This still hasn't been surpassed by any game

>>717073018 (OP)
Skyrim is better

BG3

>>717073018 (OP)
>gameplay is just you looking at pretty trees

Toussant....home.

>>717073018 (OP)
I would probably double dip if it got a Switch 2 upgrade

poorlack shill thread

>>717073018 (OP)
Terrible combat.

Place of power... Should draw from it.

>>717074403
This, with the benefit of hindsight. At the time it was a minor annoyance offset by the world building and story and pretty graphics, but trying to play it again these days it just gets on my fucking nerves. I've finished it once and enjoyed it for what it was, that's good enough.

>>717073018 (OP)
Blades of fire

>>717074548
>benefit of hindsight
Oh shut the fuck up zoomie, we always called it "alright combat for an RPG"

>>717073018 (OP)
the movement fucking sucks

Small dodge and big dodge should be everywhere

>>717074602
Who's this "we" you gen alpha shit eater?

>>717073018 (OP)
Gameplay is so ass. Just spam leftclick and hit q sometimes.

>>717074963
It's okay fren, I know you were 8 when the game came out. No need to be angry

>>717075019
Calm down there's no need to foam at the mouth grandad

>>717075258
>no u

It really hasn't. Yes, the gameplay kinda sucks but honestly no game has managed to capture the "long adventure in fantasy land" feel like Witcher 3 does. Travelling through different places, cities, doing quests for it's people and making an impact is something no game since then replicated. Even BG3 feels really small in it's scale in comparison.

>>717075364
>Travelling through different places, cities, doing quests for it's people and making an impact
Literally every single RPG does this

>>717073018 (OP)
Sorry but I don't want to play as a grumpy sterile grandpa jobbing for bossy women

Next year, we're getting The Blood of Dawnwalker, pretty much Witcher 3.5.
Looks like it inherited TW3 storytellerd from CDPR.

>>717073018 (OP)
Great game but it's a chore to replay and yes I consider that a flaw. Committing to another 150 hour playthrough is a legitimately fucked up.

>>717073018 (OP)
Good story, writing, graphics, soundtrack, atmosphere, character designs, art direction. Appallingly dogshit combat that makes it impossible to ever replay.

>>717075425
The difference is in the writing imo.
No fantasy game before or since as the maturity of The Witcher's writing.
All other fantasy video games feel weird one way or another.

TES' encyclopaedic loredump style combined with its chosen one plot feels incongruent and infantile.
Larian games suffer the cringe soiboi Belgian style humour.

The Witcher sort of feels like on the level of a good fantasy novel, stuff written pre-'00s, with very deep worldbuilding. Few, almost no video games have writing on the level of a written novel let alone a decent one. Characters are mature, complex, and logical in their own way which makes them feel realistic.

There's never the need to suspend disbelief as in other games where you lack the ability to predict how a character behaves, because they have no fully fleshed characterizations and are just slaves to what the plot demands and the whims of the amateur writers of those games.

>>717074970
You can play most games by spamming just one attack, but why would you? It gets boring pretty quick.

>>717073018 (OP)
Bloodtroons snoyjeets are STILL seething about this game

>>717076046
Also it's almost unbelievable how this was achieved given it's a Polish studio.
Like how does a Polish studio not only not have the same typical pitfalls of Russian/European-written games but manages to have such a deep understanding of anglo-centric storytelling styles? Like they either had incredible English localization teams that worked in tandem with development, or the developers all received private (public in England in Wales) English educations.

If you told me The Witcher 2 was a British game I'd believe you.

>>717076445
>anglo-centric storytelling styles
You do know they're based on Polish books

>>717076445
>anglo-centric storytelling styles?
literally based on northern european mythologies (mainly slavic)

>>717074602
Combat was worse than Skyrim.

>>717073158
amazing gameplay, terribad writing in act 3.

>>717073018 (OP)
Is it actually good? I heard the combat is shit but the story is kino. Should I pick this up on my Switch 2?

>>717076717
>Is it actually good?
If you're dumb enough to fall for it you deserve to part with your money.

>>717076498
>>717076542
I know I'm not really talking about the plot or the myths (which are pan-pagan anyways, Celts had wild hunt and avalon is matter of britain/france), I'm talking about the style and presentation. Like you had NPCs talking in British slang or whatever, whoreson etc.

>>717076751
I'm fucking rich I don't care about money. I just want a good game. Currently playing monke bananza

>>717076759
They had actual English writers for that, but swearing is inherently Slavic
As is all the sarcasm and moaning about the state of the world which is at the core of the Witcher books

>>717076717
The combat is not shit, it's just that thousands of /v/ normalniggers played the game because of marketing while never having touched an RPG before
The combat is servicable for an RPG, it's more stat-based than you'd think. All the quest writing and story is great
The open world is the only true negative, there's nothing unique to find that isn't tied to a sidequest that sends you there

>>717076848
>swearing is inherently Slavic
Oh is it you fookin' cunt?

Toussaint.... HOME

>>717076945
Yes, it is.

>>717076717
It's really good. Combat is perfectly fine for a game like this.

toussaint is the best gaming world that has ever been made

>>717077023
There are just as many profanities in English t bh
So many that a lot of them have been incorporated into every day speech and no longer considered crass.

>>717076816
The gameplay is awful bamham combat and you basically hold down a single button to make your horse auto run down roads, where you stop at points of interest in a generic open world to kill 5 generic bandits and get a treasure chest full of generic loot with entirely vertical progression. Other than this its all cutscenes, there is absolutely nothing else. There was supposed to be a system where you studied monsters and prepared the necessary ingredients to leverage against their weaknesses beforehand via alchemical ingredients, but actually this doesn't work because one buff clearly outperforms all others, so this system has mostly been restructured into unavoidable quests that handhold you the entire way and string you between objectives like an MMO. There is even a magic smell-o-vision to lead you to objectives because visually the game is made to look like a movie and terrain features are hard to distinguish. The writing is also bad. It's like an HBO or netflix movie where the NPC just monologues about meaningless edgy shit in a deep voice, and then something gay and quirky happens, like drinking a magic potion that let's him understand his horse that talks like a hollywood jew. I am not exagerrating when I say it is the most offensively anti-video game normalfag movies ever made.

And here's the writing people praise.
https://youtu.be/DebCeu5xUgw
It's probably the most cynical and depressing thing I have ever played. Everything about it feels like a sterile corporate product carefully pieced together in a board room of executives and investors, everything is dumbed down and delivered with condescending irony, like the writers have active disdain for their audience and this is just another day of feeding the pigs at the trough.

>>717077510
Ok, but tell me how you really feel

Do Witchers do big loads? Can they spaff at all? What does it taste like? So many unanswered questions.

>>717077612
I feel like the person who made this thread, and makes other awful threads on normalfag rpgs all day, should be slow roasted in one of those bronze bulls they used to torture people in ancient Greece. Not a single person would miss them. There's really no excuse for pushing this garbage and it has made me hate Poland.

RDR2

>>717077510
>nu-brony thinks his opinion matters

>>717077976
I refunded this game after 30 minutes. God bless steam.

