Search Results
7/26/2025, 6:48:25 PM
>>532773926
Funny how you just discard the canon that you dislike and validate the canon that you like, as if it's not completely arbitrary.
No, bitch. SA1 is a Sonic game. Forces is a Sonic game. They're both canon. And since they contradict each other, then there is no Sonic canon.
Shrimple as that.
Funny how you just discard the canon that you dislike and validate the canon that you like, as if it's not completely arbitrary.
No, bitch. SA1 is a Sonic game. Forces is a Sonic game. They're both canon. And since they contradict each other, then there is no Sonic canon.
Shrimple as that.
7/25/2025, 11:48:39 PM
>>532674754
Because "Gamenic" doesn't exist as the character contradicts himself multiple times in the games.
Because "Gamenic" doesn't exist as the character contradicts himself multiple times in the games.
7/17/2025, 5:46:22 PM
Even if Sparky is the biggest Windfag, he's still the best one. He understands that Sonic works best as a Kamina type, whose purpose is to be surpassed. Most windfags only see Sonic as a self-insert, whose purpose is to surpass others. This fundamental difference earns my respect.
7/12/2025, 3:00:25 AM
>>530885209
Gaslighting already? Damn, I really am good at destroying windfags. Dunno what I do special, really. I just use basic logic.
Gaslighting already? Damn, I really am good at destroying windfags. Dunno what I do special, really. I just use basic logic.
7/11/2025, 9:44:13 PM
>>530851664
>>530851789
Literally all we need to do is bring up 06 and the general flanderization of characters in the 00s to destroy you windfags. Japs did more damage to this franchise than westerners ever could.
>>530851789
Literally all we need to do is bring up 06 and the general flanderization of characters in the 00s to destroy you windfags. Japs did more damage to this franchise than westerners ever could.
7/11/2025, 2:17:50 PM
They should hire me. I would write Sonic into a relatable uwu crybaby, but at least it would be good.
7/10/2025, 4:54:48 AM
>>530626554
4000 is really far back huh. Gonna have to retcon that for my Legendary echidna warrior villain based on Alexander the great.
4000 is really far back huh. Gonna have to retcon that for my Legendary echidna warrior villain based on Alexander the great.
7/9/2025, 4:40:50 PM
>>530551536
The Job application is a multiverse-level threat that alters reality so that Sonic NEEDS to work, and also makes work boring. What now?
The Job application is a multiverse-level threat that alters reality so that Sonic NEEDS to work, and also makes work boring. What now?
7/9/2025, 4:18:21 AM
>>530496230
Yeah, that's not a counter-argument. In fact, I usually consider this type of response a concession.
Windfags lose again.
Yeah, that's not a counter-argument. In fact, I usually consider this type of response a concession.
Windfags lose again.
7/6/2025, 5:11:46 PM
>>530171736
>One Piece fan is a windfag who wants Sonic to always be the Jerry of "Tom & Jerry"
Wow, who would've thought?
I also don't want to see various sides from Sonic or have him be a dimensional character that also has things that make him angry. Nuh uh, he has to be the fairy godmother of the wind.
>One Piece fan is a windfag who wants Sonic to always be the Jerry of "Tom & Jerry"
Wow, who would've thought?
I also don't want to see various sides from Sonic or have him be a dimensional character that also has things that make him angry. Nuh uh, he has to be the fairy godmother of the wind.
7/5/2025, 3:05:31 PM
>>530036329
>What's cool is being unstoppable.
So jewish billionaires that had strings pulled for them before they were even born through nepotism are the coolest people in the world, yeah?
>To be put in the most difficult situations that should completely destroy you, yet you persevere
So a struggler like Knuckles, and not Sonic?
>What's cool is being unstoppable.
So jewish billionaires that had strings pulled for them before they were even born through nepotism are the coolest people in the world, yeah?
>To be put in the most difficult situations that should completely destroy you, yet you persevere
So a struggler like Knuckles, and not Sonic?
7/4/2025, 9:49:19 PM
>>529950271
Huh? When did I say anything was bad? I'm just trying to determine Sonic's ideology here.
>To take a life is to take away their freedom.
Sonic not respecting their freedom to take away their freedom is STILL him not respecting their freedom.
You sound like you're going through cognitive dissonance. He is either "Might makes right" or he would watch a man kill themselves, there's no other choice.
