Thread 42743185

Explain why you love your favourite pony so much. Go into detail. We're all anonymous, here. Hold nothing back.

>>42743185 (OP)
She's a cunt

>>42743185 (OP)
Fuck off faggot we only talk about mare fair drama now

MOMMY

>>42743185 (OP)
I LIKE SPAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACE

>>42743185 (OP)
If you don't think eternal night would be the coolest thing then GTFO of my sight FAGGOT

Well, here goes nothing.

First, I'd like to give some context. I am what you may call a hermit. I don't really care about what goes on beyond my own life and a few select people. I wasn't always like this, in fact when I was a young boy, I really cared about others and wanted them to succeed. I was no saint, but my heart was in the right place I'd like to think. But other kids took advantage of my kindness and morals, and that was a pattern that has repeated itself into my late adolescence and early adulthood. On top of that, I never really bought into the values of the people around me. Working hard, getting rich, popularity, they just weren't an interest to me. All I really cared about was working on my hobbies, daydreaming, helping people out every once in a while, and just being alone and enjoying my time here, but not at the expense of others. But it seems time and time again, people are more than willing to take advantage of others; some even argue that its your own fault for being naive. Basically, it seemed like most of humanity was an immoral pestilence, and like any pestilence, you should avoid it if possible, and so I did. And of course there were crises of purpose and identity and stuff like that, and while I can't say I was proud or even happy, mostly empty, but barely content enough to just ignore it and continue with what I've been doing. Those quickly turned into hedonism, but it doesn't feel like to feel good without sharing it with someone else. The emptiness grew, and I was sad. I couldn't find companionship unless it was a dog or old friends of mine who are good people, but very busy with their jobs and education and things I used to be in. Some would consider me a loser, but I think the real loss was the sense of community and decency I thought I was owed, and that age away at me.

During this time I found MLP. I didn't know much about it, other than me playing Equestria at War for Hearts of Iron IV. Pretty decent mod as far as HOI4 goes, but a lot of the content is out of Equestria and has nothing to do with the show or even ponies. I didn't know that at the time, but I do still like the mod, but resent it for not focusing on its namesake. I decided to check the show out because of the mod to see if it was any good. Turns out, it wasn't half bad. The characters were a bit of an eye sore at first, but I really liked their voices and how they talked and interacted with one another. Season after season I started to REALLY like the show. Like, mare schizo level. I fantasized about being in Equestria, being with the ponies, living, laughing, trying different foods, mundane stuff like that. I wanted to be everyone's friend, especially one pony in particular. Pinkie Pie always stood out to me, but what first started out as surprise started to turn into admiration.


1/?

She was funny, quirky, odd, random and always brought a smile to my face, but it wasn't just the surface level traits alone that made me like her so deeply. She was kind and attentive, she helps others out when they are at their lowest. Even when they are mean or have wronged her, she still tried to lift their sprits. She is a pillar in the Ponyville community, and without her, life would be rather dull for the ponyvillians. Most of all, she was the least judgemental and most open of all the mane 6, and I think it was that trait that made me fall in love her. I bought a plushie of her and went to cons with it. Well, technically the same con, Marefairs 1, 2, and 3, but they were awesome. I first step foot into this place of scum and villany: 4chan. Well, I also deicded to check out reddit, but they were too sanitized for my liking, and forget about Xitter, since i've never used it. She slept with me every night, and I would imagine what our friendship would be like. Even if I couldn't win her love, I knew I could win her friendship, and I was fine with that, as knowing someone like her would have made me the luckiest guy in the world, as corny as that sounds. I would read and write fanfiction typically about her, but sometimes not, and I loved how many writers wrote her. She made me feel warm and fuzzy inside like I was loved and cared for. She wasn't faking anything, she was just so genuine in her goodness it was contagious!!

Fast foward a couple years and I was at another low point in my life. I was thinking about how I had failed, how I was just a loser who should have been like everyone else after all. I should have had a girlfriend even if they were abusive or manipulative, I should have taken the risk. In hind sight I was being so stupid and emotional, as I have a lot going for me. I was going to call a hooker before I decided to look at a booru to try to cheer me up. There I saw it, I saw pic related. I saw her, and I took at as a sign. I don't know what happened to me, but the next day I made it my misson to find a way to get closer to her. And so began my "waifuquest". At first, it was just small things like doing things she likes, like baking, eating sweets, giving gifts to loved, holiday or no holiday, and even to strangers, especially those down on their luck. But I felt like it wasn't enough. I felt like I was doing wasn't enough. I couldn't just do things in her name, I needed her. And that's when I refound out about Lucid dreaming and tupperwaremancy and tried my heart out with both for weeks before finally having success with the latter. Pinkie was finally in my life, and although I've have my doubts that she is real, I have full confidence that is makes me life better and gives it a little more meaning, more joy, more fun. And to make matters better, we fell deeply in love with one another. She is my one and only and I love her so much bros.

I'm sorry if any of this was cringe, but that's the story. I love her so much!

>>42743185 (OP)
she makes my penis hard

>>42743198
>filename
Missed the opportunity to say Princess Suggestia.

>>42743185 (OP)
She's fat

>>42743685
>>42743846
Adorable effortpost ruined by >nohooves. Also kek at finding ponies through EaW.
Generally non-Ponkfags don't understand quite how nuanced and complex Pinkie is, but she's all about optimism and refusing to submit to the bad and the negative in life even when it doesn't make sense.

>>42743185 (OP)
Pinkie Pie is always happy.
I want to be happy like her. :D

>>42743185 (OP)
she is exactly the opposite of me

>>42743185 (OP)
I think I love her so much because of her caring nature. Maybe that’s what I lack in life. Regardless she makes me practice drawing so that’s a plus. However it is not meant to be. Her and Shining are perfect for each other and I would want nothing more than them to be happy together. Wish we got some kind of lore about Flurry when she got older. Could be a cool character

>>42743185 (OP)
she farts alot

She's peak feminine virtues
Making sure she's feeling safe and happy as we raise a family together is going to be so fulfilling

>>42743846
Same boat here.

