Thread 280349077

When did you realize MAL scores and the sites opinion on anime as a whole doesn't matter?

Many years ago.
But it's not just MAL. No one's opinion matters.

>>280349077 (OP)
When shit like Freiren even got close to winning AOTY. Thank God Solo Leveling pulled through and saved anime.

GQuuuuuX is fucking awful though

>>280349077 (OP)
Before MAL even existed when I realized I don't care about other people's taste or opinions.

>>280349154
Not really, it's rushed but doesn't deserve a 7

>using MAL post-2014
why on earth would someone do this
but then again might not be my place to say given the state of /a/ today

>>280349077 (OP)
Frieren being first on MAL is self explanatory

>>280349179
i use it because it's cool to personalize your profile with CSS, i don't interact with communities tho

>>280349171
As a 0079fag I think it deserves lower.

>>280349077 (OP)
>filename
>Gcucks AOTD
You are smoking crack. That garbage wasn't even top 10 in its own season.

>>280349290
0079 is my favorite too, Gquuuuux is obviously inferior but i still think 7 is too low

>>280349077 (OP)
I never really cared for anyone else's opinion except for mine to begin with and i dislike websites like MAL, Letterboxd, RYM, etc. because i feel their userbases influence new users into engaging with art in the wrong ways for the wrong reasons. Also:
>a 7 is still a fine score
>it's much higher than what GQX deserves

There Is nothing more worthless than westoid casuals' opinions on mecha anime, especially when they're legacy IPs like Gundam

>>280349077 (OP)
I've known that for years ever since they've had shit like Steins;Gate at the top of the rankings.

Probably when I was in elementary school.

>>280349077 (OP)
>he says this while posting an image proving the opposite

When jeets botted solo leveling as anything but 4/10.

>>280349077 (OP)
Mecha is not the paragon of quality /m/ believes it is. In fact it's pretty much just basic bitch shonen like dragon ball and I say this as someone who is pretty big into Gundam. If someone tells you mecha is the majority of anime they watch its a pretty big red flag that they have shit taste and dont know what theyre talking about. Also props to mal for recognizing 86 as a top tier anime, can't even discuss that one on /m/.

>>280349757
the og Gundam was simple but charming in its own way, idk how to explain that

>>280349830
>the og Gundam was simple but charming in its own way
Oh no, it's appeal was Tomino being a batshit insane director. Its unfortunate this is the best clip I can find of this but here you go
https://youtu.be/2vgLJp0W5jQ
This is not normal for a low budget 70s anime, theres a very particular way this is directed that really makes it dramatic and absurd. But it's a highly flawed show, no doubt about that.

>>280349433
Out of all the highly rated anime on MAL this is the one whose acclaim I understand the least. And that's saying something because I disagree with a lot of them.

>>280349077 (OP)
Probably when I was a kid and realized scores are the cheapest way of reviewing something.

>>280349077 (OP)
Did you feel so bad about everyone calling out your shit taste in the other thread >>280348676 that you ran away to make your own instead?

>>280349757
Hello Onimai tranny who LARPs as an oldfag

>>280349077 (OP)
It's hard for me to take anyone's word on the quality of a series lately.

>>280349077 (OP)
I don't know but Onimai being more popular and well received in the west than GQuuuuuuX matches my experiences here on /a/.

>>280349077 (OP)
Mal is good for getting a general sense of what do normies or the most common group think of a show and nothing else.

lazarus still isn't below 7 and I think giving it 6 is too generous. the most expensive joke ever.

>>280350558
Both Lazarus and GQX here in production hell for the same amount of time and wound up having similar problems throughout their runs. I found that a curious observation.

>>280349171
Japan agrees that it's trash.

I've always known that my own opinions are god tier and everyone else's opinions are shit tier

>>280349077 (OP)
I never even thought that in the first place.

I have literally never cared about MAL.

>>280349077 (OP)
KWAB

>>280349077 (OP)
>2nd worst gundam vs literal tranime

>When
Since day one you tard

>>280349077 (OP)
youre right
GQuuuuuX deserves a 4, not a 7
fucking trash anime

I don't understand why people rate a series after only one episode has aired, I don't understand why MAL allows you to rate a series if it's not finished or you didn't drop it either

>>280351359
LOL

>>280349077 (OP)
It's because people have gotten drastically more retarded over the past decade or so
People literally aren't capable of rating things on a scale anymore, they can only rate things either 0/10 or 10/10, nothing inbetween
And they don't wait to review things anymore, they watch 1 episode and rate it 10/10, even if they don't really like it that much, they just rate everything 10/10
If they don't like something, they'll usually just not rate it at all

This has led to an inflation of highly rated mediocre anime

>>280352361
>they can only rate things either 0/10 or 10/10
This is ironically a system that produces far more accurate results over time

MAL ratings are as arbitrary as IMDB ratings.

>>280349077 (OP)
Frieren FMAB and Steins;Gate probably fit better on a most overrated list than a top rated list.

>>280349077 (OP)
MAL ratings were always shit.

MAL ratings were always questionable but they’re even worse now. Any remotely decent seasonal is now rated an 8.5+, when 10 years ago they’d be a 7.7-8.3. You know newfags have ruined MAL scores because based off the site, almost all the best anime were made post covid.

>>280349077 (OP)
Like the first time I opened their top list and saw every fucking Gintama. MAL scores aren't important.

