Stop Killing Games - /v/ (#713794738) [Archived: 691 hours ago]

Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:06:55 PM No.713794738
Screenshot_2025-06-27-20-05-26-71_3aea4af51f236e4932235fdada7d1643
The entire future of ownership literally depends on how much drama slop YouTubers can milk from a YouTube controversy
Replies: >>713794857 >>713794876 >>713795023 >>713795102 >>713795136 >>713795167 >>713795380 >>713796136 >>713796593 >>713796996 >>713797131 >>713797567 >>713797890 >>713798117 >>713798696 >>713798846 >>713798951 >>713799019
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:07:49 PM No.713794786
>>713790004
3282 new signatures since this post was made.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:08:41 PM No.713794826
>nearly 600,000
I can't believer we have people like fucking XQC, Asmond and Charlie to thanks.
This fucking sucks. Why are EU gamers so fucking lazy that they need their sloptubers to tell them to do shit?
Replies: >>713794998 >>713795145 >>713795615 >>713795632 >>713797825 >>713797867 >>713798140 >>713798571
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:09:13 PM No.713794851
All these eceleb communities overlap heavily with the same terminally online audiences, it's not gonna reach the goal unless an actual celebrity endorses it
Replies: >>713794936
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:09:20 PM No.713794857
>>713794738 (OP)
it'll probably end at like 800k, what a shame
Replies: >>713794926 >>713794949
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:09:40 PM No.713794876
>>713794738 (OP)
Wasn't this shit at like 490k before the drama started?
Replies: >>713797638
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:09:57 PM No.713794890
Best way to get this all the way to finish is to make up fake drama around that eceleb furfaggot, people love doing something to spite the degenerates.
Replies: >>713799460
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:10:31 PM No.713794926
>>713794857
>It will plateau soon.
>And if not, it will not reach 100% in 30 days anyway.
>And if it does it doesn't matter, they will probably ignore it.
>And if they don't it will probably not amount to anything.
>And if it does, it's probably for the worse.
>And if it isn't, I was actually manufacturing attention for it all along.
Replies: >>713795389
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:10:48 PM No.713794936
>>713794851
Its legitimately a word of mouth movement
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:10:59 PM No.713794949
>>713794857
shalom, rabbi
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:11:41 PM No.713794998
>>713794826
>Why are EU gamers so fucking lazy that they need their sloptubers to tell them to do shit?
This is the most active petition in the history of the EU, man. Most people just aren't familiar with this system, its a backdoor into the senate that doesn't get used much.
Replies: >>713795806 >>713798850
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:12:01 PM No.713795013
What's your favorite unkillable game? For me it's COD 2.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:12:08 PM No.713795023
>>713794738 (OP)
My games work on my machine.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:12:31 PM No.713795047
If it succeeds because of eceleb drama, then doesn't that say it was never about the movement? Even if you succeed, the means you took to get that result would run contrary to why it was started in the first place.
Replies: >>713795163 >>713795791 >>713796920
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:13:09 PM No.713795073
Why do you want all games to be single player?
Replies: >>713795304
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:13:41 PM No.713795102
>>713794738 (OP)
I hate that literal furfag more than mold man so the latter has my support
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:14:11 PM No.713795136
>>713794738 (OP)
unfortunately it will die down, the collective attention span of this generation is maybe in the ballpark of 2-3 weeks
Replies: >>713795278
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:14:16 PM No.713795145
>>713794826
Because the name is fucking retarded and misleading
Replies: >>713795513 >>713798636 >>713799282
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:14:43 PM No.713795163
>>713795047
I don't care how it succeeds, I care that it succeeds, so I can reap the benefits as a gamer.
If some wacko jewish vegan communist gay tranny in EU senate makes it xir pet issue for gay communist reasons, and pushes it into law, then YAAAAS SLAY QUEEEEEN I love it, no homo.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:14:44 PM No.713795167
>>713794738 (OP)
lol clown world but at least that pirate faggot is making himself an easy target.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:16:32 PM No.713795278
>>713795136
Every normie plays GaaS shit and is afraid of what will happen to his gacha waifus and skins after EoS, this isn't something people are going to forget
Replies: >>713797051
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:16:37 PM No.713795282
1609396018811
1609396018811
md5: 9eaa95b644e0af619338e44d4765bda0🔍
Facts, laws and details are boring and confusing; drama and hype is exciting.

