Who is the Roaring Knight and why ISN'T it Dess?

>>715326998
>Asriel being home from college a week early would not cause The Roaring.
If that's what you're talking about then I don't see why that couldn't simply be the case. It's pretty irrelevant whether Asriel stayed in Hometown or came back in secret a week ago. And there are a litany of reasons he might want to keep it a secret, for the sake of his family and to avoid exposing himself to the Player and the rest of the Fun Gang.
>there's no sign of Dess in his room, in contrast to Dess's room still having Asriel's things.
If you seriously believe this shows he moved on then you do not understand Asriel's character whatsoever. In what world is Dess being completely scrubbed from Asriel's life a sign of Asriel having moved on? That's the exact opposite of what you would expect, that's someone repressing their feelings or, more likely, trying to hide something.
>Fortunately Toby Fox is a better writer than you
This is true but he is also a better writer than you. I warned you to be civil, this is strike one.

>>528173575

Dess is lost in the dark because of something Kris did, and made Kris promise to find her.
Asriel did something out of grief for Dess that put the world out of balance and generated the shadow crystals.
Carol is assisting Kris in finding Dess. She is coordinating with Kris and a third party to open Dark Fountains to help find Dess. Notably the Knight Crew DOES NOT WANT to start the Roaring, and is very particular about making sure Kris has the Soul on hand in the Dark World to seal the fountains, kill the Titans, and stop the Roaring from happening.
Importantly: THE KNIGHT IS NOT REAL. The entity we see in the Dark World is not a person but an artificial thing being controlled by the third member of the Knight Crew to lure the Heroes through the Dark Worlds. This is the one who speaks in red text on the phone who repeatedly encourages Carol and Kris to not allow Susie to get the code from the guitar. The deer features and bat are a misdirection. Carol's swords are misdirection.

Kris, Ralsei, and Susie ARE the heroes and will fulfill the prophecy.
Kris, Carol, and a third party are exploiting the prophecy to find Dess.
Also, and this is the only part I'm not sure about, all signs point to Asriel himself being the third party.

SCREENCAP THIS AND DON'T FORGET IT, BECAUSE IT IS TRUE