← Home ← Back to /v/

Thread 723148153

47 posts 18 images /v/
Anonymous No.723148153 [Report] >>723148234 >>723148987 >>723149089 >>723149258 >>723149338 >>723151208 >>723153770 >>723154189 >>723154627 >>723155989 >>723158275
Silent Hill 2 Remake might be the best created remake of all time
Anonymous No.723148234 [Report] >>723154279
>>723148153 (OP)
>Japanese game with realistic looking people
cringe
Anonymous No.723148242 [Report]
I agree
Anonymous No.723148987 [Report]
>>723148153 (OP)
Anonymous No.723149039 [Report] >>723149258 >>723161493 >>723163705
NOOO IT'S A REMAKE IT CAN'T BE DIFFERENT THAN THE ORIGINAL
Anonymous No.723149087 [Report] >>723149209 >>723149226 >>723162256
I could make it out of silent hill no problem just don't ask me to prove or anything I don't want to right now
Anonymous No.723149089 [Report] >>723149258
>>723148153 (OP)
I think it’s probably the best remake since ‘02 REmake.
Anonymous No.723149209 [Report]
>>723149087
As soon as it was like “jump into this dark pit that you can’t see the bottom of”, I’d probably go back to the Bowl-a-Rama and see if there was any pizza left.
Anonymous No.723149226 [Report]
>>723149087
when you're playing the game you're playing as the people who made it out. who are to say you aren't going to end up as one of the people who end up mangled and have your body used as decor for the otherworld? You could be one of the victims of some serial killer or
Anonymous No.723149258 [Report] >>723149320 >>723149365 >>723149423
>>723148153 (OP)
it is the worst one by far.
REmake 1, 2002, still remains as the golden standard of all vidya remakes.

>>723149039
You could argue that the policy Germany tried to impose on Poland back in 1939 was "just different" as well, but few would claim it to be "good".

>>723149089
And a red tricycle is totally the next best thing to the little red Corvette...
Anonymous No.723149320 [Report]
>>723149258
What an insufferable faggot
Anonymous No.723149338 [Report] >>723149439 >>723149863 >>723153923 >>723157373 >>723157827
>>723148153 (OP)
The subtlety in the uneasiness on the original James' face shifts depending on your perspective once you learn what he has done. Relatable enough for the player to feel in his shoes, but not quite there. Every character in the original was carefully modeled along that thin but clear line between reality and fiction, creating a weird limbo and surreal feeling about what is real and what isn't, given James' mental state and the entire game taking place in his head. The remake comes along, throws all that away, and presents a normal, tired-looking character, like they did with Joel in TLOU, and call it a day. James' eeriness and almost null, empty facial expression are gone, replaced by a dollar-store average sad husband.
Anonymous No.723149365 [Report]
>>723149258
You guys never seem to be able to explain why it’s bad. You just repeat “demake” like the seagulls from Finding Nemo.
Anonymous No.723149423 [Report]
>>723149258
(YOU)
Anonymous No.723149439 [Report]
>>723149338
You’re projecting your headcanon onto almost 25-year old character models and dodgy turn of the century localization.
Anonymous No.723149863 [Report]
>>723149338
I'm seeing your image and I don't feel anything what you're saying
Anonymous No.723151071 [Report] >>723153115
RE remake 1-2-4 are the best
FFVII is a close second
SH2 remake is also great
Feels like remakes are better than new games now
Anonymous No.723151208 [Report]
>>723148153 (OP)
Resident evil1*
Anonymous No.723153115 [Report]
>>723151071
to be fair, outside of REmake 1 those remakes are basically completely new games that just have same the story and aesthetics of the originals
Anonymous No.723153770 [Report]
>>723148153 (OP)
Why is he so sad?
Anonymous No.723153923 [Report] >>723155338 >>723157202
>>723149338
>Every character in the original was carefully modeled along that thin but clear line between reality and fiction, creating a weird limbo and surreal feeling about what is real and what isn't, given James' mental state and the entire game taking place in his head.
Fucking midwit pseudonarrative bullshit. This is what happens when society is filled with nothing but video essay faggotry where dumb midwit niggers compete each other in creating dumbass theory to look smart. NO, it is just pure technological limitations. Almost every game with realistic cutscene at the time looked like that.
Anonymous No.723154189 [Report]
>>723148153 (OP)
I loved it and you could certainly tell they put a ton of love into the game, the environments looked amazing, the absolute dilapidation and decay was so well done, truly draining.
Anonymous No.723154279 [Report] >>723154782
>>723148234
So just like the original SH2? Retard
Anonymous No.723154627 [Report]
>>723148153 (OP)
Spec ops the line did this way better and looks more artistically cool
Realismslop looks so ugly
Anonymous No.723154782 [Report]
>>723154279
>so just like th-GAWK GAWM GLORP GLORP PWAH
Yes faggot, keep sucking
Anonymous No.723155338 [Report]
>>723153923
The eerie, detached expressions were clearly intentional when you look at concept art or inspirations like Twin Peaks. Just look at any red room scene and you'll see the same atmosphere.
Anonymous No.723155989 [Report]
>>723148153 (OP)
Yes
Anonymous No.723156589 [Report]
I HATE MY WIFE IM SO DEPRESSED AIIIIEEEEEEE
Anonymous No.723156792 [Report] >>723157020
I can't wait to see what they do with the SH1R because they're going to have to do something new with it, they can't just use the story that is there, they'll have to do some major rewrites

