Reviewer: Silent Hills f combat ruins the horror setting
>Combat is as deeply ingrained within Silent Hill f as guilty moping was to Silent Hill 2, and from what Iβve played, doesnβt work nearly as well.
>The biggest problem lies in Hinakoβs more defensive skillset, which includes a dodge-dash that already seems weirdly generous even before it adds in a whooshing slow motion effect on particularly well-timed evasions. This is no modest, SH2 Remake-style sidestep β the girl damn near flies off the screen, easily swooping out of most monstersβ attack ranges unless you completely bung the timing.
>The effect on the horror aspect is... unfortunate. When everything short of a scripted boss can be sprinted past or danced around, the fact that your isolated hometown is infested with murderbeasts suddenly becomes a lot less intimidating. And the dodge undermines some of the heavier-handed moments of tension, too. Late in the demo, I was forced to flee a spooky Shinto shrine as a lethal red mist nibbled away at my health and sanity bars. Enemies spawned on narrow walkways to block the path, and sporadic bursts of pain limited my ability to sprint β but my dodging prowess was left completely unaffected, allowing me to casually breeze past dangers and reach the exit with plenty of life to spare.
>Unfortunately, Silent Hill fβs aggressive play also needs significant tightening-up.
>Even the simplest melee swings are frustratingly inconsistent: sometimes itβs like Hinato lunges halfway across the prefecture to land a strike, other times sheβll swipe at a baddie thatβs right up in her face and hit air. Iβm not even sure itβs a hit detection problem, as there were numerous occasions where Iβd lock on to a foe, move into eyelash-tickling range, and could only watch as Hinako slashed two feet to the abominationβs side. But I was locked on! Locked! And when a blow does connect, it might produce a bizarre non-response.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 6:58:37 PM
No.719175641
>>719180318
>>719175574 (OP)
>The impression Iβm getting so far, then, is of an action-horror game where the action isnβt very compelling and the horror isnβt very scary.
ITS OVER
>>719175574 (OP)
>a game journalist says
don't care
i'll decide for myself or trust the opinion of racist internet frogs before I listen to anything said by a gaming journalist with any weight.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:07:25 PM
No.719176228
>>719176567
>>719175574 (OP)
>soi jak reviewer
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:07:44 PM
No.719176252
>>719176567
>>719175574 (OP)
>Reviewer
Liar, fuck off
90% of people who talk about Silent Hill have never played the original 4. Their opinions don't matter.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:08:49 PM
No.719176327
AllI know is that they hired chinks to make a shitty Forbidden Siren game and call it "silent hill" despite having nothing in common with it.
What even makes it Silent Hill? Beating monsters with a pipe? Guess Dying Light is Silent Hill then lol
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:09:07 PM
No.719176351
>>719176489
>>719175574 (OP)
>Game launches at the end of February
>Reviewer
OP is a faggot and probably the stupid journo.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:09:56 PM
No.719176408
>>719176259
To be fair gameplay was never good in silent hill
It was carried by the spooky sounds actually making anticipating an enemy feel creepy
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:10:27 PM
No.719176447
>>719176567
>>719176942
>journalists and new gamers hates gameplay
colour me surprised
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:11:05 PM
No.719176489
>>719176351
release date is sept
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:11:23 PM
No.719176508
>>719182664
It's really turning out into Japanese Homecoming. Though, I think the one saving grace seems to be that you can avoid fights instead of it being necessary. Just save up resources and healing items to get to shrines and level up as fast as you can. Only fight when you have to. It might not be amazing but it could just be decent which is good enough with a series that already has a lot of bad entries in it.
>>719176195
>>719176228
>>719176252
>>719176259
>>719176447
Does Konami hire jeet shills now? Why is 80%+ of this thread extremely defensive?
>>719176567
Real Silent Hill fans are Indian. White boys too busy watching black porn
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:14:33 PM
No.719176707
>>719176567
Most companies these days are outsourcing to jeets
Gta6 is doing it too
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:15:24 PM
No.719176763
>>719176567
>now
Nobody tell him
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:17:56 PM
No.719176925
>>719177270
>>719176567
Because shills on this board tried to make this game look like a "RETURN TO FORM" and "LE TRUE SILENT HILL" but this game looks dogshit and nothing like silent hill
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:18:12 PM
No.719176942
>>719177647
>>719176447
why is a highschool girl in a horror game dodging attacks like bayonetta with time slowmo? That's not scary.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:19:40 PM
No.719177034
>>719185045
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:20:16 PM
No.719177072
>>719176567
>Batantly lie
>Calls other shills
Of course.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:20:44 PM
No.719177107
>>719175574 (OP)
Where Chinese and Indian devs only taught how to make Soulslop?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:20:48 PM
No.719177112
>>719175954
Holy sex should I get into this franchise?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:21:11 PM
No.719177142
>>719176567
>leave the jews alone!
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:21:15 PM
No.719177146
>>719176195
Based
>>719176567
how exactly is "I don't trust game journos. I will trust any opinion but there's or play it myself" defensive about the game you fucking gorilla?
>>719176643
strange post considering blacked shit is most popular in India
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:21:42 PM
No.719177172
>>719176564
>I YIELD, I YIELD
>....never should of come here.
>>719176925
All i've been saying from day 1 is it was a horrible idea setting the game in Japan, and it was a horrible idea making the protagonist a teenaged girl. There would be MUCH more interest in this game if it were set in America with a white guy as the protagonist. Journo interest is arbitrary and not a measure of anything, this game will underperform because it kneecapped its own resonance by trying to reinvent the wheel
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:23:26 PM
No.719177295
>>719175574 (OP)
>"Reviewer" a month away
>Dude reviews more hardware than games
Lol
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:24:30 PM
No.719177342
>>719178350
>>719177270
it would've been fine if she was a Japanese loli
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:25:55 PM
No.719177447
>>719178760
>be /v/
>Cry and moan about new game
>New game is released and people like it
>Say it's all shills
>New game is announced
>Cry and moan about new game...
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:26:20 PM
No.719177465
>>719188890
>its parryslop
*sigh*...
Still day 1. I get every Silent Hill game day 1. Even bought a Vita for Book of Memories... Cant stop the tradition now.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:27:02 PM
No.719177515
>>719177270
>it was a horrible idea setting the game in Japan
Not the issue with the game.
Maybe its an issue with naming it "silent hill" but a good japanese aesthetic horror game would be kino instead we got slop
Not saying that Silent Hill F will be a perfect game or that it won't suck, but /v/ giving paying attention to journalists and giving weight to what they say is so wrong.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:28:43 PM
No.719177632
>>719177674
>>719177764
>>719177517
I literally have eyes and I have seen that it's another soulslike game, no need for journos because I never read journos reviews
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:29:00 PM
No.719177647
>>719178760
>>719176942
>a game is scary when the main characters is defenseless and yells all the time to let me know when I should be scared
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:29:19 PM
No.719177663
>>719177936
>>719189078
>>719177517
>game journalism good when they say game bad
>game journalist bad when they say game good
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:29:29 PM
No.719177674
>>719177746
>>719177632
And still you're posting a journo's review and defending what he's saying.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:30:23 PM
No.719177746
>>719177674
I haven't posted any journo review
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:30:37 PM
No.719177764
>>719178026
>>719177632
Everything is a soulslike to you zoomers, you've never played anything from prior 2010.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:30:50 PM
No.719177784
>>719177517
WE ARE THE DUST BORN
GOONING TO KEK PORN
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:32:59 PM
No.719177936
>>719178748
>>719177663
It's a tiny bit more complex than that
>Journalists shit on game /v/ likes / is hyped for: "fuck journalists, they're worthless"
>Journalists praise game /v/ likes / is hyped for: "look at those high reviews! GOTY, Baby!!"
>Journalists shit on game /v/ hates / is already biased against: "told you, the game is shit!", "now it's confirmed, the game is shit!"