>>717078129
I don't see a single counter-argument in this post. I am replaying Factorio today for the first time in 8 years and checking out the new expac and genuinely having fun. How fun it is to play actual video games instead of depressingly seeking out movies meant to be consumed and thrown away.

Pure SlavKINO. OST is unmatched.
https://youtu.be/Gz3P4tN-Wvw?si=qRKu0X7W-nx3DW2M

>tranimefag
>moeshitter image
>being retarded

>>717073018 (OP)
>Dogshit action-adventure game pretending to be rpg
>This still hasn't been surpassed by any game
Rofl

>>717073092
FPBP

>>717073850
Based.

I hate both the story and gameplay. The characters are obnoxiously annoying.

What are the chances of Witcher 1 remake outselling Witcher 4. I don't people like Ciri that much.

Come home white man.

>>717078529
Why do slavs always resort to this dumb gaslighting strategy?
>get absolutely blown the fuck out
>uhh I'll just angrily call him a retard repeatedly and that means it doesn't matter
Maybe if you put effort into things instead of rotting your brain with movie games this wouldn't happen.

>>717078979
genuinely the best DLC of all time. for a meager 20 dollars or whatever the fuck it was

>>717078979
Slavs ain't white bro

>yup, I've never played any other RPG other than Witcher 3 but it's the best RPG ever made, I have on good authority to say that, me being an expert on RPGs!

>>717079109
>couldn't name a single better one

I replay witcher 3 every other year or so. Incredible world

i consider witcher 3 a top 5 game of all time and i don't own it
i'm not sure what the point is in getting it now, my save files and mods probably won't work with the current version anyway

>>717073018 (OP)
>Generic McGruff protagonist
>Fem characters all big brain stronk women
>Dull sub Souls combat with one and a half weapon types and only 5 spells
>general DEI themes rammed down your throat
it's aggressively mid

>>717079001
>immediately stops posting his moeshit garbage
>seething
Many such cases.

>>717079379
>complains about main character not being different enough
>complains about diversity in the same post
imbecile

>>717073018 (OP)
>accept quest
>go to marker
>activate bitcher sense
>monologue that explains what happened
>follow puke trail
>more monologue
>talk to npc
>shitty combat or talk-no-jutsu
>pick your ending to quest
Gothic did it better over decade earlier.

I picked Triss.

>>717079453
I hope you understand multiple people are shitting on you while you sit here and desperately samefag.

>>717079563
>muh samefag
>you should listen to a local pedophile who is obssesed with nipshit little girls
Interesting.

The best virtual world made and fantastic writing. Probably the two best DLCs I have ever played and they are good for different reasons.

CDprojekt were kangs at one point

Avatarnigger is spamming his shit all day and he also professes to hate all RPGs https://arch.b4k.dev/v/thread/716774450/#716774450 which means he either played a game from a genre he hates or is shitting on it based on what /v/ told him about it

>>717079635
>you should listen to a local pedophile who is obssesed with nipshit little girls
Well obviously yes.

>>717079557
love gingers me

>>717079557
>perfect face and personality, but the other one has MUH TITS
mogged indeed

>>717079703
Grim. Should probably troon out already.

>>717079687
This is ironic considering you've been making this thread for years, to the point where these shitty threads are basically your "avatar".

>>717079469
>main character is dull
>omg sorry he's not a black transbian
mind broken

>>717079557
Based TrissGOD.
>>717079759
>Yen
>perfect personality
Maybe if you are a cuck.

>>717079687
Hmm? I like plenty of RPGs, just not the garbage you play. I'd be willing to go along with all RPGs being banned from /v/, however, as they only hold the gates wide opened for garbage. I'd be perfectly fine with never discussing RPGs here again if that meant 40 awful daily threads being wiped from the catalogue.

>>717079880
>poe2
get that ass banned

>>717079880
>Baldur's Gate 3
>moeshit for pedophiles
Grim.

>>717073018 (OP)
>Shit combat
>Shit gameplay
>Shit quests
>Shit characters
>Shit mary sue story
>Shit NPC protagonist

>>717079910
Ressentiment coded post.

>>717073850
Velen mogs it. Love dark pagan atmosphere of this place.

>>717079956
>Skyrim out of nowhere

>>717079557
I picked Triss twice.
When i do a third playthrough i'm gonna pick Triss again

>>717080003
Skyrim is shit too, yes
Witcher 3 and Skyrim suffer fron the same exact issues

>>717079956
Name a better RPG then.

>>717079880
>I like plenty of RPGs
Incorrect, you said "There is no video game genre more casual than RPGs" >>717079687

>>717080027
BASED beyond belief.

>>717080041
>ESL

>>717079998
>dark pagan atmosphere
https://youtu.be/CbOldRsITpQ
Yuropoors really glorify this yakubian shit then pretend to be white

>>717080050
Dragon's Dogma

>combat is braindead easy, it's impossible to die in the game
>character customization revolves around picking useless shit like whether you want more damage with light attacks or more damage with heavy attacks
>quest markers, glowing footsteps, fog trails, no need to ever figure anything out
It really is the perfect game for normies, even a handicapped retard could play this game.

Skellige Isles......home.
https://youtu.be/NknjE2SBPxw?si=_ae9Jqyvdd51snMF

>>717077510
>And here's the writing people praise.
Well, that's certainly a typical quest in a dark fantasy game.

>>717080091
>There is no video game genre more casual than RPGs
Correct. I think even umamusume is more complex than the most complex RPG. This presents a problem, because RPGs become an anti-gatekeeping mechanism and you get people praising crap all day. Like this thread. Like yeah, PoE is a deep game with a very complex economy, but you can't discuss it because desperate retards will spam the catalogue with other ARPGs for months as a result. It's simply not worth discussing RPGs at all. This is the only genre like this.

>>717080237
you dont need challenge everywhere, you already challenged enough

>>717080306
> I think even umamusume is more complex than the most complex RPG
Opinion discarded.

>>717073092
lol

>>717080275
SOVL.

>>717080190
>mixed Amerimutt loves tranime
>talks about Switzerland when discussing slavs
Retard.

>>717078839
>I don't people like Ciri that much.
Are you kidding? She was THE gaming waifu when the game came out. Popular to this day and was way more prominent than say, Shadowheart etc.

>>717080334
It's objectively more complex and there's a reason there's a 147 page mechanical guide to succeeding in PvP floating around. Is it a hard game? Of course not. I just don't think you realize how retarded you are. Morons think they're genius for flow charting into slight variations on 20 year 3.5e feat stacking strategies in owlcat games then autopiloting through the game, or worse yet just looking up builds. It's always the same story with you people. All RPGs regularly discussed in 4chan are garbage.

>>717080275
>>717080423
I fucking HATE how dumb and scaled down the mountains in Skellige look like. It feels like you are walking on a diorama.

>>717080481
>discussing slavs
Where did he do that?

>>717080524
Compared to Geralt, Ciri is shit.

>>717079703
>doesn't deny being a pedophile

>>717080532
>shills his gacha faggotry
No.

