Thread 718194429

That's the most generic shit you could possibly say to sound deep. It's the equivalent of saying
>men must shit

>>718194429 (OP)
>You can't fight change

>>718194539
A MAN'S GOTTA SHIT MARSTON
AINT NOTHIN FOR IT
EVERY MAN'S GOTTA SHIT SOMETIME

>>718194558
anita won

>>718194539
Dutch was always a brainlet stringing along a bunch of dumb and desperate people. He's got high charisma but low intelligence. Hosea or Arthur himself would have been a much more effective and rational leader for the gang.

>>718194617
kek

I cam change my preference from girlydick to boypussy thoughbeit

>>718194696
I like the idea that he got hit in the head and started going insane after that. Some mission in RDR2. Dunno if that was intended to be why he descended into madness

>>718194768
IN ONE EAR OUT TH' OTHER
YOU ALWAYS WERE A HARD ONE MISTER

>>718194429 (OP)
>that's the paradox, John....you see?
kino

>>718194818
it's pretty frickitty fricking obvious that they have added a scene of dutch getting concussed during a mission to explain his shift in behaviour he's even yapping about how his head hurts at the end

>>718194429 (OP)
JUST ONE MORE BOOSTER, ARTHUR

>>718194617
When a man with a sing-song voice tells me to shit it always concerns me, boyo.

>>718194818
He flipped out and killed an innocent girl in Blackwater for no reason. He's always been a deranged retard.

>>718194539
Yes, Dutch is a pseud. It's still the most kino scene in the game

>>718194429 (OP)
>You can't fight change

Yes you can and you should. Almost all change is bad. Only in extremely rare circumstances you should allow a change to happen, when you're sure it's an improvement.

>>718194982
>killing innocent girls is deranged because it just le is!

>>718195056
Not necessarily. Change is inevitable. What you CAN do is make that change not shit, because sitting around and letting it happen will inevitably mean it's going to be shit.
You can't fight change, but you can fight to make the change better.

>>718194818
I hate the "dude he hit his head and that's why he went cuhrazzy" interpretation
Dutch was pulling the same retarded and unhinged shit since Blackwater and probably even well before that, the gang were all just on massive amounts of copium that their leader wasn't a lunatic

>>718194982
She wasn't innocent tho

>>718195106
Uhm Doctor Shekelstein at the university told me killing is bad so it just is ok?

718195106
No (You) for you, r****t retard.

I wonder what pushes a computer programmer to make a fictional story about the ways of the Wild West guys becoming outdated and incompatible with their society by technological progress. Nigga, you ain't an alcoholic gunslinger, you're a nerd with a hunchback and astigmatism. You ain't shit. Revisionist westerns make sense, they are a response to a long cinematic tradition, videogames though?

>>718194429 (OP)
>This man... see he married a whore!
What did he do it?

>>718195248
t. innocent girl, prepare to get your brains splattered with a silenced colt 1911 mk. 2 fmj

>>718194429 (OP)
>You can't fight change, John... you see, everytime I try to open this cavity, it just closes up. I got one of them dilators from the physician... I had a plan, John. But you see John, no matter how hard you try to hold on to your pussy, it tries to close and heal itself. That's a Paradox, John.

>>718195253
Shittiest take I've seen. Congrats

>>718194982
I like how this is supposed to be some Original Sin moment. Shot some bitch during a robbery. Woe is me. Considering all the shit that happens in the games.

>>718195317
>get with a whore
>she has 'your kid'
>try to bail
>everyone calls you a faggot for not sticking with a known whore
>come back and live out the rest of your life pleasing your cunt wife and raising your cuck child
a modern masterpiece

>>718195253
You're not black but you try to talk like you are, explain that.

>>718195373
your debased, moloch-possessed soul isn't something to flaunt.

>>718195106
Well from all accounts that one action was literally the most horrible action that could have possibly been taken at the moment, is considered absolutely deranged even by his own gang, and led to everything being tremendously fucked up and the heist going botched.

Every single person who was there thinks, "What happened? Why did it happen?" Nobody can make sense of it. There's simply no "logic" to whatever Dutch did.

>>718195226
She changed the entire industry over the last 12 years. No matter what retrded shit she does now, the damage is done. She has won.

>>718194429 (OP)
Trump got abortions banned and gay marriage is next.

>>718195226
What is this mean to imply? It's 2025 and you still have saved photos of her and you're still seething about woke video games.

She fucking rekt you lmao

>>718195421
They call us the negroes of Europe. Me, I take pride in that.
>>718195447
Logic is always negotiable. Truth is relative. Everything is permitted.

>>718195373
Its implied he killed her needlessly for no good reason. Its supposed to be a hint at who Dutch really is, he's not noble at all, he's evil and when in the right situation that darkness comes out. Remember in RDR1 when John asks him why he's even fighting at all and he responds "I don't know...sport, I guess?". He's violent just because he wants to be.

they made dutch too cool in 2's epilogue

he gets to kill micah, but the next time he sees john he kills a bystander and calls his wife a whore

>>718195253
>movies are ok though
>why?
>they just are, ok!??!