>Journalists praise game /v/ hates / is already biased against: "fuck journalists, they're worthless"
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:34:13 PM
No.719178026
>>719178101
>>719188975
>>719177764
I really want FromSoft to just drop something goofy. A new Echo Night game with no Combat like Echo Night Beyond. Ninja Blade 2 but it's just as jankino as Ninja Blade 1. Soulslop was a mistake.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:35:20 PM
No.719178101
>>719178026
>Fromsoft out of nowhere
These people are truly deranged.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:38:58 PM
No.719178350
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:41:09 PM
No.719178502
>>719180687
>>719175574 (OP)
>This game has actual gameplay and isnt a boring hiding simulator like Amnesia meant to be enjoyed by streamers and no else
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:43:02 PM
No.719178637
>>719181271
>>719175954
Don't know why people are jerking off over this. Its the same stiff ass over the shoulder combat as GOW which got shat on here mind you. I guess people are so desperate for a new silent hills game that they don't care if it becomes complete corporate slop
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:43:44 PM
No.719178674
>>719175574 (OP)
YEah that was true in SH2 remake and Homecoming as well. We've known this for years. Silent Hill is a pretentious art game franchise and adding mediocre combat only ruins it.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:44:06 PM
No.719178698
>>719185598
>>719203228
>>719175954
>blunt weapon phases through enemy instead of bouncing back
This will never not bother me.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:44:46 PM
No.719178748
>>719179659
>>719177936
That's the thing, /v/ was shitting on this game ever since in-game footage was revealed. It is only now when a journo came out and said bad things about it that the posts did a complete 180. That's why I wondered if all these people that suddenly came out were paid shills.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:45:00 PM
No.719178760
>>719180810
>>719177447
So true bro, Dustborn, Veilguard and Homeworld 3 were all instant classics!
>>719177647
Yes, a horror game is scary when the player character FEELS outmatched against the monster. That's why Dying Light is cool because while you feel like a badass zombie hunter by day, at night you need to keep your head down and avoid detection because you are NOT the hunter anymore(at least until you become really strong in endgame and even then its difficult)
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:45:24 PM
No.719178797
combat is fine
it's the stagger on hit that I find annoying and flow ruining
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:46:46 PM
No.719178898
>>719179068
>>719181360
This is going to be exactly fucking like the Silent Hill 2 remake where secondaries who haven't even played the remake are hating it to sound cool. You're not cool, you're annoying and immature.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:47:37 PM
No.719178976
>>719185451
Japan continues to focus group test itself into the grave.
Whether its Silent Hill or Resident Evil or Final Fantasy or anything thats not FromSoft or Nintendo, they're so concerned with "keeping up" with mainstream appeal that they lose sight of what makes their media special.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:48:51 PM
No.719179060
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:49:00 PM
No.719179068
>>719178898
Secondaries are the ones who thought Stray Souls: Silent Hill 2 Edition was cool, poser.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:51:39 PM
No.719179247
PARRY SLOPPA #763 HERE I COME
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:55:02 PM
No.719179496
>>719175574 (OP)
Yeah this was m biggest fear the game would have no actual horror. What a waste of some genuinely good monster designs.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:56:01 PM
No.719179569
Silent Hill is overrated horror, it's not even scary. It's rather boring. The reason Silent Hill fans are adverse to action horror is because they're literally the kind of people who play Dear Esther and Gone Home. Or maybe more recently the best example being Mouthwashing as to what people describe as being close to Silent Hill 2. They're probably right, Mouthwashing is total dogshit too. And Silent Hill 2 is also a steaming turd. Weebs just pretend to be scared at Japanese horror. There's nothing they make that is scary.
>>719176567
Because SH fans are fucking retards and this has repeated itself again and again and again and again.
>Homecoming reviews come in
>Journos say "Yeah it's a clunky piece of shit with bad combat and a worse story"
>SH fanboys delude themselves by going "No, the game looks great, and maybe the story isn't as good, but SH1-4 have the best stories evar!"
>Game comes out and sucks ass
>Everyone pretends they agreed with that from the start
>HDC reviews come in
>Journos say "Yeah, these are the worst ports possible and this sucks ass"
>SH fanboys go "No, the games needed new voice acting and that HD look is DIVINE"
>Game comes out and sucks ass
>Everyone pretends they agreed with that from the start
>Downpour reviews come in
>Journos say "Runs like shit, plays like shit, and it feels like it's not even finished"
>SH fanboys go "No, see Murphy's actually pretty cool and the game looks great, we always wanted a more open Silent Hill game"
>Game comes out and sucks ass
>Everyone pretends they agreed with that from the start
And so on and so on.
We'll be here 30 years from now when SH still only has 3.5 good games and about 50 bad ones, and people will still be going
>trusting journos
When a bad game is a bad game. I could've told you SHf was bad based on previews from half a fucking year ago, I could've told you it was bad when they announced the dev team was a Chinese support studio and it was being written by a massive hack who is only beloved thanks to a shit anime and trannies.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:57:20 PM
No.719179659
>>719178748
>/v/ was shitting on this game ever since in-game footage was revealed
No they weren't you absolute fucking liar. This game has been shat on for "not being a real Silent Hill game" and "muh Japan" since it's first appearance.
Horror games are scarier if you have no way to fight or if fighting requires tons of your resources so you dread having to fight.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 7:59:54 PM
No.719179836
>>719176643
I just want you to know that you and yours are by far the most hated group on the planet now and its not even close, you're like a great uniter
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:00:36 PM
No.719179886
Honestly literally all they need to do is massively nerf the dodge. At least initially. Save the OP dodge for a NG+ unlock or some shit.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:05:06 PM
No.719180182
>>719180292
>>719179814
>Horror games are scarier if you have no way to fight
That's only scary if you're retarded.
Knowing that you have no way to fight, conversely, means that you are not expected to fight, and thus, engaging with "enemies" is not a factor of the game.
I came to this realization the first time I ever encountered the concept and it has basically made any horror game that does this feel incredibly boring.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:06:43 PM
No.719180292
>>719180448
>>719180182
This.
The best horror is where you can fight but it is extremely limited and the game does not tell if you need to fight or you can skip/run and on top of that you have very limited resources so there is always a fear to fuck up and be left with nothing when you REALLY need to fight
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:07:04 PM
No.719180318
>>719180396
>>719180558
>>719175641
PARRY
IN
A
HORROR
GAME
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:08:08 PM
No.719180390
>>719180251
He's covered wars you know
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:08:16 PM
No.719180395
>>719180628
>>719175574 (OP)
>souls slop by fromsoft
>KINO
>souls based horror game
>ummmm this isn't made by fromsoft....this is cringe
Mental illness
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:08:17 PM
No.719180396
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:09:02 PM
No.719180448
>>719180524
>>719180292
yeah but then you hit a soft lock and the horror fucking disappears in a fit of frustration instead
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:10:05 PM
No.719180524
>>719180448
soft lock can be avoided with conditional spawns but then you have another problem when player realizes the system
There is no good solution and never will be. Horror is a meme genre
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:10:41 PM
No.719180558
>>719180318
>tfw you can parry a chainsaw with a knife in a horror game
Are these classrooms historically accurate?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:11:51 PM
No.719180628
>>719180395
This could work if it had bloodborne-like combat, but I bet it's going to feel unsatisfying
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:12:32 PM
No.719180669
>>719180812
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:12:51 PM
No.719180687
>>719181145
>>719178502
>gameplay
>roll slop with some of the worst hit detection
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:13:19 PM
No.719180719
>>719181034
>>719180582
that hit pause is so fucking disgusting
it's the most insane hitpause i've ever seen
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:14:27 PM
No.719180803
>>719189338
>>719180582
the last of us 2 has more atmosphere (gameplay) game looks like pure slop
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:14:34 PM
No.719180810
>>719181082
>>719181232
>>719178760
>Dustborn, Veilguard and Homeworld 3
No one cried about those games, they were certified failures from a thousand miles away. Obvious shit games are never talked about here because there's no one to bait and defend with them.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:14:33 PM
No.719180812
>>719182220
>>719182309
>>719180669
She's pretty strong dude.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:15:04 PM
No.719180850
>>719180949
>>719176195
This.
When did /v/ start liking game journos?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:15:56 PM
No.719180913
>>719175954
>them doll joints
I JUST might need to play this...
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:16:28 PM
No.719180949
>>719180850
When it fits my jeet narrative.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:17:44 PM
No.719181034
>>719180719
That's not a hit pause, nigger. That's a full ass hit confirm. This game has some straight up fighting mechanics with the tech and parry shit.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:17:57 PM
No.719181063
>>719181156
This game looked and sounded bad from the get-go. If their isn't so kind of MGS2 Raiden-tier asspull in it then im out. I hope the ending is Japs getting nuked.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:18:11 PM
No.719181082
>>719181201
>>719180810
This.