>>717073018 (OP)
Its better than a lot of games, but it was never the best game of all time or anything.
Game got some unhinged and annoying haters though, they even made a reddit page dedicated for hating the game nonstop, its pathetic.

>>717080770
>n-no I can't be retarded
Gachatards are several tiers above Witcher 3. If you don't like them here then raise the bar above them. I think we need MORE gacha threads to compete with all these rpg slop threads.

>>717079880
I may be retarded for asking this but why do you like Stalker when you claim Witcher 3 is bad?

As far as i know Stalker has janky controls, bad gunplay and lots of clutter, the side quests are all shallow, the narrative is halfassed, no memorable character in sight, the only saving grace Stalker has is the atmosphere, everything else is not good, so my question is why is The Witcher 3 so bad but Stalker 2007 is so good?

I hope W4 bombs and normies will be stuck playing that game for the next decade or so.

Generic eurojank clickslop that only made money due to one of the most massive shill marketing campaigns in recent memory when this came out practically every place on the internet was flooded with a cacophony of polacks yelling
>SAAR SAAR PLEASE BUY OUR GAME POLAND TOTALLY NOT THIRD WORLD LOOK WE MADE GAME YOU HAVE TO BUY IT SAAR
fucking everywhere
gameplay is bad, the story is fucking retarded, graphics were downgraded because thirdies couldn't run the original build this game is not remotely good in any sense of the word

I love Witcher 3 even with its flaws, it's one of my favorite games, I just really enjoy traversing the world and taking in the scenery and talking to an entirely white population (outside of a few shitskin jeets who are confined to small areas in one DLC). The fact that one of the haters in this thread is a gacha loving lolicon is all I need to reaffirm that my opinion is good and right.

>>717079107
They are whiter than Germans, murrifats or english.

Witcher caused 10 years of seethe

>>717081196
>m-muh console downgrades
>m-muh shitty combat
>m-muh shoehorned feminism!!!
>m-muh dumb story!!!
Don't care, loved it.

>>717080228
Fantastic joke.
>>717080190
I'm sorry you have no culture and history, but I don't know what this have to do with early slavic paganism.

>>717080859
>pedo shilling for more gachaSLOP
Kek.

>>717081196
I bet a lot of people think stuff like Persona is good.

>>717081021
>bad gunplay
Stalker has excellent gunplay with situational weapons/ammo that work at different ranges and on different types of opponents. Which is what Witcher wanted to do but never did.
>the side quests are all shallow
That can't be true because I spent over 300 hours collecting stashes and artifacts in GAMMA, the locations of which were directly pulled from the original trilogy, and had lots of fun navigating through these unique setpieces.

SoC is a good game with smart progression unlike Witcher 3, a genuinely alive world unlike the NPCs in Witcher 3, side content that isn't just generic points of interests unlike witcher 3, and tells most of its story environmentally without smell-o-vision unlike Witcher 3. See where I'm going with this? I could do this all day.

>>717073018 (OP)
6 fucking times I tried to get into this game and got bored within an hour or 2. It just feels like such a boring chore. Everything about it

>>717081353
>muh STALKERINOOOOOO
>plays a modded version because the base game is shit
Kek.

>>717081353
>continually posts little anime girls
Bro just end it at this point.

>>717081130
>an entirely white population
Poles definitely aren't white. You do realize literally every country has jokes about them being retarded right?
>Two Polish hunters were driving through the country to go bear hunting. They came upon a fork in the road where a sign read "BEAR LEFT" so they went home.
For example. Now report me for racism despite initiating it yourself.

>>717081415
I have 200 hours in SoC. GAMMA is a CoP mod which combines all the side content in all 3 games and turns collecting it all into a game. Unsurprisingly, it is the most popular STALKER mod.

>>717081578
Shut the fuck up you stupid retarded faggot, you will never have white skin :^)

It probably never will.

This is the golden age of emulation.

>>717081578
>mutt crying about white people again
Sad.

>>717081667
>you will never have white skin
?????

>>717081353
Really? assume im stupid and explain to me what do you mean by excellent gunplay.
Isn't it janky and too basic? i played a lot of First Person shooters and most of them have far superior gunplay than this.

And i did finish the game but im struggling to remember a single side quest, they are that forgettable, all i remember was coming across a random character (npc) and i help them so they can tell me where their stash is which is just more of the same loot.
What do you mean with smart progression?

I agree that the world of Stalker is alive, i called the game to have good atmosphere because of that immersive world, but beyond that i really struggle to find highlights in the game, there are no qualities that deserve praise here.

If you can explain that i may be able to understand where you are coming from.

>>717081578
Enjoy your pajeet genes Helmut. I can't stop laughing at Germans crying on twitter about how clean Polish pools and metros are, because they lack shitskins.

>>717081737
bro what is on your pointer finger did you stick your finger in your butt LOL

>>717081415
Ahh its a mod, so i thought we were considering base game quality only, i think thats kinda unfair now, i have no experience with the mod, i played Stalker without mods, was a fun game, but it has plenty of issues.

>>717075701
>Appallingly dogshit combat that makes it impossible to ever replay.
i never understood this. the combat wasn't anything to write home but it was never that bad

>>717077510
Your criticism is valid, but the writing IS GOOD, especially for a videogame, you cherrypicked a parody quest but if you compare the writing in the game to most games it does hold up well.

I wish people like you channeled their critical thinking energy towards other games that get infinitely more praise while they get zero amount of hate that the witcher 3 gets, games like Yakuza 0 which everybody circlejerks over.

>>717076612
Turn based games don't have gameplay.

>>717073018 (OP)
In what aspect??

>>717081413
Einstein said trying the same things expecting a different result is a kind of stupidity.

>>717082180
their faggot tranny contrarians, they only argue in bad faith and for attention. don't wish that upon any game

>>717079001
He's right though. Your post shows that your some smoothbrain zoomie, that can't handle darker, mature themes and have ann attention span of a fucking fruitfly.

>>717080228
shit meme game. can't believe i fell for it.

>>717076717
>combat shit
It's standard for western action oriented game, not worse from some stuff like Skyrim.
>Switch 2
So 30fps?

>>717081747
>Isn't it janky and too basic
No, stalker is a survival horror game. Similarly to the RE games, you have to stop and aim. which creates tension. The new first person RE games even work similarly.
https://youtu.be/PeFiMkwMo_k?si=Od5Brz-aMScSVK8N&t=25
Additionally, there is a wide variety of weapon types with different purposes, unlike New Vegas where all weapons are just DPS and you just use your chose weapon type for all engagements. This, additionally, feeds into the survival horror aspect because you're managing ammunition.
>And i did finish the game but im struggling to remember a single side quest, they are that forgettable
That's because some of them are generated by A-life, but some aren't, and if you aren't exploring the world you won't see them. NPCs are scripted to seize certain tactically advantageous locations and ambush you. The world feels alive because the things you're doing aren't tied to a narrative, its more so "I'm going to go get this nearby stash, but oops, a ton of crazy shit happened and a giant firefight broke out between patrolling factions then mutants killed everyone." As the series progresses more unique sidequests are added in, like a bandit posing as an injured loner then ambushing you, but these are done so organically and naturally you can easily overlook them. The things you are complaining about are telling, its things like "why isn't there a cinematic storyline, why isnt the loot special" instead of "was this world interesting to navigate" or "was this stash a fun adventure to find".