>>280349077 (OP)
That fan fiction UC is still too highly ranked. Should be a sub 5. Also Freiren destroyed the sites credibility. The normie masses have destroyed the one valuable ranking system on that site.

Trannies won.

MAL is retarded. There’s no reasonable explanation from a writing or animation point of view how Bleach final season is rated so highly. You think Bleach was a Dostoevsky piece or something

>>280349077 (OP)
Steins;Gate and SnK being in the top 5 makes no fucking sense.

>>280353911
It should be below AGE, and probably would be if AGE got the modern rating inflation boost.

>>280353982
It actually makes sense. MALs top scores are all popular series that have a nice enough quality of writing without being inoffensive in anyway. SNKs final season is basically marvel avengers style writing in a popular war anime. Of course it was gonna be retard highly.

>>280349077 (OP)
GCucks should be like 6 because the visuals kind of compensate the awful writing. Tranimai should be erased from existence.

>>280354017
Without being offensive* in anyway. Like, FMA and Frieren can appeal to casuals and critics, while not doing anything unique or bold enough that may put off viewers.

>>280354017
I thought both were awful but I'm sure there's some kind of mass appeal factor that explains why they're up there.

>>280349077 (OP)
We know, you are mad some randoms like more a random anime than your favorite one, Mal has always been shit but you are an insufferable zoomer

Any gems that are <7 on MAL?

>>280354694
Concrete revolutio

>>280353982
Everything in the MAL top 5 is garbage, I make no distinction between them.

>>280349077 (OP)
Day 1.

>>280354694
Momentary Lily

>>280349077 (OP)
Anything thats above 7.5 is good. 7.00 is just as abysmal as 5.00 and 6.00

And GQuuuuuuX is literally dogshit. It's genuinely a 4.00 show.

>>280354694
I really enjoyed Ore Twintail ni Narimasu.

>>280354694
Teekyuu

>>280349171
It does. Nyaan, Machu and Shuji are dogshit leads

just this week

>>280355032
I'm surprised it is in the 5.00 range. It should be 4.00 at best, probably more deserving. 2.00.

>>280354694
6-7 is where all the good shit is.

>>280349141
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaand, you lost credibility

>>280355110
Teekyuu is the only good anime series MAPPA has made

>>280354694
Basically anything that /a/ recommends.
Works for manga as well if you go by OPTs or any fotm shit manga that gets shilled hard.

>>280355110
I was hoping that, with each season, the rating would substantially improve as the people rating it lower would drop it but no, it's almost entirely 6.5 to 6.7. Craziness.

>>280349433
>>280350184
>>280353982
are you new? Steins;Gate was very popular here in particular when it came out, people were losing their shit over it and it had a chuck norris effect, if anything it's top rated because of /a/

>>280355111
Machu was a fun retard to follow.>>280354045

I'm a massive gundamfag but I wouldn't put GQuuuuuux in the realm of very good. I don't know what the other anime is but 7 is fair for GQuuuuuux, even if I have it as a 6. I had it at 4 after the final episode but I walked back some of my hate.

>>280355134
Add a -1 to all shoujo manga adaptations. For some odd reason they're always inflated.

>>280355586
Normalfags perceive shoujo as more mature and realistic shonen.

>>280349290
I adore 079. I'd give Quacks a 7.5 to 8. Fun what-if scenario that bit off a bit more than it could chew for the runtime.

>>280349077 (OP)
Both those anime are shit.

>>280349077 (OP)
Being a manchild is believing that no other opinion than your own matters and you should trust your own biased opinion, or at the very least of a group aligned with your tastes
Growing up and being an adult is to realize that every opinion matters, and while you have the last word on what to believe on your own, there's no damage in hearing both foreign opinions, both agreeing and disagreeing, as even the negative analysis might hold some truth or aspect you didn't consider before because you were either closed into your own head or hugbox community

>>280355801
No, that's the midwit perspective. Idiots and wise geniuses disregard all other opinions.

>>280355568
Frankly, my rating of it keeps going down the more I think about it.

For instance, there is no reason for the Red Gundam to exist but the RX-78-2 to not despite in the end establishing that they are two completely different Gundams. It's not even a stylistic choice. It's just that, for whatever reason, this particular Lalah dream has Eva suits in it instead of the White Devil, completely inconsistent with her other RTA dream runs.

Obviously you could say that it was all to sell a new plastic toy, but apparently that isn't going all that well either. The Gyan has to take up the slack for the main suits lackluster receptions.

>>280355801
you haven't read a negative review of an anime you really like on MAL and it shows

>>280349077 (OP)
Gigguk

>>280355801
Literally the opposite.

>>280355841
>completely inconsistent with her other RTA dream runs.
Anon one timeline had a Sazabi redesign done by the Eva mecha designer.

Only a retard pays attention to anime reviews.

>>280356117
.t watches anitubers.

>>280356169
anitubers and MAL are the same thing.

>>280356117
only a retard pays attention to ANYTHING.
close your eyes, plug your ears.
you already know all there is to know in this world

>>280356169
?

I have never touched a MAL review or an ANN review or some fucking retarded e-celeb.
The only opinion tbat matters is your own and /a/'s.

>>280355929
Even with the meme value of including a suit that shouldn't technically exist for several years, the Sazabi is still a suit that exists in their world.