If a game is talked about here as "bad" it has high chances of being pretty good.
Actual bad games don't get threads and of they do, they just die in seconds.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:18:27 PM
No.719181108
>>719181157
>>719181886
>>719175574 (OP)
The scene with the gay kitsune mask guy made me realize how bad and generic the writing will be.
>muh ryukishit07
Fell off hard since years ago.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:18:59 PM
No.719181145
>>719180687
Better than 95% of horror games already
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:19:07 PM
No.719181156
>>719181063
theres no way to save this
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:19:07 PM
No.719181157
>>719181108
>umifags trying to defend their shit
Always was bad.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:19:45 PM
No.719181201
>>719181082
>If a game is talked about here as "bad" it has high chances of being pretty good.
Please explain to everyone what looks good about this game.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:20:10 PM
No.719181232
>>719181326
>>719180810
Homeworld 3 is good, the story is just retarded. Its still a RTS game.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:20:41 PM
No.719181271
>>719178637
Honestly nu GOW has better combat than any soulslop
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:21:06 PM
No.719181298
>>719181515
This is the destiny of SH any new games: you either get a uninspiring """"""remaster""" from literall who or you get ""mainline"""" game that has to do as much with SH as Crysis with Resident Evil
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:21:08 PM
No.719181302
>>719181624
>>719181738
>>719175574 (OP)
tl;dr
literally ANYTHING is better than the combat we had in SH before,
also look at the docile soifaggot who qrote the article.
day 1 buy.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:21:28 PM
No.719181326
>>719181232
>Homeworld 3 is good
HAHAAHHAHA
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:22:09 PM
No.719181360
>>719181823
>>719178898
Only secondaries liked SH2 Remake, look at Marias outfit and Angelas face, no true SH2 fan likes that shit
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:22:43 PM
No.719181397
>>719181564
>>719175574 (OP)
How is she so powerful? Is she trans?
Demons Souls killed video games.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:23:53 PM
No.719181472
silent hill has never been good
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:24:03 PM
No.719181479
>>719181425
Can trace it back to Ocarina of Time, really.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:24:27 PM
No.719181515
>>719181298
Shut the fuck up retard. The game isn't even out yet. Ryushiki09 is a GOAT writer and he won't disappoint.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:24:30 PM
No.719181518
>>719181425
I helped kill it by buying DS off play asia
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:25:03 PM
No.719181564
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:25:04 PM
No.719181567
>>719175574 (OP)
Longtime fans are definitely not going to like SH1. This has always been a combat heavy series.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:25:47 PM
No.719181624
>>719181302
This. So funny to see /v/ defending numale basedcuck gaming journalists from polygon now. How low we've fallen.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:25:51 PM
No.719181628
This combat has oblivion levels of "I'm swinging foam sticks at ghosts".
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:26:34 PM
No.719181681
>>719181749
Horror games do not belong in AAA. They're great as short, 30min to 3 hour experiences that you pay $5-$15 for
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:27:17 PM
No.719181735
>>719175954
that hitstop is satisfying as fuck desu
it would be funny if the reason silent hill sucks is because it's too good of an action game
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:27:20 PM
No.719181738
>>719181896
>>719182637
>>719181302
>literally ANYTHING is better than the combat we had in SH before,
See
>>719179618
This is quite literally the EXACT same mindset that had people defending Homecoming, Downpour, and the 2 Remake before and after release.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:27:30 PM
No.719181749
>>719181681
absolute faggot zoomer opinion, holy shit kys
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:28:46 PM
No.719181823
>>719183416
>>719181360
True SH2fans havenβt even played the original game.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:29:38 PM
No.719181885
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:29:39 PM
No.719181886
>>719194053
>>719181108
literally all he has to do is to copy what he did in watanagashi-hen, he cannot fuck this up
>>719181738
There is nothing wrong with the 2 remake, tranny.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:30:49 PM
No.719181981
>>719182803
>>719181828
Feels like Nioh rather than Dark souls. Day one buy.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:32:23 PM
No.719182103
>>719181828
>dodges monster attack with instant transmission
>"heh nottin personnell, mister monstarr"
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:32:26 PM
No.719182105
>>719182248
>>719181896
There's dozens to hundreds of things wrong with it depending on the scope one wishes to use to analyze it.
But, now I could say would mean anything, as you're just mad.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:33:58 PM
No.719182198
>>719182434
>>719189609
I'm glad you can spot the shiteaters nowadays by asking them if they liked SH2 remake.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:34:15 PM
No.719182220
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:34:41 PM
No.719182248
>>719182295
>>719182105
You're the one seething people are liking the remake kek
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:35:20 PM
No.719182295
>>719182479
>>719182558
>>719182248
I mentioned three SH games and you zeroed in on the one super special to you anon.
First SH game?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:35:31 PM
No.719182309
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:36:21 PM
No.719182356
>>719181828
>fights with a fucking pocket knife
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:37:35 PM
No.719182434
>>719182494
>>719182198
The remake is better than the comedy that is the original.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:38:21 PM
No.719182479
>>719182637
>>719182295
You can't even follow the quote chain you're so seething in anger lol
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:38:37 PM
No.719182494
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:39:15 PM
No.719182536
>>719187064
>>719181828
>gets clawed
>no damage
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:39:39 PM
No.719182558
>>719182637
>>719182762
>>719182295
cope, seethe and dilate.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:41:00 PM
No.719182637
>>719182741
>>719183273
>>719182479
I think it's you that can't follow. If you would return to the beginning,
>>719181738
>This is quite literally the EXACT same mindset that had people defending Homecoming, Downpour, and the 2 Remake before and after release.
is what I said. You responded to this, seething that ANYONE would DARE disparage your first SH game.
>>719182558
And now you're incoherently crying.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:41:17 PM
No.719182664
>>719176508
>Level up
Wtf? This really is dark souls.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:41:58 PM
No.719182713
>>719176643
>And this will help us sell games?
>...games?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:42:07 PM
No.719182719
>>719182808
>>719175574 (OP)
I can't help but feel like they're having to double down and be defensive because they pinned a LOT of this game on
>those damn western dogs fumbled with Homecoming, Origins, and Downpour
>we're bringing it back home, and we're going full Japanese, not even westaboo bullshit no more
>BANZAIIIIIIIIIIIII
even saying as such in interviews. For them to admit they're fucking up is impossible for that infamous Japanese Game Dev Pride that's fucked over so many projects in the past, especially when East vs West comes into play.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:42:10 PM
No.719182724
>>719175954
that's a really soulless UI
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:42:29 PM
No.719182741
>>719182862
>>719182637
>And now you're incoherently crying.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:42:50 PM
No.719182762
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:43:36 PM
No.719182803
>>719181981
nioh you wish faggot
>>719182719
It's made by chinese.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:43:54 PM
No.719182812
>>719175574 (OP)
>game series with several adults as MCs
>the best hand to hand fighter is a japanese teenager
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:44:11 PM
No.719182823
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:44:34 PM
No.719182862
>>719182741
Interesting how this exact image with this exact filename can be found on /vg/, partaking in the... Deltarune general.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:44:47 PM
No.719182871
f is not a real silent hill
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:45:10 PM
No.719182893
>>719175954
>objective markers
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:45:21 PM
No.719182901
>>719182975
>>719182989
>>719175574 (OP)
>Siren but its soulless slop.
Nice game silent hill cucks.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:46:28 PM
No.719182975
>>719183267
>>719182901
Why do people who have never played Siren insist on calling all games set in Japan "Siren".
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:46:29 PM
No.719182976
>>719183362
>>719182808
Is the director Chinese? From what I know the development team simply follow orders.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:46:36 PM
No.719182989
>>719183267
>>719182901
Man, Siren was one of the creepiest and scariest games I played
Not in a sense it was horror but in a sense encountering monster was pure dread, despite you being able to use guns
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:46:42 PM
No.719182994
>>719183050
>>719184783
>>719175574 (OP)
>Iβm not even sure itβs a hit detection problem, as there were numerous occasions where Iβd lock on to a foe, move into eyelash-tickling range, and could only watch as Hinako slashed two feet to the abominationβs side. But I was locked on! Locked!
Dark Souls 2 bros we are so back
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:47:30 PM
No.719183050
>>719182994
>Here's why silent hill f is good, actually
Kino incoming?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:48:15 PM
No.719183107
>>719182808
So is everything in the West, but West vs East continues regardless
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:48:48 PM
No.719183137
Honestly the schoolgirl main character being a brutal badass who demolishes the Silent Hill demons with ease is making me want to unironically buy this game.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:50:25 PM
No.719183267
>>719184268
>>719182975
I have.