>>717082542
>It's standard for western action oriented game
Literally what do you mean by this? Name your top 5 "action" games.

>>717082559
This is off topic but why do you have so many images and webms of little anime girls bro? Obviously you're got the tism and that sucks but do you have a normal life? Like a job, a gf, have you ever had sex? Do you have friends outside of discord, like real life friends? What compels you to watch little anime girls? Are you a pedophile?

>>717082612
* RPG action oriented

Forgot to add.

>>717082559
Hmm, I see, appreciate the explanations.
As i said i did enjoy Stalker, its a pretty good game. I just think i prefer Witcher 3 to it, but your posts about it are legitimate.

>>717082180
>Yakuza 0 which everybody circlejerks over
No one makes Yakuza threads constantly, so there's no reason to bother them. These threads have been made so much that someone is having a mental breakdown about me like this is some old dying /vg/ general. Also Yakuza has this:
https://youtu.be/_dOPdLmucJg
Whereas witcher is like... this
https://youtu.be/b0qo8QVnGAQ
Obviously I'm not cherry picking here because someone saw fit to label this video as BADASS even though its like a retarded Bioware cutscene.

At least Yakuza is a funny SEGA meme game.

>>717082669
Can we not draft the thread to meaningless name calling? debate the anon based on his arguments please.
Witcher 3 fans need to make a good case, this is making us look dumb.

>>717082891
>someone saw fit to label this video as BADASS
Also I just realized the person who owns the channel is a brown pajeetuber, so this played out basically perfectly

>>717082891
I mean what are you trying to prove here?
Yakuza had a cutscene, Witcher 3 had better cutscene so Yakuza is better?

Some people enjoy videogames, others sit and seethe for 10 years

>>717082891
Sure, but you should realize Witcher 3 gets Spammed with hate threads while Yakuza doesn't, when haters never shut up about the game it compels fanboys to respond. Its a two way street bro.

Also Yakuza has the same issues as Witcher 3 but nobody calls it out, it has a lame skill tree, shit combat, bad quests and quest rewards, clunky and unresponsive controls and shallow rpg elements, it also has far lower enemy variety, its even worse.

Its also a cutscene riddled game but even worse you get zero control over the cutscene you just watch the game flip and flop back and forth between a cutscene and a standing talking faces with dialogue boxes that has padded out exposition text that treats you like a retard.

Worst of all the game has shit writing and has plot issues every chapter, characters get rewritten, asspulls every twist, it keeps bringing back characters from the dead in a cheap shock factor bait, the pacing is awful, characterization is barely thought about, the side quests are just meme with zero thought or genuine depth.

And ofcourse the presentation is ass, game looks subpar and its animation, sound mixing and directing are several tiers below Witcher 3 or Cyberpunk.

Yet it gets zero criticism, everyone sucks its dick because funny kiryu and majima or something.

>>717082891
>lolinigger posting two cutscenes
>Japan good, Poland bad
Kek.

>>717083059
>Witcher 3 had better cutscene
What's better about it? Its a bunch of reused animations which don't even match up with the scene and its full of obnoxious modern body language like bobbing they're head around and shit. Like the guard literally does pic related lol

>>717073018 (OP)
Not even the best game of 2015.

>>717083172
>Witcher 3 gets Spammed with hate threads
No it doesn't. One retard makes bait threads on RPGs every single day because he wants the catalogue to be full of these games. None of these threads are genuine. Not a single person is making threads about a game they hate. And then you, being a witcher fan, have an IQ of 30 or less, so you reply to every single thread the same exact way endlessly. This isn't a discussion, its totally one sided. None of your input has been valuable.

kino...

>>717083382
>This isn't a discussion, its totally one sided.
Correct, you are literally retarded.

>>717083172
>the presentation is ass, game looks subpar and its animation, sound mixing and directing are several tiers below Witcher 3 or Cyberpunk
Huh?
https://youtu.be/6uS8qpgnhhk
You can't possibly think these models are animated worth than Witcher 3, that's literally insane. I don't even like this game and I think that's a retarded argument to make.

>>717083631
>animated worth
animated worse

GODitcher 3....

oops i took this mutation now my new game plus death march level scaling combat is irrelevant

>>717082891
>No one makes Yakuza threads constantl
lol
lmao even

Gwent... my beloved...

>>717084264
Alchemy is broken anyway

>>717073018 (OP)
V/ealtalk, are the side quests tied to the main quest in a artisan way or not? If not, why is the game considered among the best rpg?

>>717084581
You get dudes from side quests in Kaer Morhen when you're preparing for the final battle, I think

>>717084581
Side quests don't directly relate to the main story in the vast majority of cases, but they do frame the current events in a way that helps make the setting seem more believable to sell you the world.

ER has better bosses, map and combat
KCD is more immersive and has more interesting side quests
DD is a better action rpg
RDR2 has a lot more lived in beautiful world
like a dragon has more interesting characters
TES has more freedom

>>717084872
LMAO.

>>717084872
And none of them have it all in one package like W3 :)

>>717084989
agreed TW3 is pretty good game with shit combat and shallow mechanics

>>717084934
care to elaborate?

>>717073018 (OP)
replaying right now. put like 100 mods into next gen version (only vanilla stuff and fixes), found out it runs like hot shit, you have to use mandatory dlss and the only better thing is water so I went back to old gen and put the same mods in it again. now Im running everything on ultra, pc is quiet and let me tell you, it still looks pretty

>>717085171
>it runs like hot shit

I have 4070s and runs at 60fps 4k easily on ultra or 120fps on 1440p ultra +. Game is well optimized you are just poor.

>>717085171
>100 mods to look worse than 10 year old unmodded games
https://youtu.be/h8VZhRBc6sw

>>717085527
This blurfest is supposed to look better than Witcher 3?

>>717085527
>cinematic movie
>5 years ago
>more moeshit for pedophiles
Neck yourself troon.

>>717085473
3070, next gen ran on high, no ray tracing, 60 fps 1440p. but again, had to be dlss, colors were muted (just next gen things) and gpu usage was like 80% - compared to old gen with 40% gpu usage all on ultra and more pedestrians. my choice was easy

>>717085527
you cant fucking read can you. the only modded thing on my picture are the clouds, rest of the mods are cut content and fixes

>>717085590
Yes?

>>717083065
Some people play bad videogames, others sit and play good games for 10 years.

skyrim with worse combat, worse open world, worse exploration, worse POIs, worse loot, worse crafting, worse leveling, worse skills, worse weapons, worse armor, worse npcs

>>717085527
This reminds me of how shitty and fake forests look in witcher.

>>717073018 (OP)
>This still hasn't been surpassed by any game
As far as third person narrative action RPGs i would agree. But i personally don't like to compare videogames from different gerned to one another since different types of games aim for different things.

>>717085857
>third person narrative action RPGs
lol

>>717085890
Yes? This is what The Witcher 3 is.