The Red Gundam, along with the GQuX and GFreD, are something completely new. It would make more sense pulling the F91, Crossbone or Victory 2 than any of those using the same logic. Char would still job in all of these regardless.

>>280356324
Give him a Turn A and he'd have won.

>>280356324
The Gquuux and Gfred weren't created as part of lalah's attempt to save Char. They are a by product of him surviving and going on to create a completely different history. That's how Machu was able to stop the whole cycle in the end.

>>280355586
yuri stuff is also inflated.

>>280349077 (OP)
Scores and ratings are a good way to see how popular a work is in a certain group but they are no replacement for your own opinion of things.

>>280356352
Char seems like a Turn X sort of guy. But he'd still find a way to lose to Amuro in the Grandpa.
>>280356500
Still doesn't solve why the Red Gundam exists in the first place. It shouldn't by the internal logic of the show.

>>280356593
Making my own opinion involves sitting down, watching the entire thing, reflecting on it, taking a nap, and reflecting on it again. It takes time and a lot of effort.

>>280355841
>Obviously you could say that it was all to sell a new plastic toy, but apparently that isn't going all that well either.
iirc Quuux and red Gundam have sold just fine. Gyaan’s the newest one and it’s one of the best redesigns in the show. Imo the Kikeroga was the star mobile suit(armor) of the show but the more unconventional and bigger designs tend to have to wait longer for kits.

>>280349171
youre right, its a 5 at best

>>280355111
Machu is extremely memorable to me.

>>280356838
I need Machu in the next SRW so she and Kamille’s autism combined can warp time and space.

>>280354045
Hey, Frieren was good. It wasn't the best anime of all time but it was still a 7/10 or 8/10

>>280349077 (OP)
Onimai is the better anime though.

>>280354694
School Days kek

>>280355499
I can't believe you're still posting here. It's been what, at least 16 years?

>>280356169
>>280355879
I was watching anime for over a decade before I even realized there were popular anitubers and that people watched them or took their opinions seriously.
Even MAL it took me 7+ years, annd I’ve been watching since 2009. I used to just find new anime through forums or the front page of whatever anime site I was using. All respect to giggluk though, I haven’t watched any of his videos but if his anime is good I might.

>>280349171
A 7 is a perfectly high score.

>>280350748
Where was all that cope that Japan loved it coming from???

>>280357619
The reason modern reviews are fucked is because of fucking burgers and their school grading system making below 65 failure. So now a 6.5 is the new 5

>>280357638
>cope
theres your answer anon, delusion from kharafags

>>280349077 (OP)
Japan hated Gcucks.

>>280349077 (OP)
It can be a good indicator but
it can be flawed for many reasons and your taste in anime will always have a degree of subjectivity so don't rely entirely MAL ratings to select what you're going to watch.

>>280354694
Oreimo.

>>280355111
I will not stand for Machu slander. She single-handedly made the mess that is GQuuuuuuX fun to watch.

>>280349171
the writing is shit and has nothing to do with the length
OH WOW GIANT GUNDAM BECAUSE ITS DREAM WORLD BUT REAL SUPER ROBOT WAR AIEEEEE

>>280357638
They saw 1 tweet with like a thousand likes being positive about it

>>280354694
Oreimo, School Days, Mayoiga, Masamune Kun no revenge, Kiss X Six

>>280354694
uchuujin muumuu

>>280355586
It's not just that. The manga is also highest rated in most english site.

>>280355586
People who normally don't like shoujo don't even try to start it while target audience loves it? Similar to all these inflated S2-3 rankings.

>>280360398
>S1 has a 7.0 with 100k ratings
>S2 has a 8.0 with with 25k ratings
>S2 is pretty dogshit

>>280357686
If you produced something that is just average, it is a failure. Why would you watch something that isn't at least good? Even ignoring normalfags, scoring basis they use, whether they watched the show to begin with and so on.

>>280350748
>not 0 star
still too high

>>280351359
>Bocchi vs CSM round 2
kino

>>280356749
Then you will be misinformed for your entire life.

Remember when MAL threads used to be banned on sight?
What happened to this site?

>>280360959
The influx of shonenshitters from twitter and their never ending console wars, of which MAL scores is one of their retarded metrics.

>>280357619
I hate this effect, don't know if it has a name but it goes like this
>too much choice makes everything under a certain rating automatically ignored as you don't have time and resources to give a fuck
>during the years, people who got the aforementioned habit start to rate even average shit above 7, as their taste is still average but their scores aren't
Over competitiveness generates cope at some point, as it's impossible to always go higher

>>280349077 (OP)
before I ever heard of it.
when people said MAL alot on /a/ I was increadibly confused. I couldn't after believe anyone paid attention to sites like this

>>280349077 (OP)
probably around 2014 or something like that

>MAL thread
How does /a/ do it?

>>280354694
Milky Holmes

>>280359449
>>280359957
>Oreimo
what the fuck. has it always been under a 7 there?
this doesn't seem right. i though it was rather popular for its time.
MAL is truly a shithole

>>280354694
Zettai Shounen

>>280349141
1/10

>>280349077 (OP)
When people asked me for my "mal" in the 2000s

>>280361443
five to four years ago it was around 7.3

Oreimo filters hard

>>280349171
Watch a lot more anime and lurk for 2 years.