Its clunkier than SH but still the friekest games ever.
At least you are supposed to avoid Shibitos as much as possible, here you look for a fight.
And yeah this shit looks like Siren but for modern audiences.
>>719182989
We went from Harry mising shots to an overpowered skinny schoolgirl demon slayer.
Sure Harry could use a katana but he held it with no discipline.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:50:30 PM
No.719183273
>>719183587
>>719182637
You are talking to more than one person yet are trying equivocate everyone to one person because of your seething hatred for sh2r. I would say to take your meds, but you're more entertaining this way.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:50:41 PM
No.719183286
>>719182808
The grunt slaves are Chinese, so the Jap director can blame any failure on them and not himself. Classic Japanese behavior.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:51:58 PM
No.719183362
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:52:35 PM
No.719183397
>>719177517
>Guess the game.jpg
>All the reviews are from troonborn..
So hard to guess...
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:52:51 PM
No.719183416
>>719181823
this, literally the biggest fanbase that haven't played their own game nothing else comes close
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 8:55:24 PM
No.719183587
>>719183273
>You are talking to more than one person
Prior to that post, I had only been responding to one person actually.
I don't care if it was perhaps multiple people somehow coordinating a tag team effort or something, before then it had been me responding to singular post every single time, and that 'chain' had started with someone getting mad at me saying SH2R is bad, in a post that called several SH games bad.
In short, you're the one seething.
Either you jumped in randomly to cry about your first SH game being called bad, or you're the one who saw a list of games and got mad that SH2 was in it.
You're mad. Upset, even. You're probably clenching your teeth right now, maybe a bit of sweat on your brow, perhaps even a light headache from how enraged you are, enraged at the idea that someone does not like a game you like.
>inb4 dismissive response and continued seethe
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:04:51 PM
No.719184203
>>719184273
>>719184675
Why has it been so hard for them to give us another masterpiece kino like Silent Hill 1/2/3 /v/?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:05:52 PM
No.719184268
>>719184360
>>719183267
This should have been some new horror ip about some samurai girl in some demon world, Hinako is way too fucking strong to take her seriously
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:06:01 PM
No.719184273
>>719184394
>>719184919
>>719184203
Team Silent disbanded, just make another IP.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:07:16 PM
No.719184360
>>719184268
>Hinako is way too fucking strong to take her seriously
It makes sense she is strong since she has been looping over and over so she is level 99 by now
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:07:30 PM
No.719184372
>>719175574 (OP)
>The impression Iβm getting so far, then, is of an action-horror game where the action isnβt very compelling and the horror isnβt very scary.
What a fucking great thing to read about a Silent Hill game
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:07:58 PM
No.719184394
>>719184617
>>719184273
Who cares if the team disbanded? You seriously mean to tell me nobody else can at least make half the game that SH 1 or 2 were? The slop we have been getting isn't even in the same stratosphere of greatness those games were.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:08:08 PM
No.719184408
>>719184679
>>719184909
>>719180251
>cherrypicked buggy enemy
i cant believe Bloober team just mogged the actual SH team in both combat and horror
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:09:08 PM
No.719184470
>>719176259
i played SH2remake and F is looking inferior to the remake so far
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:11:06 PM
No.719184574
>>719175574 (OP)
>Silent Hill F
Unintentionally great name choice I guess
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:11:41 PM
No.719184617
>>719184954
>>719184394
>Who cares if the team disbanded?
Real SH fans do.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:12:47 PM
No.719184675
>>719184735
>>719185037
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:12:48 PM
No.719184679
>>719184408
>the actual SH team
Anon they haven't existed in like 20 years
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:13:07 PM
No.719184705
>>719184914
You're in charge of the next mainline silent hill game
What do you do that isn't silent hill f or the correct choice of not making another fucking silent hill game
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:13:30 PM
No.719184724
>>719186350
>>719210338
Silent Hill F(lop)
general:
>80 (euro)bucks
>UE5
>chink studio (RE:Verse)
>japanese setting (silent hill PHENOMENON)
>animeslop (voice acting, kitsune guy with shiny red eyes)
>otherworld is just one lame setting (with unkillable enemies), instead of another version of the town
>poor enemy design (like homecoming/downpour)
>every enemy gets introduced by screeching into the camera (like a soulsboss)
>action horror instead of survival horror
>spin-off (just a rebranded horror game)
gameplay:
>too late to fix the combat, so devs damage control by advising to play on story mode for 'the authentic SH experience'
>heavy combat-focus (with even more enemies than in SH2R)
>stamina bar, weapon durability gauge, sanity meter
>gacha buffs
>hit-stop on every hit (enemies don't actually react to being hit)
>teleportation-tier dodging
>no guns, only breakable melee weapons
story:
>written by ryukishi07 (VNslop)
>main theme is "THE SOCIETAL OPPRESSION OF WOMEN"
>immature schoolgirl drama (like 'short message')
>"LOOK HOW CRUEL TEENS CAN BE TO ONE ANOTHER" (like every other ryushit07 story)
>time shenanigans / loops / evil twins (= several replays for the whole story)
RARE BASED REVIEWER
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:13:43 PM
No.719184735
>>719184808
>>719184675
Based.
I only played 3 like once but 4 several.
Feels like 3 is astroturfed by Heather waifu/daughterfu fags
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:14:25 PM
No.719184783
>>719185019
>>719182994
DS2 assumes the player has a high IQ and can choose to swing in a direction independent of the camera view. (added control)
The lock on in SHF is like nuGoW where you'll ice skate towards whatever the game wants you to be targeting. (less control)
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:14:42 PM
No.719184808
>>719184735
3 is good, but it's the weakest of the original 4. I blame trannies who think Heather is literally them.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:15:30 PM
No.719184852
>>719177517
Not saying, but heavily implying as hard as I possibly can...
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:16:21 PM
No.719184909
>>719185139
>>719184408
>cherrypicked buggy enemy
while it my be cherrypicked, it demonstrates how bad the combat system is, because the player has no actual freedom of control over his character, and is instead get constantly locked into animations while his swings get adjusted by the game.
this is the anti-thesis of good video game design, where the player is 100% in control of his actions at all time and can execute them with the precision of his choice.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:16:27 PM
No.719184914
>>719184705
Lynchian game set before SH1 when the people started leaving the town. MC is a hot woman detective with a Dale Cooper personality.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:16:31 PM
No.719184919
>>719186551
>>719184273
There's been lots of great new horror IPs in the last few years
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:16:48 PM
No.719184934
>>719185808
>>719175954
>Hitstop and animation out of a PS3 budget title
>Weapon doesn't even make contact with the enemy's model
>Soulslop UI
Just let this franchise stay dead please
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:17:13 PM
No.719184954
>>719185114
>>719185434
>>719184617
Okay but the team has been disbanded since like the mid 2000's. I refuse to believe nobody else could have handled this franchise and at least put something out that is quality. Kojima could have done it but they shitcanned him. Konami just doesn't care and thinks that they keep finding the right devs but they are never a good fit. Not even blooper team is a good fit yet konami in their infinitely shit wisdom thinks blooper are the only ones who can handle it.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:18:08 PM
No.719185019
>>719185950
>>719184783
Ds2 was coded by favela monkeys and little of it was deliberate
The AI can't manage targeting because the lock on is broken
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:18:25 PM
No.719185037
>>719184675
4 is good but a pretty big departure to the style of the series that was set in the games before it. It almost feels as if it could be a spinoff and considering it doesn't even take place in Silent Hill itself it kind of could have been had it not been numbered 4.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:18:31 PM
No.719185045
>>719177034
>not intented for residents of texas or massachusetts
non-american here, what exactly is their problem?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:19:47 PM
No.719185114
>>719184954
Not every fucking IP needs endless sequels, retard. Let it die with dignity and make new stories.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:20:08 PM
No.719185139
>>719185921
>>719188254
>>719184909
its done on purpose, you are not supposed to have precise full control in a horror game, its made like this so you are scared to attack and run away when enemy groups attack you later
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:20:10 PM
No.719185141
>>719186519
>>719175574 (OP)
game looks like shit but it has clothing damage so i feel obliged to support it in hopes we get more clothes destruction kino
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:20:13 PM
No.719185145
>>719179618
>Unpopular in Japan despite being mostly developed there when it's not thrown to random western studios
>Most of the fans are schizo American autists
>Every time a new game comes out it ends up going through the same cycle where journos criticize it and the fanbase tries desperately to defend it before finally admitting that it sucked 2+ years later
SH really is the Sonic of horror games, huh
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:20:22 PM
No.719185157
>people were already shitting on SH2R's combat
>japan does it even worse
This franchise is cursed with eternal failure
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:21:37 PM
No.719185246
>>719185571
>>719185698
I'm making a new silent hill fangame based on this image.