>>717079107
cope mutt

>>717086126
>Yes? This is what The Witcher 3 is.
lol

>>717073018 (OP)
Tell me about it xister!

>>717079107
>

>>717086126
youre acting just like elder scrolls morons who pretend their game exists in such a narrow genre that it cant be compared to anything else when its really the most generic one size fits all game ever

>>717085724
How so?

>>717086246
man i dont think this is even a human skull shape, why is his head so pointy

>>717073018 (OP)
True.

>>717084627
Right, at that point of the game I just rushed to the ending. Lost interest. Can't pinpoint why exactly.
>>717084785
Indeed, so they rather tie into the world or rather current events as you put it. More games should incorporate this.
>>717084989
Unironically, yes.

>>717086283
This upset me

>>717087237
>Lost interest
Too many sidequests, after which point you pick up the story again and haven't heard a peep about it in like 20 game hours so you stop giving a fuck. Many such cases in RPGs

>>717083631
The cutscene and its directing is far superior in Witcher 3 than that to Yakuza 0, not sure about Judgement because i didn't play it.

Look at Hearts of Stone, its directed like a B film (B=middle budget) and it shows, meanwhile you have a game like Yakuza 0 with presentation that is very inconsistent, often flip floping between talking faces and actual cutscene, takes you out of the tension that happens back to a static talking face scene with keyboard dialogue box sound, Witcher 3 cinematics is on par with movie games despite being open world with choices all the way through its cutscenes. not to mention the much better writing too.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YEibBLiR574

>>717083382
>o it doesn't. One retard makes bait threads on RPGs every single day because he wants the catalogue to be full of these games
If you have a proof i will admit defeat and shut up.

I told you Witcher 3 had a dedictated subreddit to hating it 24/7 every normalfag ever complains about the combat, every Rockstard fangay cries about how RDR2 is so much better (its not) and yet nobody mentions a thing about yakuza 0, you have to dig so deep in the internet to find a negative review about it.

>>717073092
fippy bippy

>>717087517
>The cutscene and its directing is far superior in Witcher 3
Anon, theres a whole ass video with a bunch of cutscenes here >>717082891 where it shows its not "directed" at all and its just franticly cutting between characters like a visual novel. you've got multiple people shitting on you now, just let it go. you lost this one.

TEN (10) years of SEETHE

Who gives a fuck about Yakuza lmao

>>717087871
weebs

>>717073018 (OP)
Why is /v/ full of shitty threads like this now? No one talks about real video games any more. What website can I do that on?

>>717086283
Glad I killed her. Always thought she looks off. Brushed it away as they used slav cgi models.

>>717087447
It's true. W3 is a check list game. Illusion of choice is big in w3, too. It's clear that their dialogue let's you belive your choice mattered, when in fact, it didn't. Big immersion breaker for me. When the fat guy died, I looked up all the possible outcomes.
>heh

>Hearts of Stone
some of the best storytelling in games

>Blood and Wine
THE best gaming world ever made

>>717077308
The way Polish is structured as a language allows for a crazy variety of slurs, and there's definitely many more words and variations in Polish and likely most slavic languages than English, some of them funny, and Witcher (both books and games in their original localization) use that really well. As a poorlack I always lament that people who enjoy witcher and don't know Polish will always receive a slightly worse version of it. Being fluent in both languages I really see how much the series gains from the expression allowed by the Polish language.
Not to say Witcher's horrible in english (unless you play witcher 1, then install the mod that fixes the fucking dogshit rushed english translation subtitles) but after playing W3 both in Polish and English the latter being when streaming for 'murican friends the difference is great.
Thanks for subscribing to my blog

>>717087990
Witcher isn't a real videogame?
Have you tried gatcha themed subreddits.

>>717088213
Personally I am of the opinion that a choice matters for you having made it. For example the murdering cat Witcher guy who never shows up again whether you let him go or kill him, it's still a moral decision you made

>>717088416
>slightly worse
Might even be worse than translated anime. I studied with a poolack and he explained this in detail to me. You can't possibly translate so many details. Polish is among the most nuanced languages iirc.

>>717088416
>there's definitely many more words and variations in Polish and likely most slavic languages than English
Uhhh, this is factually incorrect. Webster has 470k words, the Polush equivalent 145k.

>>717088556
>that a choice matters for you having made it.
This is obviously true, yet devs do exploit this. Looking outcomes up, just to see that devs de facto lied to you sours the experience pretty much. I might be wrong, but games have too many text(s) and too many spoken words. I'd rather have the quantity reduced by 2/3 and the quality multiplied times three. Too much asked for, it seems.

>>717088745
This is the most severely retarded post I have read all day.

>>717088909
>you now remember when Walking Dead was new and we actually thought KENNY WILL REMEMBER THIS was real and not a lie

>>717088772
I meant slurs in particular, see pic related. This is the equivalent of 'fucking' which can mean all of these different things when properly used, and the Witcher series uses that really well. Obviously, for a polish series. Thanks to that you can write crude and crass characters in a multitute of ways without it seeming repetetive and making some sentences admittedly funny. It's as >>717088745 said but I don't know how well that compares to translated anime as I don't speak nippon so I always watch with eng subs.

>Choices don’t matter
Like, what do you want, dude? every NPC to hand you some Macguffin for saving their crops? Or for each one you save to give you a blowjob three times throughout the story?

Can’t you just help somebody because it’s the nice thing to do, or because it’s interesting to figure out?
Can’t you roleplay as someone kind, or just curious? You guys have no sense of immersion.

>>717089064
>every NPC to hand you some Macguffin for saving their crops
Yes.
>Or for each one you save to give you a blowjob three times throughout the story?
That too.

>>717073092
Facts

>>717073850
Unironically.

>>717088982
Gotcha. I have heard our swearing too is absolutely baby level, with Russians taking 2nd no one coming close to the Italians.

>>717080524
>She was THE gaming waifu when the game came out.
she still is !

>>717084989
>And none of them have it all in one package like W3 :)
And that's a good thing. When a game tries being good at so many things it often ends up being mediocre or worse. Cyberpunk 2077 is the prime example of this. It tries to be a car game, a RPG with deep and meaningful choices, a FPS with action-packed gunplay, a stealth game with different ways of approaching situations, a cinematic crime story, etc. etc. However, it fails on pretty much all fronts and just ends up being a pretty "meh" game. I'd pick Deus Ex: Mankind Divided over it any day of the week, and that game still has major flaws.

>>717090494
What's the best RPG with deep and meaningful choices? This isn't a way to gotcha you or something, I wanna play some RPGs

>>717090578
baldurs gate 3 is unironically the most reactive game out there

>>717090578
Baldur's Gate 3.

>>717090810
Guess I'll go play BG 1 and 2 then

>>717088982
I learned it by myself and eventually learned that the translations are really nothing else than fanfic. Soka, domo and hai are constantly overinterpreted. Every now and then anon posts here how the ff games are badly translated. This holds true for all Japanese translations.

>>717090494
Going first person was their first (lol) mistake. It's like bg3, they should've never choose resting as plot advancement.

