I wish Toby continues to follow the glitchy creepypasta tone of the Weird Route with Noelle, where we walk out out bounds and encounter some weird creepy shit, like unused rooms and actual corruptions

>reposted to share opinions
To be honest, REDACTED is more Gaster than Gaster himself and I actually wished Mystery Man never existed. What makes Gaster "Gaster" is that he is a unfinished forgotten character that was never meant to exist. REDACTED looks like an actual glitch room you could find in a videogame by accident.
Gaster being able to talk and making up a videogame (project theory almost confirmed) where he specifically wrote furry gay fanservice kind of ruined his whole creepypasta atmosphere. This is like giving Herobrine a backstory and making him talk. It doesn't resemble the original character anymore.
Even so, Toby could have written Gaster similar to The Princess in IfYouSeeHeTurnOffTheGame. Gaster could have been a strange Slenderman that could appear ANYTIME when the screen transition to another room plays. The fun VALUE in Undertale was part of the same deal, you don't feel "safe" in the game, it's like you would encounter some shit like Farlands in any moment in old Minecraft.
That concept could also expand his "incomplete character" status even further, where he would try to reconstruct himself and make some kind of giygas monster for a final boss.
I can't pretend I'm not disappointed with canon Gaster. Windings don't even show up anymore.

To be honest, REDACTED is more Gaster than Gaster himself and I actually wished Mystery Man never existed. What makes Gaster "Gaster" is that he is a unfinished forgotten character that was never meant to exist. REDACTED looks like an actual glitch room you could find in a videogame by accident.
Gaster being able to talk and making up a videogame where he specifically wrote furry gay fanservice kind of ruined his whole creepypasta atmosphere. This is like giving Herobrine a backstory and making him talk. It doesn't resemble the original character anymore.
Even so, Toby could have written Gaster similar to The Princess in IfYouSeeHeTurnOffTheGame. Gaster could have been a strange Slenderman that could appear ANYTIME when the screen transition to another room plays. The fun VALUE in Undertale was part of the same deal, you don't feel "safe" in the game, it's like you would encounter some shit like Farlands in any moment in old Minecraft.
That concept could also expand his "incomplete character" status even further, where he would try to reconstruct himself and make some kind of giygas monster for a final boss.
I can't pretend I'm not disappointed with canon Gaster. Windings don't even show up anymore.

To be honest, REDACTED is more Gaster than Gaster himself and I actually wished Mystery Man never existed. What makes Gaster "Gaster" is that he is a unfinished forgotten character that was never meant to exist. REDACTED looks like an actual glitch room you could find in a videogame by accident.
Gaster being able to talk and making up a videogame where he specifically wrote furry gay fanservice kind of ruined his whole creepypasta atmosphere. This is like giving Herobrine a backstory and making him talk. It doesn't resemble the original character anymore.
Even so, Toby could have written Gaster similar to The Princess in IfYouSeeHeTurnOffTheGame. Gaster could have been a strange Slenderman that could appear ANYTIME when the screen transition to another room plays. The fun VALUE in Undertale was part of the same deal, you don't feel "safe" in the game, it's like you would encounter some shit like Farlands in any moment in old Minecraft.
That concept could also expand his "incomplete character" status even further, where he would try to reconstruct himself and make some kind of giygas monster for a final boss.
I can't pretend I'm not disappointed with canon Gaster. Windings don't even show up anymore.