>>535544293
ask grok
In Japanese mahjong (riichi mahjong), kuitan nashi (喰い断無し, literally "no open tanyao") is a rule variation that prohibits the tanyao yaku from being scored with an open hand. Explanation:Tanyao (All Simples) is a yaku (scoring condition) where a player's hand consists only of number tiles from 2 to 8 (no terminals [1 or 9] or honor tiles).
Under the kuitan nashi rule, tanyao can only be scored if the hand is closed (i.e., no tiles were claimed from other players' discards via calls like chii, pon, or kan). This makes it harder to achieve tanyao, as players cannot use open melds to form the hand.
If the kuitan ari rule is in play instead, tanyao can be scored with an open hand, making it easier and faster to complete, as players can call discards to form melds.
Purpose:The kuitan nashi rule is often used to emphasize skill and strategy over luck, as it prevents players from quickly forming cheap, open tanyao hands to claim bonus points (e.g., from dora tiles). It encourages players to aim for closed hands or other yaku, increasing the game's complexity.
Context:Kuitan nashi is part of stricter rulesets, like the nashi-nashi ruleset (which also forbids atozuke, or winning without a confirmed yaku). It’s common in conservative settings, such as the Japan Professional Mahjong League (JPML) A Rules, or in certain tournaments like the EMA Riichi Competition Rules.
In contrast, kuitan ari is more common in casual or "exciting" rulesets, like those used in many mahjong parlors or tournaments such as Mahjong Masters and Pro Queen.
In summary, kuitan nashi restricts tanyao to closed hands only, making it a more challenging yaku to achieve in Japanese mahjong.