>>280352361
I'm not going to spend time figuring out what arbitrary number to assign to some piece of media I didn't enjoy because the morons running MAL are too retarded to give me a like/dislike option. A number's not useful to me if it isn't followed by a text review noting how points are docked off. Completely meaningless without context.

>>280354694
kokoro toshokan for comfy

>>280363150
was for >>280354694

>>280357179
That’s not the real one, trip isn’t even the same
PT died in 2023

>>280363150
Those are some shitty anime, the tenshi one was complete ass.
>I like him because he's nice
>I like her because she's nice
Oh fucking die.

>>280359957
>Mayoiga, Masamune Kun no revenge

>>280354694
Busou Shoujo Machiavellianism
Colour Wars
Magikano

>>280355167
This man speaks truth, the majority of good shows are rated 6.X on that site.

>>280363465
Hence the 3 rating.
Boggles the mind how popular that series is, the LNs are some of the highest selling of all time.

>>280349077 (OP)
From the beginning. I have no clue why anyone gives that site any credibility.

>>280363548
Why do you keep bumping this thread over and over, are you retarded

>>280349077 (OP)
It doesn't matter because most of you faggots use 7-10 scaling instead of 1-10 even though MAL HAS FUCKING DESCRIPTION FOR EACH RATING NUMBER

>>280363616
Does sage not work anymore?

>>280363670
It's extremely obvious it's one schizo, but then again I guess that's just what /a/ is now, a soap box for samefagging schizos

>>280363503
It's one of the anime that makes me think 90% of people have brain worms that communicate with each other and are trying to homogenize society.

The shows I can see that I like and few else do are Henzemi, Victory Gundam, Zambot 3, Twin tails ni Narimasu, and YamiBou
I completely agree with that popular anime that suck list. I'd add Gintama and Bakemonogatari.

>>280363465
You better not be calling Moetan shit.

>>280361443
It was close to 8 in the early 2010's according to the wayback machine. The rating has been consistently going down for more than a decade.

>>280363873
No, I'm saying the series he selected as bad are such as re:zero and tenshi
I thought moetan was good but it's been many years since I've seen it.

>>280363406
>trip isn’t even the same
That's because the encryption for secure tripcodes has been reshuffled by mods after the hack.

>>280355510
Not new, and I don't care. Steins;Gate was slop long before that word even became a thing.

>>280361443
It's a bad adaptation of a light novel which also ended badly... why exactly would it be rated highly

>>280355510
The anime was ass. The VN was pretty decent but I preferred the Chaos;* series.

>>280349077 (OP)
Here's a better question. Who has worse taste nowadays, mal or /a/? Honestly my vote goes towards /a/.

>>280349077 (OP)
They never mattered. Just useful as a list. That doesn't mean gcucks is good though

>>280355841
>there is no reason for the Red Gundam to exist but the RX-78-2 to not despite in the end establishing that they are two completely different Gundams
I don't think the show tries to establish them as totally different Gundams. The Red Gundam is still the RX-78-2 of that universe, it just has a different appearance. So it's less that it's inconsistent, and more that the change in appearance or design philosophy in this case is just never addressed.

>>280364171
Without question /a/ is worse. This place is borderline unusable now.

>>280349171
Your right. It deserves less

>>280364171
Definitely /a/, psycho mods made it their personal playground

>>280364022
And?

>>280364171
/a/ is for shitposting, not anime discussion. Myspace would be a better source of information than this place. Look at the latest seasonal threads, it's atrocious.

>>280352041
Yeah its retarded. How do you know it will stay the same quality?

>>280364171
/a/ is filled with contrarians who rates shit like boruto and kaokari, while calling the likes of punpun and ergo proxy overrated.

>>280351359
>s/u/icide victims hate the codester
unsursprising

>>280356117
True. A true /a/non has watched 100s or 1000s of anime and know far better than random casuals. Why would I listen to some retard who has watched 10 anime series when I've watched 1000?

>>280364171
/a/

>>280364171
Both physically and mentally, the average user (30+ yo) of this shit board is just this

>>280364171
even back in the olden days MAL had many well-written reviews. /a/ is for shitposting.

>>280349077 (OP)
MAL scores have always been retarded, I thought everyone knew that

>>280364171
This place is a shithole now

>>280349154
This, I don't know why people are carrying water for it. Pure wasted potential.

>>280356596
Red Gundam should have just been a Char painted Grandpa. It would have sold like hotcakes, especially if they gave it a different backpack to mount the bits and the bits.

>>280349077 (OP)
>When did you realize MAL scores and the sites opinion on anime as a whole doesn't matter?
Literally the first time I looked at the top ranking list. People who unironically rate Attack on Titan and Steins;Gate that high are brain damaged.

>>280349077 (OP)
While /a/ has historically shunned MAL as some kind of anime facebook/reddit it really is a useful site for looking up information like airing dates, staff, studio, seiyuu, etc.
I don't know why you would interact with the community or anything like that though. I simply track my stuff and if I like something I can easily check out what other stuff someone worked on. Or if a character voice sounds familiar I can look up what else they did. Anidb is honestly more accurate for some things but the site is a pain to navigate. I'm sure there are other websites that fulfil the same function, I don't really care. Just don't bother with any of the subhumans there.

>>280349077 (OP)
Whent his thoroughly mediocre anime was hailed as the single greatest anime of all time. Ever since, every single fotm has had to be hyped up of as the GOAT, it's fucking unbearable.