Not kidding.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:23:59 PM
No.719185404
>>719181828
kek, it's literally the flailing enemies from dark souls 3
>which anon
the majority
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:24:28 PM
No.719185434
>>719184954
Ideally the previous team tutors the new team so there can be a combination of their fresh new perspective and the understanding of what the series is about.
Its not always perfect but should be better than this which is seemingly done by a team with no understanding of the series.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:24:50 PM
No.719185451
>>719178976
fullly agreed
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:25:59 PM
No.719185536
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:26:25 PM
No.719185559
>>719186324
>w-what the fuck I'm so scared rn...!
>*pulls out a zweihander*
>*parries a missile*
>THIS IS SO SCAWY!
Fucking re4 remake and now this
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:26:39 PM
No.719185571
>>719194113
>>719185246
A billboard for a literal who Vtuber in the middle of bumfuck Tennessee
Why? Who paid for this?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:27:00 PM
No.719185598
>>719186795
>>719178698
Are there even any games that don't do that? Those silly physics based games?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:28:17 PM
No.719185690
>>719175954
looks like that gay dead space clone that sucked ass lmao
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:28:26 PM
No.719185698
>>719185246
The west has fallen
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:28:28 PM
No.719185704
>>719175574 (OP)
I have zero regard for the opinion of game journalists, but I expected the game to have this exact problem, so I believe it.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:29:02 PM
No.719185743
>>719175954
>S-she's fast!
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:30:07 PM
No.719185808
>>719184934
>Soulslop UI
... Where?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:31:31 PM
No.719185908
>>719175574 (OP)
>>Even the simplest melee swings are frustratingly inconsistent: sometimes itβs like Hinato lunges halfway across the prefecture to land a strike, other times sheβll swipe at a baddie thatβs right up in her face and hit air. Iβm not even sure itβs a hit detection problem
So they took the nu-Capcom route and prioritized "cinematic animation" over consistent, reliable controls. I bet it feels like absolute garbage to play, just like RE4R does.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:31:42 PM
No.719185921
>>719185139
that's extremely bad design then. you don't get scared from shit like this, only frustrated. taking control away from the player is one of the biggest sins in game design.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:32:04 PM
No.719185950
>>719186367
>>719185019
If you think free aim while locked on is a glitch or oversight this argument is not worth having because it stands on a fundamentally untrue premise.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:34:21 PM
No.719186101
>>719175574 (OP)
Make the player character feel stiff and weak if you want me to be scared
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:37:35 PM
No.719186297
>>719189245
>>719179814
Were you raised on jumpscare and restart streamer bait games? Were you a fan of the "game theory" faggot growing up?
These horror games are not scary, they're just frustrating.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:37:56 PM
No.719186324
>>719186663
>>719185559
I want a stage-based horror/comedy game where the first half of each stage is you evading and being chased by a ghost as a regular person, and the second half is you beating the shit out of the ghost as a ghost hunter.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:38:21 PM
No.719186350
>>719184724
I already told you I'm buying it you don't have to sell me
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:38:30 PM
No.719186361
>>719186635
>>719175574 (OP)
Why are you secondaries defending this shit?
Game isn't even out and you're shitting on the original games to shill it.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:38:38 PM
No.719186367
>>719186928
>>719185950
So why do NPCs constantly fail at targeting players at some angles due to it?
Fuck, scratch that
Why don't DS2 npc know they should dodge out of r1 spam?
The idea that it's deliberate design is fucking hilarious
It's poor systems
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:41:33 PM
No.719186519
>>719185141
fucking imbreds. it's a story thing and only happens in story scenes
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:41:50 PM
No.719186551
>>719186628
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:42:54 PM
No.719186628
>>719186551
If I were going to I would have done it in my original post. Listing games you like has never amounted to anything worthwile on 4chan
>>719186361
They have the same script for every remake. Attack the original, say you can't criticize a game that's not even out yet, ignore all accusations about being indian, etc. They did this shit with RE4make and Dead Space remake
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:43:21 PM
No.719186663
>>719186324
That's just Clock Tower 3 lol
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:44:25 PM
No.719186737
>>719176195
Based, ban all twitter/journo threads
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:44:26 PM
No.719186738
Guess this guy was right after all, the combat IS shit and japan agrees.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:45:19 PM
No.719186795
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:47:03 PM
No.719186891
>>719186973
>this game that's not even out is the best thing ever and the original games are bad, chud!
I love this meme argument
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:47:38 PM
No.719186928
>>719186367
they do
especially the Scholar npcs
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:48:10 PM
No.719186973
>>719187620
>>719187808
>>719186891
The gameplay of the original games is objectively bad though. You haven't even played the games. God forbid Konami give these games actual gameplay.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:48:21 PM
No.719186992
>>719175954
Yeah. It's trash.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:49:13 PM
No.719187050
I don't know if this is a soulslike or not but as someone who has never played a Silent Hill and generally doesn't care much for survival horror - my 2 favorite games in that genre are Dead Space and Alan Wake - i don't see any problem with what i've read about this. It sounds really cool.
The worst thing they could do to this game is the same thing that ruined every other survival horror game that i've dropped over the years - introduce an invincible enemy that stalks you around the map. If it avoids that trap, then sure, i'm in.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:49:28 PM
No.719187064
>>719187448
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:50:19 PM
No.719187113
>>719187154
if journos hate it then it may be good
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:50:49 PM
No.719187154
>>719187113
Journalists are sweeping for it, that's the problem.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:52:48 PM
No.719187291
Is this Wuchang patch 1.6?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:55:14 PM
No.719187448
>>719187064
>Heavy focus on combat
>Side step to dodge
>Stamina bar
>Upgrade system
>Weapon durability
>Sanity system
This could either be describing Bloodborne or Silent Hill f
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:56:59 PM
No.719187550
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:57:57 PM
No.719187620
>>719187693
>>719186973
>The gameplay of the original games is objectively bad though.
why was it bad
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 9:58:54 PM
No.719187693
>>719187854
>>719187620
Tank controls. They need remakes.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:00:14 PM
No.719187779
>>719181828
>Smokin' Sexy Style!
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:00:39 PM
No.719187808
>>719186973
I don't have a problem with actual gameplay, but I don't like this half-assed attempt at merging action and horror
Slitterhead tried something similar and failed, while SH2R also doesn't feel satisfying to play
Bloodborne and Wuchang have horror elements, but they are still fundamentally action games
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:01:28 PM
No.719187854
>>719188587
>>719187693
The only SH game with just tank controls was SH1 newfag
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:02:19 PM
No.719187905
>>719189256
How is silent hill 1 gameplay bad?
You can back step, side step, side run, shoot while moving. When using weapons you can swing wildly, normally and even hold for a longer attack.
Its actually a lot of mobility.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:03:46 PM
No.719188010
>>719204956
>>719175574 (OP)
>SH turning into Souls-adjacent actionslop
>RE turning into realistic panic attack cinemaslop
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:04:07 PM
No.719188034
>>719180251
This is clearly bugged and he's not hitting the enemy.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:04:10 PM
No.719188038
>>719175574 (OP)
>Website screencap thread
>((((gaming journalist)))) review
>Muh Silent Bore 2
I'm still buying it.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:05:30 PM
No.719188116
Saying "it's not scary" is as valid as a criticism as saying "it's not fun," it doesn't mean anything and it's entirely subjective.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:07:34 PM
No.719188254
>>719185139
>its made like this so you are scared to attack and run away when enemy groups attack you later
Magnetically locking onto enemies and giving you cancels actually does not do that.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:08:57 PM
No.719188365
>>719188486
>>719189087
It looks corny as fuck le action scene bosses it's neither cool or scary man wtf....
