Search Results
7/14/2025, 12:27:46 AM
>>531111786
>a single weapon choice doesn't discount literally everything else in the design
Toby could have just made The Black Knife be the sword it's supposed to be the whole time, but instead he chose to have The Knight very conspicuously hold out a baseball bat for you to stare at for three seconds every time you restart the fight. The bat is the most significant element of The Knight's design and is undeniable proof of their strong direct connection to December.
Combined with the reindeer antlers and deer skull, and the abundance of contextual evidence setting up Dess in Chapter 3, we have proof beyond a reasonable doubt that The Knight is a member of the Holiday family and with further examination we can determine that Dess is the only viable candidate among them.
>a single weapon choice doesn't discount literally everything else in the design
Toby could have just made The Black Knife be the sword it's supposed to be the whole time, but instead he chose to have The Knight very conspicuously hold out a baseball bat for you to stare at for three seconds every time you restart the fight. The bat is the most significant element of The Knight's design and is undeniable proof of their strong direct connection to December.
Combined with the reindeer antlers and deer skull, and the abundance of contextual evidence setting up Dess in Chapter 3, we have proof beyond a reasonable doubt that The Knight is a member of the Holiday family and with further examination we can determine that Dess is the only viable candidate among them.
7/13/2025, 7:00:27 AM
>>715326521
>He's operating in secret because the Dark World situation is extremely fragile and he doesn't want to initiate the Roaring by making Dark Worlds common knowledge.
This is not at all an adequate explanation for why he couldn't have just came home earlier than expected and live in his house with his co-conspirator sibling which would enable them to coordinate anything they're doing much more effectively. Asriel being home from college a week early would not cause The Roaring.
>He is motivated to engage in dangerous and reckless activity by his grief over Dess's disappearance
I'm sure Asriel was as upset at everyone else when it happened but we also have reason to believe he moved on. He dated other girls since Dess and there's no sign of Dess in his room, in contrast to Dess's room still having Asriel's things.
>Toby is surprising you by pointing to a new and interesting character so he can pull the rug out with "lol it's Asriel again"
Fortunately Toby Fox is a better writer than you
>He's operating in secret because the Dark World situation is extremely fragile and he doesn't want to initiate the Roaring by making Dark Worlds common knowledge.
This is not at all an adequate explanation for why he couldn't have just came home earlier than expected and live in his house with his co-conspirator sibling which would enable them to coordinate anything they're doing much more effectively. Asriel being home from college a week early would not cause The Roaring.
>He is motivated to engage in dangerous and reckless activity by his grief over Dess's disappearance
I'm sure Asriel was as upset at everyone else when it happened but we also have reason to believe he moved on. He dated other girls since Dess and there's no sign of Dess in his room, in contrast to Dess's room still having Asriel's things.
>Toby is surprising you by pointing to a new and interesting character so he can pull the rug out with "lol it's Asriel again"
Fortunately Toby Fox is a better writer than you
7/9/2025, 6:19:19 PM
7/1/2025, 9:29:34 AM
>>714150030
Why are you assuming that Carol not being the Knight makes her not the mastermind?
Why are you assuming that Carol not being the Knight makes her not the mastermind?
6/29/2025, 6:02:55 AM
>>713951408
The "helmet" is clearly fused and melded to their skull given how it changes shape along with their entire body and can completely split open to reveal what is obviously a deer's skull when they "roar"
The evidence that it's a "helmet" also comes from a sequence where we try to imagine what The Knight is doing and then Kris makes us think about Jockington instead, describing him in a nest with his "eggs" which are soccer balls. Does Jockington lay soccer ball eggs? Is The Knight really wearing a helmet?
Seems to me like the simplest explanation is that they're just a fucking deer
The "helmet" is clearly fused and melded to their skull given how it changes shape along with their entire body and can completely split open to reveal what is obviously a deer's skull when they "roar"
The evidence that it's a "helmet" also comes from a sequence where we try to imagine what The Knight is doing and then Kris makes us think about Jockington instead, describing him in a nest with his "eggs" which are soccer balls. Does Jockington lay soccer ball eggs? Is The Knight really wearing a helmet?
Seems to me like the simplest explanation is that they're just a fucking deer
6/28/2025, 9:50:36 AM
>>529120252
>Chapter 5 - King Asgore and "Flowey" (Asgore + Omega Flowey)
>Chapter 6 - DECEMBER HOLIDAY (ASRIEL DREEMURR)
>Chapter 7 - ???
>Chapter 5 - King Asgore and "Flowey" (Asgore + Omega Flowey)
>Chapter 6 - DECEMBER HOLIDAY (ASRIEL DREEMURR)
>Chapter 7 - ???
6/23/2025, 1:29:43 AM
>>528454648
>you also get the weird wind blowing shit from the bunker and around the holiday mansion during the exit scene.
Wow you're saying a motif relevant to two locations explicitly connected with the Holidays is also connected to The Knight?
Very interesting!
>you also get the weird wind blowing shit from the bunker and around the holiday mansion during the exit scene.
Wow you're saying a motif relevant to two locations explicitly connected with the Holidays is also connected to The Knight?
Very interesting!
6/21/2025, 2:13:12 AM
>>528213071
Sorry chuddy but her pronouns are "they/it"
Sorry chuddy but her pronouns are "they/it"
6/15/2025, 5:16:28 AM
>>712693898
>Speculation
It's completely certain, but sure. Why are you expecting the twist identity of the main antagonist to already be revealed only halfway through the story?
>What happened to her after she got dragged into the bunker.
I don't know anon, we're going to find out later.
>For what?
Because she knows one of the codes to enter the Shelter. Toriel was being targeted because she also knows one of the codes.
They also mention something about "police sacrifice" in Chapter 4.
>The soul still controls Kris, we should know what happened.
How would you know what happened when you weren't looking?
>It's just bad story writing
Why do you think Ralsei would want you to know?
>Speculation
It's completely certain, but sure. Why are you expecting the twist identity of the main antagonist to already be revealed only halfway through the story?
>What happened to her after she got dragged into the bunker.
I don't know anon, we're going to find out later.
>For what?
Because she knows one of the codes to enter the Shelter. Toriel was being targeted because she also knows one of the codes.
They also mention something about "police sacrifice" in Chapter 4.
>The soul still controls Kris, we should know what happened.
How would you know what happened when you weren't looking?
>It's just bad story writing
Why do you think Ralsei would want you to know?
6/15/2025, 12:36:04 AM
Page 1