>>529950696
Don't bring up the trolley problem. He's just gonna say "Sonic would find a way to save everyone CAUSE HE'S SANIC!!" or some shit.
Huh? When did I say anything was bad? I'm just trying to determine Sonic's ideology here.
>To take a life is to take away their freedom.
Sonic not respecting their freedom to take away their freedom is STILL him not respecting their freedom.
You sound like you're going through cognitive dissonance. He is either "Might makes right" or he would watch a man kill themselves, there's no other choice.
>>529950696
Don't bring up the trolley problem. He's just gonna say "Sonic would find a way to save everyone CAUSE HE'S SANIC!!" or some shit.
7/2/2025, 1:52:39 AM
>>529583567
>Do you think Sonic has no sense of determination or willpower to press on towards whatever his goal is?
Wait, so he DOES compromise? I'm sorry, I thought you said that anything Sonic does isn't a sacrifice or responsibility since everything that requires effort is conveniently something he takes primal bodily pleasure in doing.
Now you're going back on it and saying he DOES have the capacity to sacrifice? I dunno, you keep using vague terms, almost as if you don't have a definition for Sonic's character and only pick and choose which characteristics sound more convenient.
Yes, convenience. Sonic is the paragon of convenience.
>Do you think Sonic has no sense of determination or willpower to press on towards whatever his goal is?
Wait, so he DOES compromise? I'm sorry, I thought you said that anything Sonic does isn't a sacrifice or responsibility since everything that requires effort is conveniently something he takes primal bodily pleasure in doing.
Now you're going back on it and saying he DOES have the capacity to sacrifice? I dunno, you keep using vague terms, almost as if you don't have a definition for Sonic's character and only pick and choose which characteristics sound more convenient.
Yes, convenience. Sonic is the paragon of convenience.
6/30/2025, 11:04:04 PM
>>529434802
Good bait, and you even added the Silver part in the end to give it away. 9/10
Good bait, and you even added the Silver part in the end to give it away. 9/10
6/27/2025, 9:25:15 PM
>>529056393
Yeah. The pitch is to change the current narrative that Sonic is not good at handling, instead of only making stories where the narrative perfectly fits the character and so they never face any challenges. Glad you understand.
Also, I like how Sonic being defeated is apparently "nerfing" him. Like he has to be the strongest person in the world at any given moment.
Yeah. The pitch is to change the current narrative that Sonic is not good at handling, instead of only making stories where the narrative perfectly fits the character and so they never face any challenges. Glad you understand.
Also, I like how Sonic being defeated is apparently "nerfing" him. Like he has to be the strongest person in the world at any given moment.
6/27/2025, 2:59:26 PM
>>529018348
>Which is why you pair him with another character.
Did you even listen to what I said? You can add a billion Sonic dicksuckers, it won't matter if he keeps being a shitty character.
>Nigga, these are cartoon characters.
I guess now every story that requires any suspension of disbelief needs to be completely nonsensical, yeah?
>>529018382
He gets closer than Gamenic, but is still a Gary Stu at its core. All the character writing energy goes to relationship drama bullshit.
>Which is why you pair him with another character.
Did you even listen to what I said? You can add a billion Sonic dicksuckers, it won't matter if he keeps being a shitty character.
>Nigga, these are cartoon characters.
I guess now every story that requires any suspension of disbelief needs to be completely nonsensical, yeah?
>>529018382
He gets closer than Gamenic, but is still a Gary Stu at its core. All the character writing energy goes to relationship drama bullshit.
6/24/2025, 5:51:38 PM
>>528647661
I'd normally say it's cool and soulful, but since you said it's the w*nd, then it's cringe and gay.
I'd normally say it's cool and soulful, but since you said it's the w*nd, then it's cringe and gay.
6/23/2025, 7:13:40 PM
>>528536524
>Get some hobbies. Go out more. Work out. Ride your bike. Take in the Sun. Feel the wind on your body.
If you did that, you wouldn't need Windnic. That's the thing.
>I did, you just didn't like what I said.
You never addressed any of my points; you just pivoted like all Windfags do.
>Get some hobbies. Go out more. Work out. Ride your bike. Take in the Sun. Feel the wind on your body.
If you did that, you wouldn't need Windnic. That's the thing.
>I did, you just didn't like what I said.
