>>715592827
The one thing I'll give you with this controller is the HE sticks (not the triggers so those will eventually wear down and break). However as a reproduction controller it's a complete disappointment:
>face buttons are mechanical rather than membrane, which you might prefer but is totally inaccurate + difficult to repair since parts are now a two-piece set
>no pressure buttons, which sure this doesn't matter on an actual Xbone/SeX, but as a repro you can't use it with Xemu for a totally authentic experience since some games will just straight up not work
>small complaint but the original S controller had a green finish to the black color, this one is straight black and totally misses the subtlety of the original controller's color
All that being said if you're planning on using this as a regular controller it's definitely better than the standard Series controller for the HE sticks, but is it worth sacrificing wireless for HE? Granted that's the sacrifice you'll make with pretty much any third party controller thanks to Microdick's greedy licensing policy.