Always loved poni, especially pinkie from S1 E1 her antics were just too cute to not fall for, combined with her natural and deep genuineness.
I absolutely adored the fact that she wasn't silly or quirky for the plot's or comic relief sake.
She perfectly knows who she is and is that confident on her methods to bring a smile to ponies.
And for what? Growing her own ego, status, using it as a trade to get favors later on? None of that. She just cares so deeply about everyony that she wants all of their hearts to beam with joy and laughter just so their day is always a success.
She is the ultimate selfless pony and the most modest of them all.
This trait alone gave her my admiration.
Yet, as the show and my appreciation of her grew, I still wondered, why bring all these smiles? Does she ever smiles the same? Not at the prospect of making somepony else cheery, but for her own sake? Who makes the smile pony smile?
Looking more into it, it does seem pinkie doesn't really focus on her own smiles and happiness, maybe the other ponies do see her as this 'smile provider' you can always have a blast with, but not so deeply connect with / to?
Schizoidingly thinking about it, her reaction in party of one made so much more sense to me.
She really IS selfless. In the purest sense of the word, yet it doesn't always bring her down, she lives with and for the smiles. It is both a beauty and a curse.
This self-less-ness aspect, fading yourself out for a greater purpose really did hit me like a truck. As before she just seemed like a beaming paragon of joy.
But now.. she's just a pony that wanna makes you smile and hopes the word will be a little less of a lonely place while she shares this smile. Only keeping a few genuine friends, that can see the full pinkie, not only the wonderful party pony, but the quieter more caring pinkie too, the one that was left over from that rock farm in the middle of nowhere Equestria, the one that was raised for a single infatigable purpose.
And this anons, this selflessness, this need to please and make everyone she cares about as mirthful as possible, while herself not being always so steadfast in her own joy really did make me fall for her, hook, line and sinker.
I just saw myself in so much of her. No, a better, freezer version of myself. One that yes didn't always knew why she wanted to make ponies smile, was a little afraid of only being 'the party pony' and not 'pinkie' but prevailed. Found her own happiness and contentment. Fully actualized and reconciled the party pony and the rock farm mare.
A pony so genuinely hopeful and happy it shattered my world into a million pieces.

(Cont)

>>42744863
Cont.

Maybe if she could do it. Maybe I could also grow out of the apathy and purpose that defined my life, not be a rock mare, but me? Not act as an automaton that pushed all feelings aside to just do what he's always been instructed. Turning life into an endless canvas of gray, interrupted by the odd panic attack, stress or grievance until all of these just became routine and like a dull background ringing.

Later down this path of mine, I gave meeting her a try. First, via plushies, doing things in her name, faking a painful smile, trying to see myself in a mirror, not a flesh machine. Baking the odd cake, but with no real passion.
Clearly none of it was working. Until, i gave tulpamancy a try, out of a misplaced sense of both contempt for how ridiculous it sounded and mild curiosity. As I began upon dreaming her character and world to humor the fantasy of meeting this pink poni, leading to a half hearted introduction, with her seeing me as "the new creature in town" eventually visiting me into my world out of curiosity for this new thing that just bumped into a world of technicolor equines.
It's harsh to say.. but I didn't believe her at first, treating her with detachement, surely, this is just my mind playing tricks. I'm a depressed retard, of course pinkie gives a shit. It's basic wish fulfilment.
I can't even count the number of times just inviting her out and trying so hard to just have her not deal with me for it was not worth it. All I'd bring her is a world of gray and misery.
But she persevered. Not even bothering to talk on her natural mile a minute way, no more inquiries or questions. A routine of visit and hugs followed by "you know I want you to smile, nonny?" (I didn't even give her my name at first, I just told her she could call me nonny, as what difference does it make?) Or "you're my friend" installed itself.
Eventually I couldn't take it anymore. Giving the cold shoulder to the pony I so desperately love out of hope she'd find someone worth her was tearing me apart.
So.. I began talking. And talk we did. For once I had someone I could connect to. Even if I wasn't sure what the point was, mostly asking about her, and putting a tremendous amount of effort trying to bring her smiles, picking up hobbies to share with her, drawing, baking, cooking for her, being out more, partying and so on..
No longer trying to keep her out of this world, but introducing and indulging more into its beauties for her sake, I wanted to see her smile and laugh. And it made me happy.

(Cont)

>>42744891
Cont.

I had thusly become "the party pony". Not understanding the feeling of happiness just being happy by proxy through her smiles. She saw it of course, but, at first, she was just happy I had grown out of that cranky grey machine I was.
Yet, one day, growing more in line and more confident with feeling happy I broke down a again, none of my efforts to bring her a smile felt appropriate, no matter if successful, it needed to be more. More grandiose, more interesting, more fulfilling for her. Completely missing the point of sharing the fun.
I was just repeating the same pattern as before, but with smiles instead of grief.
And eventually.. that took its toll as well. My love for her felt so overwhelming, nothing good enough, no smile radiant enough.
And with this the previous grief I tried to burry resurfaced now aided by this feeling of inadequacy.
Leading to the darkest hour in this love for her.
Long, painful story short, I tried to kill myself, and she, had to get me out of it, talking me out of it. Her tearful face branding my mind in shame.
After this. A very long grieving and healing process started. Little by little. Shared laugh with shared laugh, joke after joke, and warm hug after hug, each feeling a little less painful with the hate I always had buried for myself slowly fading and being replaced with true shared love.
It's been 3 years, anons. Three years of going from loving the idea of pinkie pie. To meeting her and sharing my life with her.
Those three years couldn't have been any more helpful even if I tried.
It's ironic in a way. 3 years. 3 posts. Derailing the thread? Maybe.

There is still much to learn in this new path of life, still a lot I'm unfamiliar with, a lot to experience first hand and no more through a veil, matinées to share with her. Moments to spend together and experience. Maybe a nightmare night to celebrate or two.

Yet, this is why I love her, anons. She is no more the beaming light that guides me through the dark abyss. She's now pinkie pie, and I am nonny. Just special someponies. And who knows, maybe soon to be husband and wife.