>>717090494
> I'd pick Deus Ex: Mankind Divided over it any day of the week
unfortunately for you not many would hence why one studio went bankrupt and the other is bigger than ever

Ciri is SHIT.

>>717090578
Wasteland 3, no idea why this didnt get more hype, especially after BG3.
With goid intentions I recreated all the mistakes of the Iraq War, I can no longer talk shit about Dick Cheyne. It was such an eye opening experience to learn from. Love that game.

>>717091326
Should I play the first 2? I've read nothing but negative reviews of them in the past

>>717091402
I didnt

Kino dialogue and characters like the bloody baron and djikstra

just cant bring myself to play that shitty combat anymore. love cyberpunk combat though so it seems i dont quite like sword based combat games

>>717091108
>unfortunately for you not many would
Is this supposed to be an own? Some of the most critically acclaimed games flopped. Are you going to start playing FiFa and Madden because they're popular?

>>717091827
Read the books, Dijkstra is my favorite character in them

>>717091827
Djikstra is a fag.

>>717075364
i liked ff7r for this. w3s story is obv superior but the combat there was better for me.

>>717087760
You completely missed the point.
Witcher 3 directing is consistent, it follows a formula that allows you to be interactive during its presentation, this is done while keeping the same animation and cutscene quality as you find during a movie game, and at the same time its consistent throught the game even with side quests.
Meanwhile Yakuza 0 is a game that keeps flip flopping between static talking face and an actual cutscene, the directing is bad because of this.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SlXSxy5G-fw

Witcher 3 has a much better cinematics and presentation because its directing is more consistent.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d8gQ0vcKgWU

This is much better, the tension keeps flowing and not cut to serve a talking head box of dialogue.

This interaction is visual novel tier: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qVBqw1eYdOE
one face at a time

Meanwhile this is one of the best romance cutscenes in gaming up to this date.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0eU8HsIRaE


Its clear how much better W3 presentation is, cutscenes are much more natural, and more interconnected with the dialogue and how you play the game.

I dont think i need to point out how retarded the writing in Yakuza 0 was, the game is filled with plot holes its not even funny.
Witcher 3 is much more coherent with its writing because it takes its audience seriously and respects their intelligence.

>>717091847
You can also add rage 2 to that picture, wasn't a master piece but it was a really fun game, better than doom really

>>717091881
i see. i never read the books so good recommendation. will check it out

>>717092742
nta but are there many movie games with this kind of directing during cutscenes? I love how the camera pans during the regular dialog. true cinema kino

only other one i can think of is mass effect 2. - that was true cinema kino as well

>>717073092
BASED

>>717092747
cmon, be serious. rage 2 is shit and is a downgrade from rage 1 and even that was far from good

>>717090494
>Deus Ex: Mankind Divided

MD has the same problems that plague Yakuza 0, its directing is very shit, it keeps flip flopping on itself and the result is less tension and all the stakes are gone.

At least MD has good level design and a skill tree that can be called a skill tree but beyond that its significantly worse than Cyberpunk 2077 and its a disgrace compared to the OG game that came 25 years ago.

I find it funny how CDPR writers who are Polish can write better (English stories) than North American writers who are English, this shit is so funny bro

>>717073018 (OP)
woke garbage

>>717073018 (OP)
too bad the graphical update raped it

>>717092891
Yes
Mafia a game released in 2001 or something has better directing than Yakuza 0.

Mafia Lost City of Haven is not just better directed than Yakuza, its also better written.
Graphics are outdated but everything else that is narrative related is well made.

>>717093502
Mafia 1 remake is better. Sorry

>>717093783
oh i already played that recently. excited for the next one releasing next week iirc

But it's not exactly a good game
The dialogue is fun, the world is beautiful, side quests have more depth than the main story, but the combat is abysmally boring
At some point I just dropped the difficulty to the lowest and ran through the tedious battle sections so that I could get to the fun bits of exploring the world and doing witcher work aka detective shit.

There are myriad games I would rather play over and over again than pick up TW3 again. If you have no such games, you haven't played many games in your life.

>>717094075
You're talking about it 10 years after its release. Cope however you want

>>717091827
>djikstra going full retard out of nowhere due to dev team crunch

>>717094075
If you are a gameplay person and you say Witcher 3 is not a good game thats fine, just dont go around pretending RDR2, Yakuza and Silent Hill 2 are god tier games. okay?

>>717094176
what the fuck is that even supposed to mean
I played it when it was "new" and I played the DLC's when they came out, hasn't changed how I feel about it. I would never replay Witcher 1 or 2 either. They're perfect for one playthrough and then never again.
>>717094534
I never have. RDR2 is boring dredge with a beautiful world. It's good for exploring the landscape but there's not much in terms of "gameplay".
Yakuza is literal fucking minigames - the game, with low quality hack and slash sections.
I don't play tank control slop. I play RTS, roguelikes, TDs, ARPGs etc.

>>717095760
AYO THIS NIGGA GOT AUTISM

>>717095820
Don't reply to post you haven't read, shitflinging retard.

>>717073092
modded skyrim is better*

>>717074403
Why is the combat bad exactly?

>>717095968
can polish that turd however much you want. It will still be shit

>>717092742
Pretty much this. Yakuza 0 isn't bad game, it has strong story parts, but what you forgot it's how the pacing is constantly off and how much pointless conversation it has. In Witcher 3 you feel like every dialogue bring something important, in Yakuza 0 characters repeat the same shit over and over and talk about their feelings for hours. This isn't only a problem with Yakuza, but for many Japanese games from Atlus or Falcom for example. Many times, they are also extremely kitschy and cringe with characters overacting. I think I'm just too old for Japanese writing

>>717093268
>MD has the same problems that plague Yakuza 0, its directing is very shit, it keeps flip flopping on itself and the result is less tension and all the stakes are gone.
No one plays MD for the story. It's the level design and gameplay that make it enjoyable.
>At least MD has good level design and a skill tree that can be called a skill tree
Congratulations, you just found out why people enjoy the game!
>its significantly worse than Cyberpunk 2077
In what ways? MD has an actual inventory, far superior level design, no slop open world, more memorable side quests, better weapon modifications, superior gadgets, etc.
>and its a disgrace compared to the OG game that came 25 years ago.
You can argue about that but the OG Deus Ex also had its fair share of rough edges.
>I find it funny how CDPR writers who are Polish can write better (English stories) than North American writers who are English, this shit is so funny bro
Once again, no one plays MD for the story. Even people who love the game hate on the cliffhanger ending (though to be fair Squeenix is partially to blame for that).

>>717073092
Played both recently and I can say no, no it's not.

>>717073018 (OP)
True.

>>717095820
Kek.

>>717075565
retard

>>717073018 (OP)
I will never play this shit because the combat looks gay and jank. Once you plays a souls like or a hack and slash this type of shit is unenjoyable.

I'm playing through it for the second time right now after having read all 8 books + replayed 1 and 2 again.

First time I played it, I went in totally blind.

So interesting to play it again as a full /witcher head/.

Some things are even more impressive about Witcher 3 a decade later, some things are disappointing.

