725504036
[Report]
>>725485157
ya basically this console zeldas only got worse after WW
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:35:05 AM
No.725504081
[Report]
>>725503817
It manages to often avoid directly talking about BotW like a family avoiding directly mentioning estranged relatives at Thanksgiving dinner, yet still cribbing so many of its plot and concept beats. It's a very impressive display of trying to have their cake and eat it too.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:35:21 AM
No.725504097
[Report]
>>725503685
>what are you trying?
>it being a BotW rehash
You couldn't even articulate a response that works as answer to my question, really says a lot about you dumbasses
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:38:02 AM
No.725504287
[Report]
>>725515857
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:38:15 AM
No.725504304
[Report]
>>725504501
>>725502992
botwfags dont deserve to have their full posts read
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:41:05 AM
No.725504501
[Report]
>>725504565
>>725504304
That's nice, but you're a fucking retard for getting mad that people who like LoZ have actually played LoZ and don't pretend the reason it was fun was for imaginary similarities or shallow mechanical similarities to your favorite game. Feel free to get upset, but you're not getting any more replies.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:41:53 AM
No.725504565
[Report]
>>725505546
>>725504501
You idiots tried to claim dungeons weren't important to Zelda. Sit down.
is skyward sword horrible? It looks like it might be fun... for context I want something like twilight princess
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:46:01 AM
No.725504860
[Report]
>>725505684
>>725504574
Unfortunately SS isn't the putrid shit you are looking for.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:48:38 AM
No.725505063
[Report]
>>725505684
>>725504574
SS is awful. As much as I dislike the Wild games, there IS a reason Nintendo felt a need to throw out the baby with the bathwater on the Zelda series after SS.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 2:55:43 AM
No.725505546
[Report]
>>725504565
No, anon, you just don’t get it. TRUE Zelda is all about wandering across an oversized world map, killing the same enemies scattered across camps, and applauding whenever the enemy AI does anything even remotely mundane or clever, like eating an apple!
TRUE Zelda is about aimlessly cruising on a magitech hoverboard, hurling giant rocks glued together into the shape of phalluses at monsters! That’s what Zelda has always stood for, and if you don’t like that, well, you must just hate Zelda!
>>725505063
>>725504860
why are you dickfucks so vague? in concrete terms, what is wrong with SS?
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:04:13 AM
No.725506123
[Report]
>>725513010
>>725505684
Skyward Sword is painfully linear, which by itself it isn't necessarily a bad thing, but the game keeps making you revisit the same corridor-looking 3 areas that barely change. When they do add something new, it’s usually just filler to pad out the runtime.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:05:08 AM
No.725506196
[Report]
>>725507123
>>725501427
I appreciate it. so what's the problem, that I have something like ancient stone tablets so high, and oot so low?
>>725505684
it should have been a movie, they went too far with this cinematic stuff they started doing
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:08:53 AM
No.725506450
[Report]
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:10:12 AM
No.725506523
[Report]
>>725503817
>it didn't acknowledge BOTW enough
a popular misconception, however Totk calls back to Botw all the time. Nobody has ever concretely laid out an example of where the game fail to acknowledge the previous game.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:14:24 AM
No.725506846
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
the only one I didn't get bored halfway through and actually finished was BOTW so that one
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:18:18 AM
No.725507123
[Report]
>>725507412
>>725506196
The one that really throws me off is Spirit Tracks. I wouldn't say that there's a problem with this list. I think it makes it very clear what you like about a zelda game, which is cool
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:22:09 AM
No.725507412
[Report]
>>725507608
>>725507123
similar to albw, I haven't replayed spirit tracks since it came out, but I remember having fun with it and liking it a lot more than ph. also zooming around on the train was fun and it was really cathartic to be able to kill the demon trains in the end. it's possible I wouldn't think of it as fondly if I replayed it someday
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:25:00 AM
No.725507608
[Report]
>>725507412
I too have really good memories of Spirit Tracks from when I was a kid. In my heart I know that it's probably actually not that good, but I respect anyone who's willing to rate it so high.
>>725505684
not them but it's ugly and the intro town was soulless with too much NPC babbling
I only played it for like 20 minutes before dropping it
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:29:00 AM
No.725507950
[Report]
Ocarina of Time
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:31:16 AM
No.725508126
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
OOT, MM, ALTTP and LA
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:43:20 AM
No.725508997
[Report]
>>725507827
Right decision because SS is one of those games that becomes worse and worse the more you play it and the more you think about it. Only Zelda game I have literally never had the urge to ever replay after "forcing" myself to finish it.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 3:45:42 AM
No.725509159
[Report]
>>725485157
he's still around but just doing mario stuff
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 4:01:58 AM
No.725510226
[Report]
Honestly, one of the things i dislike the most about Botw/Totk is how much of a feminized manlet Link is in those games, genuinely can't take him seriously.
>inb4 Link was always like that
Wrong, all previous Links were pretty boys at most but still obviously male and somewhat masculine, Botw/Totk attracted the worst kinds of people by making Link look like a feminine manlet.