Ryushiki07 is going to completely fuck this up isn't he?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:11:06 PM
No.719188486
>>719188365
He's only writing the story. If it was up to him, this would just be a VN.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:12:44 PM
No.719188587
>>719188767
>>719187854
Calm down freak. I've never played the games, just going off what I've watched.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:15:19 PM
No.719188767
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:15:40 PM
No.719188793
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:15:57 PM
No.719188823
>>719177270
America with a loli blonde protagonist would be better.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:16:58 PM
No.719188890
>>719177465
Same man, there's not that many anyway, but gotta support Silent Hill.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:18:10 PM
No.719188975
>>719178026
Ninja Blade fucking sucked.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:19:51 PM
No.719189078
>>719177663
Game journalists praise anything that it's woke and the rest is just random shit.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:20:04 PM
No.719189087
>>719188365
maybe at least the dai OST...
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:20:57 PM
No.719189151
I have a feeling this game will btfo everyone and the story is gonna be fucking ground breaking but we'll see.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:22:20 PM
No.719189245
>>719186297
I agree, it's way more scary to know that I have to face the monster at some point and win, more satisfying too.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:22:25 PM
No.719189256
>>719187905
SH1 is the peak of the series and anyone saying otherwise is a retard with shit taste.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:23:15 PM
No.719189319
>>719175574 (OP)
Sounds like a fair criticism, but I'm still going to pirate this
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:23:35 PM
No.719189338
>>719189828
>>719189828
>>719180803
lol no tlou2 is crap and not scary
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:23:47 PM
No.719189349
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:24:23 PM
No.719189386
>>719186635
This isnt a Remake and it looks good
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:25:29 PM
No.719189457
>>719181896
Yeah pretty much the whole narrative falls apart here, besides journos praised SH2 remake so it doesn't even make sense.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:25:35 PM
No.719189462
>>719175574 (OP)
Silent Hill: Homecoming bros... we're home
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:28:12 PM
No.719189609
>>719189742
>>719182198
you don't even know why you don't like it
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:28:43 PM
No.719189656
>>719181896
Censored Maria and Angelas face ruin the 2 remake
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:30:13 PM
No.719189742
>>719189609
You think that means he's obligated to like it instead? Fuck off.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:31:50 PM
No.719189828
>>719189338
>>719189338
atmosphere you fucked retard tlou2 shits all over this game and its not close and most likely have a better story somehow
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:32:33 PM
No.719189872
Honestly looks better than RE8 and 9.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:42:20 PM
No.719190479
>>719193168
>>719194251
>>719176195
>>719175574 (OP)
It's literally SH: Homecoming - 60s Japan edition.
Anyone even pretending to be "excited" for this slop hates Silent Hill and is a brown Hindu.
We warned you about this slop already 15 years ago.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:45:49 PM
No.719190673
All the silent hills have a decent amount of action though, about on par with re1 and 2?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:46:28 PM
No.719190716
>be Silent Hill
>one of the most venerated survival horror properties out there
>gets mogged forever by some gay schizo using rpg maker and spaghetti code
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:47:40 PM
No.719190792
>SH1 starts with Harry fighting a dinosaur and ends with him killing a god
>SH3 starts with Heather shooting a monster to death and ends with her killing a god
>SH4 is about a hikikomori fighting a serial killer
Um its not a real horror game because you're too badass
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:47:54 PM
No.719190805
>>719190898
>>719191294
Hitting a ghost with a lead pipe is dumb.
SH4 had it right when it made ghosts intangible rape monsters you DO NOT WANT.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:49:17 PM
No.719190891
>>719176564
opened the thread for this video
now that I've seen it, I can leave. thanks.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:49:22 PM
No.719190898
>>719190805
You can hit the ghosts with lead pipes though. Did you even play the game?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:51:26 PM
No.719191041
>>719192149
>>719205019
I feel like horror games with combat used to work fairly well in the past
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:55:17 PM
No.719191294
>>719191413
>>719190805
You can beat the shit out of them bruh
You just can't perma them unless you have a sword
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 10:56:56 PM
No.719191413
>>719191654
>>719191294
Don't the medallion and candles also take them out?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:00:27 PM
No.719191654
>>719191413
Not permanently, only the swords can
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:01:43 PM
No.719191758
I still don't understand why journos fawned over SH2R because it was exactly the same. The combat was shit, there was too much of it and it got repetitive.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:04:46 PM
No.719191968
>>719192113
>>719193168
>>719176195
If there's one thing I can trust journos on, it's when a game is too easy. You already know the average "skill" level a game journo is at, so for them to say SHf's gameplay is piss easy means it's basically a toddler game.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:05:18 PM
No.719192005
>>719175574 (OP)
>retarded jurno reviews matter when they agree with me
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:06:38 PM
No.719192113
>>719193168
>>719176195
yeah this
>>719191968. if journos are saying it's too easy IMAGINE how easy it actually is
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:07:20 PM
No.719192149
>>719191041
Depends what % of the game you spend fighting. I imagine SH2 if half the runtime was fighting. Oh wait, that's the remake.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:07:55 PM
No.719192187
>>719192729
>>719209348
>>719176259
i played the trilogy but i never played the room because i heard that shit sucks
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:12:50 PM
No.719192491
>>719181332
Yeah her dodge is way too nimble and covers too much ground
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:13:47 PM
No.719192551
>>719181332
the director has never made a good movie thoughbeit
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:14:49 PM
No.719192615
>>719181332
this is like fucking bloodborne man wtf are they doing to this horror game
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:15:23 PM
No.719192657
>>719206619
>implying having more focus in combat is a good thing
I don't wanna see you niggers talking shit about Homecoming ever again
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:16:30 PM
No.719192729
>>719192839
>>719192187
>he played Reddit Hill 2 but not Kino Hill 4chan
you are a drone
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:18:00 PM
No.719192830
>>719192729
>Kino Hill 4chan
*until it gets remade then we never liked that shit
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:19:31 PM
No.719192920
>>719175954
Is this oneechanbara?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:19:33 PM
No.719192923
thanks ryukishi for ruining another franchise
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:20:03 PM
No.719192960
>>719198325
>>719175574 (OP)
No Lynchian themes no buy
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:21:44 PM
No.719193074
>>719186635
drop dead tr00n
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:22:31 PM
No.719193125
>>719193354
It's a Japanese game so they are going to shit on it regardless. They only say Japanese games are good if they either get paid lots of money, or if the fanbase is so big that they HAVE to give it a good review out of fear of backlash. Silent Hills fanbase is lilliputian so western hack journalists will not give it a fair review
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:22:32 PM
No.719193126
>>719193303
Uh oh SH3 sisters, looks like Heather is going to be played as a troon in the remake
>>719192839
they won't, Reddit Hill 2 demake did not meet the absurd expectations of Konami (they thought it would pull RE2 Demake numbers kek) and the SH1 demake will obviously sell less units, and if by some chance they greenlit a SH3 demake which will sell far less units than the previous two demakes you can bet your ass Konami will gave up before touching SH4
they'll just focus on milking MGS series, watch as the MGS3 remakes becomes a far bigger success than Reddit Hill 2 demake, from now on we will see more MGS demakes
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:22:59 PM
No.719193168
>>719192113
>>719191968
Yeah I'll concede that point.
If the retarded babies called "journalists" can beat a game, and they weren't playing on "journalist difficulty", then it's too easy.
>>719190479 said it best, homecoming and all later games have not been scary and suck. Even the remake of 2 is too combat focused, not scary, not dreadful. PH please rape them all again.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:24:50 PM
No.719193303
>>719193473
>>719193126
what if it's just a regular ass boy and not a troon?
what if Harry saved a run-of-the-mill boy instead of a girl?
Huh? What then anon?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:25:32 PM
No.719193331
Eileen shaving
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:25:49 PM
No.719193354
>>719193125
>It's a Japanese game so they are going to shit on it regardless.
Look at the franchise you are currently talking about.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:26:07 PM
No.719193381
>>719193163
I just hate this "safe bet IP recycling" industry.
It's enough to make a man sick.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:26:53 PM
No.719193426
>>719194365
>>719193163
I don't think they would've near instantly greenlight the SH1 remake if SH2 remake didn't live up to expectation
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:27:31 PM
No.719193473
>>719193303
What if Harry is a woman?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:28:25 PM
No.719193527
>>719193626
>>719192839
It wont.
Konami is just using popularity as a metric.
For better or worse SH4 is not considered one of the top ones like 1-3 and not that niche enough.