Like the sound mixing and implementation, so surprised no one mentions this ever, it's literally one of the worst things about the game, the music is so static, and rarely changes to fit the mood of conversations, and it's so fucking loud. Hearing the gwent music blaring talking to Priscilla or Triss in Novigrad about the Witch Hunters or some other dark and serious conversation is so fucking dumb lol.

Luckily Cyberpunk doesn't have this issue at all, so they learned.

>>717098630
>2025
>using HDR

>>717098685
>yes

>>717098630
>complaining about witcher music
you the dumbest gorilla in this thread

>>717080321
You sound like you got filtered in Elden Ring.

>>717073092
dogshit game, the worst TES by a mile

>>717084872
wrong on all accounts

>>717096012
You will never get a coherent answer beyond "its shit"

>>717098802
I'm not complaining about the music itself retard-kun, just the sound mixing and the way it's implemented and the un-dynamic nature of it

>>717098584
What's so fantastic in souls combat? I mean, it's better than Witcher 3 but doesn't really blow it away. Almost every boss and enemy is circle around and roll until he make move than attack with same move and over. It's not really that masterpiece.

>>717084872
>KCD has more interesting side quests

What do you mean by more interesting side quests? Can you give examples?

>>717099008
>>717099083

Having played recently, I think W3 combat is decent, but the main problem is that the enemies move sets are so extremely fucking predictable, that even using mods to speed up their attack animations doesn't make it any harder really.

It makes me appreciate Fromshit so much more, the amount of fine-tuning to make interesting and challenging enemies to fight takes so much work, it makes sense that's those games main focus, not suprising that W3 couldn't and doesn't decidate their entire dev cycle to crafting attacks for drowners.

But it makes it so that the game becomes incredibly easy no matter what really, not sure how to make it harder

Like the black knights from DS1 have a more challenging moveset than almost anything in witcher 3

Comfy thread.

>>717099083
Souls combat is simplistic and basic, its not deep but normalfags heard about the Souls games being LE HARDCORE so they made it their personality to finish the game and once you finish the game you get the "Finished Souls Game Award" and now you are Elite gamer who gets to shit talk LE CASULS

It doesn't matter that the combat is basic and most enemies are a variation of the same thing, like yeah the enemy design is better than Witcher and the game is more challenging which leads to a more satisfying victory, but i mean ok, Witcher 3 was never about that?

Try doing this with Final Fantasy 7 and Persona 5, super popular JRPGs, tell the fans that these games have worse turnbased combat than lets say Xcom2, nobody fucking cares, other games are brought up only to shit on Witcher 3 and Cyberpunk.

Technically Final Fantasy 16 combat looks more competent than Witcher 3 but i enjoyed playing Witcher 3 more, games like Dragons Dogma and FF16 despite their combat being better they shove hoards of similar enemies down your throat to the point you grew tired of it, encounter design matters.

bump.

>>717076498
kinda, it's not following plot of any particular book

>>717076542
again, only some background information that devs could get from folklore

>>717098839
>I don't disagree that its better than witcher 3 though

>>717098584
>you can't enjoy anything else in witcher once you've played a souls or action game
I didn't know I was solely obsessed with combat to the exclusion of everything else, thanks for that insight about myself anon.

Base game alone is amazing but with the addition of two of the best DLCs I've ever played it might very well be my favourite game

I've reinstalled because of this thread but instantly remembered everything that happens in this game and already got bored in White Orchard.

>>717100842
kek

>>717101318
Its a boring game to replay, but its a good game to play one time.

>>717075425
> Literally every single RPG does this

They all suck ass at it.

>>717101394
Yes, it was a fantastic adventure when I played it for the first time.

>>717101318
White Orchard is a pretty boring starting area, it's worse than the opening of Witcher 2 for sure, and maybe worse than the opening village of Witcher 1.

>>717099221
Geralt is basically a stoic demon who can slaughter 30 men without breaking a sweat or feeling anything. That creates some distance between the player and the storyline. But in KCD, Henry being a bumpkin makes things matter a lot more
whether it's helping out an old prostitute or stealing money from a guard
also a lot more comedic value

>>717101506
In retrospect, it seems pretty insane to even make a tutorial zone. Like players wouldn't understand that they can run to a question mark on the map to clear a copypasted monster nest if they didn't first do it in a smaller world?

I got to the third fight and realized I would not like playing this game. Is the story really worth it? I might bump it down to easy mode and see the story through.

Blood and Wine was so KINO bros........

>>717101768
>the vineyard
>toussaint
>the fairy tale world
complete and utter KINO

>>717101768
https://youtu.be/Vt5Mxm7BPhM?si=x2A6pYN6hkxkI9V8
Listen to this accordion. Fucking majestic.

>>717101528
Relateable you mean? Either way I find KCD's writing to be mediocre and its highs are presented between Henry and Hans.

There's really nothing that stands out in terms of quests in KCD for me. Certainly not like Baron or Heart of stone did.

>>717101616
>Is the story really worth it?
The first third-ish is pretty good purely because of the characters and not the actual overarching story but it nosedives hard after that imo. In the next third of the game the side quests are cool if you find the setting itself interesting but if not there's really not much to enjoy as far main story goes. It just kind of meanders from that point onwards then in the last third it becomes really bad.

>>717096012
>>717099008
>>717099256
the biggest problem is that early game is just rolling around and hitting stuff, it gets more fun when you unlock new abilities but that takes like 50 hours

https://youtu.be/mVKPvspyyyQ?si=6OYOowfEYIGkRhxv
You did fight Olgierd? Right?

>>717102154
ig we appreciate different things.
geralt being "no fucks given" guy just messes things up for me

the man who was cucked to death kwaboty

>>717102562
>not being a bro and letting him kill the foid
NGMI.

>>717102121
I think that's a hurdy gurdy.

>>717098630
by default I could barely hear the voices over the soundtrack, and the prerendered cutscenes are insanely quiet.

cyberpunk is actually superior to w3 but the latter had more positive sentiment at launch and people who experience games mostly via hearsay are confused about it

>>717102706
>if hes cucked then you have to protect the whore from him
why not both

>>717102904
Witcher 3 doesn't have Keanu Reeves yapping in your ear every 5 minutes automatically making it superior to Cyberpunk

>>717085171
The next gen update is hot garbage so yeah. It was perfectly patched and optimized before and they fucked it up.

>>717073018 (OP)
Nigga please. I like it but pretending it's anything else besides an engaging RPG with incredible production is for tourists.

>go on bro, give her a big kiss
What would you do in this scenario?

>>717098584
>EVERY GAME SHOULD BE SOMETHING I KNOW.
kys

>>717102494
https://youtu.be/ljExTEPNFnM?si=qxlCf6WEwGSESzZL&t=100

>>717078979
going from the bleakness of HoS to this was peak comfy kino

Is he retarded
>dude Nilfgard will totally bring back termeria...

sucks since he's such a BRO in Witcher 2.... but in this game Dijkstra was totally in the right to kill him and Ves

>>717078979
Corvo Bianco......home.