and in case you don't get it, in my mind that's a good thing. Remakes should only be faithful in spirit, not 1:1 recreations. Silent Hill 1 is always going to be Silent Hill 1, so the remake can do something new with that story.
Anonymous No.723156976 [Report]
>all the textures were downgraded to the point where toluca prison looks like a school
>gameplay involves shooting the same 3 enemies for 15 hours
>character designs, cutscenes, music hasnt been improved in anyway
>BUT I WANT TO FUCK JAMES
blooper team sucks and you suck them off like a faggot
Anonymous No.723157020 [Report]
>>723156792
It better keep the "It was foretold by Gyromancy" line It's so stupid
Anonymous No.723157202 [Report]
>>723153923
Polaks can't understand subtext, kurwa.
Anonymous No.723157373 [Report] >>723157537
>>723149338
zoomers are irony poisoned and anti-intellectual so they do not understand carefully crafted art and subtlety
the original was designed like a Lynch film, the remake feels more like your average thriller flick
Anonymous No.723157537 [Report] >>723157842
>>723157373
the remake is literally subtler and has removed certain lines of dialogue that spell things out.
Anonymous No.723157827 [Report]
>>723149338
>Every character in the original was carefully modeled along that thin but clear line between reality and fiction, creating a weird limbo and surreal feeling about what is real and what isn't,
They literally stole every character from somewhere else and didn't even bother to change the details to make it less obvious.
Anonymous No.723157842 [Report] >>723158132
>>723157537
it is not about the plot and the writing, the plot is the least important thing
there's no subtlety in the remake, everything from the delivery to the camera work and the editing in the scenes is extremely in your face. the original is full of uncertainty but the remake wants to make sure that you're having the thoughts and emotions it wants you to have
Anonymous No.723158132 [Report] >>723158543
>>723157842
I think you may literally just be a hater and I say that unironically not in a meme way. SH2 is obviously more artistic and original, the remake is just taking that game and modernizing it but they did a pretty good job all things considered, they certainly did not fuck up to the degree you try to make it sound like they did.
Anonymous No.723158275 [Report]
>>723148153 (OP)
>they have resorted to ESL pags to shill their games on image boards
Grim.
Anonymous No.723158543 [Report] >>723158735
>>723158132
>take something good
>make the same thing again but worse
>"erm it's not that bad"
it has no reason to exist and you're a faggot for defending it
it's my fault for still not getting used to this board being more and more reddit-like every day
Anonymous No.723158672 [Report]
>silent hill
Can't I just be really loud and they'll kick me out?
Anonymous No.723158735 [Report] >>723159446
>>723158543
I have a friend that has played Silent Hill since 1999, this guy is obsessed with the franchise and he had plenty of good things to say about the remake. He's not some tasteless consumer either, he's very thoughtful in his analysis of what worked and what didn't.
Anonymous No.723159446 [Report] >>723160039
>>723158735
Uh-huh?
I'm one of such people, and I live with yet another + know bunch of OG SH fags, who got into the series on PS1 days already, years before Youtube even came to be a thing.