This is why god's chosen look down on goyim, they know how frightenly easy it is to manipulate people. Terms and Conditions may apply
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:17:00 PM No.713795304
>>713795073
It's not. It's literally just "let people run peer-to-peer or community servers when you shut yours down". Shit that was commonplace for over 20 years, before shareholders decided its more profitable to introduce artificial killswitches that force you to buy new products when old ones are no longer at peak profitability.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:18:22 PM No.713795380
>>713794738 (OP)
Britcuck here
Should I vote a third time or is it useless?
Replies: >>713795409 >>713795489 >>713795556
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:18:32 PM No.713795389
>>713794926
Doom piller are actual shills, don't assume stupidity when it's clearly malice
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:18:52 PM No.713795409
>>713795380
you can't vote
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:20:16 PM No.713795489
>>713795380
I doubt anything will come of it, those parliament petitions just lead to debates with 5 MPs that barely care.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:20:37 PM No.713795510
1700891805176425
1700891805176425
md5: a764c543cd401e0a3b45bcceb7b59057🔍
>give me your server binaries
Replies: >>713797452 >>713797567
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:20:40 PM No.713795513
>>713795145
I'll bite. How is the name 'retarded and misleading'?
If anything, it's too short.
Stop Killing Games (and Make an off-line version available.)
But the name is what the goal is. We want companies to stop killing games, i.e. making them inaccessible.
Replies: >>713796530 >>713799280
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:21:30 PM No.713795556
>>713795380
https://www.stopkillinggames.com/countries/united_kingdom
there's some uk petition going on but i don't think you can do the eu one.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:22:34 PM No.713795612
1723027638635547
1723027638635547
md5: afdd4561b2f9d91c14e2fc2d867a99f6🔍
I'm all for more radical shit like abolishing copyright/IP law altogether or at least having something like "game's source code is open after 5 years of release" or "once a game becomes abandonware it cannot be brought back into a license". Being able to play a live service game indefinitely is a drop in a bucket. I voted for SKG, but I wish there could've been more
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:22:35 PM No.713795615
>>713794826
because most of us don't speak english, so unless you get italian youtubers and instagrammers to talk about it, they will keep living in blissful ignorance of any of this happening
Replies: >>713796290
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:22:35 PM No.713795616
WHY
WHY
md5: 27ff1824fa45fbbc933dd1a057ce3fde🔍
The wave of sloptubers shitting on pirate isn't enough, fuck him completely. no room for recovery.

Leaked chatlogs where he's in the middle of a gay furry erp session, dox a child, brags about being an ex blizzard developer, then goes back to gay furry erping. This should be enough. Tell me it's enough to finish him off.
Replies: >>713795705 >>713796036
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:22:37 PM No.713795618
I don't think any of the games that would die are worth saving, but I also want the devs who made those shit games to suffer so I support it.
Replies: >>713796091
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:22:57 PM No.713795632
>>713794826
Because I simply don't buy live service games.
Replies: >>713796765 >>713797210 >>713797662 >>713798937
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:24:15 PM No.713795705
>>713795616
at least they can spell "dox" correctly
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:25:55 PM No.713795791
>>713795047
Yeah this anon is right, let's scrap the entire petition, make a new one and make sure no one covers it. That way we'll win honorably.

Greetings from Bijapur
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:26:13 PM No.713795806
>>713794998
this is the real answer
people just don't know about it and the jewish vampires DON'T want you to know about it
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:27:33 PM No.713795886
>Petition falls just short of goal
>Piratefag and others gloat about it failing
>Politicians see how close it got and decide to take a look anyway
That would be the funniest outcome.
Replies: >>713796001 >>713796107
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:29:47 PM No.713796001
>>713795886
>>Politicians see how close it got and decide to take a look anyway
this would never happen
if anything they would raise the signature requirement to 1 million
Replies: >>713797063
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:29:59 PM No.713796013
IMG_20250627_152917
IMG_20250627_152917
md5: bf5c09c09774fd98f00dd62e29d292e0🔍
>this is fine
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:30:20 PM No.713796036
>>713795616
nothing wrong with any of this desu
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:31:06 PM No.713796091
>>713795618
>but I also want the devs who made those shit games to suffer so I support it.
bingo. i see so many /v/tards say that that don't play online only games so why should they care. this movement still applies. it causes live service games to be more expensive to make with more requirements to make them instead of just abusing a shitty gray area. the more devs suffer for trying to do gaas memes, the less slop there will be. and it prevents even worse shit in the future where all singleplayer games will require a private server to function like the crew.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:31:21 PM No.713796107
>>713795886
i dont get why people things the suits would do anything even if they got their signatures
Replies: >>713797767
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:31:54 PM No.713796136
>>713794738 (OP)
I really want this to reach its goal. Because it will be so fucking funny when this gets up for debate in the EU and immediately they just ask why the fuck gamers are so entitled they think they deserve 100x the protections and benefits of any other entertainment medium in existence, then toss it off the debate docket instantly.
It would be better than any other prior drama leading up to it.
Replies: >>713796560 >>713797934 >>713798249 >>713798814 >>713798985
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:34:00 PM No.713796254
Is there any population-based logic behind one million signatures being the threshold for pasing, or is it just people liking nice round numbers?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:34:35 PM No.713796290
1749562445646045
1749562445646045
md5: 7c75872fc00e156f1f9544f5a47903c2🔍
>>713795615
this is true, in Poland still noone talks about that shit, american sloptubers would have to bend down to european streamers and ask them to promote it or do whatever, speaking for Polish communities, I wouldn't say they care enough to start an initiative, they literally need to be told to
Replies: >>713798256 >>713799191
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:36:28 PM No.713796394
file
file
md5: 0ce8caa51b114010d7e2f3dd50e658aa🔍
>What was I supposed to do? Not leak DMs?
Replies: >>713796725 >>713797115 >>713797234 >>713797249 >>713797542 >>713798256 >>713799303
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:37:08 PM No.713796434
Looking at the other petitions that have passed, he should have called it Stop Killing Game, to trick people into thinking it's about animal rights.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:38:35 PM No.713796530
>>713795513
Europe is a continent of geriatrics, the average age in germany is like 50 something. "Stop killing games!" sounds like a child crying about some bingbing wahoo shit when in actuality its about stopping companies from taking away the product that you bought and own
Replies: >>713797449
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:39:18 PM No.713796560
>>713796136
>they just ask why the fuck gamers are so entitled they think they deserve 100x the protections and benefits of any other entertainment medium in existence
that might happen. and if it does it's still a good opportunity to remind people that the only thing in their lives now that doesn't come with DRM is basic home furniture, even our whitegoods appliances are dangerously close to being remotely brickable subscription service machines
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:39:45 PM No.713796593
1555263437439
1555263437439
md5: b142e6929e0fa3f086402dfef5feba3e🔍
>>713794738 (OP)
I don't really care since I don't buy the kind of multiplayer slop this concerns anyway, but I just signed it out of spite because the FUD against it has been ridiculous.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:40:45 PM No.713796646
Screenshot_2025-06-27-15-39-16-444_com.android.chrome
Screenshot_2025-06-27-15-39-16-444_com.android.chrome
md5: 392e85f1a9f371e16ff3a88f0f3db072🔍
>Pirate is the top result for the initiative, before the initiative's own page
Eceleb drama is rocket fuel.
Replies: >>713796832
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:42:12 PM No.713796725
>>713796394
What a clown
Replies: >>713797249
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:42:22 PM No.713796738
vote with your wallet