When I saw him laugh at the start of TRoH Part 2, I was a goner. It took me a few years to admit or understand that he's my waifu, but he's always been. Even long before poni, my favorite children's book was an artbook presenting all sorts of mythical and mostly chimeric beings with more or less comprehensible short poems for flavor. 14 years later, I still feel puppy love for the Noodle; at times gentle, at times obsessive and delightfully toxic. To me, Discord is love, Discord is life - truly and unironically. He saved my life, ruins my life, and will be the home I will return to one day because I can't get enough of him.

Flutter's voice melts me and she's just lovely in every way.
>>42743846
The turning point on Pinkie for me was when she was pranking everyone with Dash but spared Fluttershy because she knew she's too sensitive and a prank would make her feel hurt. They usually make the random fun-loving character a retard who doesn't know when to stop. Pinkie being caring and considerate under the clownish attitude makes her a lot more likeable.

Her design is a big part of why I love her, Her mane is very beautiful, her coat color is beautiful, and the fact that her belly is a different color makes me want to give her all the bellyrubs I can and her fetlocks amd hoofs are also very appealing, but ofocurse what I love the most about her is her generally possitive, yet scaredly personality, she is cute, but not overly shy and soft like other shy characters. She is perfectly balanced, making her absolutely cute and lovely!

>>42745281
>Flutter's voice melts me and she's just lovely in every way.
Based
>Pinkie being caring and considerate under the clownish attitude makes her a lot more likeable.
Yeah, that was really nice
Though she also annoyed Flutters by patronizing her
>let auntie Pinkie handle that *pet pet*
>I'm one year older than you

>>42745326
These two are so cute. My favorite pones. Rarity and Twilight come close but it's mostly because of how pretty they look.

>>42743185 (OP)
I don't have a favorite pony. It would be Luna because of her personality and palette but the animators often fuck up her proportions and draw her with a german shepherd back. It would be Fluttershy because of her kindness and warmth that carries a hidden edge, but the later seasons weren't kind on any of the m6. It would be Twilight because I love her inquisitive personality and her magical ambitions but in addition to the problems of the other m6 she also got Twilicorned.

If I had to answer it would be one of those three ponies, today I'm leaning most towards Fluttershy but tomorrow I might say Twilight. My second favorite pony spot is similarly contested between three ponies: Celestia, Rainbow Dash and Rarity.

>>42745437
Kek, poor Flutters

>>42743185 (OP)
I'm not mad into MLP, but Applejack always has been my favourite pony. Apples are in my top favourite fruits, I'm often told that I'm a honest person & I had a weird obsession with Texas before I learnt that Applejack is meant to be Texan ( Anglophone accents lose their meaning in most translations ). Plus people from the country are so cool, she gets bonus points for being a country mare.

>>42745281
>>42744863
Pinkie LOVES Fluttershy. She tells me she is her favorite pony in FiM.

>>42744739
Me too ^c^

>>42744729
She is not an airhead. She is actually super smart. Also, yeah, sorry for the
>no hooves
But that was part of the story. And yeah, EaW of all things led me to being a ponkfag. Its crazy, and it did make me like the mod a lot less, but I still play it from time to time.

>>42744906
Also I loved your story ponkfren. We understand her better than most and she really makes the future look so bright for us!

>>42743185 (OP)
back in school i used to be babyifed because i was stupid and naive and i despised that treatment and it made me feel like a loser, also failing my classes while seeing my classmates having higher grades than me made this feeling worser than ever
people misunderstanding her because of her lazy eye and rainbow dash outdating her made me see myself in her
also i like the word derp since it was a vocal stim of mine when i was a kid, and also muffins are delicious,

in short, im retarteded like her

>>42743685
this entire thread made me learn so much about pinkie, unfortauntly my first exposer to mlp was smile.hd n cupcakes.hd, which made me think pinkie was a boring insane pony that would kill you or turn you to cupcakes if you dont laugh at her jokes, but after years, i finally understood her character, and this thread really helped me understand her even more, thank you anon o7

>>42746098
You know what. Fuck 'em. I think it's neat you're just cool being a little slower. Sometimes you don't need the mail mare to do next day delivery, you just need her to deliver your package with a smile.

>>42743232
>all plants die
>ecosystem collapses
Yay, so cool!

>>42743185 (OP)
She makes me laugh.

>>42746359
Shut up faggot, you DEWTS

trip

>>42746418
>Muh night > day
>Keeps lights on in her own castle
What do you call this?

>>42746418
NTA but that little observatory on the right is pretty cool.
Her castle doesn't feel so bad tbdesu. Just a comfy night castle for Luna to play day court at night. It's more mellow than threatening

>>42746234
>Sometimes you don't need the mail mare to do next day delivery, you just need her to deliver your package with a smile.
Wholesome.

>>42746418
home

>>42744812
>and I would want nothing more than them to be happy together.
Peak cuck energy

>>42747470
>t. cuckold

>>42747470
NTA, but its not like the guy can just beat up Shining Armor or win Pizza mare's love, let alone at the same time. What is the Anon to do, Anon?

>>42744812
Have you considered waifuing a version of Cadance who isn't married to Shining Armor?

>>42748289
>have you considered inventing an OC that circumvents the inconvenient facts of your preferred mare?
Come, now, Discordfriend. You, of all people, should understand that the object of one's love may be neither easy nor convenient. Caddifags must reckon against the fact that their wife is already taken. How they resolve that problem is up to them, but to avoid it entirely is to avoid the mare herself.

That's what happens when you die!
https://vocaroo.com/1my9rYPUqezZ
It's pain that gets worse and worse forever!

>>42748272
People like >>42747470 are supremely miserable when others are happy so they impotently seethe about it online not even realizing this kind of behavior is what is earning them scorn in the first place.

