>>21445911 (OP)>>21445920For me, it's Myers of Keswick in the West Village. They have it all: pork pies, sausage rolls, Cornish pasties, chicken & leek pies, steak & ale pies, you name it. And a nice dry goods section with HP sauce, Branston, Colman's, Tiptree ketchup, etc if you want.
We also have an Aussie chain called Bourke Street Bakery whose sausage rolls are a little different. They make their own ketchup. Tasty stuff, love their pies too. And over in Queens there's Butcher Block which is primarily an Irish store, they have their own sausage rolls too.