>>11940413
I've played them all except the newest one on 7th gen console/Steam; and except the first one on DS which is played with the touchpad because fuck that casual shit
Metal Saga on PS2 was a super comfy game however the balancing is horrible. The game is balanced in such a way that 1) if you're behind on lvls compared to your current area you'll be getting a TONS more exp to catch up and 2)once you're a few levels higher than what is intended for an area you're literally invicible (enemies won't even damage you at all). This combined with the freedom of movement the world map offers is a terrible thing: all you have to do is walk a few steps in the wrong direction, fight 4-5 fights, then go back to the "right" direction and you'll be invicible.
1, 2 and Returns are the bests. 3, 2R and 4 are okay as well but they reek of modern anime / modern RPG shit. The thing I enjoyed the most about 4 is that it punishes the players who stick to their comfort zone: if you're betting everything on multi-hit weapons like 2R and 3, you're going to do okay, but it's not the best solution. Instead if you're willing to experiment you'll be rewarded with something that truly breaks the game though I'm not going to spoil what.