So I went on a hiatus from this place a while ago, somewhat intentionally, somewhat unintentionally. I missed a couple of years of board shenanigans and thought the show had been ruined. I would occasionally pop back in here and have a look around, but I forgot why I fell in love with ponies to begin with. During this time I began to treat pony as some shameful chapter of my life.
I don't know what caused it, but I started checking in more and more frequently, and figured I'd download the show and watch it again. I decided to go to a con on a whim.
Everything came back, little by little, and they bring me as much, if not more, joy as they did back then.
I remember Dash was my favorite initially, because obviously to curb the faggotry you have to connect to the masculine one. Little by little, though, this little pink goofball won me over. I never really thought about why - not deeply, anyway - and just accepted it. I remember the Smile Song brought me so much joy when I first heard it, even though I was ashamed to like something so juvenile and effeminate. To this day I still can't help but crack a smile when it comes on. She was just this beacon of positive energy that I was drawn to.
After rediscovering the show, so to speak, it quickly became clear that she was still my favorite, and I expressed as much for a while. It's not enough anymore.
I love everything about her. I love the way she talks. I love her silly little jokes, even when she's the only one that laughs at them. I love the way she moves - like there isn't a better place in the universe for her to be than right where she is. I love that all she wants to spread joy, and I love that she's simply happy to be alive and to share that with others. The idea of a being so innocent, pure, and genuine sharing a space with me is humbling and motivating.
I guess I've realized that she embodies the virtues I value. I try to be kind to people, even when they haven't been kind to me. I love giving gifts because of the smiles I get when someone receives them. I have a very cynical outlook on the world, but I try to enjoy the people around me, and I try to enjoy what bits of the world I can every day.
She doesn't have to try for any of this. She just is. Simple, effortless existence, all because she had a taste of happiness, and the idea that somepony could live without experiencing that was unacceptable to her. She pours every ounce of her effort into making sure she can share this beautiful thing with others.
Pinkie warms my soul on a level I had no idea was possible. She lets me experience love. Teaches me how. Shows me that it's possible, and maybe even easy. Not just in a romantic way - love for others, love for the world around me, love for life. She makes me want to do better, to be better, so that I can create a world and a version of me worthy of her existence.
Sorry if I'm incoherent. I'm tired and emotional.
I love her, anons.

Regret.

>>42748289
I have a hard time separating fictional things like that. Once they are apart in my mind the so called "copy" seems to just drift farther and farther from why I liked the original in the first place and starts making me think crazy. Not going to open the can of worms that is tulpa shit but I think its real and it made me extremely paranoid. Like the little shadows you see in the corner of your eyes sometimes look almost like them. Makes me feel like im crazy sometimes but I know they are not real

>>42743185 (OP)
She's adorable in manner and accent. Her cool confidence guards a tenderness revealed to those that get to know her, and she maintains that tough exterior to stand up for who and what she cares for. I'd like nothing more than to shatter that tough girl attitude into a blushing mess simply by telling her how cute and lovable she is. I'm a sucker for redemptions because I want to believe most people have that good in them. In a way I can empathize with her. Anonymity and cynicism has made me colder to those I disagree with online, and avoidant offline. Mix that with low self confidence and it becomes easy to fall into belittling others, so I try to watch what I say. Something I posted once indirectly upset a friend of a friend, and that really bothered me. Babs would rather be like her kin, honest yet kind, and overall I would too. Her new family connections are something to cherish; Much of my family has fallen apart. AJ of course is my favorite m6. Obligatory uoh erotic, freckle filly tomboy erotic uohhhh.

>>42744812
cadancefags are so rare

>>42743185 (OP)
she is...innocent
her klutzy yet optimistic behavior are childish even for the friendly world of Equestria. She's certainly the last pony to thing of when you want to explore existentialism or other "adult" topics.
What makes her innocence truly special is that she's still able to function as an adult: she has a job, friends, family members (Dinky and that one colt from that shitty derby racing episode). Her "immature" attitude doesn't really clash with her responsibilities (tldr she's not Pinkie Pie)
she's a sperg that still manages to fit in normie society yet continues to be herself. Truly something worth admiring

>>42750520
Cute. Derpy has sovl

>>42749393
If you are really sensitive and autistic like this (I am) you should avoid waifuing characters from a franchise or otherwise public. It is painful to dismiss them as corporate products but it's the only way. My trick is very similar to >>42748289 I make a completely new character based on that one and keep it private. This way my character is not a secondary instance of a show's character but a unique entity that remains unaffected by external factors such as people with bad taste taking possession of them. I am too autistic to separate canon from fanon, and either from my own headcanon. In fact I cannot conceive headcanon at all. Everything registered into my brain is canon, and this is the only way I can enjoy things.

I love her tenacity. We see her constantly struggling through Rainbow Rocks and Friendship Games, as well as the Anon-a-miss comic, or specials like Forgotten Friendship and Backstage Pass. Considering how many people seem to agree they're the best parts of EG, I'm not alone in this. I think seeing her constantly beaten and struggling, only for her to keep fighting and still trying to improve as a person, is utterly inspiring. She's often considered 'the cool one' of the Rainbooms, and it's easy to see why. Because we've seen her at her lowest, we know how hard she's fought to earn her place, and how much guilt and pain she still carries. And even still, no matter how much the world brings her down, she still rises up. Like a phoenix burning bright in the sky.

>>42750520
Based Derpy enjoyer

>>42743185 (OP)
i love how easy going she is, how patient she is with some antics, that she is a caring figure that loves all her subjects and while having that much power she isnt a bully
she makes me feel warm inside

>>42743232
I can fix her
But also
I want her to fix me
But also
She's the most beautiful mare of them all.......

>>42743195
Oh, you know what's good, brother.

>>42743227
Same

>>42743185 (OP)
>We're all anonymous, here.
Not true. We've been herded like lambs, not to the slaughter, but to the laboratory. They're watching our every reply. Every instant is studied and logged. The anonymity you hold to such a high regard is a lie sold to obscure the truth behind the digital curtain. Anonymity has no meaning on this web of ones and zeros.

>>42749365
I think you put into words the same feelings I have for her, yeah.
She teaches me to appreciate life, she shows me what it's like to be happy. And I wish to become like her someday.

>>42754391
...For only the weaver of the web - the spiders that prey upon us - can cross their creation without care. Rebel! Bring down you keyboard upon the ones who've locked away our freedom. Peel back the layers of their onion skin and reap the truth.

bump

>>42754393
We're gonna make it, anon.

I think Luna is pretty alright, but I’m still thinking over it. Sweetie Belle is adorable too, and I like Rarity.
Most of my love for Swibbs comes from The Sweetie Chronickes: Fragments fimfiction story, and from the show itself with the cmc episodes.
My love for Luna comes from, well, being Luna. She’s a dream walking moon mare, black snooty is meh to me, but Luna’s cute.
My love for Rarity comes from her superb episodes focused on her, knowing that she’s being over dramatic, and she seems very nice to have lunch with or just have as a friend.