You never addressed any of my points; you just pivoted like all Windfags do.
6/18/2025, 10:19:17 PM
>>527877637
>The best stories managed to make it work
The best stories had the MC sacrifice nothing, change nothing, learn nothing new, and win everything in the end?
Sounds like you just have shit taste, honestly.
>do you want Sonic to be more complex with his mindset or to at least find a point on why Sonic does what he do?
I cannot see a good story coming out of the way Sonic is structured. His very nature is fundamentally flawed because it is so intertwined with how the very world operates that I can't even see him as a character.
A real character both affects his surroundings and is affected by them. But Sonic only goes one way. He affects the world but is never affected by it. In summation, while other characters are PART of the world, Sonic IS the world itself. Sonic doesn't change his personality to adapt to current circumstances; the circumstances adapt so that Sonic's unchanging personality is always the correct answer.
It's not that he's a person who doesn't wanna change. That could be interesting, a flawed character who's stagnant. But Sonic is a person who CAN'T change. His stagnance is forced upon him by the meta rulings that surround him.
And sure, you need to have meta rulings to have a story, as creating a scenario where a character needs to change his viewpoint to find the right answer is a meta rule imposed by the writer. But only Gary Stus like Sonic are DEFINED by meta rulings. The scenarios will only be ones where Sonic's viewpoint is correct, which is both boring (because nothing new happens), and not inspirational (Because it can't be applied to the real world).
You don't like the idea of me deconstructing Sonic because you know what he'll be left as without the meta: A homeless, jobless, irresponsible, dreamless adrenaline addict.
>>527879961
Yeah, picking an inconvenient path is a pretty basic form of character development. People are drawn to the path that's most convenient, so doing the opposite is usually the virtuous move.
>The best stories managed to make it work
The best stories had the MC sacrifice nothing, change nothing, learn nothing new, and win everything in the end?
Sounds like you just have shit taste, honestly.
>do you want Sonic to be more complex with his mindset or to at least find a point on why Sonic does what he do?
I cannot see a good story coming out of the way Sonic is structured. His very nature is fundamentally flawed because it is so intertwined with how the very world operates that I can't even see him as a character.
A real character both affects his surroundings and is affected by them. But Sonic only goes one way. He affects the world but is never affected by it. In summation, while other characters are PART of the world, Sonic IS the world itself. Sonic doesn't change his personality to adapt to current circumstances; the circumstances adapt so that Sonic's unchanging personality is always the correct answer.
It's not that he's a person who doesn't wanna change. That could be interesting, a flawed character who's stagnant. But Sonic is a person who CAN'T change. His stagnance is forced upon him by the meta rulings that surround him.
And sure, you need to have meta rulings to have a story, as creating a scenario where a character needs to change his viewpoint to find the right answer is a meta rule imposed by the writer. But only Gary Stus like Sonic are DEFINED by meta rulings. The scenarios will only be ones where Sonic's viewpoint is correct, which is both boring (because nothing new happens), and not inspirational (Because it can't be applied to the real world).
You don't like the idea of me deconstructing Sonic because you know what he'll be left as without the meta: A homeless, jobless, irresponsible, dreamless adrenaline addict.
>>527879961
Yeah, picking an inconvenient path is a pretty basic form of character development. People are drawn to the path that's most convenient, so doing the opposite is usually the virtuous move.
6/18/2025, 12:52:30 PM
>>527872840
Even when you have a chance to redeem yourself, you do nothing simply because it's more convenient. Just like Sonic, huh?
Well, I'll just relish in the fact that I have a foundation for my beliefs and you don't.
Even when you have a chance to redeem yourself, you do nothing simply because it's more convenient. Just like Sonic, huh?
Well, I'll just relish in the fact that I have a foundation for my beliefs and you don't.
6/18/2025, 12:35:46 PM
>>527836472
>"It's really not"
>Provides no counter-argument or justification.
I woke up expecting better.
>"It's really not"
>Provides no counter-argument or justification.
I woke up expecting better.
6/17/2025, 2:12:30 AM
>>527700002
That does sound windier than the stormy peaks of Mount Everest.
>>527700169
Sonic is windy as hell in Archie, just in a different way.
That does sound windier than the stormy peaks of Mount Everest.
>>527700169
Sonic is windy as hell in Archie, just in a different way.
Page 1