>>280349077 (OP)
around 8 years ago, thats why i always recommend for anyone to give anything a try unless i really hated like cyberpunk anime dogshit or terminator one

>>280364498
>Majimafag is a KWABdy Rhodes faggot
No wonder he's a faggot

>>280364430
The end.

>>280349077 (OP)
I thought the did fire you, king.

>>280363465
>>280363503
>>280363785
is really well written, that is the reason people like it specially now that the light Novels are in the actual couple, moments

>>280349171
The show has interesting ideas and premises but the creators seem more focused on cramming as many easter eggs for diehard UC-fags instead of telling their own story. Also there is a dire lack of actual mecha fights.

>>280366118
You could have started with “I don’t know shit”‘ instead of wasting time

>>280354694
Chimimo was very charming

>>280366731
There's no point. You're either too lazy or fearful to make a mistake to point out what I supposedly don't know.

>>280366858
>>280366975
>reverse image search
Bruh this is literally a template from reddit, why is this board so shit now

>>280367034
Dumbass.

>>280367161
Why do every single one of these samefag schizo threads just wind up being so malicious redditor trying to sock puppet a retarded agenda

Yeah, Onimai should be lower.
Never seen Gcucks, so I can't tell how bad it is, but my intuition tells me it ain't good.

>>280367034
You are a total fucking retard. I don't even use MAL and I could tell from context clues that this is something MAL gives.

>>280353950
Won at the suicide game.

>>280367349
I have no idea what you're talking about, as I'm not a zoomer. You should endeavor to stop posting and lurk for 10 years so there's room for people to make better threads.

>>280367524
MAL threads are trash. You won't find me arguing against that. But you're just playing dumb and trying to deflect to a different topic now because you realized how stupid you were.

>>280364171
I don't know about taste but I still occasionally find well written reviews on MAL but almost never comparable comments on /a/. But there's little reason to put in effort here with how the board is. There was even a half-assed best loli contest ran by MAL users, something mods won't allow here. It's pretty surreal

>>280355510
Steins;Gate is top rated because of the ironic weeb crowd. Personally I think it's a flawed work at best and loses a lot of charm if you aren't the kind of person who instinctively claps at a guy yelling EL PSY CONGROO out of nowhere.

>>280367630
>But you're just playing dumb
No I literally have no idea what you're talking about. I do not use mal. MAL forums are infamously bad. I use manga sites, old forums, and discord. anilist is entertaining but difficult to navigate and dead. Aggregators are not useful to me because I already have an extremely robust data feed.

>>280367658
4chan has become so shit half because people are afraid of their effortposts being stolen and reused elsewhere and half because retards want to put as little effort into their posts as possible for maximum return. Same shit with OC, no one wants to make something anonymously anymore because why would you when you can slap a name or social media handle on it and get a payoff, if you’re not already doing shit like Patreon or other money grubbing methods.

I could genuinely not imagine anything more disgusting than someone rating anime. The saddest fucking thing you could mention to me is that you gave an anime a "review", or that you "ranked" anime.
Why would you care about what a bunch of people who watch anime on a second monitor and barely pay attention to a show while trying to shove in as much as humanly possible say about things?

Its like someone unironically rating and taking seriously professional wrestling matches. You can just say its shit or that you didn't like it and clearly state your reasons. People will understand.

>>280368287
Pseuds.

>>280367917
>I do not use mal
Neither do I but unlike you I'm not a total moron so I could still figure out what was going on
>and discord
lmao

>>280368263
>Same shit with OC
All the OC here has gotten super forced and boring, I don't want to participate in it because it feels like the people here are actively trying to make me miserable. All the generals and dailies ruined the culture of this place.

>>280368456
>Neither do I
Very big doubt.

>>280349077 (OP)
/a/ opinion doesnt matter either
you just have to watch what you enjoy

>>280349077 (OP)
since 2007

>>280368575
I literally said I didn't in my original post. But I already figured you have to tell yourself this to make yourself feel better because you can't conceive of someone else having critical thinking skills when you lack them.

>now it's meta shit about muh OC
8shit metashitter is back on it again

>>280363886
The kusonekofags and normies killed it.

Oreimo deserves at least 7.5 the execution is good enough for that.
Imagine DEENgurashi S1 better than Oreimo

>>280368287
even if you don't explicitly rate a show on some arbitrary platform, you must still at least have an idea of how you would evaluate it. some people take the next step and contribute their rating to the respective public database. simple as.
why some choose to shit out a review is beyond my understanding, though.

>>280368947
>you must still at least have an idea of how you would evaluate it
In all honestly, a lot of people simply don't have the knowledge to accurately do so, their opinions are worth less than shit. Any evaluation you could make would just be a justification for your own opinion on things.
The problem with adding ratings or thoughts to a public database is that people's opinions aren't that interesting and they tend to overwrite. Just sum it up in a couple sentences.

>>280368923
DEENgurashi is better than Oreimo

>>280368696
>I literally said I didn't in my original post
If you're posting it and seething about it 24/7 then you obviously go there

>>280369264
>Any evaluation you could make would just be a justification for your own opinion on things.
it's either that or no shared information at all.
and i don't see how that's a problem. if a problem is unsolvable, it's not a problem anymore.
the beauty of it is that it's up to you how to interpret someone else's evaluation.
if you spin it hard enough, a particular person's negative opinion about a piece of media could indicate that it's something you might love.