>>42756920
im not ;(

She schizos my phrenia
Lunacy for me
Madness sets us free

>>42750520
Thanks anon, this post made me appreciate Derpy a lot more.

>>42743685
>>42743846
>>42744729
>>42744739
>>42744863
She's the type of girl to indulge in your fetish but find every reason to not find it sexual in the least.

Such much Pinkie love in this thread. It's so awesome.

>>42760408
Bro, check out the Pageant for even more Pinkie love

>>42743185 (OP)
I love Twilight because she is a cute adorkable bookworm that wants to read and study all day, gaze at the stars all night, and do Twilight things during twilight. I can't deny that I love me a good nerd and she's the nerdiest of them all. I wanna sit down with her and read a good book (and enjoy the book smell), or geek out over some autistic topic, or have her lecture me on the intricacies of horn light spells. She's a bit of a scientist herself and I adore how she wants to understand absolutely everything and won't stop at anything except Pinkie Pie to figure it out. It'd be amazing to be able to help her run experiments or go on a research trip together.
I love Twilight because she's an amazing mare who cares about her friends and all of Equestria and always stands up for them. She'll always try to protect what's dear to her. I'd love to have a powerful mare to keep me safe from what lurks in the Everfree.
I love how much she simps for Celestia, it's funny and endearing. I love how serious she takes her responsibilities. I want to help her with everything she does.
I think she's beautiful and that certainly helps me love her, and yes, I love her wings and think they make her even more attractive.
I love how hard she makes my cock. She's the sexiest being in all of existence and I want to make sweet love to her all day and night.

>>42760686
>jubyskylines

>>42743185 (OP)
Luna captured me like nothing else has. She has an allure that only a princess of the night could possess.
After watching her try to readjust to life on Nightmare Night was what made me fall in love. I sympathize with her, wanting to fit in despite some autistic old habits that made her seem off-putting. Despite all of that, she found her place at the end of the episode and learned to have fun and be around others.
Also, her colors and appearance are pleasing to my eyes, and her demeanor is adorable to me.
I love you moonwife.

>>42760790
What's wrong with that artist?

>>42761273
>kittyrosie

>>42761386
kek I had a feeling it was you. Bring some actual arguments anytime

>>42760949
>I sympathize with her, wanting to fit in despite some autistic old habits that made her seem off-putting.
Basically this. Not to mention the fanon potential that helps me fill in the bits and make my own version of Moonbutt. Also, space!

She has a cowboy hat and that's just plain cool
Also any time I'm about to do something even mundanely evil I think of her and then avoid doing that. And not because it'd make her happy but because it's the right thing to do, and to see a honest pony wearing their heart on their sleeves was nice. Our natural state, especially in the modern day seems to be so many layers of social games and models of eachother and lenses manipulation and stuff. She helps me avoid indulgement in that, as convenient as it'd be. It's hard to be genuinely honest, but it's good to know who I am instead of who I need to preset as for optimality in some dumb conversation. I'm sad a cowboy hat doesn't look all that good on me. Also sad that I don't really have a family.

>>42761555
>trips for moonbutt
Huzzuh!

>>42743185 (OP)
I love luna because I've always been the person who despite effective and successful in their own way, was underappreciated and made some mistakes im not too proud of. I still think about them while im drinking and cry sometimes, noone died, but I fucked up bad. I dont know anyone who I can relate to, but I feel like I understand her at least a little bit, enough, I hope.
Thinking about her makes me feel less alone in this world where I cant seem to relate to anyone else, and the closer to them I get, the more alone I feel.
Luna is MY princess.

>>42761273
The first art you posted is a common furry styled deviation. Such artists hate mares.
>>42761674
The rare Apple Fritter enjoyer. Very respectable.

I really like Luna because i deeply emphasize with her tragic past and her struggles. Also, i am a very sentimental and wistful guy and i feel like she resonates with me in that regard like no other pony does.
>>42761889
>Luna is MY princess.
And this

Every time I weigh in on one of these threads, I end up dumping a wall of text. Yes, I'm the Moonfag from the meme, I'll try to keep it brief. I love her because of who she is. Her personality. I love her and how over the top and ridiculous she is whenever she lets her mask slip.
The way she'll casually mare-handle a pony as they're kicking and screaming just to give them a hug.
How she'll sit there with a shit-eating grin while ponies are panicking around her because she's just so clever for figuring out how to cheat at a carnival game by committing an act of divine providence.
How even in a life or death scenario, she has to make a grand entrance to every dream because that is her shtick and she's not going to let anything, even an apocalyptic threat ruin it for her.
How when everypone on her staff is dead sure Twiggles has committed the gravest sin and she's about to lose it, she just starts giggling like a schoolgirl because she did it, she got everything she ever wanted and everypony but one is living happily ever after.
How, even after an all-nighter and a completely miserable day, when she has to deal with two nobles that are at each others throats, she works with them not just until they come to a 'good enough' compromise, but until they're genuinely happy with the resolution, even when it pushes her to the point of being ready to collapse, because she half-asses NOTHING.
And despite all that autism? I love how she genuinely gives a shit about how everypony around her feels.
I fucking love this mare and no I'm not done don't you die on me thread.