>but other people don't
good for them, i hope they got their money's worth
Replies: >>713797412
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:42:44 PM No.713796759
😌
😌
md5: 46a6f530264454818742cc3c2fb644db🔍
I wish I was still European.
Replies: >>713798048
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:42:49 PM No.713796765
>>713795632
Do you know it can be arbitrarily added to any kind of game?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:43:56 PM No.713796832
>>713796646
I'm strictly utilitarian on this, if e-celeb drama is what's needed then so be it. A good thing done for bad reasons is still a good thing.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:43:58 PM No.713796835
do any of the signers even care or are really informed about this or are they just zoomer zombies doing what their favorite streamer is telling them to do?
Replies: >>713796905 >>713796948
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:45:02 PM No.713796905
>>713796835
Does it matter?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:45:16 PM No.713796920
>>713795047
So?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:45:43 PM No.713796948
>>713796835
Nah it's just one guy with multiple personality that all agrees you're retarded
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:46:00 PM No.713796960
432434242
432434242
md5: 78a9f569ed960b35dd3ccfa1d5de49da🔍
>Stop Killing Games might actually succeed because of e-drama over a lolcow
Replies: >>713797014 >>713797029 >>713797112
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:46:49 PM No.713796996
>>713794738 (OP)
>Some people say that this is the worst timeline, I disagree, it could be so much worse, a lot of people have no idea, but if you where to say that this was the dumbest timeline? yeah I can't argue with you. see ya
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:46:49 PM No.713796997
The most depressing part of Ross's new video was "all it'd take to get 1mil signatures and make the EU act on this would be pewdiepie making a video"

And it's true. World is such a goddamn circus.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:47:06 PM No.713797014
>>713796960
it isnt going to succeed even if it gets 1mil
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:47:19 PM No.713797025
>Companies sell off the rights to some games they want to kill to a shell company, but retain ownership of the larger IPs
>Shell company goes out of business without releasing code or binaries or anything
>EU can't penalize a dead company, and since it doesn't belong to the original company anymore it's not their responsibility either
Why wouldn't this work?
Replies: >>713797220 >>713797497 >>713797548 >>713799267
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:47:27 PM No.713797029
>>713796960
I'm guessing the votes are going to deaccelerate and not meet the daily average quota by day 3. It's always the first couple of days that have the largest burst of votes.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:47:50 PM No.713797051
>>713795278
do you think people like that ever look up from their pachinko?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:48:00 PM No.713797063
>>713796001
>if anything they would raise the signature requirement to 1 million
It is 1 million.
Replies: >>713797089
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:48:22 PM No.713797080
zoomers are so useless and retarded
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:48:32 PM No.713797089
>>713797063
the jewish vampires win again
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:48:53 PM No.713797112
>>713796960
That's kinda how dropkiwifarms backfired. The trannies to get rid of the site but it only made it more popular while the trannies ended up being exposed as sex pests
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:48:58 PM No.713797115
>>713796394
Thank God he's so hateable. It makes more people sign
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:49:27 PM No.713797131
>>713794738 (OP)
No it doesn't, you're just retarded and do desperate for a tribe that you latched onto this.
Replies: >>713797236
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:50:47 PM No.713797210
>>713795632
They can still make a game unplayable on purpose so you buy the remaster.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:50:55 PM No.713797220
>>713797025
how do you get the employees to bag hold?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:51:07 PM No.713797234
>>713796394
holy shit cunt is such a massive narcissist
Replies: >>713797258
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:51:12 PM No.713797236
>>713797131
Jeet mad
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:51:32 PM No.713797249
>>713796394
>>713796725
Yeah, Ross is pretty funny
Chet's video is pretty spot-on, Ross is way on the left side of dunning-kruger. The moss may have infected his brain.
Replies: >>713797318 >>713797905
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:51:44 PM No.713797258
>>713797234
they are both p awful people
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:52:40 PM No.713797317
1738394539983615
1738394539983615
md5: 32f09b02406c1c7fcf25a7962c442635🔍
Just admit you fucking lost
Replies: >>713797521 >>713797527
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:52:45 PM No.713797318
>>713797249
What video?
Replies: >>713797589
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:54:20 PM No.713797412
>>713796738
They don't. They get their shit stolen.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:54:57 PM No.713797449
>>713796530
> "Stop killing games!" sounds like a child crying about some bingbing wahoo shit when in actuality-
It IS children crying about bing bing wahoo shit.
Replies: >>713797557
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:55:02 PM No.713797452
>>713795510
>give me the server binaries i paid for
FTFY
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:55:35 PM No.713797494
3779149-no-you-move-cap-says
3779149-no-you-move-cap-says
md5: 38b92c5498f4f51667d65608a8149eb8🔍
I support right to repair
I support archive org
I support scihub
I support stopkillinggames
I denounce every attempt to weaponize IPs and EULAs against the customer.
Replies: >>713797779 >>713797848 >>713797894
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:55:40 PM No.713797497
>>713797025
sound like a lot of hassle compared to just developing a game with an end of life plan, considering that a legislation would require these services to have one when they first hit the market
It would also amount to a ton of bad PR in a world where everyone else comply
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:55:55 PM No.713797515
wouldnt this greatly increase the price of those games
Replies: >>713797775
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:56:00 PM No.713797521
1745024947398d
1745024947398d
md5: 4bce151fb3dff66646ae2d56ba975eb9🔍
>>713797317
His face is so fucking hideous man, the epitome phenotype of a dumbass overconfident furfag from furaffinity.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:56:07 PM No.713797527
>>713797317
>side with the Empire
>do nothing
>Empire defeats the revolt
>declare you won
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:56:21 PM No.713797542
>>713796394
>Replying with a "your way or the highway goes both ways" to a message that clearly says it's not whether you support SKG or not
>Leak the DM as if he won
damn, he's fucking retarded
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:56:28 PM No.713797548
>>713797025
Yeah. Why don't everyone do this any time they would have gone into bankruptcy?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:56:41 PM No.713797557
>>713797449
>he smugly proclaimed, on the vietnamese basket weaving forum dedicated to said bing bing wahoo
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:56:49 PM No.713797567
>>713794738 (OP)
I got two signatures for it, one being mine