>>717102154
KCD won me over with the cutscene were Henry learns how to read and write. Its such a beatiful moment. Kino and lvdo.

Finally finished main game, HoS and B&W after all these years. What do next?
>clean up sidequests, treasure hunts, etc.
>NG+
>new game with different build

i never played blood and wine even though i consider w3 to be in my top 5 greatest games of all time

should i do it?
1. replay the entire game and then play blood and wine as the last thing
2. directly jump into blood and wine using quickstart

>>717103270
He's also barely in the game in the first place

>>717103492
replaying w3 allows you have more fun

>>717103492
>Should I play one of the best DLCs of all time to one of my favourite games of all time?

>>717103449
>webm
>magic's gone

>>717073018 (OP)
I've played both TW3 and Expedition and holy shit - TW3 mogs the hell out of the latter.
Pole writers are so much more talented, TW3 dialogues read like Shakespeare in comparison to Expedition ones.

>>717104039
rent-free

This is the taste of Witcher 3 haters.

Absolute garbage

https://backloggd.com/u/gx690/
https://backloggd.com/u/VHCOYS/
https://backloggd.com/u/Haagenth/
https://backloggd.com/u/drewboss77/

>>717104039
sorry to say lil bro but us witcher bros enjoy expedition aswell

european KINGS stay winning

>>717103015
most people arent racist towards keanu reeves

>>717073092
/thread

>>717104294
Why do people use this horrid site?

>>717104651
No idea, it filled with Turks and Brazilians.

No matter what you say, 18 years later and this game still relevant.

>>717104651
It's the perfect tool for zoomers
>make a record of what you're playing so you can show it off online, because nothing counts unless you post it on social media
>can see what is currently popular so you can absolutely make sure you only play popular games and don't have to experience FOMO

Witcher 3: 1/10
Assassin's Creed Black Flag: 10/10

Bravo anon

https://backloggd.com/u/Wilhemburg/

>>717104761
I can't tell if the website is so shit it doesn't have basic language filters or if it's genuinely 30% spics.

>>717073018 (OP)
This game sucks, it was surpassed even by cp77. Witcher 3 has shit gameplay so there's no point to playing it

>>717104843
Exactly, its filled with 15-20 year old drooling over their slop, i kid you not, its full of these kids and they shit talk popular games and think Disco Elysium is the greatest game of all time.

Its retarded

>>717105208
>and think Disco Elysium is the greatest game of all time
It is.

>>717105275
Disco Elysium is no more than a 7/10 game and thats on a good day and if we are being generous.

>>717105358
theres no game with better writing

>>717105208
>>717105275
>>717105418
its a visual novel, not a game.

>>717105418
Why didnt the white soldiers throw a bomb on their enemies instead of shooting and missing their attacks conveniently?

ARGHHHH Witcher 3 BAD BAD

My favorite game, its Assassin's Creed Black Flag Ayooooo

If all Witcher 3 haters were like the loli avatar fag i would be fine with it, but they are literally disingenuous retard stinky fucks, so i will always disrespect them and their opinions

>>717106036
That avatarfag claims CSGO among his favorite games btw

>>717106193
I'm fine with it, he is consistent.
CSGO is probably the best pvp shooter game currently.

>>717105809
Typically theres existing game franchise fans who have critiques like:
"w3 isnt dark souls, wtf. I wanted dark souls, w3 sucks at being dark souls"
"w3 isnt GTA, wtf. Wheres all the police chases???? What the fuck is cdpr even trying to accomplish here?"
"w3 isn't Skyrim, cdpr should be making a bethesda game instead of something good"

Besides the "cdpr isnt another studio Im a fan of" theres no big critiques.

>>717106239
He's not consistent at all. He cries constantly about console games but has many console games on his 10x10. Yes a fucking 10x10.

>>717073018 (OP)
where's the soul though?

>>717106420
you only like w1 because it takes 10% as long to finish as w3 and the ease of replaying it makes you mistake the multiple times experience same content as being more memorable

>>717106420
Are you excited for the Dawnwalker game?

>>717106582
Damn I always thought I liked it because I randomly picked it up in a store in 2008 and loved it. My bad

>>717106330
He also complains about Redditors while having BG3 on his grid.

>>717106687
so you played it in 2008 and never replayed it since

>>717106239
>CSGO is probably the best pvp shooter game currently.
Tarkov moggs the shit out of that normie slop.

why even make it a "rpg" at all if you can't even do anything drastic or out of character?

>>717106740
I replayed it twice since then. Why are you flailing wildly trying to le epically own me?

>>717106682
yes because it feels like witcher 1

>>717106910
retard

>>717106330
Many? most of his games are PC games, what games are you referring to?

>>717106813
CSGO has much better map design.

>>717106962
>Demon's Souls
>Sekiro
>Devil May Cry 5
>God Hand
>Resident Evil 1
>Ape Escape 2
>Donkey Kong Country
>Duck Tales
>Tomba

>>717106818
The entire game you make moral choices that there is no clear answer to. Whether to release the tree spirit or do the lady of the woods bidding. Whether to kill the Cat school Witcher. Who to put on the throne of Skellige. Whether to let a tricked werewolf take revenge on who wronged him, etc

There are moral choices in this game that to this day people still are having debates on what the "right" thing to do is.

In that way the Witcher games are basically like a fantasy Star Trek, examining "what if" moral questions through a high fantasy setting. To me and I think lots of other people that is far more interesting than sandbox RPGs getting to make your character a purple orc with le silly face and le silly name or whatever the fuck elder scrolls shit is

Fucking hated this game

>>717102121
Time to replay it.

>released 10 years ago
Bros....

>>717102121
SOVL.

bump.

>>717096087
nah there's still not a single open world adventure RPG better than Skyrim with Ordinator and Apocalypse

>>717111157
Yes there is

>>717073018 (OP)
after it hardly but before it there are tons of better games.

>>717079880
>40 awful daily threads being wiped from the catalogue.
You know what? You're right. I can look at the catalog right now and it's full of the same shitty rpg generals that have been up for months. And it's all a handful of idiots meekly bumping them.

>>717112450
Retard.

>>717073018 (OP)
It played through it. It was a good run. 60 hours on record on Steam, for 60 USD.
But I never replayed it. Every time I try to, it feels like a chore.
It was a good story. But it failed as a video game for me.

It's just that : good.
Good, but not excellent. And surely not the best.

(The gwent minigame was a nice touch. But it wasn't good enough to make play the CCG they released later)

>>717108056
>To me and I think lots of other people that is far more interesting than sandbox RPGs getting to make your character a purple orc with le silly face and le silly name or whatever the fuck elder scrolls shit is
bg3 is literally that and sold like crazy

>>717073092
Not even remotely true.

>>717111776
ok name em
>le witcher
Can only start in one place as the same guy every time

Its one of he best games of all time just by making tranime anons seethe

>>717113726
I personally never absorb that much/forget stuff from a game I played the replaying after a year or two doesnt feel bad at all.

it prob changes a lot between people or depends on autism

>>717113943
BG3 is the most reactive RPG out there, you can cope however you want.

>>717073092
Played both recently and I can say yes, yes it is.