Now just play 4 and form your own opinion.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:28:43 PM
No.719193543
>>719193627
>>719196702
Why does SH2remake being people's first SH game make /v/ seethe?
>>719193527
Can someone just give me an opinion for 4? I'm not playing it
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:29:44 PM
No.719193627
>>719193703
>>719196702
>>719193543
secret club is the foundation of 99% of /v/ taste. the less people that play a game the better it is
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:30:26 PM
No.719193678
>>719194006
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:30:44 PM
No.719193703
>>719193627
I'm glad nobody's heard of the games I like, otherwise I'd have to hate them.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:30:53 PM
No.719193716
>>719193626
it's kino
SH1, 3 and 4 are the holy trinity of series
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:33:51 PM
No.719193917
>>719193626
I loved it and its my favorite but I am not bothered by the issues most players hate SH4 for ao cant take my opinion.
I just think having a game where the main character isn't the player is kind of cool. Alessa was almost like that but I think she isn't featured enough.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:35:14 PM
No.719194006
>>719193678
>soul slop genuinely ruined video games
what a shame..
I joked that contrarian anons here would start saying 4 isn't the worst one when the series got more eyeballs on it again. I wasn't actually being serious
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:35:57 PM
No.719194053
>>719181886
he is just the writer really, even if he wrote a masterpiece(he can't, he always fumbles the ending) the rest of the team is so shit I doubt even a good story could save it
His team of 10/10 composer buddies also did a lot of the heavy lifting to improve the atmosphere, without them it isn't the same
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:36:47 PM
No.719194113
>>719194671
>>719185571
Damn almost like it's not real or something retard
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:37:32 PM
No.719194164
>>719193626
worst gameplay in the series and generally the least interesting characters. feels unfinished
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:38:45 PM
No.719194251
>>719190479
This post is slop
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:40:00 PM
No.719194339
>>719175574 (OP)
>When everything short of a scripted boss can be sprinted past or danced around,
You mean like every other Silent Hill?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:40:22 PM
No.719194365
>>719195356
>>719193163
>>719193426
I'd say it speaks volumes that they went right to the next remake and never bothered doing a Born From A Wish DLC (which, coincidentally, automatically invalidates the remake as a worthwhile version to play, even ignoring quality concerns).
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:40:54 PM
No.719194402
>>719193626
I found it fun and interesting enough; until the second half of the game where you're just backtracking the first half of the game. Can't hurt to give it a try and drop it if you become bored.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:41:30 PM
No.719194432
>>719186635
>They did this shit with RE4make and Dead Space remake
Both of those remakes were great
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:42:40 PM
No.719194503
>>719176195
I only trust game journos when they shit on a game.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:44:59 PM
No.719194669
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:44:59 PM
No.719194671
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:45:43 PM
No.719194725
>>719194013
Are you new?
SH4 has always had a vocal fanbase. And its likely to be better than this slop because it has the SH team soul in it.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:46:31 PM
No.719194773
>>719175574 (OP)
Weren't journos fellating SH2 slopmake for being more action-focused?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:48:03 PM
No.719194887
>>719195160
>>719175574 (OP)
Does Japan like Silent Hill f?
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:51:55 PM
No.719195160
>>719195347
>>719194887
wow the girls are really cute
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:53:33 PM
No.719195274
>>719195653
>>719179618
People had hope for SH Homecoming cause it was the first main SH release after Team Silent disbanded. After that peple have been negative about pretty much every release after that.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:54:42 PM
No.719195347
>>719195160
Too bad the models look like shit.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:54:50 PM
No.719195356
>>719194365
that's for the best, i don't want them to butcher it
and i doubt they will ever make it, it's too short and won't take much effort to do so any cope telling you ''they need time to cook!!!'' can be ignored
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:55:54 PM
No.719195421
>>719194013
i bet you didn't even play 3 you coomer fag
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:58:07 PM
No.719195550
>>719195705
>>719194013
Anything past 2 is trash
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:58:28 PM
No.719195568
This game is going to be the most 7/10 horror game ever made to the point that I think the new Blooper original game they're making is going to be remember more.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:59:32 PM
No.719195642
>>719175574 (OP)
>Hire chinkshit studio known that only makes remasters and ports
>They make uninspired unoriginal derivative slop
Who could have foreseen this? Not Konami apparently. Will they EVER let a competent studio touch Silent Hill? If you say Blooper Team, I'll call you a redditor.
Anonymous
8/27/2025, 11:59:42 PM
No.719195653
>>719195274
>People had hope for SH Homecoming cause it was the first main SH release after Team Silent disbanded.
First of all, Origins came out several years before then.
Secondly, you could tell from the previews and interviews that it'd be terrible. There was a press spot where the lead devs were jumping around talking about how shit the past games were and how Homecoming was going to be the first playable SH game.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:00:28 AM
No.719195705
>>719195942
>>719195550
>Anything past 2 is trash
spoken like a true poser
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:01:30 AM
No.719195775
>has more hitstop than a gs in monhun
lol wtf
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:04:13 AM
No.719195942
>>719196173
>>719195705
I played each SH on day of release on their repetitive platforms.
Despite time moving forward and le grafix improving, anyone could tell SH3 was letdown in everything else.
SH4 was simply laughable, you could tell it was a telltale of SH series end.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:07:23 AM
No.719196173
>>719196297
>>719195942
>repetitive platforms
good morning saar did you see my bloody bitch wife Mary? i rape her bery much later
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:09:01 AM
No.719196265
>>719181896
>calling other people trannies
>defending the slop remake that was touched on by a DEI consultant group
>coincidentaly all the female characters are uglier
you're such a faggot it's unreal
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:09:33 AM
No.719196297
>>719197243
>>719196173
spotted amerifat
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:12:06 AM
No.719196464
>>719175574 (OP)
still not too late to rebalance it so it's more preferable to just run away from enemies and those who choose to fight should do it at their own peril. souls games maximize risk and reward, horror games should do the opposite.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:15:47 AM
No.719196702
>>719193543
>>719193627
u should always play the original first!
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:21:21 AM
No.719197084
>>719197205
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:23:03 AM
No.719197190
>>719197813
>>719180251
> Yes a clear bug proves the combat sucks
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:23:17 AM
No.719197205
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:23:56 AM
No.719197243
>>719197303
>>719196297
>didn't even deny it
Relax brown boy
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:24:22 AM
No.719197274
>>719197485
>>719175574 (OP)
>horror is when no gameplay and just watch
>what little gamerplay there is must the the shitty ass tank controls, inventory system and sorry excuse for for a battle system that my ps1/2 diaper games had
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:24:44 AM
No.719197303
>>719197243
> didnt even deny it
take a shower, if you can even fit into it
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:27:30 AM
No.719197485
>>719197274
>says there's no gameplay
>describes the gameplay
Dumb post is dumb.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:31:53 AM
No.719197749
>>719179814
> if fighting requires tons of your resources so you dread having to fight.
Speaking of that, have any of you guys gotten a chance to try out the demo for Chronos: A New Dawn?
I liked the atmosphere, art direction, and story.
The upgrade system reminds me of dead space.
I'm not too big a fan of the combat though, but that might be because I just suck at resource management.
Though the game really does invoke the feeling of anxiety when deciding what to spend your limited resources on quite well.
Your character feels very heavy and cumbersome moving around.
The mechanic of enemies fusing with corpses is a bit stressful. Since you can only have 1 flamer fuel at once, you basically need to charge them when they spawn to keep them from empowering themselves.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:33:03 AM
No.719197813
>>719197190
That's not a bug though? That webm clearly shows a limitation of the combat system.
>Enemy is in a corner
>Player attempts to hit
>Hit refuses to register
You can clearly see that whatever weird soulstranny tracking system they used is shitting itself. I swear fans of SH2R are some of the densest retards on this board.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:33:13 AM
No.719197821
>>719175574 (OP)
>Ryukishit07 product sucks
No way wtf
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:34:39 AM
No.719197918
>>719198178
>>719198332
qrd on the ryukishi hate?
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:38:51 AM
No.719198178
>>719197918
The only narrative change people are unsure about is the game taking place in Japan. Other than that, no one is concerned about the story. The game itself is being worked on a chinkshit studio that's never been involved with a real game before.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:41:06 AM
No.719198325
>>719198497
>>719192960
what the hell was the point of this part of the movie?