I did my part, I'm sorry Ross

gamers are no longer epic, don't expect us, we don't rise up.

>>713795510
BASED
Replies: >>713797741
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:56:58 PM No.713797581
1724473861992230
1724473861992230
md5: a11704576a841e0b492756fd95063263🔍
I'm not signing shit
Replies: >>713797909
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:57:06 PM No.713797589
>>713797318
He made a long video actually pointing out all the necessary consequences and complications of SKG that Ross and co refuse to accept, but I was referring to his appraisal of how these direct arguments with Ross have gone:
https://youtu.be/jOPqzsl7Ey0?si=rcn1y-IdiLBxVYPq
Replies: >>713797726 >>713797737 >>713797787 >>713797905 >>713797961
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:58:00 PM No.713797638
eutotal
eutotal
md5: 869e01e3813e10923ffa493c5d658239🔍
>>713794876
More like 455k. Now it gets around 50k daily so they might bag this in a few days.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:58:23 PM No.713797662
>>713795632
You realize online DRM is also a "live service" that will kill your game at some point, right? That's in basically every game sold nowadays. We just want a guarantee that it'll keep working when those servers inevitably shut down.
Replies: >>713797823
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:59:26 PM No.713797726
>>713797589
>ross is retarded, because his argument is 1+1=3
I am not making a joke, that's what the guy in the video says. Its a quote from the video. I think he may be retarded.
Replies: >>713797803 >>713797843
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:59:36 PM No.713797737
>>713797589
ross and co and nothing but retarded grifters, no different from the rest of streamers
Replies: >>713797787 >>713797905
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 2:59:38 PM No.713797741
>>713797567
Why are the proponents of this so fucking cringe
You fags post awful doge memes and ancient retard-speak like an AI asked to imitate how 12 year olds talked to each other in 2005
Replies: >>713797873
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:00:04 PM No.713797767
>>713796107
Because they are required to write a legal evaluation at the bare minimum. And I highly doubt they'd just put in black and white that digital consumers have no rights.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:00:15 PM No.713797775
>>713797515
ross goes over this
realistically, adding an offline patch would have a negligible cost, 1% of the total or honestly MUCH less than that
but, corpos being greedy, they can easily jack up prices by 20 or 30 or 300% and use SKG as the excuse, like they did with inflation and covid and tariffs
Replies: >>713797875
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:00:16 PM No.713797779
530l4h
530l4h
md5: 696048dbe18029adc699f147dcbe2967🔍
>>713797494
NOOOOOOOOOOOOO THINK OF THE SHAREHOLDERS AND FISCAL QUARTERS AAAAAAIIIIIIIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:00:24 PM No.713797787
>>713797737
>>713797589
Jeet seething
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:00:32 PM No.713797794
Vote with your wallet, by getting your ID card out of it and using it to sign the petition.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:00:39 PM No.713797803
>>713797726
No, anon, that's not what he's saying and you're retarded.
Congrats.
Replies: >>713797905 >>713798112
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:00:55 PM No.713797823
Well_Yes%2C_But_Actually_No
Well_Yes%2C_But_Actually_No
md5: 8bbddfec4a4ef9fb780d856dda153582🔍
>>713797662
Yes, but actually no. DRM is just some wrapper without which the game still runs. Both pirates and devs themselves have removed denuvo from plenty of games without impacting the actual thing at all.
Replies: >>713798226
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:00:57 PM No.713797825
>>713794826
Hey I signed the petition a year ago
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:01:18 PM No.713797843
>>713797726
dude look visibly intoxicated, barely a coherent sentence
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:01:22 PM No.713797848
rubs fingers_thumb.jpg
rubs fingers_thumb.jpg
md5: 40c99ce3d6ac51c63207743c17097965🔍
>>713797494
NOOOOOO THE MONEY HATES IT WHEN YOU DO THAT AND THE MONEY WILL GO AWAY WHEN YOU DO THAT
NOOOOO MONEY PLEASE COME BACK DONT LEAVE
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:01:31 PM No.713797858
1737345912577286
1737345912577286
md5: f0e7598b37ab353088ed4cdc79b7c5e0🔍
>piRAT ROACHware is currently live and seething about people purchasing heartbound leaving a negative review and then refunding the game immediately
>reviews are 90% negative because of people doing this
kek sucked in faggot, i'm going to do this now too. gaben's very generous refund policy is such a joy
Replies: >>713797931 >>713797954 >>713798870
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:01:43 PM No.713797867
1744133599299991
1744133599299991
md5: 6e2004da8ac784037f559b1d5eebe155🔍
>>713794826
Barely anyone knew about this shit, nigga. I only found out about it last year from this place so the average normalfag would not even know about it.
Replies: >>713798183
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:01:48 PM No.713797873
file
file
md5: e3a8beb516a5e47ad0064eaf3ce90d15🔍
>>713797741
tell me how you really feel.
Replies: >>713798010
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:01:52 PM No.713797875
>>713797775
>Dude it wouldn't cost anything trust me
>Source: I made it up
Replies: >>713798002
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:02:05 PM No.713797890
le funny frog
le funny frog
md5: 1f96b1beba849301810485d44bdc5f89🔍
>>713794738 (OP)
No, I won't support european communism, thank you very much. The Free Market works.
Replies: >>713798621
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:02:12 PM No.713797894
>>713797494
>I support archive org
these faggots keep blocking URLs and taking down archives of shit people want the moment they become too popular or valuable.
I hope they shut down just to spite them.
Replies: >>713797992
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:02:20 PM No.713797905
1712783563617623_thumb.jpg
1712783563617623_thumb.jpg
md5: b625e0ee194a36364029f3f308a0fb73🔍
>>713797589
>>713797803
>>713797737
>>713797249
SAAAAAAAR DO NOT REDEEM THE PETITION
Replies: >>713798828 >>713798892
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:02:24 PM No.713797909
>>713797581
He can't even sign, he's American
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:02:54 PM No.713797931
>>713797858
>>piRAT ROACHware is currently live and seething about people purchasing heartbound leaving a negative review and then refunding the game immediately
BASED
Replies: >>713798095
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:02:57 PM No.713797934
>>713796136
this should open the door for software
Replies: >>713797998 >>713798338
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:03:11 PM No.713797954
>>713797858
thanks for letting me know this is a thing. i'll do it too.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:03:20 PM No.713797961
>>713797589
Good lord, what an unhinged seething moron.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:03:52 PM No.713797992
>>713797894
That's the price of staying up at all in this hostile landscape. Don't blame them for defending themselves from vulture lawyers.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:03:56 PM No.713797997
It's literally all here