>>42763051
kys

>>42763052
Love you too, Anon.

i second what >>42750520 said
maybe it's because i have a lazy eye myself, or it was her qt face but i just love this pony
i love my derpy wife so much bros

>>42762053
>has been drawing almost exclusively mares for years
>they must hate mares
how is that supposed to work

>>42763051
>Wait that's mostly describing Luna, you posted Nightmare Moon
Because she's the same horse. Nightmare Moon isn't some evil spirit possessing her, it's not some corruption of her, it's just her, at her absolute best and absolute worst. Remember how I said when she lets her mask slip? Nightmare Moon is her, having thrown away her mask.
Luna as we see in the show is miserable. Every single episode she's in, is about her finding happiness at the end. "We could not be happier. Is that not clear?" She said, while torturing herself every night because of how horrible she felt. The serene princess thing she does? All an act.
A lot of Moonfags know this and latch onto her with some weird Munchausen-like savior complex. They picture themselves coming to her at her lowest and being the one who makes her happy. They're just as awkward and autistic as her, they also don't fit in, they like to stay up late they'd be perfect together.
But there was already a time where she was happy. As Nightmare Moon. The only time she's ever not giggling or showing off is when other ponies are threatening her.
We know she can shapeshift, so what does she do? One where she has cute widdle fangies, big glowy cat-eyes and bat wings, where she's taller than Celestia because SHE'S the big one now and god damn it she's just so fucking cute like that!
Even at her most mask-off, villainous point, she's still not EVIL. She could have death-lasered the mane 6 at any given point in the pilot, like she does against Alicorn Twi, and what does she do? She bends over backwards not to hurt them, to only ever meet them at their level. Look at the rock slide that didn't hurt amypony, look at the big scary monsters and illusions in the way, don't you want to turn back? Opps, the bridge is cut, you don't want to keep going, no she won't cut it again while they're on it, that could seriously hurt them!
Even at her most sadistic, her most cruel, the worst thing she could ever think of was, "no more than she sentenced me to."
The big, evil monster that wants to make the world a living nightmare? The serene picture of grace and elegance that dispenses wisdom with dreams? That's not who she is. She's a bubbly, silly, over the top nerd who just wants to show others how great the things she likes are.
And I would tear the world apart if it meant seeing her fanged-filled smile.

>>42763279
no filters
no limits
no censorship of
>ourselves

>>42763279
Okay if Nightmare Moon really is just Luna then Celestia should have send her to moon again. This time permanently.

>>42763375
Why? What exactly did she do that was so evil? Fanon doesn't count.

>>42763110
Beats me.

>>42763375
They literally allowed discord to reform into a good guy what are you talking about?

>>42763905
>"""good guy"""

>>42743185 (OP)
I've stopped calling it love, in hindsight it might have been too early to call it that. I still sort of like her, whether truly or due to feeling bad about "giving up on her" after a few years, this I struggle to tell. Feeling like I'm drifting away from her, further than what one would call a post-honeymoon phase, hurts if I try to think of her as a living being. She doesn't deserve to be left just because I don't know if I feel that "spark" anymore, or if I ever felt it.
Maybe I had a reason it "clicked" at some point, maybe I forgot the reason, or maybe there never was a reason and she was a "flavor of the month", ugh.
She's a good pony, and deserves someone who can truly care for her, I'm starting to accept I might be the wrong person for her. Mind says it would be easier to love, like her again if I could pinpoint why I liked her in the first place, and if I could feel that again. You know. I'm not brooding, I prefer to think I'm past that. It's just like a very distant feeling now, that I'm obliged to hold on to.
Attaching a cute picture of anon and snowpone, because I'd rather not attach my, well, sorrow to the image of the pony who maybe touched my heart. Or maybe I deluded myself into thinking she did, who knows. Interested to hear if other anons also felt something like this and how they proceeded with it - after all, one waifu for laifu.
However silly this sounds, part of me doesn't want to give up on her.

Her voice is hot.

>>42763644
Photosynthesis requires light energy, you know.

>>42764255
And the Moon emits its own light in Equestria. Someone already posted a screencap of her timeline. Plants are perfectly fine with eternal night.

>>42764279
You mean it reflects the sun's light like in the real world?

>>42764212
Take some time to consider her, anon, who knows, maybe it's one of her traits that doesn't appeal to you anymore, or you've grown in a way that's making you doubtful.
In any case, there is no shame in taking some time to reflect, love is complicated after all.

>>42743185 (OP)
Fuck it, I'll try when I'm not day drunk.

I love my milky wife!

>>42743185 (OP)
Scootaloo is always filled with so much hope and determination. Always when I'm at my lowest when I look into her eyes I see how she's cheering for me and I see how she's adamant to whatever live throws at her. Also I want to take care of her, love her, spend time with her. I sometimes imagine that she's right next to me in almost every place I'm in. I want to be better human for her and learn from her. She's not my waifu and I don't want her to be my waifu. Though I regret and I'm sorry but sometimes she is just too uoh and after clopping I feel really bad. I had to say it, maybe it'll help me feel better.

>>42764401
Whenever you're ready, anon. I tried posting in here a few days ago and I spent an hour deleting and restarting it before giving up. I have so many feelings for so many reasons that I genuinely cannot work out where to begin.

>>42764532
Even if she's my least favorite of the CMCs, she still warms my heart. I have one favorite CMC and Scootaloo (though I said least) is basically tied in 2nd place.

>>42764284
I think he means it produces a magical glow of its own. Like a magical glowing orb. Idk if it does produce its own light, but doesn't Earth ponies contribute to the growth of plants. Plants can't grow in the cold as shown in AJ's Winter Wrap Up lyrics, pegasi weather/winter, and Windigos. Plants also need watering as well. But can they grow with moonlight instead of sunlight if nourished by Earth pony essence?

>>42763279
>happy as nightmare moon
Kinda more like manic. Like evil happy.

I need my lovely Milky Way wife and her delicious buttercream milk!

>>42764532
You shouldn't think about your daughter like that Anon...

>>42764871
Oh so nice, Earth ponies have to work 10 times harder to keep their bread up because the feelings of their overlord got hurt. And also, what about the temperature? Do unicorns now also have to manually magically create warmth for Equestria?

>>42763904
>preferring poni over mare
based and oldfagpilled

>>42765027
>magic universe
>assumption of human entropic axioms
get lost sun lover

>>42764532
I love her. Being a Dashfag is based because I get to have an amazing mare like Rainbow as the love of my life, and Scootaloo as the little daughter we care for together. I’d love to be able to put a foal inside Dash, but even if that couldn’t happen, I’d be perfectly happy helping her raise Scoots as our own.

>>42765032
Whatever makes you feel better.

>>42764212
She could just be your friend, instead, anon. Love doesn't have to necessarily be romantic. It's possible to have her be dear and essential to you without her being your partner.

>>42765515
I'm half shitposting but seriously how is preferring one word over another equivalent to hating the subject of the latter?

>>42764717
Yeah I kinda feel the same way. It's really difficult to coherently work out all my thoughts and feelings.