>>280370341
>If you're posting it
Posting what?
>seething about it 24/7
I never think about MAL until someone makes a shitty MAL thread here like this one. But thanks for the projection revealing how you think. You just confirmed you're a redditor since you're seething about reddit 24/7. What's the next thing you'll come up with to cope because you can't admit that you're wrong?

>>280363150
>>280363986
>>280366858
I love this animeplus addon thingy because it displays perfectly how fucking flawed MAL userbase rating is by telling you "they hated it" with a bunch of 6/10 which, for me, is a pretty good score all things considered.

>>280371725
it's clearly just trying to describe your largest discrepancies from the overall viewership for that anime in a fun snappy way. don't need to put too much stock on the specific wording when they show things with an average score of 7 and the user only rated it 1 above that.

>>280349433
Steins;Gate is the midwit attractor anime, of course it's highly rated by them.

>>280349077 (OP)
>>280353950
I always knew. It's especially obvious when Onimai isn't highly ranked.
To celebrate Onimai being the highest scored of these two anime, I'm going to impregnate Mahiro and watch her push the babies out.

Oreimo was always shit, and I'm glad people are starting to stop pretending otherwise.

>>280355510
You're going to half a dozen more replies from the samefagger. And yes, he is a newfag who wasn't even here when it first aired.

Ratings are for normies who needs other people's opinion to justify watching something

>>280349077 (OP)
When I looked up one of my favorite manga there and it was in the #1000+ range.
Looking at the reviews it was clear that people read the first ~20 chapters then rated.
Tl;dr zoomers will drop your manga if it has a slow start.
Atleast jap rating sites have it in the #100+ range, which is fair.

>>280351359
Man, last season with these three was peak.

>>280354694
Koi Kaze
To Love Ru
Keijo
Kiss X Sis

i think onimai's biggest sin is its so boring.

I watched a single episode of Gcucks and thought the mobile suits looked like shit and never bothered to follow up on it

>>280374399
A bad Gundam series and two seasonal tourism adverts is "peak" now?

>>280376082
I said three, I dont care about gundam.

>>280350736
>Both Lazarus and GQX here in production hell for the same amount of time and wound up having similar problems throughout their runs. I found that a curious observation.
Care to elaborate or provide a source to this information? I always like to read about production hell scenarios.

>>280371386
this nigga is a maltard

>>280357619
I think if anybody were to have a properly even distribution in their list from 1 - 10 that would imply they spend an equal amount of time watching below average anime that they probably don't enjoy as they do above average anime that they do enjoy.

I cannot understand doing this. If your median store isn't in the 7-8 range it means you watch a lot of dogshit you aren't enjoying.

Why would you do this?

>>280364141
The LN series suck ass man, if it wasn't for the anime originals and changes, especially during season 1 it wouldn't have been that popular.

It didn't deserve such execution

>>280376401
>even distribution in their list from 1 - 10 that would imply they spend an equal amount of time watching below average anime
no, I either drop a show (and don't rate it at all) or simply don't start it because I can see a 3/10 from a mile away.
doesn't mean that there are no shows <5 or that a 1-10 distribution is somehow flawed that way.
>If your median store isn't in the 7-8 range it means you watch a lot of dogshit you aren't enjoying.
it's perfectly fine to watch a 5/10 show because it literally means that it's "average", fucking retard.
5.5 and above already implies at least some sort of enjoyment.

>>280349077 (OP)
But anon, I want to know what's the opinion that matters. I need someone to tell me what anime is okay to like! How am it supposed to fit in?

>>280376401
Do you honestly even remember the plot outline and the characters of all the stuff you have scored 8 or 9? Because if you're going to say, I remember enjoying it but can't recall all of it right now, that shit is a 6.

>>280376677
>it's perfectly fine to watch a 5/10 show because it literally means that it's "average"
I never said it wasn't, fucking retard. I'm just saying if your median score isn't around at least a 7 then you are wasting your time, more than other who spend their time watching anime by watching average or below average crap.

>>280376713
>Do you honestly even remember the plot outline and the characters of all the stuff you have scored 8 or 9?
Yes, which is why I gave it such a high score. Don't project your poor memory onto me.

>>280376768
Not that anon, but you are literally implying that one needs to do some "research" before watching an anime.
Otherwise how the hell would you end up on a 7 median?

>>280376846
Easy to do when your list is <500 and you don't have anime you watched 2 decades ago.

>>280355510
S;G is only loved because retards can't get enough of time travel and think it's the most mind blowing thing ever. The pacing is plodding and the characters are average to bad.

>>280376768
a show can be objectively a 5 but resonate with you in a special way, or every aspect of it could be shitty except the one that is the most important for you (say, character writing), which would elevate your enjoyment of an otherwise mediocre experience.
how do you even know if what you're watching is 7+ if you don't even have a point of reference?
you honestly sound like a tourist with sub-100 titles

>>280349077 (OP)
quacks was a total shitshow though. It started out great and I fully stand by that fact, until it became a full first gundam jerk off parade beyond just paying good homage to it

>>280376911
There isn't more than 300 anime worth remembering anyway.
Gotta watch at least three times to grave it long in any case

>>280349077 (OP)
2007

>>280354694
ENTER

>>280377067
fr fr no cap on god. Chibineko Tom, Marco Polo no Bouken and Kasei Yakyoku are one of these. I love signaling my taste on twitter, mal and anilist!!!!
OLD GOOD NEW BAD!!!