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WzYgMEdwbIU&list=WL&index=11

Jason is literally nothing but a NPD'er
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:03:56 PM No.713797998
>>713797934
Good point. We already pay licenses for software. Games are software. Get lost.
Replies: >>713798058
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:04:00 PM No.713798002
>>713797875
>reading comprehension
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:04:11 PM No.713798010
>>713797873
I feel like I'm tired of discord children raiding the board for e-celeb trash
Replies: >>713798136
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:04:16 PM No.713798017
>this might be something good/beneficial so i have to automatically take the most contrarian position possible, and actually le good thing is le bad and the person supporting le bad thing is le good

don't you niggers get tired of having to be opposite on literally everything 24/7
Replies: >>713798103 >>713798197
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:04:44 PM No.713798048
>>713796759
brit?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:04:59 PM No.713798058
>>713797998
>things are bad
>they can't be better
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:05:39 PM No.713798095
>>713797931
Fuck, I should do that but I don't even want him to have a cent of my money for a single second of his life.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:05:44 PM No.713798103
>>713798017
theres nothing good about this though, its like black lives matter
Replies: >>713798168
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:05:50 PM No.713798112
hmmm
hmmm
md5: da973adbd38d8a6c0c34d895c21cc025🔍
>>713797803
I don't know, man. I've read the SKG website, and it didn't just say 1+1=3. I think your guy might be mistaken.
Replies: >>713798253
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:06:00 PM No.713798117
>>713794738 (OP)
>makes this thread
>most definitely owns a switch 2

Okay.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:06:20 PM No.713798136
file
file
md5: 11b1314fda0a7def40ca14d0774a119f🔍
>>713798010
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:06:23 PM No.713798140
>>713794826
Britbonger here, I would have signed it and I imagine a huge amount would have also, but we stopped counting as European and can't sign the petition.
Replies: >>713798176 >>713798207
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:06:47 PM No.713798168
>>713798103
good job you're being as contrarian as possible, this is exactly the same as black lives matter there's zero difference, very board culture you can sit at the /v/ cool kids table now my based kek chad
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:07:01 PM No.713798176
>>713798140
>leaves EU
>omg how what do u mean we're not europeans anymore??
Replies: >>713798217
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:07:10 PM No.713798183
1745924866557314
1745924866557314
md5: e48442cc913d21f0b70fa11fb87464fa🔍
>>713797867
It doesn't help it that the campaign videos were in english only and Ross didn't use his 2 braincells to maybe contact notable euro e-celebs to actually get them to advertise the movement. How fucking hard is it to go on twitch and look up the top 5 most popular gaming streamers for each EU country and tell them "hey there's this movement that will let you play online games for as long as you want. Might wanna give me a shoutout for $50?" Ross has to be genuinely retarded.
I'm eu myself and I know from 1st hand experience that most EUfags don't watch american ecelebs like XQC or Critial, they watch their own literal whos that speak in their mumble languages and think this is the shit.
Replies: >>713798430 >>713798448 >>713798639
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:07:25 PM No.713798197
>>713798017
Stripping rights from IP-holders and making entire architectures commercially unviable is not a good thing.
This is people with no foresight or understanding screeching that they want play video game forever vs actual adults telling them why what they want isn't that simple and that other people exist.