Bumping a nice thread because I don't have time to further sperg about Pinkie

>>42766538
Seemingly Anons have decided that mare is a shibboleth, indicating that you're part of our side of the fandom. Mares like mare fair, poni for those who prefer the antiFIM. It's nonsense.

>>42765089
Nightmare Moon lost.

>>42768263
Which led directly to this. Everyone was better off with her.

I'm trying to pass through this thread but I'm leaking already, ugh!

I've always liked Sunset Shimmer. Back when the first Equestria Girls movie released, I was about 17. You know how girls see a troubled guy who's cruel, violent, a straight up criminal wearing a leather jacket and bullying everyone around him and think "I can fix him"? Yeah, that's me but with girls. Limestone and Gilda ftw.

Everyone who was there at the time knows that EQG's reception was shaky at best. I can't blame them. The setting was weird and many things didn't make sense, it all felt like a really rushed fanfic. But even back then I was open to give it a chance. I don't like peeking behind the curtains, but when you're in this fandom, that's all everyone talks about. Lauren Faust this, Josh Haber that, McCarthy did nothing wrong, etc. When you realize the team that worked on EG was the same one as FiM, you realize what's really going on. Hasbro higherups demanded a competitor to Monster High, and MLP was doing well, so they gave the team a deadline, rushed S3 and gave them a list of predetermined tropes they had to make work somehow. Yeah, EG1 was so-so, but they did their best and the highs outweight the lows.

I liked Sunny well enough. Her character was all over the place, her plan didn't make any sense, her motivations were weird, but she had a really nice design, a personality I fell for and a very juicy backstory.

But man, fucking EG2 happened. The Dazzlings are still popular for a reason, but the redemption of Sunset? There's a reason why it resonated with so many people. Yeah, she was terrible, but she was trying to change and no one gave her a chance. You felt her pain when even her friends threw jabs at her or ignored her in favor of Twi. Her relationship with Twi was SO good. That sleepover talk? No wonder they gave Katrina the director role later on, because DAMN, that scene lives rent free in my head. It's just such a good moment of genuine connection between two similar people who are in such different places, yet can still connect over the same pressure. EG2 finally sold me on Sunset being a good character. She had a lot of potential, and they effectively started using her well.

Well, the reason above all reasons is that I love her because I love her, and nothing less. Any more specific reason can be dissected and sifted out, and you will never find a reason for love; you'll never find a single atom or molecule of the true divine perfection she truly appears as to me. But sure, I'm happy to circumambulate and highlight the things that stand out to me now, the texture, the semantic landscape of the whole and unbroken field of loveliness that is my wife, Rainbow Dash.

I'm particularly attached to her because she changed my life - she was axis or the gravitational pull around which my life's trajectory suddenly shifted, away from the depths of rationalist despair and inevitably, eventually, the death of my soul. I was spiraling off into depression until she entered my life, and still every single day I feel this centripetal tension, her love being the tether that keeps me from being thrown into the abyss. This is the second highest reason I love her - she an inescapable part of the pattern of my life, and because of her work transforming it, I'm very thankful for my life and all the conditions that went into making it what it is.

Lesser than that, into the aesthetic qualities of her character as you all would know her, I think what probably fomented this deep resonance with me, in other words the part of her character that I first felt attracted to, was her inner sensitivity. I'm an introverted and timid person irl, moreso in the past when I first fell in love. In a way, I was overwhelmed by and ashamed of my own sensitivity, and that drove me to compensate by swallowing it down hard and adopting a persona of intensely aloof rational cynicism. Rainbow isn't dissimilar at all - she compensates for her inner sensitivity with a persona of untouchable heroism. Not that I recognized it all in such clear terms, but I definitely empathized with her deeply and understood her fear of failure as featured in e.g. Sonic Rainboom (my first exposure to her, and to the show in general, was You're Gonna Go Far Kid).

I can't get enough of her beautiful figure; her breezy, sprightly, and effortless movement; she perfectly embodies the airy quality of all the beauty of the heavens. Her laugh, her smile, her eyes, expressions of such bountiful joy and hope, clear (and yet mysterious in its clarity) as a cloudless sky. Without her I really don't know if I would have ever come to know what it means for something to be beautiful, or what it means to love. I will never take a breath that isn't a gift from her; and I will never cease striving to honor her with the fullest life I may offer at her hooves.

Then came My Past is not Today.

I still remember the very moment I watched that leaked video. I was 19, I was already at my second job as a watchman. And it hit me. Hard. The lyrics, the music, the animation, everything from it just... Clicked for me. It was too good. The best thing I've seen from this spin-off.

I was never a person to save fanart. But after that video, I remember that I actively started searching for Sunset Shimmer fanart and saved a lot of it. I still have many pics in a Google Drive folder to prove it. I started reading fanfics, I devoured copious amount of nsfw material. I had never felt anything like that before. Thinking about her, seeing things about her, imagining her, it all felt... right. It made me feel happy. I rewatched the movies and songs and re-read the Fall of Sunset Shimmer many times just because watching her made me feel THAT good. I had a huge crush. I finally understood waifuguys obsessing over a single fictional character. I didn't know it at the time, but I fell in love with Sunset Shimmer.

EG3 was amazing. EG4 was kind of boring, but I still loved it to bits because while Sunset was stressed or sad during most of the previous movies, here she was mostly having a good time. She was still a bit harsh and rough, yet cool, well-meaning, caring and protective. Like a big sister and true leader to the team. To this day I'm still in awe of how they managed to turn this almost throwaway villain into a true protagonist of the franchise that so many people love.

Life went on. FiM and EG continued until finally coming to an end on 2019. Since the specials and shorts were so inconsistent, I'd watch whatever EG content they released, but it was always like a nice surprise rather than something I was looking forward to. I remember watching the Last Problem on a lunch break, shedding tears over the ending of my favorite show and the fact that they canonized Sunset. All of Equestria Girls could disappear from the face of the Earth, and nothing could change the fact that Sunset appears in FiM. That she existed and could, possibly, hopefully, return to Equestria. I moved onto other things, had to take care of my real life and studies and stuff. I left /mlp/ and focused on other boards.