>>280355134
>>280355586
>>280355633
>>280360398
Kaoru Hana is a shounen, not a shoujo.

>>280377013
>objectively a 5
That isn't real. A 7 is a 7. I don't care if 99.9% of everyone else rates it 5, quality isn't determined by popular vote.

>>280377359
>quality isn't determined by popular vote.
isn't what i said. quite the opposite of what i said.
>a 5 isn't real.
what a retarded individual

>>280377504
You implied it by saying "objectively". There are no "objective rating" in art. You're an ESL cunt who doesn't understand what words mean.

>>280377305
heh I had to look up its score when I read the previous post but was too lazy to recommend it. the threads were great too, maybe I'm jaded but it feels as if we get a third of the anime originals we used to a decade ago.

>>280367917
>and discord
Onimai tranny not beating the allegations

>>280377761
watch less anime; your minds a bare wall: art is both objective and subjective. no nuance = no taste.
watch less anime.

>>280376859
>but you are literally implying that one needs to do some "research" before watching an anime
Do you not read a synopsis or watch PVs? Figure out the general reception of the source material if there is one? The studio? The staff? Anything? It doesn't take much to know if an anime is worth your time or not. I already had Ruri no Houseki pinned as something to watch this season before the catalog got flooded with threads about it as an example. I can't imagine just picking shows up on a whim and hoping they will turn out half decent and then finishing them if they aren't. A little bit of window shopping goes a long way.

>>280377761
the starting point is 5/10.
flaws take away and enjoyment bumps the score.
if there's nothing particularly wrong with a show, while simultaneously there being nothing to praise it for, it's an "objective" 5.
you are a retard who doesn't know how to interface with art.
what i said in my previous reply meant that if a show is an honest 5 but you enjoyed it (maybe the mood was right), then, depending on how honest you want to be with your score, you could give it a 5 or more. saying that in this situation it meant that you watched a 7 is dishonest.
i never implied that someone else's opinion plays role in the evaluation.

also
>"There are no "objective rating" in art"
>You're an ESL
watch your step

>>280376911
>>280377013
Well over 600 now. And I occasionally rewatch some stuff here and there to see if I still like it as much as I did when I started really getting into anime 15 years ago.

>>280367917
>discord
Go back

>>280376768
> if your median score isn't around at least a 7 then you are wasting your time
nothing wrong with watching average shows anon. I don't want to watch "really good/great" shows all the time, sometimes I want to watch some absolute trash and enjoy it.

>mal
im an anidb chad user

>>280363150
redo healer is TOP KINO

>>280378342
But if you enjoy it, why would you not give it a good rating?

>>280349077 (OP)
I always knew that because everything on the top anime list is shit. Frieren? Shit. FMA? Shit. Steins;Gate? Shit.
You don't get anything good until LotGH which I don't think is even in the top 10 anymore, and maybe HxH or Gintama depending on how you're feeling. And even then Gintama being on the list like 5 times is completely ridiculous.

>>280378484
If I'm going to rate every show that didn't make me want to kill myself while watching it a 10/10, then there's no point in scoring in the first place.

>>280378042
The only objective parts of art are what actually exists in reality. Quality and enjoyment are subjective. This is not up for debate.

>>280349077 (OP)
When was MAL founded? Before that.

>>280378683
I didn't say you should give anything you like a 10 out of 10. I'm just saying that if you enjoy something should it not get a good rating? If 5 is pure indifference then would enjoyment not be at least a 6 or 7?

>>280349077 (OP)
>there a are people wgp unironically use MAL
Kid, we've been throwing hate at every MAL-like site since the dawn of time, is this your first week here?

>>280378811
The anon you were replying to has already explained his point.
If you enjoy a show for "wrong reasons", then how is it sensible to rate it highly? It ends up being misleading.

>>280378905
>If you enjoy a show for "wrong reasons", then how is it sensible to rate it highly?
What does that even mean? If you enjoy something then it set out what it was meant to do as a peice of entertainment.

>>280378982
If the story or character intercations are so stupid it makes you laugh, i.e. "provides entertainment", does that mean that either aspect is well executed and deserves to be rated highly?
I mean, if you attach a sidenote to your every score explaining how it should be interpreted, then it's fine. But, realistically, it's a retarded approach.

>>280379185
Then you aren't enjoying it for what it is, you are rationalizing how bad or stupid it is and finding comedy in that rationalization. That an easy distinction to make. I've watched a handful of notorious dumpster fires like Garzey's Wing and Twinkle Nora Rock Me. They are garbage deserving of the lowest score possible. Did I laugh at the Garzey's Wing dub specifically? Sure. But it's still trash.

>>280378874
>we've been throwing hate at every MAL-like site since the dawn of time

You used to post links of your MAL account in dedicated MAL threads. The archives don't lie.

>>280379569
>Then you aren't enjoying it for what it is
No shit? That's what I said >>280378905
What is your point? It wasn't me who asked "What does that even mean?"

>>280352361
This is especially true for new-ish (within the last few years) shows. Now that anime has somewhat become mainstream and a handful of them have entered the cultural zeitgeist, there are droves of npcs who overrate new anime because it's the first ones they've seen

>>280379774
I wanted you to clarify what you meant by "enjoying something for the wrong reason" because I had never heard that before.