>>718195439
Says the retard who is in a gang of murderers thieves and whores

>>718194429 (OP)
>"you can't fight gravity"
>fall in the sun

Both RDR and RDR 2 were good not great. The Mexico stuff in RDR was fairly boring and RDR2 was tracking to be great but the story post chapter 3 was fucking dogshit. You literally go to an island and do some turret defence shit for an entire chapter like some old assassins creed game. What the fuck were they thinking? Also just mowing down the entire town of Strawberry (you kill at least 40 NPCs after breaking Micah out) never gets mentioned??

>>718195609
Some of the first movies were westerns. Some of the greatest movies of all time are westerns. The genre has been well established and later deconstructed and that's fine and dandy. A videogame doing that? All cake, no context.

>>718195480
>combats moral corruption by legislating prudency and outlawing this and that while having a laundry list of child rape and a closet loaded with skeletons
where did I see this before?

>>718195503
Okay but beyond any pseud shit, Dutch just fucked up in a completely incomprehensible way that doesn't make sense to anyone and won't make sense to anyone because he himself doesn't have any reason or excuse. This isn't "limited morals" it's Dutch just being a retarded insane person.

>>718195142
brain damage happens, and it's not really as funny as Scott Pilgrim makes it out to be
you can see it when Arthur tries to talk to Tommy a week after the bar fight, and thanks to the beating Arthur gave him, he can only mumble vague noises because of the permanent brain damage even though Arthur just thought he was just letting off steam pounding a guy who he thought could take it

undead nightmare was pretty cool

>>718194539
Dutch is lamenting wasting his life.

>>718195729
>how dare a 50 hours long videogame have two or three silly missions where you massacre hundreds in an unrealistic manner
Yikes.
>>718195750
It makes sense to me. I find the killing of the girl justifiable and rational.

>>718195862
Okay so what is the rationale.

>>718195735
>its interactive, therefore the same exact themes about industry destroying the mystery and wonder of the world are suddenly invalid because....because they just are ok???!

>>718195895
She was making a move. Dutch had to get it on.

Did they ALL really have her?

>>718195790
Yeah but to say Dutch's entire decline is because he hit his head is wrong because he was being erratic and emotional the whole game, he just hid it better early on. Its possible he had some sort of concussion, but regardless the trolley mission made him desperate to exact revenge on Bronte and that desperation to lord over him and be the big dog is what led to the downfall of the gang.

>>718195895
Dutch is anit-semitic

>>718195373
It shows how Dutch acts under pressure, what he reaches for when he has no script and the answer is that he loses control, there is no depth to him. All flash, no substance.

>>718196082
Well, she and all the other girls were prostitutes and Grimshaw was their madame, so probably. It's definitely heavily implied Arthur had her, and if he did then the rest of the gang definitely did too.

>>718195448
>she caused thousands of game devs fired and closed dozens of studios
ok, will admit this part was pretty based

>>718196280
>It's definitely heavily implied Arthur had her
source: your gaping anus

>>718196082
one of the background conflicts at the start of 2 is that john isn't sure jack is his

>>718196082
Yes
She only stopped fucking the crew when she got pregnant with Jack

>>718195790
>brain damage happens
Yes, but it doesn't fit Rockstar's MO of leaning on modern psychology nor explain Dutch's history. The better fit is that Dutch's decline is him being unable to recover from multiple narcissistic injuries while Arthur and Hosea fail him as friends and Micah being his Gríma Wormtongue.

>>718196345
>Took young Jack out fishing as a favor to Abigail. Many years ago, before she fell so hard for that fool MARSTON, perhaps I should have married her. I think part of me has always thought that, yet, God damn you, Mary!
Or maybe Arthur is a rapist and thought he could marry her against her will?

>>718195972
>i know that the world was mysterious and wonderous before the industrialization as in before i was even born to experience these sensations in their "real" manner because... uh...

>>718195448
anon, it's 2025
sjw/woke shit in gaming peaked ages ago and hasn't been this weak since it first began to fester. game journalism is dead, anita is beyond irrelevant, and the future of gaming is more china than san fran.

>>718196508
huh, interesting, never read that.

Jack looks all like John and nothing like Arthur, though.

>>718195448
>>718195495
I thank anita for radicalizing a generation of chuddies

>>718196585
I'm aware, but the damage is irreparable. GTA 6 will be the final litmus test.

>>718196602
he's Javier's

>>718194982
She was making a move

>>718196632
Same. It has been over a decade of endless entertainment so far. I've never seen a woman have such a lasting seethe on a generation of weak beta males.