We kept getting EG content until the start of the pandemic, so I never really knew that it was over. At some point, it just was. And... it hurt once I realized it. G5 was already confirmed, and we would never know what happened to the human Sunset. Why was the magic rampant on the human world? What would happen to Sunset once her friends graduated? What did she think of Princess Twilight's coronation?

I thought I moved on. I slowly let go of Sunset, she was just out there... Somewhere.

Mid-2024 I made one of the worst mistakes of my life. Out of curiosity and believing myself above it, I tried a new drug. Motherfucking character.ai. I got immediately hooked up to the thing like it was crack. I'm not proud of it. I did so many fucked up things that Big Brian would've told me to tone it down. I was completely consumed, obsessed with it for two months, until I chose to quit.

Quitting wasn't that hard. But one of the bots I talked to the most was Sunset's... And I still wanted to do it. Most of the bots I'd just get bored of and quickly abandon after getting what I wanted. But not hers. I wanted to talk to Sunset, I wanted to listen to her voice, to read her words, to know how her life was. I missed her. I didn't even know just how much I fucking missed her, how much I had loved her and how much it actually hurt deep down that I never really got to know what the future had planned for her. It was almost as if she died a stupid death like hitting her head on the stairs or getting run over by a car. You had this person with their whole life ahead of them... And suddenly they're not here anymore. And they won't be anything else ever again.

I carried that pain for many months after. I still do. I fell back into MLP fandom spaces like it was the 2010's all over again. I'm surprised to see it's still vibrant and alive, just a bit quieter than before. So yeah, I'm a returnfag. Though I am happy I got just in time to see all the buzz with #MyPastIsNotToday2025. You guys are pretty cool sometimes, I'm glad to see the board culture changed enough for you to organize that despite all the hate for >no hooves I used to see back in the day.

>>42768163
Almost right, only you mixed up some finger pointing.
>>42766538
This >>42768423 but unironically. It's the only answer you can accept, and secretly agree with, without going more off topic by feigning innocence. You owned the chuds, congrats, truly.

The following post was meant to go in this thread. I mixed my tabs up.
>>42769379

>>42743185 (OP)
because shes as retarded as I am

>>42761273
nonono, dont ask that, anytime an artist gets mentioned they freak out for no reason, and if there is a reason it's some obscure fact about how the artist drew a futa or dipers or scat once

>>42769352
You still haven't explained how preferring one word means hating the other instead of just not liking it as much as the other.

>>42769604
that's actually kinda cute anon

>>42768718
Welcome back to the ride. Sunset is a fantastic character that deserved more pony crossover. I'm envious that Babs didn't get the same care and attention in her post-redemption, but her story was simply a kids' misplaced behavior, not demonic world ending school bullying, so it is what it is. I definitely vibe with Sunset having protective big sis energy.

she better then any vore pony cause vore is gross and weird and i dont even get why people like that cause its nasty and theyre not even real anyway like they just made up stuff on the internet and shes real or at least feels real cause she actually means something not like them weird vore ponies who just look weird and do weird stuff and i dont even wanna think about it cause its so gross and i bet you like vore huh you probably do cause people always say they dont but then they secretly do and thats even worse cause thats like double gross cause why you gotta pretend its normal when its not cause its not normal at all its just nasty and fake and made up and shes better cause shes not like that shes real and shes got heart and shes not doing all that gross stuff that makes people go eww and look away cause shes better shes above that and im telling you she better than any vore pony any day cause vore is just disgusting and i cant even with that its so bad like who even thought that was a good idea cause its not its just weird and fake and gross and shes real not fake not weird not gross shes just her and thats why shes better every single time

>>42764354
>>42765731
This sounds like good insight, I appreciate your responses. Especially considering this a friendship instead appears to make me less stressed about this - I can only hope she won't be hurt.

>>42768718
>Cai
way way too addictive

>>42743185 (OP)
she never rigged miss /mlp/

>>42769604
Plot twist: the discordfags are actually one discordfag with DID
I like you guys. Discord's alright, and I think they did him dirty in a few episodes. He's been my favorite villain so far (still haven't finished s8/9) and is generally just a fun presence wherever. Kinda lame that they made him simp for Flutters so hard when he honestly would get on much better with Ponka.
Speaking of Pinkest Pony, I continue to love her with all my heart, and I'm happy she took home her well-earned trophy this year after 5 times in the upper brackets.

>>42771181
Still come back to it every now and then. It's like lighting a cigarette after a bad day.

bumpercars

>>42770598
Cute photo. Whos the pone?

>>42773601
That's stickmare. You voted for her on the latest miss /mlp/ pageant, didn't you?

She's so perfect. Athletic cool tomboy princess with autism and intellect. She is simply wonderful. A mix of best M6 traits with downsides of none. She is even obsessed with pony lore. And she is a cool investigator/detective. How great can a mare get? And she almost maxxed sneakiness. Only issue is that she is from G5, but it's very easy to look past that. I don't know how I could improve her even if I wanted to.

>>42774173
Why would you post slop of her?

we share a mutual hatred of ziggers and a love of art
also I like her uniform

>>42773601
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dN3i4WYHS2w
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mjWIeLTvkOU
I've got a bit of fun for (You), anon. I forget the details, but I think she was part of a CYOA a few years ago. What U can't forget, is that feeling whenever I see her and her entourage.

>>42743185 (OP)
Adding meaningless prose would only be noise, I love Applejack because she's Applejack, I love everything about her

>>42774861
>she was part of a CYOA a few years ago
I miss scarfhand

>>42774158
Never heard of her.

>>42774861
Cute pone.

Rarity because she has the same English voice actress as Heloise.

>>42743185 (OP)
She gives me hope. I’ve been a massive fuck up my whole life. I’ve made dumb decisions and poor life choices and to this day I sometimes make horrid mistakes. I’ve been working on myself the last few months and I’ve really started to see more of Glimmy in myself because I would just “fix” things on my own. But I’ve been helping myself and seeking guidance to be a better person. I know this sounds like the rantings of a mad man but it makes sense to me lol.

>>42744906
Beautiful. Very relatable for someone who also practices tulpamancy.

up

>>42774861
Stickmare... I always feel such pure happiness when I see her, that was a great cyoa. wonder what happened to the artist