>>280364171
/a/ is superior by far. MAL is not even a community, but if it was, you would never see it rate itself badly as everyone here has done.b

>>280380685
I swear that most of those replies are samefagging.

>>280376231
Bamco's Ogata revealed during the last winter press conference that GQuuuuuuX was initially proposed back in 2018:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J9MDjzKXBGk
This was later corroborated by Anno himself in a tweet that also revealed just how involved he was in the production of the show, much more than shitposters here wanted to believe:
https://x.com/khara_inc2/status/1901250325350436967
Apparently it was a mess trying to herd the cats known as Khara together long enough to get anything done. It wasn't until mid-2023 that they finally got Anno's notes together, finished drafting out the plot and script and gave it to Tsurumaki.
GWitch was also proposed at the same time, but got everything done on a shorter timescale.

For Lazarus, it also was proposed back in 2018 by Watanabe, before he had finished Carole and Tuesday:
https://cocotame.jp/series/110488/
Unfortunately, Nobumoto, the screenwriter who made sure Watanabe's works were actually watchable, had gotten cancer and died in 2021:
https://x.com/S_Kabut_/status/1909219486651105364
They thought with Nobumoto's illness and death that it would have been the end of Lazarus, but true to name it revived and kept going as a tribute to her. Unfortunately with her no longer there to keep it together, we got what we did.
Interestingly enough, it was inspired by the opioid crisis in the US rather than the koof, but it just took so long that the latter happened and it's what everyone thinks about first.

Gcucks sucks, it should be a 0

Has anyone here ever found a show with a low score, watched the whole thing, and thought it was good unironically? (And no, it doesn't count if it's related to something you watched as a kid or you watched it in the background)

Despite that MAL ratings are flawed, generally anything under mid-to-high 6 is actually unwatchable.

>>280381091
Hey, thanks for following up.

So Khara really is just a total mess. I have heard rumors of this before so it's not really any sort of surprise.

>For Lazarus, it also was proposed back in 2018 by Watanabe, before he had finished Carole and Tuesday
>Unfortunately, Nobumoto, the screenwriter who made sure Watanabe's works were actually watchable, had gotten cancer and died in 2021
This is kind of surprising to me because I found Carol and Tuesday to be garbage but I guess there was only so much this woman could do to service the beginnings of Watanabe's burgerland current events obsession. I had no idea he had a tard-wrangler along side him for his whole career.

>>280381908
>Despite that MAL ratings are flawed, generally anything under mid-to-high 6 is actually unwatchable.
Maybe if you don't like anime

>>280381091
so gwitch came out faster, longer and less of a mess
this is objective proof that Sunrise > Khara

>>280364171
MAL by far, /a/ is completely degraded by tourists whose brains are rotted by western culture war bullshit. The Gqux threads themselves were a perfect demonstration of how worthless the majority of posters are now. They watch anime ironically despite hating it because it’s nerd adjacent media and come to /a/ only to bitch about the things that trigger them. Just look at all the retards who started comparing it to Star Wars and Marvel as if it’s a given their hate bandwagon matters to otaku.

>>280349136
my opinion matters

>>280349077 (OP)
When almost every single anime was getting a 7/10 rating.

MAL is 90% bots

>>280349077 (OP)
>check out the episode discussions
>it's nothing but AI generated synopsis of the episode

>>280385243
share some of your opinions

>>280349077 (OP)
>OP only just realized this
You’re either a teenager or you have severe mental deficiency.

>>280355801
>being 15: others are stupid and my opinion is the right one
>being 20: maybe others are right and my opinions are wrong, I should adapt
>being 30: people are retarded, I was right to not care about their opinions
>being 50: everyone who disagrees with me should be in jail or shot

>>280366650
>the creators seem more focused on cramming as many easter eggs for diehard UC-fags
yeah thats why i liked it

>>280385846
in my experience it was
>being 15: others are stupid and my opinion is the right one
>being 16: maybe others are right and my opinions are wrong, I should adapt
>being 18: people are retarded, I was right to not care about their opinions
>being 35: everyone who disagrees with me should be in jail or shot

>>280385995
Wonder how it will look for gen alpha, they will probably speedrun it.

>>280385995
>>280385846
>being 15: others are stupid and my opinion is the right one
>being 16: maybe others are right and my opinions are wrong, I should adapt
>being 22: people are retarded, I was right to not care about their opinions
>being 25: everyone who disagrees with me should be in jail or shot

>>280349077 (OP)
>guuuuux
Retarded ass name. Studio Bind takes the win here.

>>280386218
That depends on how much time they precieve they have to waste on other people's opinions. It's good to be wstablished in doing your own thing, but pigheadedness and refusing to learn anything new is pretty bad

>>280364276
I miss sakura fish and r/a/dio

>>280349077 (OP)
Gquacks deserves to be way lower.

Any site with an average the numerical score doesn't matter at all. Most people vote by what they think the average should be. If it's too high they vote 0. If it's too low it's a 10. YouTube figured that out ages ago when they removed star ratings.

>>280388797
it still averages out thoughbeit

>>280380685
>by far
Samefag

>>280382146
Its true though. Anything below 5 is just trash that somehow exists, you can only ever like those shows if youre heavily biased to it. Average shows are at 6-7, even the isekai slops.