A pretty classic internet tale, honestly.
Replies: >>713798232 >>713798269 >>713798309 >>713798952 >>713798956 >>713799101
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:07:39 PM No.713798207
>>713798140
There is a UK stop killing game petition too
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:07:54 PM No.713798217
>>713798176
TRUE, that anon is a total dick for singlehandedly doing that
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:08:00 PM No.713798225
hope this fails so the normie faggots that watch streamers can fuck off from my board
Replies: >>713798334
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:08:01 PM No.713798226
>>713797823
That's one form of drm.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:08:12 PM No.713798232
>>713798197
yeah it's childish to expect the digital equivalent of right to repair, post nose rabbi
Replies: >>713798312
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:08:25 PM No.713798249
>>713796136
having the whole thing being dismissed is still better than the current limbo we live in right now, where people BELIEVE that they can own things digitally.
shattering this belief once and for all would have value in itself. not the outcome ross wishes for, he genuinely wants to save as many games as possible, but we would finally have closure at least.
no more legal loopholes
no more grey areas
transparency is all i ask. if the EU gives up on our digital ownership rights like japan and america did, then i'll just never buy anything online ever again
it's our last chance to make things right
Replies: >>713798365 >>713798729
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:08:26 PM No.713798253
>>713798112
You had me for a second ngl
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:08:26 PM No.713798256
>>713796290
That's a cute gal
>>713796394
>was hoping to have an actual conversation
The fuck?
Didn't this faggot tell Ross to fuck off at every instance dialogue was offered?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:08:32 PM No.713798262
>pirate everything
>no drm
>no always online
>keep it forever as a backup on my dedicated NAS
I techically already own everything.
Replies: >>713798590
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:08:43 PM No.713798269
>>713798197
>Stripping rights from IP-holders
you should have your voting rights stripped mouthbreather
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:09:26 PM No.713798309
>>713798197
>making entire architectures commercially unviable
not that anon but if live service games became unviable it would be the best thing to happen to gaming in decades. i'd support it twice as hard if it wasn't about preserving anything at all but rather just making live service games illegal.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:09:26 PM No.713798312
>>713798232
>This is the same as right to repair!
Yeah, you're a child.
Replies: >>713798405 >>713798486
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:09:53 PM No.713798334
>>713798225
never gonna happen, me and my e-daddies run this board, bitch
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:09:58 PM No.713798338
>>713797934
Software that sells like a good, but acts like a subscription anyway.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:10:39 PM No.713798365
>>713798249
>People believe that buying a game means they get to play it forever!
No, that's just children and retards.
Replies: >>713798470 >>713798556
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:11:26 PM No.713798405
>>713798312
Its literally a crime to create an emulator for a game that the publisher has taken down from market.
It is a crime to emulate vanilla WoW. You aren't allowed to repair the World of Warcraft that you bought, and that the company which sold to you has since broken.
Replies: >>713798931
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:11:50 PM No.713798430
>>713798183
I can bet you my mother's life that most EU gamers have never heard of ross or "thor"
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:12:04 PM No.713798448
>>713798183
Ross is too autistic/good to follow actual political strategies.
He would never consider paying someone for a shoutout, not because he's cheap, but because it's not right.
He probably didn't even intend to get this much exposure just from fighting Pirate
Replies: >>713798614
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:12:33 PM No.713798470
>>713798365
You got it the wrong way around.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:12:53 PM No.713798486
>>713798312
I'm going to sign it 5 more times just so that you shit yourself in your synagogue out of rage
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:14:03 PM No.713798556
>>713798365
you would be right if the buy button explicitly included an expiration date, like live service subscriptions do
again, transparency
if digital purchases are really RENTING LICENSES, then remove the buy button and change it to rent, everywhere, with an explicit expiration date.
being legally defined as a live service demands specific requirements that a LOT of games shutting down nowadays with no refunds do not have.
Replies: >>713799104
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:14:16 PM No.713798571
>>713794826
Maybe because there was no advertisement for this, and no one even knows this exists?!
We NEED someone talking about this, genious.
Replies: >>713798662
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:14:31 PM No.713798590
>>713798262
I literally haven't bought a game in 19 years. I have three 18 TB HDDs full of installers, romsets, ISO compilations, romhack archives, movies, anime and shit
I still signed the petition because I miss the era where you could hold your own servers. I also greatly appreciate the private server culture so there's that. I haven't been affected by live service game slop in a long time but can still see the benefits of the stop killing games initiative.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:14:54 PM No.713798614
>>713798448
Ross admitted this shit at every step of the way, that he doesn't want to do any of this shit. But alas, he got too bothered by the state of things and no-one was doing shit about it. So he became the call to arms
Replies: >>713798725
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:14:58 PM No.713798621
>>713797890
>ownership is communism
KEK
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:15:15 PM No.713798636
>>713795145
you retards never offer alternatives
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:15:16 PM No.713798639
19576a90b6c61515263309377af47693
19576a90b6c61515263309377af47693
md5: 35e4787841aa9a0612ff8e32d3a55603🔍
>>713798183
I think he DID say that he did not want to be a nuisance and if I recall something about this being political so you never know how Twitch/Youtube would react to it.
Replies: >>713798723
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:15:36 PM No.713798654
>petition
Amazing how deluded retards are thinking it will actually matter even if it hits its signature goal and is tabled infront of the eu parliment
Replies: >>713798729 >>713798785 >>713799052
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:15:40 PM No.713798662
>>713798571
>We NEED someone talking about this, genious
And by someone maybe an european talking europeans. Ross is an american preaching to an american audience about a movement only european can vote for.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:16:17 PM No.713798696
>>713794738 (OP)
if this ross nigga is actually serious about Stop Killing Games why doesn't he make videos for the German or Spanish audiences? Who is he pandering to the UK?
Replies: >>713799468
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:16:41 PM No.713798723
>>713798639
OH MY FUCKING GOD SO HE *IS* A RETARD!
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:16:43 PM No.713798725
>>713798614
he should've looked for someone to pass the mantle to once it got off the ground, then. if you aren't going to steer the ship, get the fuck off of the wheel. why commit to something with only half of your heart?
Replies: >>713798798 >>713798840 >>713798989
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:16:48 PM No.713798729
>>713798654
>>713798249
Replies: >>713798896
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:17:52 PM No.713798785
>>713798654
At least it was worth trying
Replies: >>713798896
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:18:07 PM No.713798798
>>713798725
Pass the mantle to who? No one ever stepped up
Replies: >>713798994
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:18:21 PM No.713798814
>>713796136
give up for the 3000th post of "heh...even if you get the signatures, it won't matter....."
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:18:35 PM No.713798828
>>713797905
This indian is more white than us.
Replies: >>713798948
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:18:47 PM No.713798840
>>713798725
He said that he's leaving the efforts if the initiative fails and that people are free to take after him
Replies: >>713798994
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:18:52 PM No.713798846
>>713794738 (OP)
Didn't this reach 50% in like the first week? Did shit deflate that quickly?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:18:54 PM No.713798850
>>713794998
No it isn't, there was one that got 1.8 million signatures
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:19:08 PM No.713798870
>>713797858
These people are fucking retarded. If you want to review bomb at least avoid mentioning SKG or any other offtopic shit. Now the cockroach will be able to cry to Gaben and have those reviews removed for brigading.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:19:25 PM No.713798892
>>713797905
I can't tell if this is sarcastic or not. I think that makes it even funnier.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:19:29 PM No.713798896
>>713798729
>>713798785
You have too much faith in the democratic process my anons nothing will come of this whether it succeeds or fails and free to screencap this post if im wrong and i will put a shoe on my head with a timestamp
Replies: >>713799131
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:20:00 PM No.713798931
>>713798405
>It's a crime to make an emulator/server!
No it isn't you fucking moron
It's illegal to use protected documentation or decompilation to steal code/info and use that to make an emu/server.
If you can manage to reverse engineer one without cracking or stealing documentation it's perfectly legal.

