>>11805330People get confused when they try to remember responses for old things and extrapolate their own circle's opinions to a wider scale.
I remember fans of Morrowind were disappointed and "hardcore" crpg players never really cared for elder scrolls/bethesda in the first place, and they also panned it. Original Fallout fans also hated it. All three of these groups were relatively small, but seemed significant because they were the existing audience for that type of game.
The game ended up selling well because it tapped into the more mainstream market which had previously never heard of or touched the genre. So in the end you have these contradictory accounts people have formed where the game was super unpopular and majorly panned but it was ALSO very popular and sold well.