>>725507827
>>725506379
>>725506123
fuck you niggerfaggots, I just started and im having fun
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 4:51:18 AM
No.725513278
[Report]
i kinda like this bitch too
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 4:54:26 AM
No.725513460
[Report]
>>725513531
>>725513010
>I just started and im having fun
Yeah that's what 12-year old me thought too.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 4:54:30 AM
No.725513464
[Report]
and yes i play in japanese
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 4:55:39 AM
No.725513531
[Report]
>>725513460
so you hate it because you thought you were having fun but in hindsight you reject all the fun you had for reasons unknown?
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 4:56:44 AM
No.725513617
[Report]
SPROOT SPROOT, IM FLYING
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:05:02 AM
No.725514073
[Report]
>>725505684
The biggest problem with Skyward Sword is that it holds your hand the whole way through the game. Fi pops out every 15 seconds to tell you something that you already noticed. There's no real sense of exploration because the game just funnels you to exactly where you're supposed to go. And it's so easy. I don't think Zelda games need to be hard by any means, but nothing in skyward sword feels worthwhile because it's so ridiculously easy. I was 13 when this came out and I 100% the game on my first playthrough without realizing it. The dungeons are alright though, but a lot of the items you get in them never get used later on in the game.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:17:00 AM
No.725514698
[Report]
>>725502334
Pic related made Ganondorf a tranny too.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:19:20 AM
No.725514840
[Report]
>>725502334
>Jay Sherman in real life
>>725500746
I beat botw, I dunno why I stopped in the middle of totk like its objectively better from like a dungeon standpoint but I just kind of fell off from totk before I even fought ganondorf who actually looked kinda cool in that one
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:34:34 AM
No.725515684
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
Four Sword Adventures is my favorite because my mom bought me the mangas and I like the dynamic between the four Links in it.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:36:00 AM
No.725515780
[Report]
Majora's mask is my favorite purely because of the darker atmosphere. I wish Nintendo would do more dark stuff in general. BotW is the most fun to play though. OoT and its clones all feel really outdated after playing BotW.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:37:30 AM
No.725515857
[Report]
>>725504287
Based Ganon killing the goatfuckers.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:39:44 AM
No.725515987
[Report]
>>725515528
>I beat botw, I dunno why I stopped in the middle of totk like its objectively better from like a dungeon standpoint but I just kind of fell off from totk before I even fought ganondorf who actually looked kinda cool in that one
The problem with TotK is that they broke the traversal mechanics. BotW's main difficulty/challenge is just getting around the world. Climbing a mountain, crossing a river, getting across an ocean, surviving in the desert/volcano, etc took a lot of work and time. It felt satisfying to explore the world because of how difficult it often was to do so. TotK gives you too many tools to bypass this difficulty. Even if you don't cheese with a flying machine the ability to make a car or launch yourself into the sky and fly somewhere completely destroys all semblance of difficulty in exploring the world, making it trivial.
I don't blame them for doing this, they had to do it. Exploring the world a second time wouldn't be as fun, and the challenge of doing so would turn into frustration and boredom. It's the nature of making a direct sequel to BotW.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:46:28 AM
No.725516368
[Report]
>>725501943
Based anon shitting on BotWtrannies.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:47:28 AM
No.725516424
[Report]
>>725501943
What's that guy's problem?
>"What's your favorite Zelda?"
>Thread devolves into BotW fatigue discussion
I hate BotW but I'm sick of discussing how much I hate it.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:48:52 AM
No.725516516
[Report]
>>725474838
You aren't a Zelda fan if the only games you like are 25+ years old, sorry
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:49:00 AM
No.725516524
[Report]
>>725515528
The dungeons can be completed in 5 minutes. They are a severe downgrade.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:49:52 AM
No.725516578
[Report]
>>725482387
based as always
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:50:41 AM
No.725516639
[Report]
>>725516489
I genuflect...
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:51:21 AM
No.725516680
[Report]
>>725513010
Its good. There are no bad Zelda games.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:54:05 AM
No.725516857
[Report]
>>725517217
>>725473639 (OP)
TP is based asf and should be more respected as an artistic continuation of the N64 titles.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:54:45 AM
No.725516898
[Report]
>>725516489
Zelda has been written off by the mods as only good for engagement farming. All Zelda threads will be derailed by bots, human or otherwise, to be about BOTK because those same five arguments from 5+ years ago still produce massive amounts of site engagement which in turn gets Hiro advertisers and their money.
You will only get the first week or so of a game's release to discuss, and then you are to stop talking about video games and re-engage with the culture wars.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:57:12 AM
No.725517050
[Report]
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:57:41 AM
No.725517091
[Report]
>>725473639 (OP)
S tier
>TP OOT MM
A tier
>SS MC ALTTP ALBW
B tier
>WW BOTW PH ST LA
C tier
>TOTK 4SA EOW
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 5:59:48 AM
No.725517217
[Report]
>>725516857
I don't know if I'd call it an artistic continuation of the N64 duology.
Anonymous
11/11/2025, 6:08:15 AM
No.725517694
[Report]
Majora's Mask, also I might be the only guy in the Orion-Cygnus spiral arm to like Zelda 1 more than Alttp