>>21659774
>After COVID, no one carries brownies anymore. I'm not talking about the mass produced shit like little Debbie or that tasteless shit at 7-11. We used to have locally made brownies at the gas stations and convenience stores and they're gone now. I can't remember the last time I had a good brownie.
I recently replicated the test of the top 2 winners from Erika Kwee's updated Brownie Bakeoff here:
https://www.thepancakeprincess.com/best-brownie-bake-off-2-0/
I pitted King Arthur Flour's vs. Brian Lagerstrom's Ultimate Recipe which he developed/released after Erika' bakeoff was conducted:
https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/fudge-brownies-recipe
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=al7_0j1h9x4
I also threw in the control of a box of Ghirardelli Dark Chocolate brownie mix and it's knockoff from Aldi's.
My results were that KAF came out on top just in Erika's bakeoff followed by the box mixes. Brian's recipe was a bit too salty and I had to make a simple chocolate American Buttercream frosting to balance it with sweetness. IDK what went wrong as I weighed the salt (4g). A few comments noted the same issue, so I'd half the amount (use flakey salt on top if extra is desired)
All pans had immaculate texture (between fudgey and chewy) and developed that nice shiny sugar crust on top.
As I said the KAF will be might go-to scratch brownie recipe, but honestly I don't even think it was worth it over the boxed mixes in terms of effort/time.
This Ghirardelli-mimic box mix @ Aldi's was 98% as good at almost half the price ($2.85/18oz vs $3.96/20oz) and 95% as good as from scratch.
What I took away from this baking exercise is that brownies are THE ONE dessert that industrial chemistry has rendered a solved problem.
Protip: Use high-fat (22-24%) cocoa, sometimes it's advertised but if not look for 1-1.5g fat per serving on the label. ATK showed reg. cocoa is too starchy and makes brick brownies + fat carries flavor:
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W-59aMuG92Q&t=85s