You. Are. A. Child.
Replies: >>713799043 >>713799105
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:20:05 PM No.713798937
u are amazing
u are amazing
md5: 619918498994f97d0ae726d31a72b679🔍
>>713795632
You can still vote for it.
Despite not living at some town farther away in my country, if there is a petition on fixing/building a bridge to make travel safer for people, I happily vote for it and even throw a small donation if I can.
It is nice to help people and advocate for stuff that is useful for others. Same reason why you take back your shopping cart or move a larger stone from the to the ditch so nobody hits it with their bike/wheelchair or generally trip on it.

You can do stuff that helps others even if it doesn't affect you right now. Do the right thing.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:20:15 PM No.713798948
1737500661668657
1737500661668657
md5: 36ee8d1a2e4e4b65c98e9e786636a7ba🔍
>>713798828
>than us
speak for yourself you fucking mystery meat mutt with 500 preservatives
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:20:17 PM No.713798951
>>713794738 (OP)
>The entire future of ownership
Who are you helping by spreading lies like this?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:20:18 PM No.713798952
>>713798197
Wild idea, but maybe a business model SHOULDN'T be viable if it relies on violating consumer rights? If your company needs to do that to survive it needs to die.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:20:21 PM No.713798956
>>713798197
>Stripping rights from IP-holders and making entire architectures commercially unviable is not a good thing
>because... BECAUSE I SAID SO OKAY??!
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:20:46 PM No.713798985
>>713796136
Nothing about the legislation would e about "games", they'd have to treat it as software
I always wondered why Ross never tackled it from that angle, he's either hyperfocused on vidya or knows that his only hope is to tile up manchildren
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:20:48 PM No.713798989
>>713798725
>why commit to something with only half of your heart?
Ross done so much shit and sacrificed so much that admittedly he can't even pay rent
Promoting, doing legal research and preparations, talking with EU representatives, you name it. Guy is just tired
Replies: >>713799237
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:20:50 PM No.713798994
>>713798798
i said look for, e.g. take an active role in reaching out to and talking to people, not waiting for someone to "step up".
>>713798840
if you aim for the king, you can't miss. there won't be a second chance.
Replies: >>713799120
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:21:15 PM No.713799019
>>713794738 (OP)
woah did it gain 100k+ new votes?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:21:40 PM No.713799043
>>713798931
Blizzard sued and shut down many servers based on reverse engineering code, not including the leaked early WoW beta code. So... no?
Also Bethesda shut down a Skyrim multiplayer mod, for creating from scratch a server for that game, to synchronize 2 clients.
Replies: >>713799297
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:21:49 PM No.713799052
>>713798654
Citizen's initiative is not a petition.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:22:34 PM No.713799101
>>713798197
>Stripping rights from IP-holders
It is absolutely a good thing. The fact that a corporate entity can own IPs, which were originally created for human artists, is a sick perversion of the legal system.
It's absolute clownshit that companies are treated like people and this entire notion needs to be torn down with extreme prejudice.
Replies: >>713799165
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:22:37 PM No.713799104
>>713798556
You are purchasing a limited license to run client software and access online services.
This is made clear both on storefronts and in the licensing agreement.
All of which is meaningless, because the actual demand is that "all games be left in a playable state."
You're basically just blanking out the actual petition and substituting what you want it to be. Because you're a child.
Replies: >>713799221 >>713799346
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:22:38 PM No.713799105
>>713798931
Breaking DRM is the illegal part. How would you get the game running without publisher support and NOT break the DRM? It's basically illegal in practice.