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:41:15 AM
No.719198332
>>719197918
It's cyclical really
>umineko starts, ryukishi is beloved
>umineko ends, ryukishi is hated
>years pass
>new generations discover umineko, ryukishi is beloved again
>culture shifts, trannys claim Umineko as "theirs", ryukishi is hated again
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:43:47 AM
No.719198481
>>719175574 (OP)
Okay for once, I actually trust this game journalist's review
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:43:58 AM
No.719198497
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:46:28 AM
No.719198632
>>719175954
>Silent Hill Homecoming: Japan Edition
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:47:09 AM
No.719198671
>>719198739
Gee folks, don't you love BRAND? I sure love BRAND! No, it doesn't matter to me if it has nothing to do with the original in spirit, or if the original artists are long gone. BRAND! I love BRAND! Yes I want more remakes that round off all the edges and extract all passion and soul. It's BRAND baby!
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:47:49 AM
No.719198714
>>719175954
That hit stop is fucking insane, it's like I'm watching a fighting game.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:48:07 AM
No.719198739
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:49:40 AM
No.719198851
>english VAs got confirmed
>kitsune guy is NOT shu
>nubzombie was wrong AGAIN
lol
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:51:23 AM
No.719198965
>>719175574 (OP)
Does Fromslop breed facists?
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 12:54:57 AM
No.719199182
The aesthetic is cool as fuck but the gameplay looks like total fucking shit and I already know better than to buy UE5 games.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:05:37 AM
No.719199878
>>719176564
Wait is this supposed to make me not want to play it?
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:06:30 AM
No.719199924
>>719200018
>>719200097
Japanese developers in 2025 do not understand Silent Hill
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:08:00 AM
No.719200018
>>719199924
>Japanese
does no one bother to look this shit uo anymore? the devs are CHINESE
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:09:14 AM
No.719200097
>>719200376
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:12:45 AM
No.719200327
>>719202018
It will be so fucking funny when this game gets a 90+ score on metacritic and /v/ immediately turns on the journos again.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:13:33 AM
No.719200376
>>719200097
Shattered memories is so good desu yhe whole time i was thinking man this game had some really horny devs. Then i realized it was "profiling" me and i was making the game more horny by looking at the female characters boobs during the cutscenes
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:19:38 AM
No.719200786
>>719202240
>>719181828
Looks fun to me and I like games with horror aesthetic
You guys can seethe while I have fun
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:39:00 AM
No.719202018
>>719204330
>>719200327
This game won't get 90 lol. Maybe an 80 if they're lucky.
>turn on the journos
You are not from here are you? No one here, except maybe tourists like you, hates every article that's ever been written simply because of whatever journo meme got popular on twitter or youtube.
You see, certain people can tell if the reviewer is being genuine or not. It's called having basic reading comprehension skills.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:42:25 AM
No.719202240
>>719203558
>>719200786
.>this game is shit
>no i dont think its shit?
>why?
>fuck you kill yourself this game is great seethe and dilate tranny
OK...
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:44:33 AM
No.719202367
>>719175574 (OP)
>bald basedbeard hates it and is concerned
all you had to say, I'm sold
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:53:33 AM
No.719202903
>>719207930
>>719175574 (OP)
Silent Hill always has combat since the very first game. What a faggot bitching about combat in a horror game. Resident Evil which is a horror game has combat. Same with Silent Hill, Dead Space, etc.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 1:58:20 AM
No.719203228
>>719178698
The weapon doesn't even collide with the enemy. Visually it clearly misses, but massive hitboxes register it as a hit.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:03:21 AM
No.719203558
>>719202240
Who the fuck are you quoting lmao
It looks fun. I'm going to play it and have fun, you can keep seething here I guess. I hope that's fun for you at least otherwise...
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:05:57 AM
No.719203716
>>719206847
>ended using a guide for the second half of the hospital
why is she barefoot?
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:15:29 AM
No.719204330
>>719204419
>>719202018
It will get a 90 and be hated like it is now or a 60 and become an instant /v/ classic as reviewers will not understand the "kino" action.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:16:47 AM
No.719204419
>>719204865
>>719204330
a 60 is good you know
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:20:18 AM
No.719204691
The second half of SH4 is some of the worst gameplay I've ever experienced.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:22:52 AM
No.719204865
>>719205038
>>719204419
for a video game it is a death sentence. unless you are a contrarian like me
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:24:29 AM
No.719204956
>>719188010
>Bibo's anus is turning into my urinal
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:25:30 AM
No.719205019
>>719191041
To be fucking honest, Eternal Darkness is extremely easy when you know where to hit and remember to enhance your weapon from time to time.
Attacking without aiming with R was a complete waste of time with most characters. It only tires your character and deals minimum damage. Looked cool sometimes, though.
Oh, and I liked that you couldn't do the reload trick people used to do in Resident Evil.
A cool combat concept. Perhaps a more balanced one would work well in many horror games.
>t. autistically played this game for many years
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:25:50 AM
No.719205038
>>719204865
not contrarian
i just know 50 means average game
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:45:19 AM
No.719206275
>>719176195
I'd rather listen to a reasonable review of someone who's played the game for longer than I + gameplay footage I've seen to arrive at my conclusion
I'm not willing to buy the game, play it, decide it's trash and then refund before the 2 hours are up.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:49:15 AM
No.719206494
>>719181828
i was defending this based on the initial reveal but now that theyre actually showing gameplay and more of the story/presentation its literally just downpour 2
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:51:14 AM
No.719206619
>>719192657
The problem with Homecoming wasnt the combat
>>719192839
If they censored Eileens shaving cutscenes then yes the Remake is shit
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:55:22 AM
No.719206847
>>719207105
>>719203716
It was foretold by gyromancy!
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 2:59:18 AM
No.719207105
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 3:12:05 AM
No.719207930
>>719202903
>Resident Evil which is a horror game has combat
some resi games are pure action with no punishment for playing recklessly, some have resource management where you have to save bullets for boss fights and special occasions, they are puzzle game not an action game.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 3:22:27 AM
No.719208585
The only way you can do combat is by making something you dont want to be doing like 70% of the time. You want to be avoiding monsters or throwing things at or in front of them to slow them down. Use the the system from RE4 where you can disable them with certain weak spots with certain weapons. Character should be kinda slow and clearly inexperienced at any sort of fighting. The fight itself should be a real figh for your life (and progress).
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 3:25:45 AM
No.719208817
>>719175954
I don't want to hear anyone complain about Homecoming ever again.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 3:31:35 AM
No.719209180
>>719175954
Bro your character should be severely underpowered if it's supposed to be horror. If you have to kill one monster, it should nearly cost you your life and make you shit your pants.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 3:34:12 AM
No.719209348
>>719192187
I like it better than 2, the story of sh4 is fucking cool
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 3:39:17 AM
No.719209696
>>719176259
honestly the whole
hitstop is fucking retarded
you dont need to play the franchise to know that
not that i've played it more than 2-3 hours
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 3:51:04 AM
No.719210338
>>719184724
>>"LOOK HOW CRUEL TEENS CAN BE TO ONE ANOTHER" (like every other ryushit07 story)
just making shit up
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 3:51:46 AM
No.719210383
>>719210512
>>719175574 (OP)
You can run past and ignore every enemy in this game. Only the bosses are the ones you have to fight.
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 3:54:04 AM
No.719210512
>>719210383
Blooborned 2???
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 4:11:50 AM
No.719211457
>>719212138
I usually try to be optimistic about upcoming games in series I care about, but the excessive hitstop is all I needed to see to know this game's not in the greatest of hands. SH2 Remake's combat is the upper limit of how action-y survival horror combat should be, imo. That game pushed it with the slight hitstop and spammable dodge iframes, anything more excessive feels closer to a Platinum game than to Silent Hill
Anonymous
8/28/2025, 4:25:37 AM
No.719212138
>>719211457
You liked demake, you'll like this. Eat your Silent Hillβ’ slop, piggy. It's for you.
sage
8/28/2025, 4:29:59 AM
No.719212373
>>719175574 (OP)
>Silent Hill 2 went full action in it's 2nd half
>MGS Delta is a lazy remake that runs like shit
>Silent Hills F is shit
THE KONAMI REDEMPTION ARC BROS??!?!? WHAT THE FUCK HAPPENED?!?!?
sage
8/28/2025, 4:34:24 AM
No.719212641
Konami lost.