There's not a single detail in the DE-make that would not have been downgraded significantly. Many of the scenes and alterations outright miss the point, and the gameplay is exact same shit as SH:HC, that was universally loathed by every SH fan.
The problem is, Sony managed to normalize that sort of Soulsborne-like action slop the past 15 years, so now the Piss5 generation glomps that sort of shit with a smile.
Anonymous No.723160039 [Report] >>723164197
>>723159446
Well that's your opinion then, I guess. Problem is when you argue from a bitter standpoint then its too easy to hate everything, if you can't see an ounce of good in something then you're probably coming at it from a position so cynical that you were never going to like it no matter what it did or how it did it.

Like you can't even admit that Blue Creek is more interesting in its more fleshed out form in the remake? You can't admit Eddie is handled better? You can't admit the otherworld being expanded on is at least visually more interesting than in the original game? Nothing, just a complete void of negativity from your standpoint? What's the point of engaging with something in that cynical a way? Of course you're gonna hate everything.

But you're absolutely free to dislike it, not my place to say. Obviously a remake can never replace the original experience. But from my perspective I certainly see a lot of good in it and a lot of love put into it, even if its not without flaws.
Anonymous No.723161493 [Report] >>723163705
>>723149039
Enjoy this meme
Anonymous No.723162256 [Report]
>>723149087
If you could "make it out", you wouldn't be there in the first place
Anonymous No.723163705 [Report]
>>723161493
>>723149039
remakes shouldnt exist :)
Anonymous No.723164197 [Report]
>>723160039
>you can't even admit that Blue Creek is more interesting ?
>the otherworld expanded/ visually more interesting ?
You're just spewing bullshit, kid.
I was initially EXCITED for the Apartments, because it SEEMED LIKE they would've done a REmake 1 style expansion of the building.

But in the end, the whole place was significantly DOWNGRADED, streamlined, and "Zelda dungeonified". All the typical modern AAA slop and RE / SH DEmake cancers pop up right there and now:
Everything is spoonfed to you, all the "puzzles" have their "solutions" or "keys" in the very same room / in the absolute near vicinity, and entire segments are cut out as you "progress" through what are essentially closed loops taking you back to the main puzzle of the dungeon (the hanging radio, the locker box...). All while you get bombarded with what are essentially Doom 2016 style combat arena rooms.

And then there is the goddamn "Otherworld", taken straight out of The Movie once again, butchering the James' own inner world design and atmosphere of the whole game.

>You can't admit Eddie is handled better?
Sorry and not sorry, but anyone claiming such BS with a straight face is a school-dropout moron.
There's not a single character that was treated well in the SH2 demake, with Eddie being perhaps THE worst offending case of pure Flanderization.
Apparently, the old Eddie was not fat enough for the modern American audiences, so they made him a literal Jabba The Hut, clearly missing out the "Fit Fat" archetype, that not only actually COULD be into fucking Football, but was also clearly an indirect reference to Fullmetal Jacket.

Not only that, but you clearly cannot have sad, relatable "villains", so Eddie was now made disgusting and abnoxious in every single scene he pops up. Crapcom ruined the Chief Briar in similar manner in the RE2 demake, making him into fullblown schizo that blows his cover and cool the very first second he waltzes into the scene.

>you hate everything!!
Incorrect.