And they still actively go after perfectly legal emulated private servers, just because they can, not because they are illegal.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:22:54 PM No.713799120
>>713798994
what makes you think he hasn't been doing just that for the past few years?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:23:04 PM No.713799131
>>713798896
you seem to misunderstand the situation we are in
we are not doing this because we see it as the ideal way
we are doing this because THERE IS NO OTHER WAY.
it's this petition passing, or we own nothing and be happy, for generations to come
the chances are slim to none, but the alternative is holing up in my room playing my old ps1 discs til the day i did
Replies: >>713799234
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:23:28 PM No.713799165
>>713799101
>The fact that a corporate entity can own IPs
And before that an IP was owned by a person
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:23:47 PM No.713799191
>>713796290
Poles are so cucked you could shit in their mouths and they'd ask for more. Their society has the same bad habit of corpo worship as redneck America, in both cases it's usually the uneducated poorfags who bend over backwards so that corpos can make moar monies. For some reason these "people" are allowed to vote alongside the rest of us.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:24:18 PM No.713799221
>>713799104
>licensing agreements
eulas are not legally binding
a main goal of this campaign is creating legislation that will throw all current eula out of the window
they will all have to br rewritten
Replies: >>713799371
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:24:28 PM No.713799234
>>713799131
>it's this petition passing, or we own nothing and be happy, for generations to come
You're not helping your cause by spreading hyperbolic lies
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:24:31 PM No.713799237
>>713798989
Sounds like Ross is just kind of fucking retarded.
Not my problem.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:24:58 PM No.713799267
>>713797025
Do that few times and it goes under investigation, then when someone speaks up or leaks some e-mails it's fucking nightmare for the company, a PR disaster, and a legal battle you cannot win.
...Or you could just add the offline mode. Or rather, NOT REMOVE THE OFFLINE MODE THAT DEVS USE ALL THE TIME TO TEST THEIR SHIT.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:25:16 PM No.713799280
>>713795513
Game Preservation Initiative
Game Anti-Extinction Movement

Hell, "Save Games!" sounds less alarmist than "Stop Killing Games!"
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:25:17 PM No.713799282
>>713795145
This. Should be something like "Preserve Our Games"
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:25:31 PM No.713799297
>>713799043
>Nuh uh!
Blizzard shut down servers that were made with code leaks
You're just wrong, anon. There's a reason Nintendo can't go after shit like bsnes.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:25:35 PM No.713799303
>>713796394
>was hoping to have an actual conversation with you
THIS FUCKING GUY
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:26:12 PM No.713799346
>>713799104
It's fucking irrelevant if it's buried in the license agreement. Those are mostly void in the EU anyway. And if the button says "buy", then they are selling it as a good, which can't be taken away at a whim.
Replies: >>713799453
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:26:30 PM No.713799359
Just boycott Pirate's game and Rivals 2. Once they see how much of a liability this faggot is he'll be dropped in an instant. Spam Rivals 2 with claims that they want to kill digital ownership. See how fast they'll turn on this faggot.
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:26:39 PM No.713799371
>>713799221
No, that isn't a main goal of this campaign
You are ignoring reality and substituting your own assumptions
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:28:07 PM No.713799453
>>713799346
>If the button says buy it's a physical good!
It's fucking hilarious that you think your retarded semantic bullshit is the same as legal precedent
You're the sovereign citizens of video games

I'm not driving, officer, I'm traveling!
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:28:12 PM No.713799456
is this going to be more detrimental to the video game industry than helpful?
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:28:16 PM No.713799460
>>713794890
honestly worked for me.

The whole "I'm a dev, you're the consumer, you have to listen to me oooh being a gamedev is so hard you guys don't understand" bullshit is so obnoxious to hear that I actively want devs to throw more fits about it (and whoever this guy is, he's not anymore of a dev than an RPGMaker author is)
Anonymous
6/27/2025, 3:28:20 PM No.713799468
>>713798696
The videos are translated to all kinds of EU languages. How would he make a video in Spanish if he doesn't himself speak Spanish?