>>718196602
>>718196834
>that Antagonize dialogue where Arthur tells Jack he looks more like a Williams or an Escuela
https://youtu.be/wXc_LTP2kzQ?t=35

Actually good thread wtf

>>718196105
>Yeah but to say Dutch's ENTIRE decline is because
no bitch
dats a whole new sentence
wtf is you talkin about

>>718194429 (OP)
Do you guys think the next RDR will be a prequel that will end with the Black Water robbery, or a sequence with old cool cars? The name is red dead redemption. This 3 words can take place in pretty much any timeline. I dont think Rockstar would go past the 40s tho

Ross did nothing wrong

>>718196983
The funniest thing is that you believe yourself above those beta males when you're not. You're posting in the same threads. Stop deluding yourself.

>>718201000
California gold rush, don't even make it a prequel, just the same universe. I don't think they can get any further into the 20th century without going full GTA absurdity.

>>718194539
>men must shit
No... no you're wrong!

>>718194429 (OP)
Red Dead Redemption 3000

>having a white guy say you can't fight change before killing himself
Subtle, rockstar.

>>718194429 (OP)
I remember when I used to think 360/PS3 graphics looked phenomenal and nothing could possibly ever look as good. Now when I see games from back then they all look like slightly higher fidelity PS2 models to me.

>>718194539
Nigga its a mother fucking paradox alright.

>>718194617
>>718194539
>HAVE SOME GODDAMN FIBER ORTHOR!
>I HAD A GODDAMN EATING PLAN!

>>718202095
>Now when I see games from back then they all look like slightly higher fidelity PS2 models to me.
Now a shit ton of modern games using unreal look like uncanny claymation, at least to my eyes anyway.

>>718195480
Epstein Files
Unredacted or GTFO

>>718196995
>>718196834
Fun to theorize about it, but NPCs in RDR1 will either think he’s John or know they’re related if you stagger out the side quests across the time gap. Pretty solid proof that it was never really a question and the devs pretty much always intended John to be his biological dad.

>>718194429 (OP)
He's right. You can not stop entropy.

>>718194558
Reminder that the UN was so embarassed by this that they wrote a letter denouncing their claims.

>>718203230
So how come Biden in the 4 years that he had power didn't release them when he was actively trying to put Trump in Jail through any means necessary?

>>718203415
yeah he's obviously John's kid but Abigail really did sleep around before

>>718203645
cause he was in them too

>>718203645
Mutually assured destruction
Mossad was playing the field
Fuck off glowie/glowie-asset
The elite are not my friends

>>718195503
>Truth is relative. Everything is permitted.
so men can in fact be women?

>>718194429 (OP)
He had a pretty good plan tho

Were any of Dutch's plans a success?

>>718194429 (OP)
> Be me
> Bought RDR 2 last year
> After one month of playing it, I immediately uninstall it because I can't get used to the clunky, godawful controls and confusingly obtuse keybinds
> Last month, after reading all over R*ddit that RDR2 is "supposed" to be clunky because it helps immersion and realism, I reinstalled the game to give it another chance
> Arthur still feels like I'm watching someone else playing him with input lag, as he wades through molasses
> Rage uninstall for the final time
The lesson I've learned here? Fuck R*ddit.

>>718204760
Reddit is 80% children. RDR2 fans are 80% children. Coincidence? I think NOT!

>>718195448
We won. She saved us from video game addiction. From wasting our precious hard earned dollars on digital media that should be $20 at best. She walked so we can run.

>>718204473
no, the gang was just able to get away with their shenanigans because civilisation wasn't taking law enforcement seriously

>>718194690
>Literally got her government funding pulled
>Causes millions of dollars in losses
>Shifted 6% of young people to the right.
>Even the UN put out statements distancing themselves from her, and issued a official apology for bringing her onto the panel.

>>718195448
I mean, sure she changed the industry. Just in the complete opposite direction. She was very clear in what she wanted. To combat the "Male fantasy" remove games like Call of Duty, and replace them with intersectional representation, and non colonial themes.

Games like Concord, Redfall, Assassin's Creed Syndicate, Watch Dogs 2, are all games she praises as being the sort of titles she advocates for. These games all of course, flopped massively. The industry listened, and everyone who listened went broke.

>>718194429 (OP)

You were a useless narcissist that surrounded yourself with the dregs of society as your own personal echo chamber.

Now I insist you throw your dumbass off that fucking cliff, now.

NIGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGA!

>>718201000
>Sequel to RDR1
>Jack Marston
>World War 1
>Prohibition Era Gangster

>>718195226
Has she found a real person to marry her yet?

>>718194818
That's so fucking retarded and you're a brainlet if you believe it.

>>718195226
pathetic

>>718205086
I don't like any of those games but watch dogs 2 didn't flop and ass creed had many successful games after anita so your point seems pretty dumb. Go woke go broke isn't always true. It's always a case by case basis.